For a particular reason, there is not that much that can be said in reviewing this edition of this new text. For those that have brought this text but also posses the original 2001 first edition, they may feel somewhat ‘cheated’ if they did not read the preface or the back cover to this second edition before making that purchase. The vast majority of this book (in fact ten out of its 11 chapters) is essentially a direct lift from the original. Only the final chapter entitled The Saga Continues: The District Health Board System and Beyond, is an actual update from the 2001 position to today. This final chapter, while of interest, is quite brief and superficial of the substantial changes that healthcare has undergone over recent years in New Zealand – since the first edition of this book. While a relatively recent event in New Zealand, there has been a change of government post-2008 – from the Labour to the National Party. The final chapter mainly discusses issues relating to the last Labour government. Appreciating that this book was most likely to have been in the review and proof stages during the early stages of this change in government, nevertheless lively discussion and debate was in place quite some time before the event. One would have expected far more than the brief final two-page indication of the implications of this event – both immediately post-2008 and into the future.
The central bedrock of recent New Zealand health service reform has been the specific targeting of Māori and Pacifica populations. The vast majority of current New Zealand health service funding, policy and research places a heavy emphasis on targeting indigenous populations who are disproportionately over-represented in mortality and morbidity statistics and under-served in terms of health service access and on-going quality care provision. While indigenous issues are discussed in the final chapter, they are not covered to the depth that one would expect to see. One of the more emotive and controversial health service reforms in New Zealand of the last few years concerning the health professions, has been the relatively rapid implementation of the nurse practitioner role. This role has evolved against the backdrop of the current and predicted future dropping in numbers of GPs in the national workforce. Particularly, against the backdrop of community-based nurse practitioners with prescribing rights, much debate has ensued – most vehemently between the medical and nursing professions. There is barely a mention of this context in the final chapter, which is a large omission.
The original text was certainly worth buying up to five-years ago as a representation of health policy in New Zealand leading up to the early part of this decade – but is obviously too dated now to offer a current perspective. Where this text will appeal to readers is to those, both nationally and internationally, who have a particular interest in the recent history of healthcare reform in New Zealand. Specifically, what is done very well in this book is the discussion and critique around the historical context of the reformation of a general New Zealand health service a decade or so ago into its current structure – with the formation of District Health Boards, Primary Health Organisations and Non-Government Organisations. However, for those looking for a very recent and extensive critical exploration and update on New Zealand healthcare reform at the end of this decade compared with the early and mid-part of this decade, this text may leave the reader somewhat wanting.
