No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 February 2005
In the course of some forty years, Jacques Waardenburg (b. 1930), a Dutch-born scholar of Islam and comparative religions, has produced a stream of work on contemporary Islamic thought, society, and culture in the modern Islamic world, East–West relations, Muslims in Europe, and the “science of religion” (Religionwissenschaft). Widely cited is his L'Islam dans le miroir de l'Occident (Paris, 1963), a close, methodical study of significant figures of Orientalism such as Ignaz Goldziher, Carl Becker, and Louis Massignon. According to the author's very useful survey of Orientalism in the second edition of the Encyclopaedia of Islam, a third edition of the book was published in 1970.
The present work is a collection of essays that reflect the breadth of Waardenburg's interests. An introduction situates the stages of his career against the recent history of Islamic studies in the West. It serves his immediate purpose—that is, to provide a sense of his training and research areas—but one wishes for a bit more substance here, given the extent of his career and publications. Thirteen of the nineteen essays appeared previously between 1979 and 1995. Each was apparently revised for the present volume (no attempt was made for this review to assess the extent of the revisions).
Inevitably in a work of this sort, particular chapters are more successful than others. Two essays (chaps. 3 and 4) on theoretical approaches to the study of Islam, for example, are more suggestive than substantial. Other essays have a narrow focus and thus will be chiefly of interest to specialists and students in the respective fields. Chapter 1, for example, “Changes in Belief and the Rise of Islam,” outlines the “reordered” spiritual landscape of Arabia following the onset of Muhammad's teachings. The essay can be read usefully alongside those cited by Robert Hoyland in his chapter on pre-Islamic Arabian religion (Arabia and the Arabs [London, 2001], 139–66). Similarly, Waardenburg's essay (chap. 11) on the history of the Wahhabi movement prior to the establishment of the Saudi state provides a succinct narrative of events leading to the movement's success. A companion essay on Daniel van der Meulen (d. 1989), Dutch consul in Jeddah and later minister plenipotentiary in 1926–31 and 1941–45, is of even narrower interest, though it provides, from Van der Meulen's own writing on his tenure in the Hijaz, an intimate glimpse of

Abd al-Aziz ibn Sa

ud, founder of the Saudi state.
More substantial are essays on currents of the modern Islamic world. While again it is difficult to find the appropriate means to assess a long and wide-ranging set of essays, the remaining chapters tend to view their respective subjects in broad historical and theoretical terms. The modern Islamic world in recent years has come in for considerably more than its share of attention by journalists and scholars alike, so, particularly for specialists, Waardenburg covers much familiar territory. Many of these essays, however, could be used to positive effect in the classroom. Waardenburg is sensitive to the array of ideological currents that have surfaced from Morocco to Indonesia, all in the name of Islam, and for the most part avoids explicit judgment of his subject. Students may have trouble with Waardenburg's formal style (notwithstanding the effort to render the author's “hollandish English into present-day American English” [p. vii]). Waardenburg also hews closely to the apparent dictates of a “history of religions” approach. He is interested throughout, as he says early on, in the problem of meaning, particularly when cast in religious forms.
Chapter 7 introduces the thought of six modern North African scholars (Bennabi, Djait, Merad, Talbi, Laroui, and Arkoun) as it relates to the Islamic tradition and the impact of colonialism and modernity. Arkoun—and little surprise, given the extent of his writing on these topics—receives the largest share of attention. Waardenburg is clearly receptive to Arkoun's reasoned, cosmopolitan approach to the study of Islam and religious traditions more generally. A subsequent chapter, “Human Rights, Human Dignity, and Islam,” seems particularly timely given recent turns in the U.S. occupation of Iraq. It provides, as do many of the other chapters, a decent bibliography.
Six chapters on modern formulations of Islam—one might say, overtly politicized forms of the tradition—close the book. These later essays, if one can generalize, concern the variety of reactions by Muslim ideologues, movements, and nation-states to the project of nationalism and state formation, on the one hand, the presence of a postcolonial West, on the other. Again, Waardenburg is careful enough to underscore the variety of formulations and stances—the shaping of plainly Islamic forms of political ideology, the emergence of what he terms “new Islamic states” (Saudi Arabia, Iran, Pakistan, Libya), and the shaping of Islamic protest movements, for example—adopted by states and nonstate players alike.