Hamlet avers that theatrical performance holds a mirror up to nature and, in doing so, creates a reflection of truth. In Marvin Carlson's latest book, an investigation of how mimesis has changed through time, he finds the metaphorical mirror shattered as real objects, bodies, and settings fracture this reflection of reality. Examining the mirror's shards, Carlson acts as a historical detective, uncovering performances from various eras in which the “real” breaks the mimetic illusion. He questions how text, bodies, spaces, objects, and audiences have changed the concept of mimesis. In particular, Carlson outlines a shift from the mimetic to the postmimetic as audiences (especially from the eighteenth century forward) desired more reality in stage performance. He treats realism, naturalism, and the conflation of mimesis with verisimilitude as factors integral in this shift. Carlson divides the book into five chapters, each focusing on a particular component of theatre: text, actors, settings, objects, and audience.
“Verbatim,” Carlson's first chapter, explores the use in theatrical productions of text written and spoken in everyday life. Prewritten and documentary material serve as leading examples in Carlson's analysis. He highlights courtroom documents used as text in dramas, such as The Trial of the Catonsville Nine, and interviews used in productions by the Wooster Group and the solo performances of Anna Deavere Smith. Throughout the book, Carlson references Bert O. States and phenomenology in his connections between what is real (material forms) and the attractions and perpetuation of that concept of the real within art. Carlson reveals how verbatim text has been used in performance through his detailed case studies, and though they do not extend far back into theatre history in this chapter, he nevertheless succeeds in showing key connections between reality and theatrical illusion.
Carlson examines actors’ bodies as another real material that complicates mimesis in his second chapter, “Who's There?” Since actors—and their physical bodies—exist dually within the real world and the theatrical world, their presence onstage remains a constant reminder of a certain reality within the illusion of theatre. Carlson points to the removal of masks (prominent in Greek theatre, Japanese nōh, and commedia dell'arte) as a step away from illusion to reality, as actors can be recognized and audiences reminded that these are individuals with real personalities. He demonstrates that actors who are seen repeatedly onstage and celebrities (drawing on his earlier work on theatre semiotics and ghosting, as well as the writings of Jean Alter and Michael Quinn) can, through audience recognition, break with the theatrical illusion. The stage figure also invokes reality when the body, through urination, defecation, or nudity, is simulated or exposed onstage. Carlson employs Buffalo Bill Cody and Ned Buntline's theatrical endeavors in the nineteenth century as his primary case study in this chapter, with additional references to Luigi Pirandello, Bruce Nauman, Yvonne Rainer, Eleanor Antin, and the creative team Rimini Protokoll. Carlson's knowledge of history and performance allow him easily to expose and charismatically to illuminate how the actor's body represents the real.
Setting is the focus of Carlson's investigation in Chapter 3, “There Must Be a Lot of Fish in That Lake.” Drawing on phenomenology and semiotics, Carlson indicates that the theatrical space provides the frame for the performance, and that productions through time have been set in real locations or staged to look like real locations. The Quem quæritis, the Vienna staging of the via dolorosa, and Johann Wolfgang von Goethe's 1782 comic opera The Fishermen are three examples of site-specific drama. In bringing reality to the indoor stage, Carlson references Beerbohm Tree, Belasco, and Bel Geddes. The desire for theatre to mimic reality onstage—much as it appeared in the cinema, which heightened the illusion of reality through editing, effects, and the camera's ability to film on location—is palpable in this chapter. Carlson illustrates a clear evolution in reality in stage design, and credits naturalism and realism as accelerants in the increase of reality in theatre space.
Chapter 4, “Simon's Chair and Launce's Dog,” considers stage properties as real objects. Carlson indicates that, even from the “beginnings of theatre,” properties have been a “product of the real world outside” (82). Simon McBurney's chair, which was used and addressed by McBurney in Mnemonic, and Launce's dog Crab in Shakespeare's Two Gentlemen of Verona, an example of animals as living properties, are both included in this chapter. Carlson selects performances throughout time from Polus, the Greek actor whose son's ashes were used in a production of Sophocles’ Electra, to modern instances in which the recycling of stage properties and costumes give the objects a life of their own. By illustrating how objects from the real world have been brought in and, in some cases, recognized and remembered by audience members, Carlson shows that properties, even dismembered skulls, can have a life and history offstage, in actuality, that can become ghosted onstage during performance.
“All the World's a Stage,” the fifth and final chapter, brings audiences into the examination. Their perception, participation, placement, and arrangement are all considered. Carlson shows how Jerzy Grotowski, Peter Hall, Richard Schechner's Dionysus in ’69, the Living Theatre, Maria Irene Fornés's Fefu and Her Friends, and Punchdrunk's Sleep No More challenge the binary between the real world and the mimetic world. Further reviewing Scott Magelssen's use of “simming,” the simulacrum, and capitalism, he successfully completes his revelation of how mimesis functions with and is challenged by the real world, especially when the live audience is asked to engage and participate in the performance.
Carlson's latest book succeeds as a historical foray into the evolution (or devolution) of mimesis and the theatre's complicated relationship with reality wrapped up in illusion. While he draws upon the theatre of the real, the book does not so much contribute to the theoretical consideration as deepen its roots into Western theatre history. Carlson's use of case studies is not only apropos but delightful for those with a keen appreciation of theatre history. This thought-provoking book provides theatre scholars, regardless of their specific areas of study, with insight into how theatre is and has been crafted and how mimesis has changed and intersected with reality throughout history.
