This is an excellent introduction to a personality and phenomenon too long relegated to the margins of “what is really important in Islamic studies.” Both the publisher and the author are to be congratulated for bringing to light, as if it were a normal human activity, a movement and religious orientation that is normally minimized—not to say anathematized—by the orthodox (whether confessional or academic) but that continues to have serious influence in the religious and spiritual life of Islam. The man and the movement represent perhaps the most well-known, historically significant style of piety that may be characterized as an apotheosis of the logocentric orientation and potentialities of the Islamic theophany.
The hero of this story, Fazl Allah Astarabadi (d. 1394), “was an Islamic religious leader who believed that the world was about to come to an end and that he had been appointed the final divine messenger for humanity” (p. ix). Apart from excellent but necessarily brief articles in the Encyclopaedia of Islam and Encyclopaedia Iranica, prior to this book scholars had really only two or three sources of information, and none of them was readily available to an English audience (Clement, Kiya, Lory, and Ritter). Some years ago an attempt to improve this situation was offered by Norris in a fine article on the legacy of the Hurufis. All of these earlier discussions are noticed and utilized to one degree or another (the recent foundational work by Mir-Kasimov was not yet published). The author, however, has improved upon them in a number of ways, and the result here is “the most comprehensive academic treatment to date” (p. x).
Bashir divides his book into seven sections, in an obvious gesture of homage to Astarabadi's ministry and confession. Despite the very careful language quoted previously, Bashir considers his subject to have been a bona fide Muslim. Chapter 1 (pp. 1–18) is on the early life; Chapter 2 (pp. 19–32), “Enlightenment,” discusses the event and, more important, the terms in which the Islamic annunciation occurred; Chapter 3 (pp. 33–43), “Death,” is the neutral word that covers the range of interpretations of the event, from criminal execution to martyrdom; and Chapter 4 (pp. 45–60), “Cosmos and Humanity,” delves into the Gedankenwelt of Astarabadi. Chapter 5 (pp. 61–84), “Apocalypse, Language, and Salvation,” highlights the robustness of the form and content of a so-called “glory motif” in the present instance of Islamic apocalypticism and is worth reading twice. Chapter 6 (pp. 85–108) is titled “Shrine and Successors,” and the books ends with Chapter 7 (pp. 109–27) and an appendix (pp. 129–31) on Hurufi literature (primary and secondary), a guide to further reading (pp. 132–33), and an index (pp. 135–41).
Although the man and his legacy may be seen here as another stage in the assertion-cum-sacralization of a Persian cultural and linguistic “nation” (an earlier stage being the life and work of Shihab al-Din Suhrawardi, al-maqtul, d. 1191), followed by the enormous impact of the poetic achievement of Jalal al-Din Rumi (d. 1273), the degree to which the Hurufi moment is clearly dependent upon an Arabic apperception of theophanic problems is not sufficiently indicated. Although we are assured that the text is based upon the writings of Astarabadi and his followers, almost no direct quotation of these is present. The few times that they are quoted, the influence of Arabic is obvious. More to the point, the influence of the highly sprung language of the greatest exponent of Arabic mystical exposition, Ibn ʿArabi (d. 1240), is obvious. As the author indicates (p. 67), both Ibn ʿArabi and others before and after him were fascinated by the expressive/experiential possibilities inherent in a sacred alphabet.
The problem of Shiʿi Islam is, appropriately enough, also conspicuous by its absence. The terminology and forms of Shiʿi messianism populate both the author's text and those few quotations he has translated throughout the book. The chiliastic office—“master of the age” (doubtless ṣaḥib-i zaman), so translated in the (unreferenced) quotation from Nafaji—is unlikely to have been heard or read by anyone capable of dissociating it from Shiʿi messianic expectations/aspirations (either then or now). Both the earlier Sufi tradition and the complex Shiʿi tradition should have had more space in this work, where topics such as “divine self-manifestation/tajalli,” “return/rajʿa,” and “resurrection/qiyama” might have been introduced with some fuller notice of their various historical contexts and intentions. Such would have added to an appreciation for the power with which Fazl Allah Astarabadi's own experience and expression thereof was able to capture the hearts and minds of an impressive army of followers.
Granted, the book is published as one in a series meant to give a relatively brief account of individual “Makers of Muslim World,” and space is at a premium. One looks forward, therefore, to a fuller discussion of the Hurufis from this scholar, whose ability to encapsulate whole swaths of complex religio-philosophical landscape in remarkably accurate, faithful, and concise language verges on the (licitly) magical. The contribution made here is to the broadening of an understanding of the variegated forms of Islamic piety at once unified in their logocentric and rationalist orientation and differentiated according to the various centers of that distinctively Muslim category of “spiritual” authority known as walaya, recognized from time to time by its bearers and proponents.
