Taking up feminist plays and performance art from the 1970s to the present, Ryan Claycomb's first book, Lives in Play: Autobiography and Biography on the Feminist Stage, reconsiders works of feminist theatre that have fallen out of favor in the wake of shifting critical trends. Claycomb presents a nuanced treatment of the tensions attendant on performing subjectivity onstage, and pays careful attention to the original contexts of the plays that he discusses; ultimately, he attempts to return life narrative to a central position in the project of feminist art. A carefully researched, theory-rich study that is both clearly written and conceptually complex, Lives in Play does important recovery work for a wide range of feminist plays and performance art.
The introduction and first chapter of Lives in Play lay out Claycomb's complex historical and theoretical argument. Claycomb, who is clearly well versed in critical theory, hinges his argument on the premise that discussion of performance must take into account six interlocking elements: narrative, identity, voice, body, community, and history. Arguing that since the 1980s, women's life narratives often meet criticism under charges of essentialism, Claycomb refocuses the conversation surrounding these works to suggest instead that the performance of “real life” often functions in feminist theatre to “reveal real life as performative” (2; his italics). This distinction allows him to skirt the well-worn grooves of the debate between essentialism and social constructionism in feminist theory by allowing for both constructs simultaneously: for Claycomb, all of the elements that make up a performance are both manipulated consciously by performers and, at the same time, always operating outside of authorial intent. Methodologically, Claycomb, who is based in an English department, draws from narrative studies and performance theory to consider both the words spoken onstage and the body who speaks them. His foundational claim is twofold: first, the tension between the artifice of the theatre and the authority of the “real” provides a space where truth claims are uniquely positioned to be called into question by the audience; and second, this dialectical relationship between radical gender performance and a claim to the real is precisely what gives feminist performances political heft. Undoubtedly, this attention to multiple axes of analysis makes Lives in Play a dense study, but it is this very complexity that allows Claycomb to bring something new to the field of feminist theatre criticism.
Throughout Lives in Play, Claycomb grounds his theoretical approach in the texts themselves, using performance to test and challenge theory and often making a historical point of recognizing these theatrical works as a source of theory. The first chapter considers feminist performance artists of the 1990s, including Orlan, Kate Bornstein, Carmelita Tropicana, and Bobby Baker, whose quasi-autobiographical performance pieces clearly engage emerging constructionist or deconstructive theories. But while these texts align with critical trends that have attained dominance since the 1990 publication of Judith Butler's extremely influential Gender Trouble, Claycomb turns in his second chapter to autobiographical feminist performances by Carolee Schneemann, Karen Finley, Holly Hughes, and Terry Galloway that have met with greater critical backlash for their seemingly more stable notions of female biology and identity. Attempting to complicate the notion that these pieces simply peddle stable identities, Claycomb argues that this second group of performers instead self-consciously uses its works' grounding in the “real” to engage audiences.
Taken together, Claycomb's two opening chapters lay the groundwork for his third, an analysis of Sarah Kane's final and posthumously performed play, 4.48 Psychosis (2000), as both importantly autobiographical and self-consciously constructed. Arguing against a critical tendency that suggests that reading the play autobiographically functions to minimize its artistry, Claycomb persuasively argues that only by considering the circumstances surrounding the play's creation as Kane's “‘suicide note’” (93) can critics understand the full weight of 4.48 Psychosis's powerful impact on audiences.
The second half of Lives in Play extends the analytic premise that the blending of “real life” and crafted performance proves particularly important to feminist theatre, and considers a number of feminist biography plays. Chapter 4 functions as a critical and theoretical overview of the goals of feminist biography plays, whereas Chapter 5 analyzes three particularly metatheatrical examples of the genre: Hélène Cixous's Portrait of Dora (1976), April De Angelis's Playhouse Creatures (1993), and María Irene Fornés's The Summer in Gossensass (1998). For Claycomb, these three plays model for their audiences different modes of critical engagement with the ways that history is written, rewritten, and adapted for present purposes.
The final chapter of Lives in Play attempts to extend these analytic tools to theatre dealing with race as well as gender, considering Timberlake Wertenbaker's New Anatomies (1981) and Suzan-Lori Parks's Venus (1996); the book's conclusion continues this opening out in its focus on Judith Thompson's Palace of the End (2008), three monologues that explore U.S. and British intervention in Iraq, which Claycomb claims bridge feminism and global humanism by ultimately working to push the audience “to witness, feel deeply, and watch over others” (212). Lives in Play thus resolutely emphasizes that although feminist theatre must be evaluated in relation to the theory and culture of the historical moment in which it was produced, the moment for feminist autobiographical and biographical theatre is not over, and, indeed, can expand to find a place within the intersectional, international framework that forms the backbone of twenty-first-century feminist theory and activism.
For scholars of feminist theatre and feminist theory, there is much to recommend Lives in Play. Claycomb has an impressive grasp of these fields, and makes a strong case for their coconstitutive nature; the book is admirably nuanced in its analysis, and expansive in its objects of study. Admittedly, in racing through detailed analysis of more than fifteen plays and performance pieces, Lives in Play finds little time to catch up a reader less versed in the history and criticism of the plays addressed or in the canon of feminist theory; a reader who hopes to turn to the book for an overview of the tradition of life narrative in feminist performance will likely find herself a bit lost. But for the specialist audience for whom Claycomb writes, and as a corrective to trends in the canon formation of feminist theatre criticism, the book is valuable, and perhaps even necessary, in the strong case it makes for returning dismissed or understudied works by female playwrights and performance artists to a place of critical value.
