Remote Homeland, Recovered Borderland provides a detailed account of the Manchu people and their place of origin beginning at that point in time where most histories abandon them. The standard narrative of the Manchus—one told to me ages ago when I took a survey course on modern China—is that the people who came from the northeast to rule China during the last dynasty were assimilated into the Chinese population after the 1911 revolution. Shao Dan proves that assumption false. Dan uses an impressive array of Chinese, Japanese, English, and Manchu language sources. These sources include anthropologists’ field notes, government reports, gazetteers and census reports, memoirs, and oral interviews. He uses a combination of borderland theory and ethnic studies to identify the way that elites understood Manchus and in turn how Manchus defined and redefined themselves. In doing so, Dan uses a holistic approach to analyze the complex process of a people adapting to the violent events in East Asia during the twentieth century as they created a Manchu self-image.
Shao Dan's analysis begins with the waning Qing dynasty on the cusp of the 1911 Revolution, just where standard histories end. He gives a detailed description of the banners, the hereditary military institution that led the Manchus to victory in 1644. Indeed the make-up of the banners was quite complex, including many Han Chinese who later found themselves in an ethnic limbo. Thus, discussing Manchuria becomes a tale of both Manchus and banner peoples. Manchu elites remembered the northeast as a sacred homeland, but once comfortable in Beijing they rarely visited. This changed in 1907 as the Qing dynasty made last-ditch reform efforts, including the “provincialization” of their homeland to make a larger China into a modern and inclusive nation-state (pp. 2, 49).
The 1911 revolution rejected this inclusion. While Sun Yat-sen waffled on the issue, even offering Manchuria to Japan, many of his cohorts took up anti-Qing slogans that demonized the Tatars. In a second chapter, Dan demonstrates the harsh treatment dealt out to Manchus and banner peoples by Nationalist armies and later the Guomindang.
Given the hostile treatment Manchu people suffered after the 1911 revolution, the choice of many Manchus to pin their hopes for a homeland to Japanese Manchukuo seems a natural one. Less well known, and somewhat surprising, are the many who stayed in China proper and opposed the new experiment in nation building in the northeast. Given the ambiguity of the border territory in the 1930s, scholars studied the history and ethnicity of Manchuria in order to bolster their own nation's strategic interests. Han Chinese Fu Sinian, for instance, claimed that the borderland had always been China's northeast going back to the ancient times, that the Manchus had been “Hanized” (p. 3), and that the name Manchuria was a ploy of imperialism. In response, Japanese Yano Jin'ichi argued for the distinctiveness of the history, ethnicity, and culture of the Manchu people. As an author, Dan is less interested in the veracity of such statements than in their political uses.
Dan then looks at the years after 1949, when the uneasy relationship with the Nationalists often led Manchus and other banner people to side with the People's Liberation Army. He traces Manchu efforts from liberation to the 1980s to gain recognition as an ethnic group, and thus claim autonomous zones, as the Mongols and Tibetans had. With even Zhou Enlai claiming that Manchus had become Han, this proved to be quite an undertaking.
The best chapter, one that beautifully illustrates the complexities of what it meant to be Manchu in the twentieth century, details the experience of Aisin Gioro Xianyu, aka Jin Xianyu, aka Kawashima Yoshiko. Famous as a cross-dressing supporter of Japan in Manchukuo, the princess self-identified as Chinese, Japanese, and Manchu, sometimes all in one paragraph. Dan studies her treason trial, in which the woman who could so easily cross borders of identity during the war years was forced to come to terms with a solidifying national legal structure. At the end of an eventful life, Jin Xianyu had to redefine herself in terms of China, a nation she had betrayed.
This book is dense with valuable information meant for East Asian studies specialists. It provides a superb case study for anyone interested in borderland studies and ethnic identity. It presumes a familiarity with Asian history in general and an interest in the rigorous application of borderland theory to texts. A general reader would be lost in detail. For those among us who research and teach in the field, however, this book is invaluable. It provides a wealth of information about a significant group living in China, people who made an impact on history only to seemingly fade into obscurity.
