When Evo Morales's government called a Constituent Assembly in 2007, two indigenous organisations stepped forward as key protagonists. The Confederación Sindical Única de Trabajadores Campesinos (CSTUCB) (Unitary Union Confederation of Peasant Workers) and the Consejo Nacional de Ayllus y Markas del Qullasuyu (CONAMAQ) (the National Council of Ayllus and Markas of Qullasuyu) represented nearly all of the country's indigenous peoples during the assembly's 2006–07 deliberations.
Radoslaw Powᶒska's rigorous and thoroughly researched study uses social movement theory to examine these organisations' history and their roles in the assembly. His main contention is that not only does collective identity shape the form an organisation takes, coherence between these two aspects is essential for the organisation to effectively represent its members' demands. Collective identity and shared values are critical to movement formation, and also shape organisational structure, agenda and strategy as Powᶒska admirably demonstrates through a wide-ranging use of secondary sources, both Bolivian and international, and extensive interviews with social movement actors.
While the Morales government embraced the social movement demand for a new Constitution, it also made concerted efforts to control the Constituent Assembly process through its influence over the Pacto Unidad. This Unity Pact was formed in 2004 and comprised of the country's five principal indigenous movements, including the CSTUCB and CONAMAQ.
Radowska posits the ayllu as the key element in understanding both highland state-indigenous relations and who the CSUTCB and CONAMAQ were when they participated in the Constituent Assembly. Despite regional variations, he contends that the ayllu's high degree of internal organisational coherence and its defence of communal autonomy has shaped all recent indigenous organisational forms and demands whether after the 1952 Revolution or during the 1990s period of multicultural neoliberalism.
The CSUTCB is the country's largest indigenous organisation with affiliates nationwide, although its origins were in the highlands in the late 1970s. From its beginnings, the organisation was closely aligned with the then-powerful labour movement, and espoused a hybrid analysis of class and ethnicity. For almost 20 years, it served as the primary political vehicle for indigenous people.
Powᶒska argues that the CSUTCB's umbrella structure meant that it lacked shared approaches to territory and community which would have given it internal coherence. While it fostered high degrees of participation at the community level – even though traditional, non-union authorities were often marginalised or ignored – the CSTUCB was top-down at leadership levels, with almost no participation by women.
CONAMAQ emerged as a direct competitor to CSTUCB in the late 1990s in the southern highlands. Organised along ayllu lines, it saw the CSTUCB as too western and not a genuine representative of indigenous people. Outside non-governmental organisations, both national and international, played a critical role in its ascendance, using their funding to shape debates about what and who was considered indigenous, culturally and politically important and even authentic. CONAMAQ has a high degree of internal coherence with a consistent political agenda which has proven invulnerable to changes in leadership. Grounded in a strong sense of territory, it prioritises decolonialisation, indigenous autonomy and self-determination. While discursively championing women's history of participation in the ayllu, in practice men still make public decisions almost exclusively.
Once the two organisations became immersed in the Constituent Assembly, their relationships with the MAS became paramount in shaping the outcomes of their agendas, and indeed their futures. The CSTUCB's close alignment with the government, Powᶒska contends, meant that much of its base remained underrepresented in the assembly and their demands not heard. In contrast, while CONAMAQ's demands were coherent and unshakable, their frequent opposition to government positions made their alliance with the government through the Pacto Unidad highly unstable. The end result was that many CONAMAQ proposals did not go through, for example: no indigenous autonomies are permitted beyond the local level; prior consultation over proposed projects in indigenous territories is not binding on the government and indigenous groups do not control non-renewable resources on their lands.
While Powᶒska's arguments are compelling, I wonder if CONAMAQ's greater internal coherence can in part be attributed to its briefer history, smaller size and the homogeneity of its membership. In contrast, the CSTUCB is almost 20 years older, much larger, and far more heterogeneous in its composition. The early CSTUCB emerged in a time where the labour union struggle through the umbrella Central Obrera Boliviana was the only viable option pressing for political, social and economic change. The CSTUCB's decision to become an ideologically hybrid organisation seems pretty coherent in that context. Like so many social movements, the CSTUCB functioned reasonably well in opposition, but has floundered in pursuing its former more radical agenda once aligned with the government in power.
Since Powᶒska's book was completed, the MAS weary of CONAMAQ's opposition to it on almost every issue, employed in 2011 an old divide-and-conquer tactic: setting up a parallel organisation. Given that this twin organisation has all the funding, the original CONAMAQ has become a shadow of its former self. Arguably the CSTUCB, still closely affiliated with the government, is a shadow of its former self as well, as it obediently takes it direction from the top rather than forcefully articulating proposals from its bases.
But the bigger question raised by Powᶒska's research is what does the organisational/identity incoherence that he points to between CSTUCB and CONAMAQ mean for a future national level articulation of indigenous rights in Bolivia. Now that its rival CONAMAQ has been effectively destroyed, is the CSUTCB more or less able to articulate a distinct indigenous vision?
The problem of absorption and co-optation by a powerful, relatively progressive state is another chapter in the long struggle for indigenous rights in Bolivia. This book not only makes an important contribution to understanding the differences in perspectives, rivalries and functioning between indigenous organisations, but also to the broader issues that confront movements for social change everywhere.
