Yusuf Sarfati's Mobilizing Religion in Middle East Politics is one of a growing number of studies that challenge the overly simplistic secularization thesis—namely, that stable and lasting democracy requires a secular state—in favor of more nuanced explanations of the relationship between religion and politics in democratic settings. The secularization thesis has dominated literature in the study of religion and politics following the momentous resurgence in recent decades of religious political movements around the globe, and, more particularly, the growing power of political Islam in the Middle East and beyond.
The book is both an innovative and a timely study of the social bases of religious mobilization in the political arenas of the only two democratic Middle Eastern regimes: Israel and Turkey. It is innovative for two reasons. First, it studies the issue of religious mobilization from a social mobilization theory perspective, which researchers have commonly applied in the study of secular groups in Western democracies. By so doing, Sarfati implies that we should consider religious groups important components of civil society, thus challenging the dominance of the overly liberal school of civil society. Second, Sarfati's book compares the mobilization of religious groups in Israel and Turkey, two states that scholars rarely analyze together. At first glance, such a comparison might raise eyebrows. Turkey and Israel are different in many respects, including size, political history, geostrategic situation, and most importantly, dominant religion and state policy vis-à-vis religious actors. While Israel granted religion and religious actors an important official role in the state, the Kemalist founders of the Turkish Republic took considerable measures to marginalize them from the social and political sphere. However, Sarfati shows that differences between Israel and Turkey make the insights that emerge from a comparison between them more generalizable. Throughout the book, he shows how religious actors in both contexts used similar strategies to engage the state. This is especially true in regard to their effective identification of political windows of opportunity and framing of grievances vis-à-vis the state and the broader society. For example, in Turkey in the 1970s and Israel in the 1980s, religious factions formed formal parties and joined the government as coalition partners in times of political stalemate, thus exploiting the needs of dominant political groups. The evidence suggests that there exist common patterns of mutual interaction between states and religious groups, regardless of context.
Mobilizing Religion is timely because it appears in a moment of profound political transformation in the Middle East. The consolidation of religion as a central social and political force in the region has drawn much attention to the issue of religion in politics in newly emerging regimes. The ways that Israel and Turkey have dealt with this issue in recent decades, and the long-term ramifications of their policies, might be relevant—even valuable—to their Arab neighbors, who still struggle to find the right political path to stability and prosperity.
The most intriguing chapter in Mobilizing Religion is Sarfati's account of religious schooling and its long-term political payoffs for the groups that operate it. In a postideological era, most political actors in democratic settings channel their behavior and energies to the achievement of short-term political gains. Sarfati reveals that the opposite is true of religious actors in Turkey and Israel, who have invested a significant share of their political leverage in establishing and promoting systems of education. In Turkey, Erbakan's Millî Görüş movement has been advancing the Imam Hatip schools since the 1970s; in Israel, Rav Ovadia's Shas party has been expanding the national outreach of its Maayan schooling system since this system's establishment in the mid-1980s. As the graduates of these education systems joined the national electorate, the two parties reached new levels of electoral success, with Refah Partisi winning 22 percent of the vote in the 1995 Turkish national elections and Shas winning 15 percent of the vote in the 1999 Israeli national elections. This outcome suggests that religious actors in the political sphere operate with a different temporal perspective than other political parties and that their patience might benefit them politically, even if it does not benefit individual politicians.
One point about which I would have expected a more comprehensive discussion and bottom line conclusion is the relationship between cultural and socioeconomic elements in the agendas of the religious groups in Turkey and Israel. While Mobilizing Religion demonstrates very nicely how these groups use socioeconomic grievances as well as cultural and theological elements to frame their ideological worldview and political demands, it is not entirely clear which of the two—socioeconomic incentives or cultural and theological elements—is the core driving force of their politics and which a complementing rhetorical tool. In other words, are religious movements in Israel and Turkey authentic manifestations of religious ideology or voices of and platforms for the empowerment of the weaker strata in society? This is an important question because the socioeconomic empowerment of traditional populations over time, such as the emergence of a solid religious bourgeoisie in Turkey, might make them less dependent on the socioeconomic incentives offered by the religious movements and, as a result, decrease the latter's recruitment capacity. This issue definitely warrants more research.
To conclude, Mobilizing Religion in Middle East Politics is a very welcome addition to the existing literature on religion and politics. It is recommended reading for students and scholars not only of religion and politics but also of Israel's and Turkey's complex political systems as well as Middle East politics and democratization more broadly. The book offers new paths for researching and thinking about the complex role of religion in non-Western democratic politics, and provides very important lessons that are relevant to every society dealing with the presence of religion in the public sphere.
