For those of us who teach cultural production by or about minoritarian subjects, one line of questioning feels inevitable with each new batch of students: Is this representation of identity good or bad? In Dissatisfactions: Queer Latinidad and the Politics of Style, Joshua Javier Guzmán productively needles this provocation by revealing (and reveling in) “the internal contradictions” of identity politics and representation (16). Dissatisfactions maps a trajectory of what Guzmán calls “stylized discontents,” aesthetically inflected manifestations that evidence the political and affective structures shaping minoritarian experiences in Los Angeles from the late 1960s through the height of the AIDS epidemic (7). The titular dissatisfactions include “nausea, lo-fi, ambivalence, and malaise” (19); each grounding one of the book’s chapters. These styles emerge in film, conceptual art, literature, experimental performance, and other underground or do-it-yourself (DIY) cultural production by queer Chicanos and those with resonant discontents. Rather than revealing any fixed identity in representation, Guzmán instead argues that these dissatisfactions evidence queer latinidad as a “sensibility across social difference” (35). By following minor strains in cultural production that resist identity politics’ normalizing call for coherent representation, Guzmán stages minoritarian cultural production that emerges from and produces a commons.
Dissatisfaction opens with an early performance by the band Nervous Gender, one cornerstone of punk’s early queercore movement that centered gender and sexual deviance in lyrics, performance, and style. The 1979 performance by the quartet of androgynous, primarily Chicano queers is described as a difficult one. Staged as part of a feminist, all-women, fundraising event, Nervous Gender’s style rubbed against the event’s frame, “which both titillated and confused its audience” (1). This dissonant encounter offers one example of the generative possibilities of thinking with styles as aesthetic representations of politics and the commons they create. Building on José Esteban Muñoz, whose influence on the fields of performance, queer, and Latino studies is palpable throughout, Guzmán argues that discontent produces a communal feeling of lack in the present. This signals a desire for some future, one forestalled by, if not impossible due to, the material conditions shaping minoritarian life. For Guzmán, these dissonant tensions are more generative sites for analysis than any categorically fixed identity.
From this vantage, Guzmán’s project aligns himself with “a ‘new wave’ of queer Latino scholarship” by offering an “unflinching critique” of overly tidied representations and identities, namely, an idealized Chicano identity or universalizing formation of latinidad (16). Such identitarian questions inherently invoke the “systems of oppressions, or forms of violence, discrimination, and the like” that structure the norms by which political quality is measured (16). Yet they fail to question how those norms calcify in dominant and minoritarian spheres in the first place or interrogate the impact of that political policing on queer people. To resolve these hermeneutic limits, Gúzman finds productive tension in the aesthetics of “ambivalent, equivocal style politics” that emerge materially and relationally like those described at Nervous Gender’s performance (16). Guzmán’s refiguring emerges largely from a critique of the “postpositivist realism” of gay Latino studies that disavows much (presumably white) queer theory that remains generative for Guzmán (116). Indeed, Dissatisfactions engages a range of intellectual interlocutors, drawing together Marxist, Frankfurt School, and psychoanalytic philosophy, foundational queer and performance studies work by scholars including Muñoz and Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick, and others in this “new wave” of queer Latino scholarship, perhaps most notably the work on abjection by performance studies scholar Leticia Alvarado.
The case studies guiding Dissatisfactions, too, are promiscuously productive in their diversity. Presented in chronological order, they develop a rich tapestry of the dynamic materiality of Los Angeles from which they emerge. After the Introduction’s engagement with Nervous Gender, Guzmán turns in Chapter 1 to the Chicano performance group Asco, French existentialist Jean-Paul Sartre, and the punk band X to describe how nausea became an emotional habitus in post-1968 Los Angeles. Guzmán argues that Asco’s style rejected assimilation into US politics while remaining “‘cool’ in its flatness and disinterest toward the Chicano movement” (73). This “political disorientation” produced a nausea around identification, which “movement amplifies” and makes contagious (41–3). Chapter 2 explores the stylized discontent of lo-fi in the late 1970s and early 1980s, a mode of representing identities with a low fidelity to norms. Thinking with the careers of Chicano punk artist Alice Bag and others like Vaginal Davis, The Brat, and Simone de Beauvoir, Guzmán suggests that lo-fi “becomes embodied as an attitude in the process of reworking life’s constitutive lack” (108). This transmits “knowledge about the limits of norms, a knowing that escapes the confines of the here and now and that exists in the future” (108).
Now in the mid-1980s amid the growing AIDS epidemic, Chapter 3 finds Guzmán’s most pointed disciplinary intervention. Here he resoundingly critiques the identity politics inherent to gay Latino studies invested in “postpositivist realism,” disavowing what he argues is its ahistorical rendering of coherent identities. Instead, he turns to ambivalence, a style that, in the video work and writing of Ray Navarro, literature of Gil Cuadros, and sculptural work of Laura Aguilar, reveals “a subject’s willful refusal to be fully knowable and therefore potentially masterable” by those that left queer Latinos to inevitable deaths from AIDS-related illness (114). In Chapter 4, Guzmán closes by turning his attention to malaise, a style—inflected by Freudian pessimism—that characterized video by Aguilar, conceptual art by Felix Gonzalez-Torres, and films by Gregg Araki. Here, Guzmán explores how the agnosticism of malaise, “a diffused yet ubiquitously palpable cynicism,” resulted in a withdrawn social realm that refused both separatism and assimilation (155). Counterintuitively, this dissatisfaction signals and perhaps produces desire—for pleasure, beauty, joy—despite an overarching disappointment.
Returning to the opening question, Dissatisfactions might suggest that representation’s impossibility defangs minoritarian cultural production. Yet Guzmán concludes on a Muñozian note, offering that the impulse to try reveals “oneself enmeshed in a constellation of differences; admiring the horizon over which a new dawn fades into the negative” (200). Thus, minoritarian cultural production remains vital to being-in-difference, even and maybe especially when emerging in these dissatisfied styles.
