Current research on the institution of slavery often concerns the subject of agency. What are the boundaries that defined a slave's mastery over his own life? Although slaves were treated as property by their owners, they also bought and sold property for themselves. The transactions made by slaves, the so-called “internal economy,” are the subject of a new book by Kathleen Hilliard entitled Masters, Slaves, and Exchange: Power's Purchase in the Old South. Hilliard confines her study to the eastern seaboard states and the 1815–1860 time period. For slaveholders, allowing slaves to buy and sell goods created both benefits and costs. Slaveholders benefited from allocating garden plots to their slaves because they could save money on provisions. Some planters thought that providing garden plots strengthened paternal ties between owner and slave and reduced the number of runaways. Obviously, there was an opportunity cost to the land and the slave's time. Providing garden plots may have also weakened the planter's control of his labor force. Income provided slaves with choices, and planters worried about the choices made by their slaves.
Slaves used their discretionary income to purchase items not provided by their owners. According to Hilliard, owners typically provided an adequate quantity of food and clothing, most of which was of relatively low quality. Using records from country stores, Hilliard examines the types of goods purchased by slaves and finds that many were luxury items. In response to falling textile prices, she finds that slaves switched from homespun to manufactured cloth. Hilliard (p. 89) also finds that slaves purchased relatively little alcohol from country store (only 8 percent of their total purchases). This figure may be biased, however, because alcohol sales to slaves may have been underreported by merchants.
In addition to earning money through extra labor, some slaves stole money or property. Accusations of thefts within plantation boundaries were normally handled by the planters themselves. When slaves stole from others, court cases might arise. In chapter 4, Hilliard examines the records of court cases in which slaves were accused of stealing. She finds that most goods allegedly stolen by slaves were higher-valued items rather than basic provisions, such as those provided by owners. Of course, not all thefts were reported to the police and the goods recorded in these court cases may not be representative of all stolen goods. Her findings, however, suggest that slaves stole for other reasons than to supplement a meager diet.
Slaves also acquired property through gifts from their owners. As Hilliard discusses in chapter 5, it is often difficult to discern the owner's motive for making such gifts. Was this an act of philanthropy, an expected payment based on tradition or paternalism, or a reward for exemplary service? Economic historians have long debated how such transfers should be classified (Robert W. Fogel and Stanley L. Engerman. Time on the Cross: The Economics of American Negro Slavery, Boston: Little, Brown and Company, 1974; Herbert Gutman and Richard Sutch. “Sambo Makes Good, or Were Slaves Imbued with the Protestant Work Ethic?” In Reckoning with Slavery, Paul David et al. New York: Oxford University Press, 1976, p. 73). Hilliard argues that gifts were often made in public to influence the behavior of the gift recipient. Although provisions can never be thought of as gifts, some owners may have blurred the distinction. In general, most gifts were cash or luxury items, rather than lower-quality items such as basic provisions.
Relatively few slaves were able to purchase their freedom. Because slaves valued their labor more than their owners, self-purchase represented a mutually advantageous exchange (John E. Moes, “The Economics of Slavery in the Ante Bellum South: Another Comment.” Journal of Political Economy 68 (1960): 183–87). Of course, slaves were among the poorest of all consumers and most were unable to save enough to purchase themselves. In addition, white southerners used the political system to place obstacles in the slave's path towards freedom. Because many whites feared the presence of free blacks, many southern states required emigration as a condition for emancipation (making self-purchase less attractive for the slave). For slaves to be freed on their owner's death, the heirs to the estate might contest the will, thus preventing their freedom. These factors may help to explain why relatively few slaves were able to purchase their freedom.
Economic historians interested in slavery will appreciate Hilliard's use of primary data. They will also note the omission of recent work by economic historians. For example, there is no discussion of the research on the diets or net nutrition of slaves (Robert W. Fogel. Without Consent or Contract: The Rise and Fall of American Slavery, New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 1989). How typical were the experiences of these slaves? Did most slaves participate in the internal economy of the antebellum South? Finally, legal historians would benefit from a discussion of the legal rights of slaves. Because slaves were property, they could not own property or be party to a contract. The earnings of the slaves belonged to the owners. Yet slaves produced goods for their own benefit, engaged in trade, acquired personal wealth, and in some cases, purchased their freedom. How were they able to do this? Indeed, the tenuous property rights of slaves may help to account for much of the internal economy of slavery.
