Theorizing by Misdirection
More than a century after Edward Gordon Craig published “The Actor and the Über-Marionette” (1908), the core of his conception of acting still poses a hermeneutical challenge to the theatre scholar.Footnote 1 Many intriguing interpretations have stemmed from his statements on acting: from Denis Bablet's or Christopher Innes's argument that the Über-marionette is a metaphor for the perfect performer, to Irène Eynat-Confino's thesis that it is a real, oversized puppet; from the idea (Lindsay Mary Newman's or Cesare Molinari's, for instance) that the concept evolved with time along with the details of Craig's acting theory, to Patrick Le Boeuf's recent hypothesis that the Über-marionette is a full-body puppet. Le Boeuf's interpretation is somehow a telling example of the puzzling quality of Craig's acting theory: his studies originally led him to believe that the Über-marionette was a technically perfect gymnast, in perfect control of his own body, but he was induced to reconsider his hypothesis only a couple of years later, in the light of newly recovered documents.Footnote 2 The same ineffable quality Jane Goodall detects in “stage presence” seems to be an inherent feature of Craig's ideal performer, and as with presence, the Über-marionette appears to be best definable by approximation.Footnote 3
Several factors determine the fundamental elusiveness of Craig's concept, the first and more noticeable being the seemingly dual nature of his statements about the actor, which oscillate from outright damnation to open admiration. How can the views of the author of “The Actor and the Über-Marionette,” who quotes Eleonora Duse describing the extinction of the actor as the event that would allow the theatre to be saved, be reconciled with those of the writer of the 1908 letter to Eleonora Duse or the fervent admirer of Henry Irving?Footnote 4 Or, as Joseph Roach might rephrase the question, how can his apparently radical mechanistic conception of ideal acting be reconciled with his appreciation of living—and therefore emotional—actors?Footnote 5 Not only that: Craig's need for secrecy, which was connected to his fear of being plagiarized by fellow innovators in the theatre arts, often led him to camouflage his true meanings in order to protect his work, making his intent hard to decipher.
An illustration of such a strategy emerges in Craig's marionette drama, one of the most relevant examples being Blue Sky, a farce published in 1921 in The English Review.Footnote 6 The plot centers on the attempt of two ignorant rogues (Sly-Boots and Muggins) to steal from a magician (Looney, Craig's alter ego) the secret for making the sky blue so they can sell it and Looney's strategy for deflecting this attempt. Far more complex than the subtitle, which calls the piece “a sketch,” leads the reader to expect, the play contains a number of references to Craig's work and its context—some overt, such as Sly-Boots's accusation that Looney is impractical, and some hidden, such as the allusions to Craig's earlier essays (for instance, “On Learning Magic,” 1914).Footnote 7 However, what is more relevant to my present argument is the underlying theatrical motif of the play: Craig's relationship with whomever is interested in his art. He clearly refers to his conviction that his ideas must be protected from mediocre minds who would prostitute them, a conviction that led him to let only the initiated in on his artistic conception. This is well expressed by Looney's attitude toward the scoundrel Sly-Boots—possibly an allusion to Max Reinhardt, one of the main targets of Craig's charges of plagiarism—and toward the pure-minded Blind Boy, a representation of the esoteric master's novice. While the magician lets the Blind Boy into his practices because of his disinterestedness, he keeps making fun of Sly-Boots, intentionally misleading him by means of half-incomprehensible statements, well aware of his profane and purely materialistic aims. The rhetorical strategies at the heart of Craig's writings on the Über-marionette seem to answer the same need for secrecy: never transparent, his essays seem to be constructed with a code that can be deciphered only by the initiated or by those who, driven by an unpolluted devotion to the theatre, are both willing and able to go beneath the surface and dig out the essence of the author's thought.
The hide-and-seek game Craig deployed in The Mask may be due—at least in part—to the same necessity: in addition to a number of articles that he signed with his own name, he wrote essays under a great variety of pseudonyms (from the more easily recognizable Yoo-no-hoo or Edward Edwardovitch to the less transparent John Semar, John Balance, or Adolf Furst). There is undoubtedly a playful side to the use of such disguises in addition to a practical one (the need to convince his readers that a multiplicity of authors contributed to the periodical), but the confusing effect it creates may also be the result of Craig's desire to restrict access to his theories to a select few.
The Shadow of the Über-Marionette
Addressing the apparently paradoxical nature of Craig's statements on actors may help remove the debris he deliberately laid down to protect his notion of the Über-marionette. Indeed, although it cannot be denied that Craig untiringly censured the human performer as an individual whose body—to borrow Roach's words—is “a spontaneously vital organism whose innate powers of feeling must somehow naturally predominate,”Footnote 8 he expressed admiration for specific players on several occasions. The primary object of his high regard was Henry Irving. Part of this appreciation is attributable to the role Irving played in Craig's life as a mentor and to some extent as a foster father, but the analysis of the actor's technique provided in Henry Irving strongly suggests that more than mere affection lies beneath his praise.Footnote 9
An interesting indication of the theoretical relevance of this biographical work can be found in the peculiar way Craig chooses to talk about Irving's journey from theatrical apprenticeship to fame. Instead of mentioning his mentor's real name—John Brodribb—in passing, as mere biographical information, and using his adopted and better-known stage name—Henry Irving—as a general rule, he confers a particular meaning on the duality John Henry Brodribb/Henry Irving:
The date when Brodribb set out to become Irving was when he set out to act in Sunderland, 1856. The date when he became Irving was fifteen years later, 1871, November 25th, when he acted and produced The Bells.
The artist [italics added] begins his career on the date that he completes his masterpiece. There can be but one masterpiece, although we often hear of the thing in the plural. I had this from a connoisseur of pictures, who explained to me that a masterpiece was that piece of work done by a painter when his tutor had no more to teach him, and which entitled him to be called a master. This piece, The Bells, was Irving's masterpiece, and proclaimed him a master. (HI, 24)
Regardless of the fact that Irving adopted his stage name well before acting in The Bells, Craig describes the evolution of his mentor as the story of a metamorphosis in which the earlier individual, John Henry Brodribb, literally became a new being, Henry Irving. And although Craig carefully describes this transformation from a rhetorical point of view, it is no mere rhetorical embellishment. Craig carefully chooses his terms and metaphors. In particular, he uses the term “artist” as a sort of signpost that invites the reader to pay particular attention to the progress he is describing. As anyone who is familiar with Craig's theoretical writings knows well, he uses the words “art” and “artist” in the highest meaning of the terms throughout his works, particularly where acting is concerned. As he maintains in “The Actor and the Über-Marionette,” “acting is not an art. It is therefore incorrect to speak of the actor as an artist.”Footnote 10 The entire essay revolves around this concept, and Craig repeatedly affirms the idea in subsequent works. It is very significant therefore that he should use the term to describe the greatest late Victorian actor. Craig's choice of word is not surprising, however, if we consider that he described Irving as “the very nearest approach that has ever been to the ideal actor” in “The Artists of the Theatre of the Future,” an essay that—like “The Actor and the Über-Marionette”—Craig wrote in 1907 and published in The Mask the following year.Footnote 11
As the biography proceeds it becomes more and more clear that Craig's use of the term is not a slip or a chance usage. The details of Irving's—or rather, of Brodribb's—approach to acting cohere with Craig's explicitly theoretical writings:
I think that the advice of the Sunderland critic [to quit acting] would have been followed by the actor had he allowed himself for a moment to believe that it was John Brodribb who was going to become a great actor. But he knew better than that. He knew that it was his mask that was to be the great actor—a mask which could be a hundred faces in one—and he had to design, cut out, polish, and perfect that mask. This notion of being somebody whom you are not does not find favour among all actors of today. Most prefer to be their natural selves, and I doubt whether any other actor has ever set out to transform himself so completely as did Brodribb. [. . .] [He] was never in a hurry: [. . .] although he believed that it would be a matter of three or four years ere he could become the Haunted Man, if not Hamlet, he was not put out by the discovery that it was taking much longer. On perceiving this he did not change his direction; he went no faster—he only went more steadily on. (HI, 26–7)
The metamorphosis of Brodribb the actor into Irving the great actor—the transformation of the craftsman into the artist—comes about because of long, untiring, slow work that was perfectly in line with Craig's conception of theatrical apprenticeship. In his opinion, acquiring the status of an artist was the only worthy goal. Trainees must disinterestedly devote their attention to all details, never hurrying through a process that must take a long time if perfection is the goal. This is one of the reasons why, for Craig, Brodribb is the epitome of the theatrical apprentice as much as Irving is the epitome of what elsewhere Craig seems to consider an impossibility—the performer as an artist. Because of his dedication Brodribb builds for himself what his pupil conceives as the perfect tool for facial expression: a mask. This is no mere detail; as Denis Bablet points out, in Craig's theory “[t]he mask is a safeguard against realism, a guarantee against the emotions. It turns a man into an Über-marionette.”Footnote 12 In Craig's biography of Irving, the term “mask” has a double meaning: it refers to the actor's face and its instrumental, artificial quality, where artifice is a feature of excellence, but it also refers to Irving as the persona Brodribb wore when he became an artist. Craig confirms that such a persona can be considered a human prototype for the Über-marionette: “[W]hile he was making his mask in Sunderland, Edinburgh, and Dublin, he was at the same time measuring himself for a suit of mail which, when it should be ready, would cover him from head to foot: for, indeed, Irving was the nearest thing ever known to what I have called the Über-marionette” (HI, 32).
A well-known statement Craig included in his 1924 preface to On the Art of the Theatre is useful for reconstructing the evidence of Irving's Über-marionette nature: “The Über-marionette is the actor plus fire, minus egoism: the fire of the gods and demons, without the smoke and steam of mortality.”Footnote 13 As we will see, the fire Craig mentions here seems to be a feature of Brodribb/Irving's personality.
From the time of his training period, Brodribb possessed a trait that would prove to be a necessary component of his later Irving years: le diable au corps (the devil inside). This is what enabled him to “explode” all tradition in his art, and—having turned into Irving—to enthrall his audience (HI, 18–20). Craig is not certain whether the diable au corps is a characteristic an artist in any art should possess, but he believes that it is essential to theatrical performers if they are “to obtain perfection”: it confers on “a tragic actor a capacity to blaze [. . .] [and allows] a great comedian to laugh”; as an actor “[y]ou must have it. If it hasn't arrived, just go on until it does” (HI, 20). This diable is reminiscent of the “fire of the gods and demons” of Craig's 1924 preface, but on that occasion Craig clarified that however necessary the quality is for the Über-marionette, it is not sufficient to create one. That is why while the diable au corps is also attributed to Brodribb (i.e., Irving in his pre-Über-marionette phase), it is only when Craig turns his attention to Irving's perfected persona that he adds: “Irving was never agitated . . . Irving never rushed in any way. I suppose he was the coolest actor possessing le diable au corps that ever came upon this earth” (HI,21). Having achieved his finished artistic state, Irving coupled his “fire of the gods and demons” with coolness, a trait performers need to rid themselves of the “smoke and steam of mortality” that so impairs them it deprives them of the ability to become artists. Irving's coolness was not just the self-possession of the artist facing his character; it implied a detachment that immunized him from the effect that audiences and critics may have had, that is to say from anything that might have triggered his vanity. Ordinary performers cannot help but be influenced by the attitudes critics and playgoers demonstrate toward their efforts. Irving, however, was so perfectly self-possessed that instead of suffering from criticism or being flattered by applause, he kept a distance, assuming an attitude of “good-natured contempt” toward both admirers and detractors, which is—as Craig writes, quoting Irving himself—“‘[t]he only feeling then to which the triumphant artist may be tempted’” (HI, 33). This immunity from vanity, this good-natured contempt, is another symptom of Irving's Über-marionette quality:
That is not human, is it? It is more than human, is it not? [. . .] Will you not agree with me that it belongs to something a little more than human? [. . .] That [good-natured contempt] was the suit of armour for which I said that this remarkable man was measuring himself; not for the defence of his person, but for the defence of the spirit of the artist. (HI, 33–4, 36)
In Irving, good-natured contempt is the sign of inhumanity, closer to Goodall's “uncanny” than to pure mechanicalism. It is not the result of arrogance because Irving was “far more self-critical than any of his spectators. [. . .] [He would] never accept the criticism of other people, because it is impossible that they [could] estimate him as exactly as he [could] himself” (34).Footnote 14 This is not conceit, therefore, but the necessary consequence of his superior knowledge of his own art, of a constant and extremely exacting practice of self-criticism and detachment. In Craig's eyes, Irving's capacity to go beyond humanity, leaving behind emotional turmoil, also influenced his extremely precise construction of his part, which followed a mathematical pattern rather than accidental inspiration. Everything was designed and artificial in his composition of gestural and vocal signs, exactly as it should be for the Über-marionette, “[f]or accident is an enemy of the artist. Art is the exact antithesis of Pandemonium, and Pandemonium is created by the tumbling together of many accidents; Art arrives only by design.”Footnote 15 Moreover, Irving's “score” was harmonious, ruled by rhythm, another feature he shared with the Über-marionette, so much so that instead of merely acting, he danced:
He danced, he did not merely walk—he sang, he by no means merely spoke. He was essentially artificial in distinction to being merely natural. [. . .] His movements were all measured. He was for ever counting—one, two, three—pause—one, two—a step, another, a halt, a faintest turn, another step, a word. (Call it a beat, a foot, a step, all is one—I like to use the word “step”). That constituted one of his dances. Or seated on a chair, at a table—raising a glass, drinking—and then lowering his hand and glass—one, two, three, four—suspense—a slight step with his eyes—five—then a patter of steps—two slow syllables—another step—two more syllables—and a second passage in his dance was done. [. . .] [T]here was no chance movement; he left no loose ends. All was sharp cut at beginning and end, and all joined by an immensely subtle rhythm—the Shakespearean rhythm—discerned by Brodribb when wondering how to do it, and not a soul to tell him how. [. . .]
[E]very sound, each movement, was intentional—clear-cut, measured dance: nothing real—all massively artificial—yet all flashing with the light and the pulse of nature. [. . .]
His movements being measured, rhythmic, planned, it may be too obvious to state that the action of his face was part of all this, and was measured too; yet it may not have occurred to one or two of my readers that this control of feature till immobility was achieved constituted a mask. (HI, 74, 77–8)
Behind Craig's analysis of Brodribb's apprenticeship and its result—Irving's planned, minutely calculated acting technique—clearly lies the ideal that the Über-marionette embodies. The portrait of his mentor bears its signs: the careful building up of an armor and a mask that allowed Irving to be an artist instead of an ordinary, although admired, actor; the detachment that immunized him from emotional stimuli in a way that revealed his capacity to go beyond humanity, to dissipate all the abhorred “smoke and steam of mortality.” No wonder, then, that Craig describes Irving as “that shadow of a coming event, the Über-marionette” (HI, 40).
Craig never goes so far as to state that Irving is a complete Über-marionette. He says his mentor foreshadows it, that he is the closest example to it ever known, but he never maintains that Irving is the perfect embodiment of the ideal. I believe the reason is not so difficult to deduce, and it seems to lie not so much in the infrequent occasions when Irving showed instances of nature (as opposed to art) as in the role Irving had onstage. However much Craig admires Irving, he does not fail to notice that his mentor built all his theatrical productions upon himself. However harmonious the whole might be, Irving never renounced his leading role in the performance to create a work of art—he never became the mere tool toward an artistic end that Craig believes the ideal performer should be—but rather arranged everything and everyone else in a centripetal way, with himself in the center: “He set out not to produce a play as we do today [. . .] but to act one: he stage-managed it himself, but he stage-managed for one actor's sake, for the sake of Irving—and a producer does not do that” (HI, 87). Raised as an actor in the hierarchical structure of the traditional nineteenth-century theatre company, Irving kept to the self-centered perspective the great Georgian and Victorian actor-managers adopted. What prevented him from completely becoming an Über-marionette was the fact that he acted according to his own subjective perspective instead of making himself a vessel for a universal, impersonal, divine truth, which is what an Über-marionette is supposed to be.Footnote 16 There is no implied criticism in Craig's comments. On the contrary, the tone is unwaveringly admiring: in a system in which he believed there was no modern producer who could create a theatrical work of art, Irving went beyond the limits of the traditional actor to reach the borderline of the Über-marionette, and—Craig seems to imply—nothing more could reasonably be asked of him (HI, 135–7).
The Potential Sybil
Henry Irving was published in 1930, but Craig's tendency to detect an Über-marionette potential in Irving and other actors dates back to the period when “The Actor and the Über-Marionette” and other essays that proposed a dehumanization of the player were published. A striking instance of this attitude emerges from two public letters Craig wrote to Eleonora Duse in 1907 and 1908. As these documents testify, Craig was fascinated by Duse, although by no means without some criticism.
Craig and Duse had some initial indirect contact in 1905—through his German patron and writer Harry Kessler and the Austrian Hugo von Hoffmansthal—when Duse seemed to be interested in staging Hoffmansthal's drama Elektra (1903).Footnote 17 They first met in 1906, when the actress asked Craig to contribute as a scene designer for a new production of Ibsen's Rosmersholm. The main source for the relationship between them in the months leading to the performance is Isadora Duncan's autobiography.Footnote 18 The American dancer portrays their experiment as successful thanks to her own mediation, which prevented them from clashing, and—what is more interesting in this context—reports Duse's enthusiastic reaction to Craig's work. She also describes Craig's tendency to ignore Duse's instructions (for instance, regarding the size of the window in Rosmer's sitting room), implying that he applied his visionary style to the scene designs instead of adopting the realistic perspective Duse was accustomed to and that characterized her 1905 production of the play. In other words, he apparently convinced the actress to adapt to his ideas and therefore to some extent shaped the entire mise-en-scène, although he was not the director.Footnote 19 According to Duncan, she managed to deflect Duse's wish to see how the designs were proceeding until Craig finished his work. When Duse saw the final results, her reaction—if we believe Isadora—was enthusiastic, so much so that she declared she would devote the rest of her career “to showing the world his great work.”Footnote 20
The apparently idyllic theatrical relationship, however, was short-lived. A few months later the scenery was defaced by stagehands while Duse was on tour with the production.Footnote 21 When Craig reached her in Nice to supervise the mounting of the sets and saw the damage, he quarreled with her personnel, and although Duse—who was not in the theatre at that moment—gave him her support to the point of dismissing the guilty technician, the artistic partnership between them ended.Footnote 22 When he published a letter to Duse in the Washington Post later that year, however, he did not linger on the incident, as the technician and not Duse was responsible for the mishandling. Instead, he urged her to become the leading personality in what might be termed a revolution in theatrical art, although he began with an apparently provocative statement:
When you [Duse] say the actors and actresses must die of the plague you do not mean individuals, but you mean the entire family, and the entire family includes yourself. You say you all poison the air and you all make art impossible. Well, then, you would exterminate your profession, those only would survive who were more than “professionals”; those who have the spirit would live, those who are without a grain of selfishness and those who desire nothing but the triumph of beauty and courage.Footnote 23
In Craig's interpretation of the actress's well-known statement, the death of the whole profession would allow a different class of performer to emerge: individuals endowed with “spirit” who would be absolutely selfless and devoted to art. These are significant characteristics as they belong also to the Über-marionette. Especially interesting is the kind of death Craig maintains actors should suffer—the kind he exhorts Duse to embrace:
Do it! You who may perhaps fear all else in the world cannot fear that. I, who fear all things upon earth, have no fear of dying for my art. And as I have the liberty to choose the form which that death shall take, I will choose the most painful, the most long drawn out; the daily death, living but fighting every inch of the way and not giving in one-hundredth part of an inch until the last breath of me shall be consumed; neither compromising when alone in my room nor compromising before others; but deliberately undermining and destroying ugliness while constructing beauty.Footnote 24
The solution Craig describes is not the mere extermination of the actor; it rather resembles the metamorphic process a caterpillar undergoes in order be reborn as a butterfly. As with a pupa, which breaks down its larval structure in order to create its new form, the actress should kill her own old self daily so that she can simultaneously recreate herself as an artist.
The rest of the article is a warm-hearted exhortation to Duse to discard all doubt, all fear of being unequal to the task, a reminder of the qualities—intelligence above all—she possesses that will enable her to be the pioneer of the liberation and rebirth of acting. And it is also a declaration of faith in Duse: “Others have acted, others have failed, others have wearied. But you, the youngest daughter of the Muse, shall justify her, your mother. [. . .] I believe you will be the first to take the most daring step which leads to our freedom.”Footnote 25
Three months later, in the essay/letter to Duse published in The Mask, Craig further explains and develops his argument, although in a less flattering tone. From the outset he expresses a qualified admiration for the Italian star: “No, not an actress, but something more; not an artist, but something less; a personality; and then something far more than all these three.”Footnote 26 Duse's charm is an unfathomable “secret,” in Craig's opinion, mesmerizing critics and the general public alike; a mesmeric presence that Jane Goodall interestingly detects in the theoretician's Über-marionette prototype, Henry Irving.Footnote 27 But Duse's mesmeric ability is not sufficient for attaining Craig's ideal. However brilliant and astounding Duse might be at times, she is not an artist, although she is far more than “these three” (actress, artist, and personality). Craig maintains that her basic defects—which she shares with her fellow actors—are individualism and what might be called laziness. She is too subjective (“She abhors all that goes to make up great art . . . that is to say, the obedience to laws which are impersonal and immortal. She is personal love, personal courage, personal hope, and personal beauty”)Footnote 28 and she does not seek perfection, being content with less than what she might reach if she constantly worked to the best of her abilities.Footnote 29 Several critics have pointed out that her performances were inconsistent, sometimes reaching exceptional expressiveness, other times quite ordinary.Footnote 30 It is likely to this lack of consistency that Craig refers when he says that actors (including Duse) become content too easily. An artist, in fact,
dies for his art. To an artist nothing less than perfection will do. An artist will sooner never commence his work than end with it in an imperfect state. An artist is unselfishness personified. He lives for an ideal, and for that ideal everything else in the world is destroyed. An artist is never to be heard saying “I should like to,” but only “I will.” And what is it he wills? It is, as I have said, perfection, perfection, and nothing short of perfection.Footnote 31
The death Craig invited Duse to embrace in December 1907—which in his opinion is the same death the Italian actress calls upon the whole profession—is clarified here: artists should kill everything accidental, extinguish all trace of human feebleness, whatever detracts or distracts from the ideal, in order to reach perfection, which should be their sole aim. What Duse does instead, however, is to allow herself to be content with a potentially artistic project that falls short of perfection. Craig's intent is not merely to criticize Duse; he urges her to move forward. Although she is not yet the ideal artist Craig conceives of, she has the potential to become one:
I began to write of her, of Eleonora Duse, that is, of a great name. But now I speak to her; to this something which is not a name.
To you . . . who when you will, may step up the ladder of the fairies which has waited for you until now . . . a silver thing hanging down from the skies, thrown down by the gods and held at the end which touches our earth by the youngest children of the theatre who love their lost art with all their heart, boys who beg of you to step upon this ladder and rise before their eyes, rung by rung, higher and higher, away from us, so that you may be for ever near us . . . enthroned.
The thought and vision of the Sibyls fill my mind. I see the Sibyls of old and listen to the tale of their great happiness. Their story opens with a long unutterable sorrow . . . it ends with a deep and mounting joy. [. . .] They seem to wail on incessantly for an age—an age which is but a moment, so lonely, so unending a pain upon the dry and lonely mountains. And then, as before some strange upheaval in Nature, all sounds of birds and beasts cease; so their voices are hushed—Silence . . . and then slowly the wonder of morning's light . . . Wisdom. Step up, Sweet Mystery, ascend this ladder which we hold. Become the eleventh Sibyl: ascend, find there wisdom which awaits you and then cast down to us a truth to heal us, and another truth to guide us, and another truth to cheer us, and innumerable truths of eternal life that we may live for that which we love, for our art, for our beautiful Theatre.Footnote 32
This exhortation, which is quite similar in tone and content to the appeal in the 1907 letter, urges Duse to transform herself into an ideal performer, to seek perfection and thus become the channel through which the divine sphere can communicate eternal truths to humanity. A few months earlier Craig had referred to Duse as the daughter of the muses; now he asks her to become the eleventh sibyl. His lexical choice seems interesting if we consider that Isadora Duncan used the same word when describing Duse on the opening night of the 1906 production of Rosmersholm, as if Craig's contribution to the mise-en-scène had enhanced Duse's mystical traits: “When she appeared, she looked less like Rebecca West than a Delphic sibyl. With an unerring genius she adapted herself to every great line and to each shaft of light which enveloped her. She changed all her gestures and movements. She moved in the scene like a prophetess announcing great tidings.”Footnote 33 Of course Duncan's memoirs were published in 1927 and may have been influenced by Craig's letter, but the idea that Craig might have perceived Duse's divine quality in the 1906 performance is intriguing.
Whether or not this is the case, Craig's words in the 1908 letter clearly show that he perceived a mystical potential in her that is strikingly similar to the divine essence of the Über-marionette; he seems to be urging her to appropriate the same kind of wires that in 1912 he would state would guide the ideal performer:
What the wires of the Über-marionette shall be, what shall guide him, who can say? I do not believe in the mechanical . . . nor in the material. . . . The wires which stretch from Divinity to the soul of the Poet are wires which might command him; . . . has God no more such threads to spare. . . . for one more figure? I cannot doubt it.Footnote 34
Craig believed that it would require further effort on Duse's part to overcome her shortcomings and start on this path, the stair leading her to the status of a superhuman; but the potential to achieve this ambitious goal was there, so much so that he repeatedly published his invitations over the years, first in his 1907 article, then in his 1908 essay, and again in 1919, when he included the 1908 essay in The Theatre—Advancing (and we might also add in 1921, when the British edition of the volume was printed).Footnote 35
A Precious Death
Craig's attitudes toward Irving and Duse seem to undermine the hypothesis that he sought to get rid of actors, replacing them with a new kind of puppets.Footnote 36 This impression is supported by occasions when he stated that the wires of the Über-marionette are not material, as well as by instances when he described the ideal human actor in terms that closely recall those defining his Über-marionette.
Irène Eynat-Confino argues that his appreciative statements regarding human performers were part of a strategy he used to avoid alienating actors, for whom he still had some use until the oversized puppet she believes to be the Über-marionette appeared. Several reasons, however, lead me to view this hypothesis—in an otherwise fascinating monograph that is especially valuable for her critical analysis of Craig's concept of movement and the esoteric symbols he uses—as problematic.
First of all, the strategy to which Eynat-Confino refers implies a tendency to compromise for practical reasons that is contradicted by the practices of Craig's theatrical career. He participated in a very limited number of productions—in several cases not as a producer but as a scene designer—because of his difficulty in reaching a compromise. Both Craig's dissatisfaction with the Moscow Hamlet, given Stanislavsky's inability to meet his requirements as much as he desired, and the consequences of the Rosmersholm incident illustrate the problematic nature of his relationships with other artists and companies, due to his difficulty making concessions where his art and convictions were involved. He confirms this intransigence in his Day-book 1: “Everyone I have ever been working with or living with have broken the progress by continually imagining that I admitted of any but one way—mine.”Footnote 37 The fact that the productions he participated in were one-time collaborations seems to be another expression of his inflexibility.
There are other reasons why it is unlikely that Craig was willing to compromise with regard to his relationship with actors for practical reasons. After 1911, when his statements that implicitly or explicitly contradicted the puppetlike nature of the Über-marionette sensibly increased in number, he engaged less and less frequently with actual performances. After the Moscow Hamlet (1912), the only other play he produced was Ibsen's The Pretenders (1926), and two years later, in 1928, he provided the set designs for a New York production of Macbeth. Craig did not seem to have much practical need for actors, therefore, as a 1909 note implicitly confirms: “I want time to study the theatre. I do not want to waste time producing plays.”Footnote 38 And considering his very low opinion of most of his colleagues, it is unlikely that he would have promoted the development of improved but not Über-marionettische actors for other directors to use. But Craig's words suggest another explanation for his appreciation of human performers in spite of their obvious limits. In the section devoted to the actor in “The Artists of the Theatre of the Future,” he invites his fictional listener (an actor who wants to become a real artist) to continue acting, learning everything that can be learned about the craft, until he realizes that the face—which, as the main means of expressing emotion, is also the least controllable part of the body—cannot ever be entirely mastered.Footnote 39 Prospective artists of the theatre, in other words, need to keep acting until they fully realize the limits of the human body in order to proceed beyond the actor: they need experience.
Although these elements suggest that Craig's seemingly ambivalent attitude may be explained not as a strategy to avoid alienating the sympathies of actors but rather as the result of a pedagogical need, they cannot be used to reject the hypothesis that Craig's Über-marionette is a puppet. However, other elements contradict this contention. In 1905, when Craig was starting his Dresden Über-Marionette International Theatre project, he met Isadora Duncan, whom he seems to have considered as a potential Über-marionette. Eynat-Confino rejects Duncan as evidence that the Über-marionette is the ultimate model for the human performer because she considers the American dancer to be a unique—and therefore unrepeatable—instance of perfection.Footnote 40 My doubts about Eynat-Confino's argument derive from two considerations. First, the very existence of a human performer, however unique, who has capacity to become an Über-marionette implies that there is a potential in humanity to reach Craig's perfect ideal. Moreover, Duncan is not alone among such admirable performers. As we have seen, in Craig's opinion, Irving came very close to perfection, and he felt that Duse had the potential to become another superhuman creature who could lead the theatre to artistic salvation, opening up a new era. Given the fact that Craig believed there were at least three instances of near-Über-marionettes (and his essays on Sarah Bernhardt and Yvette Guilbert suggest that there may have been more), the hypothesis that Craig excluded the possibility of a human agent becoming the ideal performer seems remote.Footnote 41
The strongest evidence that supports the idea of the Über-marionette as a puppet is furnished by the documentation of Craig's Über-Marionette International Theatre project. As Eynat-Confino points out, the project, whose initial phase is illustrated in the so-called Über-Marion Notebooks, concerns an experimental sort of puppetry.Footnote 42 However, even these notebooks—and the financial projections that Craig, Harry Kessler, and American expat writer Maurice Magnus compiled in 1904–1905—raise a few doubts about the theory that the Über-marionette was simply a puppet.Footnote 43 A significant piece of evidence against this theory can be found in Über-Marion Notebook A: early therein, we find a few comments on Dido and Æneas, some sketches of masks, and portraits in ink (in color) of two figures—or rather the same figure in two different poses.Footnote 44 The first represents a masked figure in black holding another mask in its right hand. Two or three (the drawing is not perfectly clear in this detail) more masks hang from the front of its tunic at hip level. A very large blue cloak rests on its left arm, and it holds a large red cloak—which partly rests on the floor behind the figure—with its left hand. The second image represents the same figure—in this case seen from the side—in the act of changing masks while holding the blue cloak.Footnote 45 Craig's comments here are quite interesting. His description of the masks that should be used in Purcell's opera specify that they should “be made of elastic and cloth cut to make certain lines—not thick heavy masks covering the face [. . .] The actor or performer can then see to do his work and is not tormented by a hot and blinded face.”Footnote 46 There is no mention of an equation of this actor/performer with the Über-marionette on this sheet, but the fact that Craig titled this notebook “Über-Marions Berlin” and the comment on the actor/performer seems at least curious. What is more significant, however, is what we find on the following pages. Although the two figures drawn on these pages are not explicitly labeled Dido and Æneas, they both seem to concern Purcell's opera, as the similarity of at least one of the masks shown in the first drawing with those sketched in the preceding comment on Purcell's opera is quite striking. On the page facing the first figure—captioned “An Actor 1905”—we find the following instructions: “For the manipulation of the 2 cloaks a couple of attendants on the actor: who place them ready for him to manipulate further.”Footnote 47 The performer portrayed here is an actor whose features are similar to those of the Über-marionette. The images—showing an actor dressed in a costume that, although stylized, appears rather cumbersome—suggest that his motions must be slow and symbolic, rather inclining to the perfect stillness Craig attributes to his own marionettes:
Let me say a word as to the stillness of my marionettes.
That is not being unnatural—far from it[,] it is in fact being more like life. [. . .]
Much movement doesn't represent life any more that much calm represent life or much sound.
Only a certain selected movement as only a selected colour or sound.
And just as a bad painter will cover a canvas with all the colours at once because he thinks that will [supply] the rich gleaming colours of life, so have bad artists in the theatre believed that exuberant action—unconsidered action in short would suggest the movement of life—joy—whereas a good painter knows that by the use of but a very little but well selected colour he can create the impression of intense gaiety so does a good theatre artist also knows that the use of etc. etc. movement. Hence the stillness of my marionette.Footnote 48
Craig's notes on the second drawing of the figure throw further light on its nature: “The change from one mask to another. The figure revolves, ducks, hides face with mantle (& in this revolving the Über-m. shows his Über dexterity).”Footnote 49 What was an actor/performer has become a perfectly agile, “über-dexterous” Über-marionette.
Even the Über-Marion Notebooks, then, raise some doubts about the purely puppetlike nature of the Über-marionette, which become even stronger when Craig alludes to the Über-Marionette International Theatre with these words: “These two months [January and February 1905 or 1906] must be given to the training of the 25 Über-marionettes and to the designing of the scenes and costumes of the 3 pieces.”Footnote 50 What strikes one as peculiar is the need to train Über-marionettes as if they were living beings: if Craig meant training whatever puppeteer might be needed, he would have specified that the manipulators needed training and not the Über-marionettes, which anyway do not hang on ordinary wires but on invisible, intangible wires and therefore do not depend on ordinary puppeteers but on divinity, which of course does not need to be trained.Footnote 51 Even the papers relating to the Dresden Über-Marionette International Theatre project raise such doubts. First of all, when Craig is asked to describe the nature of his marionette theatre, he answers: “Not a marionette theatre.”Footnote 52 In addition, in all detailed financial projections a curious entry can be found under “Personnel expenses” relating to the monthly expenses for Über-marionettes; when listed in brief, such expenses are listed as salaries.Footnote 53 The idea of having Über-marionettes on a payroll would be quite bizarre unless they were not puppets but living beings.
However, the Über-Marionette International Theatre project manuscripts also include comments that seem to imply that the Über-marionettes were puppets. The notes provide specifications about their height, which should be 5 to 5½ feet, except for heroes and noteworthy people, which could be up to 6 feet tall, and gods, which should be 6½ feet tall and over, if necessary.Footnote 54 A curious correction may help explain the apparently contradictory statements about the nature of the Über-marionette. In the Über-Marion Notebook A, which lists the same personnel as the documents related to the Dresden project, we find this entry: “25 × actors or manipulators Über-marionettes” to which is added—obviously at a later date, as the slightly different ink and writing seems to indicate—“4½ to 5” inside a small rectangle.Footnote 55 The ambiguity of the notes in these documents, in other words, seems to reflect the decision process Craig was undergoing, not so much about deciding whether the Über-marionette is a higher version of the human performer or the marionette but rather whether to employ actors or puppets in his Dresden plan.
The decision Craig was trying to make may be explained by considering the nature of this project. If we study it in the context of Craig's theatrical projects, it may turn out to be something quite different from a concrete attempt to create a purely puppetlike Über-marionette. From the early stages of his career, Craig used models to explore performance possibilities. His training in graphic arts (woodcutting, etching, etc.) was of primary importance for his study of space, scenery, costume, and lighting and the overall proportions and spatial relationships between components (including performers) that should be used in the production of certain plays, whether or not an actual performance took place. He also used models and sketches as graphical and tridimensional notes for potential productions. The clearest example is his mise-en-scène for Bach's St. Matthew Passion, on which he worked for years, using and perfecting his well-known model stage, without ever producing the oratorio theatrically.Footnote 56
Given Craig's intensive and meaningful use of models, there seems to be more than a mere chance that his Über-Marionette International Theatre was not meant to create a concrete instance of the “real” Über-marionette but rather was a project that allowed him to study the movements and potentialities that could be exploited once the Über-marionette truly appeared. Craig was well aware that the ordinary contemporary performer could not be used as “material.” He could not expect unmanageable actors to offer themselves as guinea pigs for him to experiment on. This would explain the correction in the Über-Marion Notebook A (“25 × actors or manipulators Über-marionettes”); even his potential Über-marionettes—Irving, Duse, and Duncan—could not be used as mere subjects on which to experiment. Duncan was an artist in her own right and far too independent to submit to Craig—so much so that despite their sentimental liaison and Craig's admiration for her, Duncan never worked with him—and as an inspiration rather than possible laboratory material, she could at most be passively watched so Craig could focus on and select some traits that the Über-marionette should have. Irving was also out of the question for a number of reasons, most saliently the fact that he died in 1905, when Craig was beginning the project. A different argument could be made for Duse. Her public statements on actors, as Craig himself pointed out on several occasions, were quite consonant with his own, and her theatrical history—especially her professional relationship with Gabriele D'Annunzio—showed that she could fully devote herself to a single artist. If we believe Isadora Duncan, Duse showed her willingness to devote herself to Craig's art as soon as she saw his creations for Rosmersholm.Footnote 57 As a performer, she had traits that may have appealed to Craig—such as her talent for blushing or paling at will, a sign that she might have been or may have become able to completely control her body—or her celebrated ability to efface herself, to vanish behind her character.Footnote 58 In this context Craig's entreaties in “A Letter to Eleonora Duse from Gordon Craig” and his essay “To Madame Eleonora Duse” might be construed as appeals to her to become the supple material he needed, a human model on which he could experiment. His intention may have been taking shape from 1904, when he noted in his Dresden papers that “ET and ED must hear the truth and must admit it as such.”Footnote 59 (There is little doubt that ET is Ellen Terry and ED is Eleonora Duse.) Craig was too skeptical, however, to expect her to give him the answer he wanted, although apparently the possibility of succeeding was enough for him to believe it was worth trying to persuade her. As the likelihood that Duse would accede to his request was slim, he could count on only puppets—a new kind of puppet of his own conception—as material on which to experiment. If that is the case, then the concept of the Über-marionette and its relationship with the human performer are worth reconsidering.
Craig's statements on the need to replace the human actor with a nonhuman performer seem to work against the hypothesis that the Über-marionette could be a model for the human being. His most radical essays in this respect are “The Artists of the Theatre of the Future” and “The Actor and the Über-Marionette.” Let us not forget, however, Craig's habit of mischievously employing misleading tactics, what I called theorizing by misdirection, so that only a restricted number of adepts—those who really disinterestedly wanted the art of the theatre to develop and were willing to take the trouble to go beneath the surface of his statements—could understand the essence of his statements.
One of the curious aspects of “The Artists of the Theatre of the Future” is that here Craig describes the perfect actor and also—apparently contradicting himself—states that the actor must be eliminated. The language he uses to illustrate the features of ideal actors is quite close—albeit with some differences—to the language he later uses to define the Über-marionette: they must be creatures whose art is defined by intellectual strength, and the intellect must govern all and limit all individual freedom so they can transform both self and emotion into usable material. As with the Über-marionette, they must become tools for shaping and communicating perfect symbols. In the first stages of their inner process of transformation, they must find such symbols by delving into their own “depths, to learn all that lies there” and then move into a different sphere—imagination—allowing for the creation of purely intellectual symbols “which, without exhibiting the bare passions, would none the less tell us clearly about them.” After that, the actor will learn that “the symbols are to be made mainly from material which lies outside his person.”Footnote 60 The obvious difference between this kind of performer and the Über-marionette is the presence and use of an emotional sphere: passions are the raw material to be neutralized and transformed into unemotional symbols, a process that reaches perfection once the source of the symbols is found outside, rather than inside, the performer. Craig's words portray an educational path by subtraction: perfect actors should first learn to unemotionally investigate their own passions and transform them into symbols (thus separating themselves from them), and then gradually move away from their own interior world to find their material outside the self, thus eliminating emotion. The final step is the actors' “disappearance,” an event that seems to imply the annihilation of the human performer. However, if we look more closely at Craig's statement, his words seem to point in a different direction: “The actor as he is today, must ultimately disappear and be merged in something else if works of art are to be seen in our kingdom of the Theatre.”Footnote 61 This passage seems to some extent hidden, coming immediately after a sentence that informs the reader that the actor's future will be explained at the end of the essay; this positioning suggests that once again Craig's misdirecting tactics may be at work so as to induce his reader to pay less attention to the statement that closes the paragraph. But its theoretical relevance becomes clearer when we see that Craig links it directly with his major essay on the Über-marionette, although he hides the reference in a footnote: “See ‘The Actor & the Über-Marionette’ in the April number of ‘The Mask’ 1908.”Footnote 62 Craig declares that the “actor as he is today” will disappear to “be merged in something else” (we may infer that this will happen after the performer has walked the path Craig has laid). Merging, however, is not eliminating: what Craig seems to say here is that once actors learn to detach themselves from human passions, they will disappear into new creatures, not that they will be eliminated. And Craig's reference to “The Actor and the Über-Marionette” suggests that the “something else” he is talking about is the new puppet with which he is experimenting in his Über-Marionette International Theatre.
The same apparent paradox in “The Artists of the Theatre of the Future” finds its way into “The Actor and the Über-Marionette.” Although in this essay Craig's exclusion of actors from the art of the theatre seems to be unequivocal, a puzzling statement can be found on its initial pages:
As I have written elsewhere, the theatre will continue its growth and actors will continue for some years to hinder its development. But I see a loop-hole by which in time the actors can escape from the bondage they are in. They must create for themselves a new form of acting, consisting for the main part of symbolical gesture. To-day they impersonate and interpret; to-morrow they must represent and interpret; and the third day they must create. By this means style may return.Footnote 63
The “loop-hole” Craig is describing is similar to the itinerary he envisages in “The Artists of the Theatre of the Future,” a journey in which the actor moves from representational to symbolical acting, gradually leaving behind the emotion of impersonation in order to reach the detachment of the artist in the creative process, a coolness on which Craig expands in the subsequent conversation between the painter, the actor, and the musician. Although the essay is not in the Socratic form that the author uses for the two dialogues on the art of the theatre, the maieutic process is recognizable in the long exchange among these three, Craig's point of view being voiced mainly by the painter. The dialogue centers on the question Joseph Roach identifies as the vital key of Diderot's Observations sur Garrick: “Why should the actor's art differ from that of the sculptor, the painter, the orator, and the musician? Why should the great actor not command materials, processes, and techniques[?]”Footnote 64 In Craig's text, the painter insists that acting cannot be an art because the performer “is subject to every conceivable change which emotion chooses to bring about.” What is especially interesting is his final suggestion to the actor after the latter accuses him of shattering actors' finest dream – that of becoming artists – and of giving them nothing to compensate:
“No, no, that's not for me to give you. That's for you to find. Surely there must be laws at the roots of the Art of the Theatre, just as there are Laws at the roots of all true Arts, which if found and mastered, would bring you all you desire?” “Yes, the search would bring the actors to a wall.” “Leap it, then!” “Too high!” “Scale it, then!” “How do we know where it would lead?” “Why, up and over.” “Yes, but that's talking wildly, talking in the air.” “Well, that's the direction you fellows have to go . . . fly in the air, live in the air. Something will follow when some of you begin to. I suppose,” continued he, “you will get at the root of the matter in time, and then what a splendid future opens before you!”Footnote 65
Craig is saying that a fearful wall stands between the actor and art that must be climbed with great difficulty. Of course this suggestion does not give any practical clue to actors; it is rather intended to spur them to move away from the inartistic tradition to which they are chained. This is a necessity, he suggests in 1909: “But they [actors] must be taught to learn to know by being taught to search.”Footnote 66 Craig goes further and points to a more practical suggestion that echoes the 1907 letter to Duse: in order to become an artist the actor must pursue death. Craig is once again playing his hide-and-seek game, insisting on a metaphor that may well scare away materialistic actors; only those who want to become artists strongly enough will make an effort and go beneath the surface of his words to understand his intention. But death is not just a theoretical scarecrow for Craig: as an ideal it is mentioned over and over again in “The Actor and the Über-Marionette,” both explicitly and indirectly as a renunciation of life.Footnote 67 And a rich and positive ideal it is in his words:
[It is possible to draw inspiration] from that mysterious, joyous, and superbly complete life which is called Death . . . that life of shadow and of unknown shapes where all can not be blackness and fog as is supposed, but vivid colour, vivid light, sharp cut form, and which one finds peopled with strange, fierce and solemn figures, pretty figures and calm figures, and those figures impelled to some wondrous harmony of movement, all this is something more than a mere matter of fact; from this idea of death which seems a kind of spring, a blossoming [. . .] can come so vast an inspiration, that with unhesitating exultation I leap forward to it and behold, in an instant, I find my arms full of flowers.Footnote 68
When we connect this passage with the Washington Post letter to Duse, Craig's conception of the pursuit of death becomes more practically significant than it may appear at first reading. Craig insists on the necessity of getting rid of emotion and subjectivity—and realism with them—if an actor is to reach some kind of spiritual, universal truth. The life that subjectivity and passion express is inartistic and sterile; it is the smoke and steam of mortality. In contrast, death represents a state in which this sort of life is excluded, terminated, to be replaced with a richer form of vitality. Anyone familiar with Tadeusz Kantor's “theatre of death” may perceive at least part of Craig's meaning and the actual possibility of applying it to performance.Footnote 69 Life crystallized in a material cage, focused on all-too-human emotion and physical reality, is in fact lifeless, while death, which frees the individual from all such insignificant interests, allows the artist to explore a different, universal, eternal, and lively life. Craig is suggesting that actors get rid of the sort of mortality that binds them to such inessentials so as to be able to grasp a different sort of beauty, a deathlike beauty because it is characterized by the exclusion of all material, sterile lifelike chains that bind contemporary performers. As he notes in 1909: “[D]eath is the one point in life where an entirely new conception of life becomes necessary. To feel/sense the secret which must lie under the mask of what we call Death, that is the part of the artist.”Footnote 70
One of his best-known statements supports this interpretation. When Craig declares that “[t]he actor must go, and in his place comes the inanimate figure—the Über-marionette we may call him, until he has won for himself a better name,” he is reiterating this very concept.Footnote 71 Here he defines the Über-marionette as an “inanimate figure.” The Oxford English Dictionary offers this definition of the term “inanimate”: “Not animated or alive; destitute of life, lifeless; spec. not endowed with animal life.” The Über-marionette is therefore destitute of life, of animal life. In other words it is deathlike, and as Craig's invitation to Duse to embrace death suggests, he believed it is a condition that even a human actor has the potential to reach.
Actors, however, are still quite far from achieving this goal, according to Craig. Even a potential “sybil” such as Duse has not responded yet to Craig's invitation. No prospective human example of deathlike perfection is therefore available to him; until the actor demonstrates a willingness to start on the path he indicates, the only available possibility is offering past examples of perfection: the puppets of antiquity, especially Hindu puppets. He devotes several pages of “The Actor and the Über-Marionette” to the otherworldly connotations of such figures. What has not been sufficiently stressed, however, is Craig's assertion of the unattainability of such perfection, which is beyond reach, irremediably contaminated by humanity. This is why Craig does not propose going back to the idols of the past but instead promotes an entirely new performer, the Über-marionette, whose very Nietzschean name signifies that it will exceed the characteristics of the marionette. The impossibility of bringing back the “idols” of the past and the need to look forward instead evoke analogous concepts that inform an essay Craig published in another of his periodicals, The Marionnette, in 1918: Heinrich von Kleist's essay “On the Marionette Theatre.”Footnote 72 The influence of this essay on “The Actor and the Über-Marionette” has been acknowledged: both authors agree that the marionette is superior to human beings and that it represents perfect harmony.Footnote 73 What has been underestimated, however, is the influence of another notion that permeates Kleist's essay on Craig's conception of the Über-marionette. Kleist's main argument is that consciousness prevents humankind from attaining grace, and his explicit allusion to the third chapter of Genesis, where the Fall is described, implies that this inability was caused by the original sin.Footnote 74 One other useful detail may be gathered from the conclusion of the chapter in Genesis: after God banished Adam and Eve from Eden, he placed a cherub at its entrance so they could never return. The implication in Kleist's essay is that going back to an Edenic state of grace is impossible for humanity. Kleist, however, is no pessimist: once he excludes that solution, he suggests another pathway. If going back is impossible, then humanity must take the opposite direction: instead of pursuing innocence it should look for knowledge, so that—like in the case of a concave mirror that, as we near its focal point, shows our image farther and farther away until it reaches an infinite distance at the focal point and suddenly, as we pass that point, shows our image very close—by pushing knowledge to its utmost limit humanity might paradoxically be able to reach innocence, and therefore grace, once again.Footnote 75
The idea of the impossibility of going back and the need to look forward until the actor reaches death and “an entirely new conception of life becomes necessary” are also at the heart of Craig's discourse on the Über-marionette.Footnote 76 This is why a puppet—even the life-sized sacred puppet Ananda Coomaraswamy described in The Mask—is no longer an option.Footnote 77 Craig studied puppets in his work with the Über-Marionette International Theatre, at his Florence School for the Art of the Theatre, and in the essays he published in The Mask, refining his knowledge of their history and the laws governing their movements. At the same time he urged devoted actors to move forward, leaving behind the chains of tradition. Gaining experience to the point of dying to the theatrical world as they know it, they would prepare themselves for the “merging” he hinted at in “The Artists of the Theatre of the Future,” so that after a long journey the Über-marionette might appear. There seems to be both the marionette and the actor in the Über-marionette: the performer sheds the mortal actor's shape to merge with the newly made divine marionette Craig was refining in his Über-Marionette International Theatre project, thus creating the Über-marionette, a being superior to both. This understanding of Craig's ideas would explain the apparent ambivalence of his statements about the actor. It would also explain why four years later he emphasized the immaterial nature of the wires connecting the Über-marionette to divinityFootnote 78 and why in Henry Irving he stated: “Now an Über-marionette is all sorts of things at which I have hinted in books and drawings which I have made since 1907. I only hope that I have not wearied anybody with the notion of an actor who should be all that a marionette is and much more—and that I do not weary you now” (HI, 32; italics added). The Über-marionette is not a puppet but a living performer who is the result of the fusion of a human being who is dead to all imperfections (the smoke and steam of mortality) with the perfection of the marionette (the fire of the gods and demons). This idea is compatible with what Craig writes in “A Plea for Two Theatres”:
I have been told (since I wrote of the Über-Marionette) of a race of actors that existed (and a few today preserve the tradition), who were fitted to be part and parcel of the most durable theatre it is possible to conceive. When I heard of this I was astounded, pleasurably astounded. I was told that this race of actors was so noble . . . sparing themselves no pain and austerely disciplining themselves . . . that all the weaknesses of the flesh were eradicated, and nothing remained but the perfect man. This race was not English or American, but Indian. [ . . . ]
If the Western actor can become what I am told the Eastern actor was and is, I withdraw all that I have written in my essay “On the Actor and the Über-Marionette.”Footnote 79
Here Craig is not really recanting what he said in “The Actor and the Über-Marionette”; rather, he is provocatively stating that if the Western actor could reach the perfection of Indian performers, the merging he theorized in that essay would no longer be necessary. He is not repudiating his ideal; he is just suggesting that if actors could reach a condition of perfect deathlike life without merging with—that is, assuming the traits of—his newly conceived puppets, then the difficult way he suggested would be irrelevant because there would be no need to look outside actors for an instrument to improve them and attain the ideal. But Craig did not believe Western actors could follow the steps of Indian actors, and thus he challenged them once again to move forward on the path he had outlined, as his words in “Asia America Europe”—which immediately follows the last installment of “A Plea for Two Theatres” in the same issue of The Mask—show:
[W]e are like fools beside wise men, we Europeans and Americans standing by Asiatics. [. . .] Why delude yourself into fancying you are capable of understanding without first feeling . . . of feeling without experiencing . . . of experiencing without being? For I tell you it is impossible. [. . .] [T]he path is English and is American, and it's not on the road to Mandalay that we are moving . . . or are expected to move. Europe and America look to us, remember, to remain ourselves.Footnote 80
Thus, his argument in “The Actor and the Über-Marionette” endures, suggesting an itinerary for the Western actor to follow. What is still missing, and what cannot be found in Craig's works, is a concrete and detailed definition of the Über-marionette, and I think for a very good reason. Some critics have tried to provide a concrete “solution” for the Über-marionette enigma, as if, when Craig was refining his notion, he was trying to create a working technical solution for the imperfection of acting. But as Lorenzo Mango points out, Craig's discourse on the Über-marionette develops at an ontological, not at a practical, level.Footnote 81 This is why, when in “The Actor and the Über-Marionette,” the actor complains that the painter does not suggest how to make his profession an art, the painter—Craig's alter ego—answers: “No, no, that's not for me to give you. That's for you to find.”Footnote 82 The actor seeks a practical answer, but the painter can only point to the path and the ideal; the practical details are up to the actors who decide to walk that path. The only well-defined features of the Über-marionette are those Craig repeatedly remarks in his essays in order to define its divine essence: a quality that actors can acquire by depriving themselves of all debased and uncontrollable human traits and by ideally joining with the sacred idols Craig was trying to evoke through his experiments in the Über-Marionette International Theatre.Footnote 83
