Over roughly the past 25 years, writing on the late medieval Hijaz has shifted in scope and ambition, moving from the margins of Islamic historiography towards a more prominent, if still incomplete, place in current research. Earlier work tended to treat Mecca and Medina as ritual poles or imperial outposts, where Cairene or, later, Ottoman authority made itself visible, or as fixed points in narratives concerned above all with pilgrimage and piety, rather than as historical centres worthy of close study on their own terms. Over the same period, a series of studies marked a clear turn. They treated the Hijaz in its own environment, took sharifian autonomy as a central factor in regional political dynamics, and showed that Hijazi historical sources could sustain close analysis of brokerage and commercial ties, so that Mecca and Medina no longer appeared simply as an imperial margin of Syro-Egyptian dominion. Building on this shift, more recent work has read local chronicles, biographical dictionaries, and endowment records as sources for the internal organisation of the two main regional cities, their hinterland, and their position within wider Middle Eastern, Red Sea, and Indian Ocean circuits.
This renewal has not yet coalesced into a structured and organised field of research, and scholarship on the Hijaz has remained relatively marginal. The number of academic works dedicated to Mecca and Medina is thus remarkably limited, and few collective projects take the region’s history as their core topic. The gap is particularly clear in the later medieval period (circa AH 597–923/1201–1517 CE), as surveys of Mamlūk historiography and history by Li Guo, Th. Emil Homerin, or Konrad Hirschler scarcely register the Hijaz,Footnote 1 with scant mentions of the region, even though the same period has seen a steady growth of engagement in English and French academic literature, alongside an increase of works in Arabic on Meccan and Medinan history. That asymmetry frames the questions that organise the present introduction: How might one locate the Hijaz within an academic map that still privileges Cairo, Damascus, or Istanbul as primary centres of political and historiographical production? How far can Arabic historiography on Mecca and Medina be drawn into wider discussions of urban society, confessional realignment, and regional economies? What concrete limits, from manuscript access to institutional priorities, still shape our engagement with the history of the Hijaz, and in which directions does current research seem to be moving?
The present introduction grows out of that historiographical moment and from a more concrete setting. In May 2023, a workshop held at the University of Liège on ‘The Hijaz and the Making of Islamic History’, convened by the editors of this special issue, gathered historians working on Mecca, Medina, and their wider connections between the seventh/thirteenth and early tenth/sixteenth centuries. The discussions at Liège brought into focus both the advances achieved in recent decades and the degree to which research on the Hijaz has remained fragmented across linguistic and institutional boundaries. The special issue that emerged from this meeting represents an initial response to that situation.
The pages that follow take up these questions on two levels. They first set out the historical context of the late medieval Hijaz, tracing the ways in which Mecca and Medina acted as political centres, sites of confessional negotiation,Footnote 2 and spaces of local historiographical production in a broader Western Arabian corridor linking Jeddah, caravan routes, and inland settlements, and in so doing bring into view the political and religious economy of the Hijaz. They then sketch a state of the art that charts recent scholarship, its advances, and its gaps, across different languages and academic settings. This introduction makes no claim to exhaustiveness in a field that continues to expand. It offers instead a contextual assessment of current knowledge, of the main lines of inquiry that have taken shape, and of the conceptual and material constraints that still structure work on the history and historiography of the Hijaz. On that basis, the articles in this special issue turn to local actors, endowments, genealogies, and textual practices as points of entry into the history of the late medieval Hijaz and invite a wider reconsideration of the place of Mecca and Medina within accounts of political, social, and intellectual change in the Muslim world from the seventh/thirteenth to the early tenth/sixteenth centuries.
Situating the late medieval Hijaz
Context and historical framework
From the seventh/thirteenth to the tenth/sixteenth centuries, the region formed a dense zone of contact in which changing configurations of power, confession, and circulation left traces in local texts that historians have only recently begun to read on their own terms. The workshop on ‘The Hijaz and the Making of Islamic History’ rests on this shift in perspective. The present volume follows the same line by placing Mecca, Medina, their hinterland, and their littoral façade, at the centre of inquiry rather than at the margins of Mamlūk, Rasūlid, or Ottoman narratives.
The contributions gathered here focus mainly on the period stretching from the consolidation of the Banū Qatāda emirate in Mecca at the turn of the seventh/thirteenth century to the early Ottoman presence in the tenth/sixteenth century. This chronology overlaps with three major processes that late medieval sources allow us to follow in some detail: the consolidation of an ʿAlid principality in Mecca as a regional power, the gradual, if partial, ‘Sunnitisation’ of religious life in the Holy Cities, and the emergence of a local historiographical tradition that treated the Hijaz as a subject in its own right.
First, the political ordering of the Hijaz around a Meccan emirate that claimed descent from al-Ḥasan b. ʿAlī and negotiated its rank among regional powers in Cairo, Zabīd, Tabriz, and Herat,Footnote 3 underlined the region’s role as a political and symbolic centre. By the mid ninth/fifteenth century, Meccan influence extended over Medina, ʿAsīr, and the Mikhlāf Sulaymānī.Footnote 4 Arabic sources allow one to trace a succession of arrangements in which local emirs,Footnote 5 especially the ashrāf Footnote 6 of Mecca, were increasingly successful. From the seventh/thirteenth century onwards, they were able to balance local armed groupsFootnote 7 and extract revenues from taxes and dues,Footnote 8 as well as rentier income channelled through pious endowments and gifts from the wider Dār al-Islām.Footnote 9 They controlled the routes to Mecca,Footnote 10 managed rivalries among elite scholarly families,Footnote 11 and increased the symbolic capital attached to the custody of the Ḥaram al-Sharīf.Footnote 12 The authority of the Meccan emirate—and probably that of Medina, although the evidence is much thinner—also rested on the rulers’ ability to mediate among numerous social and kinship groups within the Hijaz. These included the ʿUrbān of the Hijazi hinterland—generically designated al-ʿArab in Yemeni sources—urban notables, merchants, and professional soldiers such as the ʿabīd (enslaved soldiers) and the sharif’s ghilmān Footnote 13 in Mecca and Medina,Footnote 14 and Muslim rulers who sought recognition in the Holy Cities to bolster their legitimacy at home.Footnote 15 In this system, which in the Meccan case apparently became increasingly successful over the course of the eighth/fourteenth and ninth/fifteenth centuries,Footnote 16 intermittent crises of succession and co-rule, limited wars, and the constraints imposed by Rasūlid Yemen and, above all, the Cairo Sultanate revealed the fragility as well as the resilience of these evolving configurations. The Rasūlid conquest and consolidation of Yemen in the seventh/thirteenth century, together with expanding Indian Ocean trade, intensified these dynamics by drawing Mecca more tightly into Red Sea commercial and political circuits, even as Yemeni claims to protect the Holy City competed with those of Cairo, until Cairene predominance and recognition emerged mostly unchallenged in the course of the eighth/fourteenth century.Footnote 17
Second, the same period witnessed a profound transformation of the confessional configuration in the Holy Cities.Footnote 18 Partly under external pressure and partly in response to changing patterns of patronage and scholarship, ruling families in both cities began to adopt more favourable attitudes towards Sunnism.Footnote 19 In Mecca, from the establishment of the Banū Qatāda emirate in 597/1201 through roughly the middle of the seventh/thirteenth century, Zaydī and Sunni elites held key posts under a ruling house that itself adhered to Zaydīsm. The Banū Qatāda are described as originally Zaydī, following earlier Meccan rulers in adopting a Zaydī version of the call to prayer. Contemporary and near-contemporary descriptions from the first half of the seventh/thirteenth century underline that Sunni scholars in the city were in no position to alter this order as long as the emirate openly supported Zaydīsm. Over the second half of the eighth/fourteenth and early ninth/fifteenth centuries, however, leading sharifs studied hadith with scholars in Egypt and Syria, founded madrasas in which Sunni jurisprudence and hadith were taught, and forged marital ties with Sunni scholarly families, even as some observers still suspected sections of the sharifian elite of Zaydī sympathies behind an outward adherence to the Shāfiʿī rite.Footnote 20 At the same time, the ritual life of the Ḥaram of Mecca already displayed a plural configuration: there could be an imam for each of the four Sunni schools of law alongside the Zaydī imam, and both a Shāfiʿī and a Zaydī judge worked in the city’s courts.Footnote 21
Medina, by contrast, appears in the sources as more closely associated with Twelver Shīʿism. Its Ḥusaynid emirate, founded in the last third of the fourth/tenth century and led by the Banū Muhannā, remained the city’s principal political framework throughout the Mamlūk period.Footnote 22 Down to the later seventh/thirteenth century, after the Banū Jammāz branch of the Banū Muhannā took over Medina, Syro-Egyptian rulers did not systematically interfere in the city’s internal religious and political arrangements.Footnote 23 From the late seventh/thirteenth century onwards, however, appointments and interventions issued from Cairo progressively reshaped this equilibrium. In Medina, Sunni imams, preachers, and judges (quḍāt) attached to the Prophet’s Mosque were introduced alongside existing Twelver office-holders, who had dominated the legal and religious landscape of the seventh/thirteenth century.Footnote 24 During the eighth/fourteenth century, certain emirs were portrayed as ostentatiously professing Sunnism in order to satisfy Cairo, even when their own attachment to Twelver Shīʿism remained strong, and the introduction of Sunni judgeships did not immediately dislodge Twelver office-holders. In 700/1300, the Cairo sultan al-Nāṣir Muḥammad appointed a Shāfiʿī qāḍī (judge) in the city.Footnote 25 The Banū Jammāz increasingly supported Sunnism, leading to serious tensions in the city: in the mid eighth/fourteenth century, Faḍl b. Qāsim b. Jammāz proclaimed the preeminence of the Shāfiʿī qāḍī, and prevented Twelvers from participating in legal affairs and from entering the Medinan ḥujra (Prophet’s burial chamber).Footnote 26 Additional positions for the Mālikī and Ḥanafī schools were created during the second half of the eighth/fourteenth century,Footnote 27 and eventually, a Ḥanbalī qāḍī was appointed in the early ninth/fifteenth century, combining this office with that of the Ḥanbalī judge in Mecca.Footnote 28 Narrative sources nonetheless suggest that Ḥusaynid elites and Twelver jurists continued to play an important role well into the later ninth/fifteenth century and that the shift towards a predominantly Sunni judiciary was gradual rather than abrupt.
In Mecca, the Cairo Sultanate acted more directly on the religious personnel of the Ḥaram. Al-Nāṣir Muḥammad (r. 693–694/1293–1294, 698–708/1299–1309, 709–741/1310–1341) repeatedly ordered the removal of Shīʿī formulas from the adhān (call to prayer) and the expulsion of the Zaydī imam from the Sacred Mosque. Initial attempts around the turn of the eighth/fourteenth century appear to have had only temporary effects, but from around the mid-century the pressure became more persistent.Footnote 29 Episodes recorded in local and Cairene sources—such as the Shāfiʿī judge preventing the Zaydī imam from leading the funeral prayer over the emir Rumaytha in 746/1346, or the later imprisonment of the Zaydī imam and the killing of a Zaydī muezzin by the commander of the Egyptian caravan—mark the growing assertiveness of Sunni officials backed by Cairo.Footnote 30 Over the early ninth/fifteenth century, a full four-madhhab judiciary took shape in Mecca under Syro-Egyptian patronage, following the judicial policy favoured by the Cairo Sultanate.Footnote 31
Even after these interventions, Shīʿī actors did not disappear from the Hijazi social landscape. Zaydīs and Twelvers still surface in biographical dictionaries, local chronicles, and faḍāʾil (virtues) works as scholars and pilgrims, and in some cases retained influence in specific neighbourhoods, endowments, or informal networks despite the transfer of formal offices to Sunni incumbents. At the same time, Sunni scholars and authors from the Hijaz elaborated distinctive forms of imamophilia, a learned affirmation of the virtues and status of the Twelve Imams grounded in Sunni hadith collections and earlier faḍāʾil literature. This tendency can be traced from Muḥibb al-Dīn al-Ṭabarī’s (615–694/1218–1295) Meccan compilation on the virtues of ʿAlī and the Prophet’s family, Dhakhāʾir al-ʿuqbā fī manāqib dhawī al-qurbā, to the Medinan scholar Shams al-Dīn al-Zarandī’s (d. 747/1346) Naẓm Durar al-Simṭayn and Maʿārij al-Wuṣūl. In the latter works, devotion to the imams was explicitly distinguished from key Twelver doctrines, including the occultation and continuing life of the twelfth imam.Footnote 32
The result, by the early ninth/fifteenth century, was thus not a passage from a ‘Shīʿī’ to a ‘Sunni’ Hijaz but a rearticulation of loyalties and doctrinal positions of scholarly and political elites around the ḥarams of Mecca and Medina in which ʿAlid descent, juridical affiliation, and attitudes to the imams all played a part. Lineages tracing their ancestry to ʿAlī and Fāṭima could, in the changing social landscape of the late medieval Hijaz, reposition themselves within a predominantly Shāfiʿī and Mālikī legal order without abandoning ʿAlid identity and claims to a superior sharaf (honour and social prestige, especially that derived from lineage). Sunni scholars in the Hijaz could cultivate intense devotion to the imams while marking clear boundaries with Twelver theology. And the symbolism of custodianship over the holy places became increasingly entangled with claims to defend the ahl al-sunna wa-l-jamāʿa,Footnote 33 at least in Mecca.Footnote 34 Within these layered and evolving confessional configurations, interventions from Cairo, local strategies of accommodation, and the enduring prestige of ʿAlid genealogies together shaped the ways in which authority and belonging were imagined, negotiated, and contested.
Third, this period saw the growth of a Meccan and Medinan historiography through which the Hijaz and its history became an object of local historical writing in its own right. From the seventh/thirteenth century onwards, locally produced works in Mecca and Medina presented the two cities, their elites, and their institutions as coherent historical objects, although much of this literature, particularly from the later eighth/fourteenth century, survives only partially. In Medina, the Mālikī scholar and deputy qāḍī ʿAbd Allāh Ibn Farḥūn (d. 769/1367), together with his relative Burhān al-Dīn Ibrāhīm b. Farḥūn (d. 799/1397), highlighted the city’s judicial elite, the servants of the Prophet’s Mosque, pious visitors (zuwwār), and the ways in which the authority of the Ḥusaynid emirs was intertwined with the administration of sacred space. Ibn Farḥūn’s history organised Medina around offices and families as much as events, systematically recording the careers of judges, preachers, and khuddām (servants or custodians of the Ḥaram) alongside those of emirs, thereby embedding a specifically Medinan Sunni scholarly milieu into the city’s history. In Mecca, a generation later, Taqī al-Dīn Muḥammad al-Fāsī (d. 832/1429) undertook a parallel enterprise on a larger scale. His topographical narratives filled a gap since the early works of al-Azraqī and al-Fākihī, moving outwards from the Kaʿba and the Ḥaram to neighbourhoods, cemeteries, markets, and surrounding valleys. His Shifāʾ al-gharām organised political events around emiral succession, caravan arrivals, and the recurring rhythms of the hajj, while his biographical works amassed thousands of entries on scholars, emirs, jurists, preachers, muezzins, and temporary residents (mujāwirūn). These narratives combined a layered understanding of the city’s history with careful tracing of lineages, offices, and concrete forms of service to the Holy City.
The Banū Fahd, writing across the ninth/fifteenth and early tenth/sixteenth centuries, recast and continued this Meccan history, year by year, extending coverage down to their own time and weaving into it notices on prices, taxation, urban works, the management of endowments, military mobilisations, and conflicts within and around the city. Their chronicles and biographical dictionaries both preserved and rearranged al-Fāsī’s narratives, while adding new layers drawn from documents, oral reports, and their own participation in the scholarly life of the city. Najm al-Dīn ʿUmar b. Faḥd (d. 885/1480) produced an annalistic history of Mecca from the Hijra to the author’s death, filling in many of the chronological and social lacunae of al-Fāsī’s more thematically ordered work. He also composed a biographical collection devoted entirely to the rulers of Mecca, Bughyat al-marām bi-akhbār wulāt al-balad al-ḥarām, later continued by his son ʿIzz al-Dīn under the title Ghāyat al-marām bi-akhbār salṭanat al-balad al-ḥarām.Footnote 35 These works reconfigured the emirate as a ‘sultanate’ under Muḥammad b. Barakāt (r. 859–903/1455–1497),Footnote 36 and retrospectively organised the sharifian line into a continuous political genealogy. In their hands, the late medieval Meccan emirate appeared not merely as a sequence of turbulent reigns but as a durable ʿAlid power whose ceremonies, alliances, and conflicts were embedded in a dense urban fabric. These shifts in the representation of Meccan history unfolded alongside broader transformations in the social, economic, and political structures of the Meccan polity.
Reimagining Mecca and Medina in their local and regional environments
The reconceptualisation of Meccan history by Taqī al-Dīn al-Fāsī and the Banū Fahd unfolded against a shifting landscape in which the emirate of Mecca was being reimagined and to a considerable extent reconfigured as a territorially grounded, fiscally articulated and socially stratified polity. In the course of the ninth/fifteenth century, the older pattern in which the Banū Qatāda brokered between imperial centres and local factions for control of pilgrimage routes and the city gave way to a more densely urban and regionally integrated order, in which power, wealth, and status were increasingly concentrated in a limited number of households and lineages anchored in the city itself and its immediate hinterland, and in which Mecca and Jeddah functioned as a single, hierarchised node in the wider Red Sea–Indian Ocean economy.
At a social level, the bayt of the ruling emir—first under Ḥasan b. ʿAjlān, then Barakāt and Muḥammad, and finally Barakāt’s sons—appeared as the apex of local interconnected households, each combining kinship, clients, and retainers into a compact social and political unit. Around the princely house clustered the ashrāf of the Banū Ḥasan, segments such as the Dhū Rumaytha, Dhū ʿAjlān, or the Banū ʿAbd al Karīm, whose buyūt were simultaneously rivals and props of emiral authority, bound into it by marriages and negotiated access to revenues. Below and alongside these stood the quwwād and armed followings, ʿArab tribal elites, as well as retainers, often of enslaved origins (ghilmān), and corps of black and white military slaves (ʿabīd, mamālīk), whose presence was pivotal in every succession crisis.Footnote 37
At the same time, the civilian elite of judges, scholars, and merchants—families such as the Banū Zuhayra among the Shāfiʿī judiciary, and the khawwājāt, merchants who during the ninth/fifteenth century supplied the Meccan market but whose maritime operations extended as far as Calicut, Malabar, and Southeast Asia—embedded the emirate within an urban culture of learning, political and social mediation, and charitable patronage. These scholarly communities, comprising both permanent residents and temporary sojourners (mujāwirūn), possessed internal hierarchies, ceremonial roles, and channels of influence in local governance. Sermons and duʿāʾ (supplication) for the emir and distant sultans were proclaimed from the minbar and the dome of Zamzam, while funerals of emirs and aʿyān (notables) involved circumambulations and processions threading together the Kaʿba, the Maqām Ibrāhīm, and the cemetery of al-Maʿlāh, spatially inscribing sharifian authority into city and graveyard alike.Footnote 38 The Banū Fahd’s chronicles, with attention to births, deaths, processions, marriages, and patronage ties, mirror this apparently bayt-centred sociability of the aʿyān, tracing how alliances and feuds among ashrāf, quwwād, jurists, and merchants structured the political possibilities of each year alongside circulations tied to the hajj and trade.
Economically, the foundations of emiral power were transformed by the rise of Jeddah in the ninth/fifteenth century as the northern hinge of Indian Ocean commerce and by the progressive monetisation of Meccan society.Footnote 39 From the early ninth/fifteenth century, the ruling sharifs, above all Ḥasan b. ʿAjlān, his son Barakāt, and his grandson Muḥammad, converted their ability to guarantee or disrupt security on caravan- and sea-lanes into fiscal claims over customs, fees, and protection payments. The establishment and defence of the sharifian customs (furḍa) in Jeddah, distinct from the sultanic house, and the concurrent decline of Yemen’s role in Indian Ocean trade allowed the Meccan emirate to tap the swelling tide of spice, textiles, and bullion from Calicut, Cambay, and Daybul, while periodic Mamlūk attempts to reassert control left the Cairo Sultanate’s authority partial and subject to negotiation. Growth in Indian Ocean trade over the eighth–ninth/fourteenth–fifteenth centuries thus intensified commercial ties between South Asia, the Horn of Africa, and the Red Sea, integrating South Asian and Abyssinian communities into the Hijaz and redirecting some scholarly and Sufi networks previously routed through Yemen.Footnote 40
By the late ninth/fifteenth century, the ruling sharif was no longer merely taxing trade but directly investing in it: Muḥammad b. Barakāt owned and outfitted murawwas vesselsFootnote 41 engaged in the Calicut trade and likely patronised a small shipbuilding industry at Jeddah, importing timber and expertise to construct hulls adapted to the upper Red Sea. Shipping lists compiled by ʿIzz al-Dīn b. Fahd reveal dense traffic of Indian ships—predominantly from Calicut, but also from Cambay and Daybul—whose arrivals rose through the 880s–890s/1470s–1490s, declining only when Portuguese violence and civil strife made the route hazardous. To these maritime revenues were added ṣadaqāt (voluntary alms) from Anatolia, India, and the Maghrib, carefully tallied by ʿIzz al-Dīn b. Fahd to reflect the hierarchy of their beneficiaries: one third to the sharif, substantial sums to the Shāfiʿī chief judge and other quḍāt (judges) and khuṭabāʾ (preachers who delivered the Friday sermon), diminishing shares to lesser notables, and a residual trickle to the poor.Footnote 42 Overlaying these revenue streams, a local monetary regime, managed by the emirs, absorbed pilgrim gold and foreign coin, converting it into silver and copper, and through periodic debasement and recoinage, extracted substantial wealth. Reissues of masʿūdī dirhams in 889/1484 and 901/1495, staged as public festivals with processions, illustrated both the ceremonialisation of monetary policy and the way in which pilgrimage and trade were harnessed into controlled, profitable circulation. The Banū Fahd’s attention to prices, exchange rates, and coinage reflected how economic power became calculable, visible, and politically contested, an instrument of authority demonstrating the emirate’s autonomy.
Politically, these social and economic shifts underlined what contemporaries increasingly perceived as a Meccan sultanate. The sovereignty of the Banū Ḥasan, already evident in earlier competition among Qatāda descendants, acquired a more sharply dynastic form in the later ninth/fifteenth century. Ḥasan, Barakāt, and Muḥammad subordinated rival sharifian lines and extended control from Medina and Yanbuʿ in the north to Ḥalī and Jāzān in the south, aided by the decline of Rasūlid power in Yemen. Cairene chancery formulae, particularly the decrees of al-Ashraf Qāytbāy in the 880s/1470s–1480s, recognised this reality by granting the ruling sharif not only the revived title of nāʾib in the Hijaz but also authority over judges, fiscal officials, and local commanders. While Jeddah remained contested between sultanic and sharifian agents, correspondence, robe-sending, and hostage practices gradually reframed Mecca–Cairo relations from seasonal domination to negotiated partnership. The Banū Fahd’s decision to recast Meccan history into annals of reigns, conflicts, and accessions, alongside biographical collections of rulers, scholars, and merchants, can itself be understood as political work. By ordering succession into coherent genealogies, adopting a terminology corresponding to the emirate’s autonomy and territorial reach, and documenting treaties, sermons, coinage, and patronage, they rendered legible a durable ʿAlid principality whose social hierarchies, economic mechanisms, and political rituals carried weight beyond its relations with distant sultans.
Although less is known about Medina’s history, a comparable, though differently configured process can be traced there. Unlike Mecca, where the Banū Qatāda leveraged Indian Ocean trade and pilgrimage security to build a territorially expansive polity from Yanbuʿ to Jāzān, Medina’s Banū Jammāz faced tighter constraints. The available evidence does not reveal a port or customs income comparable to Jeddah’s, or equally substantial caravan taxation. Medina’s political economy appears instead to have relied heavily on Egyptian and Syrian endowments, grain shipments funded by sultanic waqfs, and the ritual and scholarly prestige of the Prophet’s Mosque. As Takao Ito illustrates in the present issue, Sultan Qāʾitbāy’s waqf al-dashīshah (1470s–1480s) alone provided 7,500 irdabbs (circa 522,000 kg) of wheat annually, along with funding for madrasas, ribāṭs (endowed residences offering charitable lodging and, in some cases, instruction), and numerous salaried posts. This late Mamlūk configuration recalled an older relationship between Egyptian political influence and the provisioning of the Hijaz: in the late fourth/tenth century, al-Muqaddasī already attributed the region’s dependence on the ruler of Egypt specifically to its need for food supplies.Footnote 43 Dependence on Cairo-based endowments gave Egyptian-recognised governors greater institutional leverage than in Mecca, binding Medina to the sultanate through provisioning and patronage rather than coercion or taxation. Within this framework, the Ḥusaynid emirs held a pivotal dual role as political rulers and naqīb al-ashrāf (head or representative of the lineages claiming descent from the Prophet), partly echoing Meccan sharifian arrangements within a different confessional terrain.
Ibn Farḥūn’s juridical and historical writings, composed in the mid eighth/fourteenth century, already registered this negotiation, framing Sunni ascendancy through transformation narratives that contrasted Sunni piety with Shīʿī oppression whilst documenting the role of Cairo-appointed judges and Sunni migrants in reshaping the city’s religious character. Al-Sakhāwī’s biographical dictionary of Medina, al-Tuḥfat al-laṭīfa, modelled in part on Meccan precedents, juxtaposed entries on Medinan notables with lives of ʿAlid figures and Twelver and Sunni scholars whose birth, death, or burial were associated with the city. In doing so, he registered ongoing ʿAlid claims while reframing them within the historiographical framework of the dominant regional scholarly milieu through a narrative of piety, knowledge transmission, and politics.Footnote 44 Al-Samhūdī’s monumental topographical history, completed in the early tenth/sixteenth century, carried this project forward by tracing how the Prophet’s Mosque, the Baqīʿ cemetery, and the wider urban space served as sites where patterns of presence, hierarchy, and access were staged and periodically renegotiated.Footnote 45 His works on the merits of the Prophet’s family and the virtues of the Twelve Imams inscribed an imamophilic sensibility within a consciously Sunni Medinan framework, providing a later point of comparison for the Sunni imamophilia examined through al-Zarandī in Ryo Mizukami’s contribution to this issue.Footnote 46
What emerges from the sources is thus a political order in which power in both cities rested heavily upon mediation among local elite networks and between these networks and Egyptian or Yemeni institutions, although the Meccan emirs could also draw upon a commercial and fiscal base for which no equivalent has yet been identified in Medina. The Meccan Ḥaram and the Prophet’s Mosque in Medina appear to have served as the respective organisational centres through which endowment revenues, scholarly appointments, ritual performances, and political negotiations were channelled. Whereas the Meccan sharifs could seemingly translate their control over trade and pilgrimage into a durable fiscal base, one may perhaps propose, while keeping in mind the considerable gaps in our knowledge of Medina, that the political position of the Banū Jammāz was more heavily shaped by dependence on sultanic patronage. Such a configuration would have made Medina at once more closely integrated into Syro-Egyptian administrative systems and more vulnerable to disruptions in Cairo’s capacity or willingness to provision the city and sustain its ruling circles.
Taken together, the principal historiographical works produced in both cities that have survived or been rediscovered—those of al-Fāsī and the Banū Fahd in Mecca, those of Ibn Farḥūn and al-Samhūdī in Medina—emerged from within the milieus they described. Al-Samhūdī’s corpus, in particular, constituted the most significant late medieval expression of a Medinan tradition of local history-writing whose re-emergence can be traced at least to Ibn al-Najjār (d. 643/1245). Judges, preachers, and the aʿyān of the Holy Cities turned to history, topography, and biography to register the spaces in which they moved, the offices they held, the rituals they enacted, the lineages through which they claimed authority, and the implicit and explicit mechanisms of control through which they perpetuated their status as elites. Through choices of inclusion, emphasis, and exclusion in their biographical dictionaries, the prominence accorded to particular lineages and offices, and their narration of conflicts over the custody of the sanctuaries and the reception of rulers’ claims to serve them, these authors made legible and visible the political, social, and confessional configurations that structured late medieval Hijazi urban life, and, to a much lesser extent, its rural hinterland. For the purposes of this issue, these texts function both as indispensable primary witnesses and as a lens through which the late medieval Hijaz was conceptualised by its own learned elites.
Transregional circulations and the Holy Cities
Yet these locally grounded histories were only one layer of the late medieval Hijaz’s textual presence. The configurations described above also shaped the ways in which Mecca and Medina were imagined, approached, and used beyond the Hijaz. The Maghrib and South Asia provide two distinct vantage points from which to apprehend the transformations of the late medieval Hijaz and help situate developments within Mecca and Medina amid the broader shifts that redefined their transregional position. To follow Maghribi, Andalusi, or South Asian engagements with the Holy Cities is thus to trace how Hijazi forms of authority and knowledge transmission entered wider Islamic circulations, within which proximity to the Ḥaramayn could support claims to legitimacy and scholarly standing, shape scholarly practices, and attract patronage.
Beyond the Red Sea basin, Mecca and Medina also occupied a distinctive place in Maghribi imaginaries and itineraries. In the seventh–ninth/thirteenth–fifteenth centuries, three interrelated developments shaped Maghribi engagement with the Holy Cities: the rise of sharifism as a tool of political legitimation in the Maghrib, the eastward expansion of certain Sufi brotherhoods (ṭuruq), and the intensification of prophetic veneration through new devotional practices and texts. From the late seventh/thirteenth century onwards, claims to sharif status became an increasingly significant source of political legitimacy. While the Marinid sultans did not themselves claim sharifian lineage, they actively promoted those who did, according them special honours and ceremonial precedence to recognised descendants of the Prophet. Within this framework, Mecca and Medina were used as sites where genealogical claims could be authenticated by specialists in ʿilm al-nasab (science of genealogy), and as places where authority effectively lay with the Prophet’s kinsfolk, a highly active and prominent group in the social structure of both cities.
In the same period, the circulation of texts such as Ibn ʿArabī’s al-Futūḥāt al-makkiyya (The Meccan illuminations) and al-Jazūlī’s Dalāʾil al-khayrāt (Proofs of good deeds), together with the spread of Maghribi ṭuruq (Sufi paths) such as the Shādhiliyya, tied the Holy Cities to forms of prophetic veneration, scholarly affiliation, spiritual genealogies (silsilas), hospitality, and instruction articulated in distinctively Maghribi terms.Footnote 47 In the post-Almohad period, knowledge-transmission networks linking the Maghrib to the Ḥaramayn were reconfigured: riḥla narratives (travel accounts) and fahāris, bio-bibliographical catalogues listing teachers, works studied, and scholarly transmissions, recorded pilgrimages, extended residencies (mujāwara), teaching sessions, ijāzāt (licences to transmit), and asānīd (chains of transmission) that tied Maghribi students to teachers in Mecca. This literature suggests that much interaction occurred within relatively discrete Maghribi communities in the Holy Cities, which preserved local chains of transmission and maintained distinctively Maghribi practices even in Meccan and Medinan settings.Footnote 48
These patterns must be read against the difficulties of Maghribi pilgrimage from the fifth/eleventh century onwards, when Hilālī invasions, Norman piracy, Fatimid restrictions, and the struggle against Christian rulers in Spain made routes increasingly insecure and prompted legal debates over whether hajj remained obligatory, especially during the Almohad period, when rulers discouraged the pilgrimage to Mecca.Footnote 49 Some jurists declared pilgrimage suspended or prohibited when roads were unsafe, while others, including Sufis such as Ibn ʿArabī, insisted on its continuing obligation, and a genre of ‘pilgrimage by pen’ (al-ḥajj bi-l-qalam) emerged in the form of letters to Mecca and the Prophet’s tomb. These constraints help explain why those Maghribis who did reach the Holy Cities often formed tight-knit communities and relied heavily on mutual support networks. Within these socially dense yet circumscribed channels of access, thanks to projects such as the Prosopographical Record of the ʿUlamāʾ of al-Andalus, we can discern a system of circulations whose routes between al-Andalūs and the Hijaz formed one of the principal arteries of post-classical Islamic learning. Earlier research has partially reconstructed these regional practices of travel and piety, extending even to the participation of women in pilgrimage.Footnote 50 The authority attached to knowledge acquired in the Holy Cities rested both on the prestige of presence within the sacred precincts of the Ḥaramayn and on the symbolic capital derived from the convergence of so many intellectual lineages.
After the Almohad era, renewed devotion to Medina underlined a shift in the understanding of sanctity.Footnote 51 The principle of saintly intercession remained intact, yet the Prophet came to embody its consummate form, the single source from which all derivative forms drew their legitimacy.Footnote 52 Maghribi texts of the period capture the ambiguities of this moment: sanctuaries of local saints retained their vitality, though subordinated to a vision in which the Prophet’s tomb represented the highest degree of possible mediation. The movement of scholars through pilgrimage became an enactment of this relation. Returning scholars transplanted Hijazi asānīd and eastern intellectual currents into Maghribi settings, while reaffirming the autonomy of local scholarly genealogies and reproducing regional distinctions.Footnote 53 The link between the Holy Cities and the Maghrib thus assumed a dual function: it maintained a sense of shared religious geography while preserving internal hierarchies of learning and devotion. In this sense, the Holy Cities functioned as pivotal spaces within networks that connected local devotional practices to universal prophetic origins, while the ways in which Maghribi scholars and pious pilgrims experienced and represented the Ḥaramayn may have contributed to articulating a transregional Islamic identity, locally rooted and universally oriented.
In South Asia, the rise of the Delhi Sultanate in the seventh/thirteenth century and the consolidation of regional sultanates in the eighth–ninth/fourteenth–fifteenth centuries were closely intertwined with the formation of Sufi lineages that anchored their authority in different kinds of ties to Mecca, Medina, and the Prophet.Footnote 54 Hagiographical collections and malfūẓāt (collections of the spoken discourses or conversations of a Sufi master) repeatedly stage shaykhs as travelling to the Holy Cities, receiving signs there, or being spiritually present at the Holy Cities. The Ḥaramayn could therefore structure sacred and genealogical geographies even when no physical journey was documented. Claims of Prophetic descent through ʿAlī and Fāṭima provided a parallel idiom through which ninth–tenth/fifteenth–sixteenth century actors situated local lineages within wider ʿAlid and Ḥaramayn-centred geographies, as Christopher Bahl shows in the present issue. These narratives of actual or imagined visits, combined with prestigious nisbas and chains of transmission, served to anchor Sufi communities vis-à-vis political elites and rival lineages, even though the precise ways in which Meccan and Medinan connections shaped the everyday social worlds of courts, madrasas, and Sufi lodges in the subcontinent remain only partially understood.Footnote 55
From the ninth/fifteenth century onwards, the Bahmani, Gujarat, Bengal, Malwa, and Jaunpur sultanates actively recruited administrators, scholars, soldiers, enslaved people, and other skilled personnel from western Asia and across the western Indian Ocean.Footnote 56 South Asian courts also attracted mobile scholars and Sufis whose itineraries had taken them through the Hijaz and Yemen, offering them patronage, administrative or scholarly appointments, and opportunities to teach and compose works.Footnote 57 Political and biographical sources likewise present Mecca and Medina as destinations for South Asian pilgrims and students and as places of encounter among South Asian, Red Sea, and Persianate actors, some of whom subsequently entered new scholarly or courtly settings. Yet the social profiles and trajectories of these circulations remain to be reconstructed systematically.Footnote 58 In the early Mughal period, the establishment of a state-sponsored caravan from Surat institutionalised one channel of movement between the empire and the Holy Cities, while Akbar’s later suspension of this caravan, as he asserted a more universal and court-centred religious authority, has been read as a telling moment in which facilitating or curtailing access to Mecca and Medina became a tool of imperial self-definition.Footnote 59 These fragmentary configurations leave open the question of how the symbolic capital of the Ḥaramayn was translated into concrete resources and positions within South Asian political and religious environments.
The modern historiography of the Hijaz
Early orientalist constructions of Meccan history
The formation of modern historical writing on Mecca emerged within the institutional and ideological frameworks of nineteenth-century European orientalism, bearing the marks of colonial epistemologies.
Ferdinand Wüstenfeld’s four-volume Chroniken der Stadt Mekka (1273–1278/1857–1861) was the first systematic attempt to narrate the city’s past, editing chronicles from al-Azraqī and al-Fākihī in the third/ninth century through al-Fāsī, Ibn Ẓuhayrah (d. 986/1578), and al-Nahrawālī (d. 990/1582) into the early Ottoman period.Footnote 60 His work offered only a cursory synthesis for the late medieval and early Ottoman centuries, reproducing selected annalistic entries rather than a dense narrative, thereby shaping later research around his own choices and omissions. Christiaan Snouck Hurgronje’s two-volume Mekka expanded this foundation through sources unavailable to Wüstenfeld, such as ʿAlī al-Sinjārī (d. 1125/1713), and through ethnographic observation from his 1301–1302/1884–1885 stay in Mecca and Jeddah.Footnote 61 The first volume devoted only brief attention to the late medieval period yet advanced an influential conception of Mecca that emphasised distance and autonomy over wider connections. The second volume’s focus on contemporary society, especially the Southeast Asian community, served Dutch colonial concerns while also embedding Mecca in broader Islamic networks. In the mid twentieth century, Gerald de Gaury’s Rulers of Mecca offered a more continuous political narrative from Mecca’s founding to 1925, drawing on al-Fāsī and travel accounts by Ibn Jubayr and Ibn Baṭṭūṭa alongside European sources.Footnote 62 De Gaury stressed the independence of the sharifs but engaged the primary materials unevenly, casting them in the shadow of Cairo and largely glossing over late medieval developments. These orientalist works identified key textual corpora and established basic chronologies, but their access to sources and their analytical frameworks were shaped by the colonial settings in which they worked and often privileged external imperial perspectives over local agency. They consequently reinforced an image of Mecca primarily as a religious site rather than as an urban polity with its own political, economic, and social dynamics, a framing that later twentieth-century scholarship would begin to dismantle even as some of its assumptions persisted.
Even when explicitly challenged, these early works still set the terms in which Meccan history appears, with Wüstenfeld’s editions sustaining much of the citation apparatus in non-Arabic scholarship and Snouck Hurgronje’s labels such as ‘political isolation’ recurring as shorthand for configurations that local sources describe in more differentiated fashion. Later re-editions, translations, and digital surrogates of the Chroniken der Stadt Mekka expanded access yet fixed a narrow nineteenth-century selection as an effective canon for readers distant from the manuscript tradition, and reliance on this limited group of chronicles confirmed a hierarchy of genres in which annals and political narratives eclipse legal documentation, fatwā collections, and waqf registers that could support a reading of late medieval Hijazi society less tied to events and more attentive to social regulation. Snouck Hurgronje’s ethnographic material, often read through the angle of colonial surveillance, supplied a pattern for later anthropological and sociological work on Mecca and the hajj and helped normalise the use of a late Ottoman ‘snapshot’ as a proxy for much earlier urban and ritual configurations, with the effect of fixing the Hijaz in a set of ahistorical constructs. A comparable reliance on modern ethnographic analogy appeared in several of R. B. Serjeant’s studies of Yemen and the Hijaz, in which mid twentieth-century observations were used to fill gaps in the premodern evidence and reconstruct earlier institutions and forms of social practice and regulation.Footnote 63
European philology, which may look like a sharp break, belongs instead to a longer history of textual work on the Hijaz, in which a quieter stratum of German, French, and Italian scholarship—from Carl Brockelmann’s Geschichte der arabischen Litteratur to Maurice Gaudefroy-Demombynes’s studies of the hajj and the long afterlife of Varthema’s account—helped decide which Hijazi texts would be visible, excerpted, and catalogued, even when Mecca was not the principal object of inquiry.Footnote 64 These orientalist constructions intersected with and selectively drew upon Ottoman, Indo-Muslim, Arabic, and Persian historiographical traditions that had already treated the city as a major historiographical concern, so that European orientalism appears here as one phase in a longer sequence in which Muslim scholars, Ottoman and Indo-Persian bureaucrats, and European philologists all contributed to determining what could be said about Mecca under specific imperial conditions, with the modern study of the city resting on overlapping, sometimes competing histories of scholarly practice rather than on a simple break between a premodern and an orientalist age.
From political and imperial narratives to a Hijazi-centred social history
The movement from general political surveys and imperial framings towards a more locally grounded social and political history unfolded gradually across the late twentieth century, as source engagement expanded and methods from wider Islamic historical studies were adopted.Footnote 65 This development was preceded by the work of several Saudi scholars, notably Ḥamad al-Jāsir (1910–2000), whose study of al-Samhūdī and role in publishing Rasāʾil fī tārīkh al-Madīna drew attention to Medina’s local historiographical corpus and made several little-known texts available to later researchers.Footnote 66 The decisive methodological shift, however, came with Richard T. Mortel’s work of the 1980s and 1990s. His doctoral thesis, published in Arabic in 1985 as al-Aḥwāl al-siyāsīyah wa-al-iqtiṣādīyah bi-Makkah fī al-ʿaṣr al-mamlūkī, represented the first comprehensive analysis grounded in systematic examination of both Meccan chronicles and Syro-Egyptian sources.Footnote 67 Mortel deployed local biographical dictionaries and annals alongside Egyptian materials to investigate the political, economic, and religious dimensions of medieval Meccan history. His numerous subsequent articles explored taxation, institutional endowments, scholarly networks, and commercial activities, assembling an empirical foundation of remarkable detail. The significance of this literature resided not merely in its descriptive wealth but also in its demonstration that Meccan sources existed in sufficient abundance to sustain a serious historical inquiry, still barely explored.Footnote 68
The interpretive framework guiding Mortel’s analysis remained partially shaped by Mamlūk historiographical traditions, which posited Cairo’s sovereignty over the Hijaz from the sultanate’s inception. Mortel argued that political turmoil generated by Meccan emirs facilitated Syro-Egyptian sultans’ establishment of hegemony, emphasising Cairo’s suzerainty over the Holy City. This Cairo-centric attitude, while more nuanced than earlier orientalist scholarship through its incorporation of local sources, still read Meccan political dynamics primarily through the lens of a Cairo-centred imperial power projection. Mortel’s strict analytical separation of political and economic dimensions could lead the sharifs to appear primarily as actors within the Cairo Sultanate’s environment and hegemony, and to understate the significance of maritime commerce and local political structures. Within this framework, recurring conflicts between the sharifs and Cairo could appear as manifestations of provincial disorder rather than interpreted as the pursuit of competing interests within a complex regional political economy. This work remained predominantly event-driven and factual, accumulating evidence without always developing broader analytical frameworks capable of explaining the patterns observed. As a consequence, it also anchored for several decades, perhaps incidentally, the study of the Hijaz within the broader framework of the so-called Mamlūk studies.
Parallel to Mortel’s efforts, other works in Arabic-language scholarship in the 1980s and 1990s followed similar trajectories, expanding the documentary basis for the social and political history of the Hijaz. These studies shifted towards more systematic analyses of administrative, economic, and scholarly structures, particularly under Mamlūk rule. Foundational studies thus scrutinised Meccan governance and its urban organisation, notably the consolidation of the Banū Qatāda emirate as a local power,Footnote 69 alongside studies of the economic circulations that sustained the city.Footnote 70 Institutional histories examined the judiciary and the management of the Ḥaram as key interfaces between local elites and Mamlūk authority.Footnote 71 Topographical investigations further tied urban space to social hierarchies and everyday practices,Footnote 72 and prosopographical research mapped the strategies and interlocking networks of elite Meccan households.Footnote 73
Work on endowments pushed the empirical turn further: Aḥmad Hāshim al-Badrashīnī’s research on waqf for the two Holy Mosques during the Mamlūk period published a substantial corpus of documents and showed how legal instruments sustaining religious and educational infrastructures also conveyed detailed topographical and economic information about the city, wells, caravan stations, and villages.Footnote 74 That demonstration established endowment deeds as key sources for urban morphology and historical geography of the Hijaz, as well as the material histories of ports such as Jeddah and Yanbuʿ. The analysis still focused more on pious intent and charitable function than on how waqf shaped property, controlled access to resources, or redistributed power among patrons.
From the 1980s onwards, scholarly families also emerged as a distinct object of research in studies of Meccan urban society, through mostly prosopographical and family-based studies. ʿAlī Maṭūq’s foundational prosopography on hadith transmission and transmitters in the Mamlūk period brought together major lineages such as the al-Ṭabarī, al-Nuwayrī, and Banū Ẓuhayra and traced their genealogies and contributions to scholarly transmission.Footnote 75 His study reconstructed social relations, while leaving questions of patronage networks and the politics of office-holding largely open. Subsequent academic studies largely followed this framework, cataloguing individual lineages and their educational and administrative posts, while leaving mechanisms of wealth accumulation, social reproduction, and intra-elite rivalry less systematically examined.Footnote 76
By contrast with the more extensive historiographical tradition centred on Mecca, a distinct historiographical terrain formed around Medina more gradually. To date, the history of the city and its hinterland has been remarkably neglected in modern scholarship. Outside the chronological scope of this special issue, the excellent work by Harry Munt, Holy City of Medina, demonstrated that Medinan historiography pursued historical topography with unusual precision during the formative centuries, recording sacred sites’ positions and legal status in ways that differentiated local writing from Egyptian and Syrian contemporaries.Footnote 77 Moving into the period addressed by this special issue, Munt’s study of al-Samhūdī (844–911/1440–1506) remains one of the few analyses to approach late medieval Medinan historiography as an object in its own right. By reconstructing the successive versions of Wafāʾ al-wafā and al-Samhūdī’s related works, Munt showed that the author’s preference for faḍāʾil and historical topography over annalistic or prosopographical history was a deliberate historiographical choice, shaped by patronage relations, intended readerships, and his own interventions in Medina’s sacred landscape. The case also demonstrates why Hijazi local histories must be incorporated into broader accounts of Mamlūk historiography, in which works produced outside Egypt and Syria remain markedly underrepresented.Footnote 78 Beyond this important study of an individual historian, however, scholarship on late medieval Medina remains strikingly limited. Mortel described the Ḥusaynid emirate as structurally fragile,Footnote 79 while Fumihiko Hasebe reconstructed how Cairo shaped Medinan society through administrative appointments, stipends, and the patronage of mujāwirūn, which contributed to the consolidation of Sunni norms and intersected with broader confessional and social transformations across western Arabia. These studies deepened our perceptions of Medina as an imperial periphery of the Cairo Sultanate, while simultaneously shifting analytical attention away from local dynastic politics. In a complementary vein, Shaun Marmon introduced a socio-ritual perspective that redirected focus towards the governance of sacred space, highlighting how authority and order in Medina were enacted through ritual practices and custodianship rather than formal political structures alone.Footnote 80
ʿAbd al-Raḥmān al-Mudayris’s al-Madīna al-munawwara fī al-ʿaṣr al-Mamlūkī is perhaps the most substantial attempt to date to synthesise political, institutional, and spatial evidence.Footnote 81 Building on a wide array of local chronicles, biographical dictionaries, and documentary material, he reconstructs the evolution of Medinan offices, endowments, and urban topography under Mamlūk rule, and offers a detailed map of the city’s leading families and their entanglement with Cairo-appointed authorities. Its focus, however, remains largely descriptive, engaging only in a limited way with how shifting configurations of power among emirs, leading families, and scholarly networks—together with trade routes, pilgrimage flows, and Medina’s embedding in its wider regional environment—reshaped the city’s social fabric. These studies delineate a historiographical landscape in which sacred topography mattered intensely, where the intervention of the Cairo Sultanate created specific institutional pressures, and the production of local history was closely connected to the definition and governance of sacred spaces, though the more systematic social history now available for Mecca still eludes us for Medina. Here too, the dominant analytical trend privileges institutional patronage over the social dynamics that animated urban life. This leaves unexplored how sacred geography, political networks, and everyday experience together shaped how inhabitants saw and lived in their city.
Taken together, this Arabic-language academic production broadened the empirical base of Hijazi history, often through doctoral research at Saudi universities, and opened fields largely absent from European, Japanese, and US scholarship. It reconstructed political structures, economic foundations, scholarly environments, endowments, offices, and elite families across nearly three centuries, especially for Mecca. A major contribution of this scholarship lies in establishing dense factual baselines and making new corpora available. Much of it remains event-driven and institution-centred, however, and only some studies develop explicit arguments on power, spatial practices, cultural circulation, social reproduction, or the wider regional environment of the Hijaz beyond its relationship with the Cairo Sultanate. This disjunction also reflects the persistent under-engagement of many scholars writing in English with Arabic-language work, despite the historical information it has brought to the study of Mecca and Medina.
Against this backdrop of largely event-driven, documentary, and institution-centred scholarship, John L. Meloy’s Imperial Power represented a watershed in Meccan historiography. One of the first works to directly challenge Cairo-centric narratives through systematic integration of Meccan local sources with broader regional material, Meloy’s research focused on the period between 797/1395 and 923/1517. It revealed that Meccan emirs maintained significant autonomy as political brokers mediating between the Mamlūk Sultanate and the local Hijazi elite groups, granting them considerable leverage in regional politics and trade. Rather than viewing sharifs as subordinate vassals or recalcitrant provincials managing the Holy City for the powerful masters of Egypt and Syria, Meloy demonstrated how they exploited their position as brokers to accumulate resources and resist external domination. They balanced local demands against sultanic interests through a nuanced, sophisticated politics of negotiation and political management. His analysis connected long-distance maritime trade flows through the Red Sea to transformations in Meccan political capacity, showing how commercial revenues empowered sharifs to build autonomous polities that maintained ceremonial recognition of Mamlūk overlordship while evading effective subordination. This reconceptualisation exposed the weaknesses of central imperial authority at its peripheries and the strengths of local orders embedded in a dense network of regional and inter-regional alliances and exchanges.
Recent scholarship has refined these insights across several dimensions. While already in 1990, Muḥammad Ṣāliḥ al-Ṭāsān’s work explored the role of the religious offices in the Sacred Mosque, including imams and preachers,Footnote 82 Layla ʿAbd al-Majīd’s 2010 study advanced a better understanding of the institutional structure within the Meccan polity, particularly examining how administrative and religious positions (al-waẓāʾif al-dīniyya wa-l-idāriyya) functioned within the city’s organisational framework. Her work underlined the structural foundations through which scholarly families (al-usar al-ʿilmiyya) exercised influence, revealing networks of patronage and authority that underpinned Meccan society during the seventh/thirteenth–ninth/fifteenth-century period.Footnote 83 Building on this, Nādia al-ʿAdwānī’s study Waẓāʾif ʿulamāʾ al-Ḥijāz wa-mihanuhum wa-ḥirafuhum wa-atharuhā ʿalā al-ḥayāt al-ʿāmma khilāl al-ʿaṣr al-Mamlūkī broadens the focus from Mecca to the wider Hijaz, including Medinan scholars, mapping how religious, scientific, administrative, and economic roles performed by scholars shaped religious, social, and economic life.Footnote 84 Complementing ʿAbd al-Majīd’s and al-ʿAdwānī’s institutional focus, Hanadi Abokadejah’s prosopographical reconstruction of three great Meccan families—the al-Ṭabarī, Banū Ẓuhayra, and al-Nuwayrī—demonstrated how scholarly lineages converted genealogy, offices, marriage, and education into durable social authority across the seventh/thirteenth through the ninth/fifteenth centuries.Footnote 85 Read alongside a work of social history such as ʿĀʾisha al-Qaysī’s study of how Meccan historians recorded crimes committed by slaves, which tracks social actors through the narrative fabric of local chronicles, several works now show that the Hijazi corpus encompassed a socially grounded reading of Meccan history.Footnote 86
Kaori Otsuya’s recent dissertation has also deepened our grasp of historiographical practices in the Hijaz, engaging with a comparative analysis of Meccan and Medinan historical writing. It treats local historiography as a medium through which Meccan and Medinan historians developed different narrative strategies to represent confessional change and to negotiate both their distinct confessional environments and the legitimacy of ʿAlid ruling houses. She argues that Sunni scholars writing under ʿAlid ashrāf—originally Shīʿī rulers—developed different narrative strategies in response to Mecca’s and Medina’s distinct confessional configurations. In Mecca, the Hasanid Dynasty’s shift from Zaydī Shīʿism to Sunnism by the early ninth/fifteenth century, under Mamlūk pressure, led Meccan authors such as al-Fāsī and the Banū Fahd family to craft inclusive narratives that legitimated the ashrāf as Sunni rulers. In Medina, where Ḥusaynid rulers with Twelver leanings remained influential longer, historians like Ibn Farḥūn instead framed Sunni ascendancy through stark transformation narratives, contrasting Sunni piety with Shīʿī oppression and highlighting the role of Sunni migrants and Cairo-appointed judges.Footnote 87
Clarck Junior Membourou Moimecheme’s 2022 dissertation also offers a new, detailed study of Meccan internal politics in the seventh/thirteenth–eighth/fourteenth centuries. He refines Meloy’s model by shifting from external relations to internal mechanisms, showing how titles such as amīr Makka, ṣāḥib Makka, sharīf, and sayyid anchored the dynastic legitimacy of the Banū Qatāda through a carefully calibrated lexicon of power, authority, and sovereignty. His analysis of power rituals demonstrates how the Qatāda family (597–797/1201–1395) staged authority through ceremonies in the Sacred Mosque, turning the proximity to the Kaʿba into both a spatial advantage and an ideological claim. Equally important is his use of the emiral ‘House’ (bayt) to map relations with sharifs, military leaders, Bedouin contingents, slave-soldiers, and urban notables, conceived as circles of dependents and clients exchanging service for benefaction. By reconstructing factional alignments across four phases, he underlined highly dynamic situations in which groups split, recombined, and competed through marriage, violence, and exile. His reading of conflict resolution highlights ṣulḥ (negotiated settlement) and truces as the normal mode of regulation of political competition within the Holy City, with Rasūlid and Cairo sultans usually mediating rather than ruling directly, as already illustrated by Meloy, recasting Meccan politics as a managed competition within the sharifian and emiral bayt.Footnote 88
Collectively, these studies have refined our understanding from Meloy’s foundational insight that Meccan emirs operated as semi-independent brokers between regional powers and local society. The field has now moved towards a more granular appreciation of how this brokerage actually worked: through institutionalised administrative positions, via historiographical self-fashioning that navigated sectarian tensions, by means of ritual performances of proximity to the sacred, within factional networks under constant renegotiation, and through conflict-management practices that preserved emiral autonomy by accommodating as much as possible rather than eliminating rival centres of power, at least most of the time. The result is a portrait of the Meccan emirate as possessing a level of political sophistication and complexity in the governance of its affairs that earlier twentieth-century scholarship had largely left unexplored and treated merely as an in-between space separating supposedly more fully articulated imperial formations. Precisely because of this, it is striking how much of the burgeoning literature on the hajj has approached the pilgrimage with only a limited engagement with Hijaz social history itself.
Hajj studies and the marginalisation of Hijazi history
Modern scholarship on the hajj has grown into a substantial and internally diverse field. Its centre of gravity, however, has rarely lain in the social history of Mecca and Medina themselves. From the late nineteenth century onwards, historians, orientalists, anthropologists and political scientists have treated the pilgrimage as a privileged entry point into Islamic ritual, jurisprudence, empire, global mobility, or contemporary Saudi governance, while Hijazi urban and rural societies have remained peripheral to the main lines of inquiry. The resulting corpus is therefore both rich and uneven, in the sense that it amasses a detailed knowledge about routes, rituals, caravans, and imperial states, yet often treats the Holy Cities primarily as symbolic destinations rather than as historically evolving environments populated by specific families, institutions, and conflicts, thereby leaving entire social ecosystems largely unexamined and separated from the core aspects of hajj studies.
From itineraries and ritual to social and economic readings of the pilgrimage
Foundational works of modern hajj scholarship were shaped by philological and historical concerns with the rites and itineraries of the pilgrimage. Gaudefroy-Demombynes’s study (1923) of the history, routes, and rites (manāsik) of the pilgrimage, for example, organised its material around the geography of the roads, the sequence of ritual acts, and their doctrinal underpinnings, drawing extensively on legal, historical, and travel sources to try to reconstruct what Muslims were supposed to do and how they moved. Later, Francis E. Peters’s volumes on Mecca and the hajj, including The Hajj: The Muslim Pilgrimage to Mecca and the Holy Places, extended this line of inquiry, offering a synthesis of scriptural foundations, juristic debates, and narrative accounts that traced the development of the pilgrimage from late antique precedents to the contemporary period, with special attention to the Kaʿba, the Ḥaram, and their ritual codification. Here too, Mecca and Medina appeared primarily as sacred topoi and ritual theatres rather than as objects of urban or social analysis in their own right.
Within this broader field, some studies on the Muslim West have also given the Maghribi and Andalusi dimensions of the hajj a sharper profile. Muḥammad Ḥaqqī’s article on the hajj in the Maghrib reconstructs how, from the fifth/eleventh century onwards, insecurity on land and sea-routes, Bedouin exactions, and Christian naval power turned pilgrimage from a routine practice into a burden that generated repeated fatāwā on whether the obligation still applied, whether it could be offset by jihād, and whether letters to Mecca or to the Prophet’s tomb could stand in for physical presence.Footnote 89 Maribel Fierro and Mayte Penelas’s Maghrib in the Mashrek follows Maghribi and Andalusi scholars who combined hajj, hadith study, and Mālikī law during their eastward journeys, and shows how their itineraries, anchored in visits to Mecca and Medina, tied al-Andalus and the Maghrib into Ayyubid and Mamlūk scholarly networks. Building on this, the collective volume edited by José C. Carvajal López and Maribel Fierro, Intellectual Connections Between Jazirat al-ʿArab and Jazirat al-Andalus, moved the focus towards a more explicit engagement with the Arabian Peninsula itself, tracing how Andalusi and Maghribi scholars engaged with Meccan and Medinan scholarly environments and how these dynamics had an important impact on both shores of the Islamic West and the Hijaz.Footnote 90
A related line of study has examined the office of amīr al-ḥajj as an institution that mediated between the sultanic authorities and Mecca. ʿĀʾisha al-ʿAbdalī’s ‘Imārat al-ḥajj fī ʿAṣr al-dawla al-Mamlūkiyya’ reconstructed the procedures of appointments, the responsibilities and military functions of the pilgrimage commanders dispatched from Cairo, Damascus, Iraq, and Yemen, and traced how the plurality of these umarāʾ (military commanders) and their overlapping jurisdictions affected the internal affairs of the Holy City.Footnote 91 In that regard, the office could fuel or mediate factional rivalries among the ruling ashrāf, play a role in the alteration of market prices, the organisation of the pilgrimage season, and the transmission of sultanic decrees that extended Cairo’s claims over the Ḥaramayn. Her analysis showed that the amīr al-ḥajj was far more than the commander of the caravan escort. His personality and conduct could determine pilgrim numbers, and his interventions in the city’s political disputes made the office a direct instrument of Mamlūk power projection into Hijazi urban life, an element also well integrated in Meloy’s Imperial Power. This body of work broadens the range of questions asked of the hajj, yet it still engages only intermittently with the social and political dynamics of Hijaz itself, and rarely treats Meccan and Medinan evidence as a field in which to think through the interplay of local orders, regional political economies, and global circulations, or to experiment with the analytical shifts captured by Jacques Revel’s Jeux d’échelles.Footnote 92
Routes, logistics, and imperial policies
The philological and ritual orientation exemplified by Gaudefroy-Demombynes carried within, from the outset, a second preoccupation: the material infrastructure of the great land routes from Damascus, Cairo, and Baghdad, and the regimes that secured, taxed, and provisioned them. From the 1980s onwards, this concern was extended by archaeological and historical studies of specific routes: Saad al-Rashīd’s work on the Iraqi Darb Zubayda and the station of al-Rabadhah, ʿAlī al-Ghabbān’s detailed reconstruction of the Syrian and Egyptian routes,Footnote 93 and Andrew Petersen’s collective volume on the Jordanian hajj road, which together discussed large sections of the land networks converging on the Hijaz and helped to define the six main itineraries most studied in modern scholarship.Footnote 94 Beyond late medieval history, tenth/sixteenth–eleventh/seventeenth-century Ottoman history extended this line in another temporal register. Suraiya Faroqhi’s Pilgrims and Sultans reconstructed caravan organisation, provisioning, route protection, and the management of Bedouin alliances from administrative correspondence and pilgrims’ accounts. It also showed how sultans and governors used control over the pilgrimage to claim authority and moral prestige.Footnote 95 Studies of the maḥmal and kiswa (the ceremonial cloth covering the Kaʿba, periodically renewed), from Jacques Jomier’s work on the Egyptian maḥmal to Venetia Porter’s essays on maḥmal processions and the Kaʿba’s covering, have in turn examined how specific objects and ceremonies carried imperial claims into Mecca.Footnote 96 Rishad Choudhury’s Hajj Across Empires adds a connected account of South Asian, Ottoman, and British actors, and of the ways Indo-Muslim pilgrims used the pilgrimage to negotiate imperial transition.Footnote 97
Exhibitions and catalogues such as Routes d’Arabie (Louvre, 2010), Hajj: Journey to the Heart of Islam (British Museum, 2012), and the Institut du Monde Arabe’s Hajj (2013) have also fixed selective cartographic images of the principal routes and their infrastructures, leaving others schematic or unmentioned, as in the case of Yemeni itineraries. These works lie outside the late medieval centuries that concern this issue, yet they define much current writing on the hajj as an affair of corridors, states, and flows.
Within this body of literature, the internal dynamics of the Holy Cities rarely form a specific object of study. Rivalries among sharifian lineages, the place of merchants and scholars in supply networks, or the impact of caravan rhythms on urban life tend to appear, if at all, as incidental remarks. Local Meccan and Medinan historiographical texts are often mined for isolated scenes—a maḥmal procession, a riot over provisions, a refurbishment of the Kaʿba—rather than treated as a corpus with its own narrative strategies, silences, and internal rationality.
Disconnects between Hajj scholarship and the history of Mecca and Medina
The result is a structural disconnect between hajj studies and the historiography of the Hijaz: routes, rituals, imperial claims, and state management are well documented, yet they remain only weakly integrated into the social and institutional histories of Mecca and Medina and the social worlds that made pilgrimage possible. When Mecca and Medina appear primarily as abstract ‘centres’ towards which pilgrims converge, the hajj acquires a timeless quality, and the profound transformations that reconfigured the cities between the seventh/thirteenth and tenth/sixteenth centuries recede from view: the consolidation and fragmentation of sharifian rule, the proliferation of madrasas and ribāṭs, the growth and reorganisation of the urban setting, the expansion of Jeddah as a commercial hinge, and the changing composition of scholarly and mercantile elites. Conversely, when local histories proceed without a solid engagement with pilgrimage literature, the hajj becomes a mere backdrop, although it shaped demographic pressure, commercial opportunity, imperial rivalries, cultural circulations, and social entanglements. The substantial body of evidence concerning scholarly interactions among the ahl al-ḥaramayn, established residents, and temporary mujāwirūn remains largely unexamined from social and cultural perspectives. How these communities subsisted, evolved alongside changes in the scale and organisation of the hajj, and participated in knowledge transmission across linguistic and cultural boundaries raises questions that await further investigation. One aim of this special issue is to help bridge this gap by bringing Meccan and Medinan sources into dialogue with hajj studies, showing how pilgrimage both depended upon and reshaped local configurations of authority, and arguing that the social history of the Holy Cities cannot be disentangled from the ritual and imperial geographies converging upon them.
Beyond recent scholarship on the Hijaz: new trajectories of inquiry
As we can see, contemporary historiography of the late medieval Hijaz has substantially revised older orientalist frameworks that stressed the political subordination of the Holy Cities and their ritual functions, yet the field remains marked by uneven development. The turn towards local sources initiated by Mortel and extended by Meloy has allowed for a more granular reconstruction of sharifian political strategies, commercial networks, and institutional environments. Critical editions of Meccan chronicles, such as al-Fāsī’s biographical dictionary al-ʿIqd al-thamīn,Footnote 98 his Shifāʾ al-gharām, a historical and topographical compendium on Mecca and its Ḥaram, or the Banū Fahd works spanning 150 years, have unveiled mechanisms of urban governance and factional competition invisible in Syro-Egyptian sources.
Four structural limits continue to constrain current scholarship. First, the bifurcation described above persists: studies of pilgrimage and studies of Meccan and Medinan societies still rarely ask how routes, rituals, and imperial claims were mediated by specific constellations of power, wealth, and knowledge within the Holy Cities. Second, the social and cultural history of the Hijaz beyond elite politics and formal institutions remains under-developed, particularly with regard to transregional religious connections. Studies often isolate Hijazi history from transregional contexts, failing to trace how hajj participation created connections linking Mecca to intellectual and religious currents across the Muslim world. The Hijaz’s role in the development of Sufism has been studied most extensively in its social and institutional dimensions for the eleventh/seventeenth century, through Numan Dumairieh’s work on Ibrāhīm al-Kūrānī (1025–1101/1616–1690). The seventh/thirteenth through tenth/sixteenth centuries remain comparatively unexplored, despite Mecca’s prominence in Sufi thought—the city in which Muḥyī al-Dīn Ibn ʿArabī began composing the Futūḥāt Makkiyya—and the apparent function of the Holy Cities as nodes connecting Southeast Asia, the Horn of Africa, Fārs, India, and the Arab lands. Yet the distinct roles played by the two Holy Cities in these exchanges, and the participation of Meccan and Medinan actors in them, remain poorly understood.
Studies of non-elite urban populations, gendered experiences of piety and scholarship, and everyday social practices are likewise largely absent. Even work that moves beyond rulers, state policy, and imperial control generally remains confined to scholarly elites, offering only occasional glimpses of enslaved men and women, petty traders, service workers, and the inhabitants of the Hijazi hinterland and smaller towns, who probably formed a substantial part of the populations of Mecca and Medina. Colonial and orientalist frameworks long presented the Hijaz primarily as a stage for imperial rule, dynastic politics, and ritual, further reinforcing this invisibility. These omissions remain a structural weakness of the field, rooted in sparse documentation, medieval writers’ limited attention to subaltern groups, and the lack of sustained work on class and gender before the expansion of the Ottoman documentary record in the tenth/sixteenth century. Although scholarship on early Ottoman Mecca is more developed than that on Medina, it likewise remains uneven and still lacks a comprehensive synthesis of the city’s social, institutional, cultural, and intellectual transformations under Ottoman rule.
Third, knowledge of Medinan history remains superficial, constrained by the absence of attention to questions partially addressed for Mecca. Political history, institutional structures, scholarly networks, and confessional transformations have been traced for Mecca with increasing sophistication. While scholarship has moved beyond the conditions that led Robert Hillenbrand in the late 1980s to describe much of the Peninsula's architectural history as ‘terra incognita’, expanding knowledge of Medina's early Islamic topography and urban development has not yet yielded a comparably integrated social and political history.Footnote 99 The ways in which Ḥusaynid emirs negotiated authority with Mamlūk governors or with competing local groups and elites, the role of scholarly families in political and social arrangements, and the institutional apparatus through which Medina was administered have received little scholarly attention. The Medinan dimensions of the transregional scholarly and religious networks discussed above remain particularly difficult to reconstruct. As Atef Alshehri noted in 2018, work on Ottoman Medina also remains fragmentary.Footnote 100 There is still no comprehensive local history of how incorporation into Ottoman dominion reshaped the city’s political economy, pilgrimage, and commercial connections, sacred authority, and scholarly institutions. This absence limits our understanding of Medina’s social, institutional, cultural, and intellectual development.
Fourth, a broader cluster of methodological, material, linguistic, and institutional barriers continues to constrain the field’s development. Approaches developed in recent decades that might yield fresh insights have not been fully adopted, including spatial analysis, network analysis, and digital methods. Much scholarship also remains dependent on narrative chronicles and biographical dictionaries, leaving the potential of documentary, paratextual, material, and spatial evidence insufficiently explored. Such evidence could help reconstruct the social and institutional structures of Mecca and Medina and clarify their relationships with wider social, cultural, and political environments in ways that narrative chronicles and ṭabaqāt alone cannot.
The extent of documentary loss and manuscript survival is itself difficult to gauge. Muḥammad al-Ḥabīb al-Hilā’s 1994 compendium al-Taʾrīkh wa-l-Muʾarrikhūn bi-Makkah identified more than 180 Meccan historians active between the third/ninth and the thirteenth/nineteenth centuries. They produced at least 846 works, dealing with history and related subjects or serving as sources for historical research. Although his figures extend well beyond the late medieval period, they reveal the scale of local scholarly production and the fragmentary survival of the Meccan textual record.Footnote 101 Though most texts remain lost or inaccessible, recognition of this local production corrected earlier assumptions about medieval Meccan historiographical neglect. Yet, overall, the scale and distribution of works relevant to the late medieval history of the Hijaz, as well as their circulation in the wider Muslim world, remain poorly understood: many titles survive only in later citations or partial copies, and reference works such as al-Ḥilāʾ’s survey underline how much of this textual landscape remains effectively invisible in under-catalogued and undigitised collections. Although the challenges remain considerable, important efforts have nevertheless been made to preserve and digitise manuscript collections in Saudi Arabia. The King Faisal Centre for Research and Islamic Studies, for example, reports a collection of more than 28,500 manuscripts,Footnote 102 while the Saudi Culture Ministry’s Libraries Authority has initiated the digitisation of the original collections of the King Abdulaziz Public Library and the King Fahd National Library to facilitate wider online access.
Beyond studies on the Hijaz, recent works in Islamic studies have increasingly drawn on understudied paratextual materials to reconstruct scholarly networks,Footnote 103 transmission chains, and institutional frameworks in ways unavailable through narrative chronicles alone.Footnote 104 Konrad Hirschler’s reconstruction of the Ibn ʿAbd al-Hādī Library in Damascus, for example, demonstrated how catalogues, ownership marks, and audition certificates could be integrated to recover the social life of books and the networks through which texts, scholars, and authority circulated across late medieval urban centres. This methodology could be profitably applied to Meccan and Medinan manuscript traditions but has not yet been attempted for the Hijaz,Footnote 105 apart from Christopher Bahl’s work on manuscript circulation, which draws on a wide range of paratextual information and marginalia.Footnote 106 The field has also yet to engage substantially with emerging technologies for manuscript analysis, including optical character recognition, handwriting identification, and computational collation. These tools could accelerate the production of critical editions and facilitate systematic comparison across manuscript traditions. Although digital humanities approaches to Arabic manuscripts remain unevenly developed, scholarship on late medieval Hijazi sources has been particularly slow to undertake even preliminary applications that could help to map textual relationships, variant readings, and transmission chains.
Archaeological research has nevertheless begun to reshape how the Hijaz is perceived and approached as a historical space. While this expansion is due in part to conflicts elsewhere in the wider Middle East, which have reoriented the geography of archaeological research, it also reflects the efforts of the Saudi Heritage Commission, the Royal Commission for AlUla (RCU), and their partnerships with institutions from France, the United Kingdom, Germany, Spain, and elsewhere. These initiatives form part of a broader programme of state-backed archaeological investment. Within north-western Arabia, the RCU has commissioned extensive long-term surveys and excavations across al-ʿUlā and parts of Khaybar, documenting tens of thousands of sites from the Palaeolithic to the present.Footnote 107 Excavations and surveys in the region of al-ʿUlā, at sites such as al-Mābiyāt/Qurḥ and Jabal Ikmah, have thus documented long sequences of settlement from the Bronze and Iron Ages through the early and middle Islamic periods. They have revealed urban fabrics and material traces of the Red Sea and overland trade that rarely surface in narrative chronicles.Footnote 108 The Khaybar Longue Durée Archaeological Project, involving Saudi and French teams, has identified Islamic-period settlements and mosques within a much longer sequence of occupation extending from the Bronze Age to the present. It underlined how oasis infrastructures and religious landscapes were repeatedly reworked over time, in the Hijaz as elsewhere.Footnote 109
Most published work focuses on the early Islamic or pre-Islamic and Nabataean phases, while systematic archaeological investigation of the late medieval Hijaz has scarcely begun.Footnote 110 This imbalance may partly reflect the current scarcity of archaeological data for these centuries. Future fieldwork on caravan facilities, maritime infrastructure, and late medieval layers at sites such as Jeddah and Yanbuʿ may yield evidence that permits a fuller assessment of the period. The prospects are more limited for the urban worlds described by al-Fāsī, the Banū Fahd, and al-Samhūdī for Mecca and Medina. Their accounts document changes in material culture and urban morphology through the construction of madrasas, ribāṭs, endowed complexes, and neighbourhoods reorganised around the Ḥaram of Mecca and the Prophet’s Mosque. Much of this historical fabric has been overwritten by modern redevelopment, while the cities’ status as sacred spaces imposes distinct constraints on excavation and survey. These transformations therefore remain accessible primarily through textual and documentary traces, although future archaeological research may still provide evidence from particular sites and peripheral areas.
This imbalance is partly institutional. Much of the published archaeological research considered has concentrated on sites containing monumental pre-Islamic or early Islamic remains, particularly at Hegra, Dadan/al-ʿUlā, and Khaybar. The late medieval fabric of Mecca, Medina, Jeddah, smaller Hijazi towns, their hinterlands, and the maritime front has received considerably less attention. The disconnect is also disciplinary. Historians of the late medieval Hijaz have engaged only intermittently with archaeological findings, while archaeologists working in the region have rarely interpreted their findings in dialogue with the rich historiographical corpus of the Mamlūk and early Ottoman centuries. Future research on the late medieval Hijaz would therefore benefit from a closer integration of textual, spatial, and archaeological evidence.Footnote 111
Linguistic divisions also limit engagement with different traditions of research, although the same could be said regarding the study of most regions of the Muslim world. Despite the significant productivity of Japanese and French scholars writing about western Arabia, these works remain largely invisible within anglophone scholarship, which currently dominates publication in Islamic studies. Yet, Fumihiko Hasebe’s article, ‘Kingship, eunuchs, and the mujāwirūn in Medina’,Footnote 112 Tsukada Ōta’s work on Zayn al-Dīn Ibn Muzhir (d. 893/1488) and his relation to the Ḥaramayn,Footnote 113 and Tamon Baba’s work on Rasūlid YemenFootnote 114 demonstrate the range of Japanese contributions. French-language scholarship has similarly opened important perspectives, of which two examples may suffice here. Éric Vallet’s analysis of al-Fāsī’s accounts of fitna (civil strife, factional conflict) shows how the recurrent narration of disorder could help neutralise its effects and traces while articulating an ideal of the emerging sharifian authority around Ḥasan b. ʿAjlān.Footnote 115 Drawing on new evidence, particularly Meccan accounts, Hadrien Collet reconstructs the previously obscure Arabian phase of Mansa Musa’s pilgrimage in 724–725/1324–1325, tracing his journeys between Cairo and Mecca and his stay in the Holy City.Footnote 116 To a lesser extent, perhaps the same could be said about several Iranian studies published recently, which shed light on otherwise understudied topics, including ʿAbbās Baṣīrī’s study of the cultural and social conditions in the Ḥaramayn during the Mamlūk period, Saʿīdah ʿAqīlī and Mahdī ʿIbādī’s study of pilgrimage routes during the seventh/thirteenth and eighth/fourteenth centuries, or ʿAlī Baḥrānī-Pūr’s analysis of the impact of Ilkhanid policies on maritime and overland pilgrimage routes throughout the Islamic world.Footnote 117
Today, the autonomy and agency of the late medieval Hijaz are better understood. The increasing use of local sources has also changed the way scholars engage with the region. Yet the late medieval Hijaz is still too often depicted as a marginal or peripheral space and its social relations, cultural practices, conflicts, and everyday life do not yet occupy a central place in historical analysis. However, it seems now possible to move towards a more comprehensive picture of the region’s history. The corpus has expanded and is more accessible. Studies of urban societies, knowledge transmission, and factional struggles in other regions now offer valuable points for comparison. A more deliberate engagement with this material, along with a framework that systematically places Mecca and Medina within transregional circulations, while keeping the internal social trajectories of the Holy Cities in clear view, would help strengthen our perspective on the history of this region. This special issue offers one contribution to that collective task.
The articles in this issue
The articles assembled in this issue pursue the history of the Hijaz through the intersection of family narratives, institutions, and textual practices that bound Mecca and Medina to the wider Islamic world between the seventh/thirteenth and tenth/sixteenth centuries. They use several approaches, from documentary analysis of waqf records to genealogical reconstruction, from intellectual history to the study of pilgrimage and teaching networks, from historiographical criticism to manuscript marginalia. These contributions privilege local actors and documentary sources to trace how genealogical prestige, pious endowments, and historiographical narratives operated as mechanisms for negotiating authority within the Holy Cities and across networks connecting them to distant courts, shrine centres, and trading hubs.
Christopher Bahl traces how one Medinese Ḥusaynid Sayyid lineage, the Āl Shadqam, transformed prophetic descent into mobile resources during the tenth/sixteenth century. Through genealogical treatises and Deccani court chronicles, Bahl examines the career of Abū l-Makārim al-Ḥasan b. ʿAlī b. Shadqam, who deployed his status as a kinsman of the Prophet to establish himself primarily at the Niẓāmshāhī court of Ahmadnagar in the Deccan while maintaining custodial and scholarly authority in Medina. Holding office simultaneously as naqīb al-ashrāf and mutawallī of the Prophet’s Mosque, al-Ḥasan quit Medina in 954/1547 to pursue an itinerant career connecting courtly and scholarly circles across the Hijaz, Iran, and the Deccan. His marriage to Fāṭḥ Shāh Begum, daughter of Sultan Burhān Niẓām Shāh, and the substantial royal patronage he received reveal how sayyid prestige became embedded in courtly and socio-economic relations across the western Indian Ocean. Al-Ḥasan’s genealogical treatise, al-Mustaṭāba fī nasab sādāt ṭāba, systematically traced Ḥusaynid lineages back to Zayn al-ʿĀbidīn, providing a textual foundation for claims to genealogical authority. His son Zayn al-Dīn’s nasab work presented al-Ḥasan’s genealogical standing alongside his role as a social and economic actor, fixing his transregional prominence within Medinese institutional memory. In Ahmadnagar during the tenth/sixteenth century, the Niẓāmshāhī court’s adoption of Imāmī Shīʿism under Shāh Ṭāhir created a favourable setting in which al-Ḥasan’s genealogical prestige and Medinese connections could be converted into courtly and socio-economic opportunities. As Bahl shows in this issue, his position illustrates how changing patterns of courtly patronage in South Asia opened new opportunities for sayyid families from Medina.
Takao Ito investigates the material infrastructure supporting the Ḥaramayn through Sultan Qāʾitbāy’s monumental waqf al-dashīshah, an endowment designed to distribute dashīshah (grain porridge) and bread in Mecca and Medina. Reconstructing this network from a manuscript that has received little scholarly attention, Ito demonstrates how properties in Egypt, Syria, and Medina were transferred into an endowment managed by successive Mamlūk and Ottoman administrators. Between 888/1483 and 895/1490, Qāʾitbāy endowed at least 82 properties, 63 of which, approximately 77 per cent, were located in Egypt, generating revenue to provision the Holy Cities with food, maintain educational and residential facilities, and fund dozens of scholarly and service positions. The waqf demonstrates how endowments functioned as durable institutions that participated in creating the material conditions for cosmopolitan exchange and political patronage. Pious foundations helped support extended residence and study in Mecca and Medina. The structure’s persistence is traced into the Ottoman period, when administrative continuity points to ongoing investment in the Holy Cities’ infrastructure. The waqf al-dashīshah thus emerges as an important material foundation that facilitated the growth of scholarly networks and translocal intellectual circulations analysed by other contributions to this issue.
Ryo Mizukami follows a Medinese scholar beyond the Hijaz, examining how Shams al-Dīn al-Zarandī (fl. 747/1346) theorised a specifically Sunni form of imamophilia in eighth/fourteenth-century Injuid Shiraz. Through close readings of Naẓm Durar al-Simṭayn and Maʿārij al-Wuṣūl, he shows that al-Zarandī selectively invoked recognised Sunni authorities and limited his use of Shīʿī materials, presenting veneration of the Twelve Imams as compatible with Sunni belief. In Maʿārij al-Wuṣūl, al-Zarandī questioned Muḥammad b. al-Ḥasan’s existence, occultation, and extraordinary longevity and rejected his identification as the Mahdī (saviour), although he apparently continued to count him among the Twelve Imams. Across the two works, he drew on authorities including the compilers of the Kutub al-Sitta, Abū al-Shaykh Ibn Ḥayyān, al-Ḥākim al-Naysābūrī, Abū Nuʿaym al-Iṣfahānī, and al-Bayhaqī. Mizukami cautiously situates this project within a possible rivalry between the Zarandī and Ḥammūyī families. Ṣadr al-Dīn al-Ḥammūyī’s grandson had established connections with religious figures in Kirman. Kirman had come under Muẓaffarid rule in 741/1341, and the Muẓaffarids were then engaged in conflict with the Injuids. Within this context, Mizukami suggests that al-Zarandī’s criticism of Ṣadr al-Dīn may have reinforced his own claim to religious authority before the Injuid ruler Abū Isḥāq. Al-Zarandī taught his four Shirazi works to local grandees and notables. His faḍāʾil writings later reached the Hijaz, where Ibn al-Ṣabbāgh used the Naẓm and al-Samhūdī drew extensively on both works. Al-Zarandī’s movement from Medina to Shiraz and the subsequent Hijazi reception of his writings show how Sunni imamophilia developed through the interaction of scholarly authority, dynastic conflict, patronage, and the circulation of texts.
John Meloy examines the chronicles of ʿIzz al-Dīn Ibn Fahd (d. 922/1516–1517) and his son Jār Allāh (d. 954/1547–1548) to reassess Mecca’s external connections during the decades around 1500. He identifies a gradual reorientation towards South Asia, visible in the increasing attention local chroniclers accorded to Indian commerce in non-luxury commodities and to alms dispatched by Indian rulers. Their accounts disclosed intersecting networks of trade, charity, and political influence that connected Mecca with India, Anatolia, Egypt, and Yemen, while showing how imported goods and distant patronage entered the city’s provisioning systems and social relations. Meloy thereby decentres historiographical accounts that view Mecca primarily through Cairo and challenges periodisations structured around the Ottoman conquest of 923/1517 or Portuguese intervention in the Indian Ocean. Viewed from Mecca and Jeddah, connections with India acquired greater visibility without displacing those with Ottoman lands, while commercial activity persisted despite Portuguese depredations. The Hijazi chronicles thus recover a local perspective from which conventional divisions between Mamlūk and Ottoman rule, and between the late medieval and early modern periods, appear less decisive than the continuities and gradual reconfiguration of Mecca’s commercial, political, and cultural networks.
Frédéric Bauden traces the emergence of the Banū Fahd as a scholarly dynasty whose authority endured from the eighth/fourteenth to the early eleventh/seventeenth century. Its material foundations lay in the conjunction of judicial service, commerce, and ownership of properties. Jamāl al-Dīn Muḥammad (d. 736/1336), deputy judge in Mecca, accumulated considerable wealth through trade, partly conducted by his brother al-Ḥasan in Yemen. These resources later financed education, travel, and the accumulation of manuscripts. Specialisation in hadith transmission began with Najm al-Dīn Muḥammad (d. 811/1408) and his sister Sitt Quraysh Fāṭimah (d. 827/1424), before Taqī al-Dīn Muḥammad (d. 871/1466) consolidated it into a durable dynastic project. Through the systematic education of his kin, the cultivation of visiting scholars, and the formation and endowment of a substantial library, Taqī al-Dīn converted the scholarly sociability generated by the pilgrimage into an instrument of familial reproduction. He served as principal reader during al-Maqrīzī’s Meccan sessions and integrated his children, including his daughters, into circuits of transmission that later generations extended through relations with scholars such as al-Sakhāwī. Reading statements, consultation notes, ownership marks, indexes, and surviving working manuscripts reveal the cumulative transmission of texts, licences to transmit, scholarly techniques, and social connections. The family library likewise served both descendants and, with occasional restrictions, Meccan and visiting scholars. Bauden thus presents scholarly dynastic authority as the cumulative outcome of intergenerational strategies.
Clarck Junior Membourou Moimecheme reassesses the power of the Banū Qatāda emirs between 597/1201 and 797/1395 through the representations preserved by local historians, particularly al-Fāsī, Najm al-Dīn Ibn Fahd, and ʿIzz al-Dīn Ibn Fahd. Their biographical and chronicle writing contributed to the historiographical normalisation of Meccan emiral authority by integrating the sharifs among the city’s notables, arranging successive rulers within a continuous dynastic history, and standardising genealogies, titles, and princely virtues. Membourou Moimecheme nevertheless shows that this increasingly sultanic representation did not erase the familial and factional foundations of the Banū Qatāda. Their authority rested upon Ḥasanid genealogy, the patrimonial organisation of competing bayts, and what he terms the ‘power of the House’: a spatial and genealogical construction linking the ahl al-bayt to the Bayt Allāh through a reciprocal ideology of protection. Sermons, official prayers, and ceremonies associated with the Ḥaram inscribed these claims within sacred space, while also expressing the shared suzerainty of Meccan emirs and external authorities. Territorial control, access to commercial and agricultural resources, and the mobilisation of dependants and allied factions allowed the emirate to develop into a largely autonomous regional political field. Its sovereignty nonetheless remained incomplete, constrained by its dependence upon external provisioning and the continuing interventions of caliphal and sultanic powers.
My own contribution examines how Taqī al-Dīn al-Fāsī (d. 832/1429) mobilised his biographical dictionary, the ʿIqd al-thamīn (The precious necklace), as an instrument to position his family within Mecca’s scholarly order. It traces the Banū al-Fāsī’s ascent from their establishment in Mecca in 686/1288 as a family of Maghribi origin to the highest levels of the city’s judicial and religious institutions by the early ninth/fifteenth century. Through the prominence accorded to prestigious scholarly affiliations, matrimonial alliances, and institutional appointments, al-Fāsī anchored this comparatively recent ascent in a narrative of piety, continuity, and established belonging. The article further situates this family history within a broader social configuration. By al-Fāsī’s lifetime, the Banū al-Fāsī had contracted marriages with at least seven of Mecca’s leading scholarly families, among them the Banū al-Ṭabarī and the Banū al-Nuwayrī, as well as with members of the Banū Qatāda emiral dynasty. The scholarly families within this interconnected group occupied many of the principal judicial, religious, and teaching offices of the city, while the alliance with the Banū Qatāda connected the Banū al-Fāsī to Mecca’s ruling house. Together, these relationships delineated a circumscribed elite whose reproduction rested upon matrimonial alliances, inherited scholarly capital, and access to scholarly and judicial institutions and the privileges they offered. The ʿIqd al-thamīn recorded this social formation while consolidating its historical memory, giving the interconnected elite to which al-Fāsī belonged a coherent, if highly selective, historiographical representation.
Across these diverse approaches, the articles converge on several insights about how authority was made, claimed, and expressed in the late medieval Hijaz. Historiographical practices simultaneously described and constituted political and social realities, as authors like al-Fāsī, Ibn Fahd, and al-Sakhāwī used biographical and chronicle genres to negotiate confessional identities, claim elite status, and legitimate ruling families. At the most local level, the articles reconstruct who served as judges, led prayers, distributed food to the poor, and controlled the libraries consulted by visitors. At the regional level, the actors and institutions examined connected the Hijaz to Cairo, Damascus, Shiraz, Zabīd, and Ahmadnagar through networks of scholars, officials, and charitable flows. At the conceptual level, the texts shaped how people understood legitimate authority, through ʿAlid genealogy, scholarly credentials, administrative service, or patronage of the sacred spaces and their scholarly and religious environment. The Holy Cities do not appear as static repositories of sacred memory but as centres where actors with agency negotiated authority, fashioned dynasties, and constructed their own legacies within and across the networks of the Islamic world.
What emerges is a historical field characterised by dynamic interactions. The Āl Shadqam’s rise connected Medinan genealogical authority to confessional and political realignments at the Niẓāmshāhī court. The Banū Fahd converted Mecca’s pilgrimage centrality into scholarly capital by cultivating visiting scholars, transmission networks, and access to their library. Qāʾitbāy’s endowment translated Mamlūk patronage into an institutional infrastructure that continued to support the Holy Cities under Ottoman administration. Al-Fāsī’s historiography simultaneously asserted his family’s position and helped define the criteria by which elite status was recognised in Mecca. These cases collectively show that genealogical prestige, institutional resources, textual authority, and political power did not operate independently. They were repeatedly mobilised and reconfigured by actors pursuing intersecting strategies across local and transregional scales.
***
The articles in this volume take as their starting point the proposition that neither Mecca nor Medina can be treated as an isolated ritual destination or a marginal extension of imperial politics. They approach the late medieval Hijaz as a region of complex societies, in which political economies, institutions, scholarly networks, and confessional alignments appear to have responded to, and sometimes reshaped, factional conflict, pilgrimage movements, and wider circulations of knowledge, piety, and power. Taken together, they propose that the late medieval Hijaz may be approached perhaps less as a peripheral zone of history than as one of the sites in which political, economic, social, and intellectual shifts within the Dār al-Islām were argued through, contested, redirected, and given distinctive local forms between the seventh/thirteenth and the early tenth/sixteenth centuries. This account necessarily remains partial and open to revision.
Acknowledgements
I owe heartfelt thanks to Frédéric Bauden, Harry Munt, Christopher Bahl, and the anonymous reviewers for their incisive and constructive comments on earlier versions of this introduction. The argument also benefited immeasurably from the many conversations on the late medieval Hijaz that we had with Evrim Binbaş, José Carvajal López, Maribel Fierro, Albrecht Fuess, and Sarah Savant in 2025 and 2026. I am deeply grateful for their intellectual generosity and critical insight.
Conflicts of interest
None.
