Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T22:00:31.143Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Dynamics of azimuthally oscillating cylinder wakes

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  30 March 2026

Ayush Boral
Affiliation:
Department of Aerospace Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology , Kanpur 208016, India
Pradeep Moise
Affiliation:
Department of Aerospace Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology , Kanpur 208016, India
Arnab Samanta*
Affiliation:
Department of Aerospace Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology , Kanpur 208016, India
*
Corresponding author: Arnab Samanta, asamanta@iitk.ac.in

Abstract

We numerically study the flow past an azimuthally oscillating cylinder at Reynolds number ${\textit{Re}}=250$ to analyse the three-dimensionalities observed in the recent experiments of Bhattacharyya et al. (J. Fluid Mech., vol. 950, 2022, p. A10). Specifically, we focus on the two newly discovered three-dimensional instability modes, referred to as modes Z and Y in the experiments, by suitably varying the cylinder oscillation amplitude and forcing frequency. Our direct numerical simulations (DNS) visually confirm the unique honeycomb-like structure of mode Y, also matching its spanwise wavelength, while mode Z, also referred to as mode D elsewhere, is not found at the expected parametric space but at an oscillation amplitude three times higher. Spectral proper orthogonal decomposition modes extracted from the DNS data reveal the near-wake dynamics of mode Y to be modulated by the forcing frequency and its subharmonics. Mode D/Z is found to be strongly correlated with a two-dimensional modal regime, especially at the forcing frequency, its subharmonic and higher harmonics. Mode Y does not show significant correlations with this two-dimensional flow except at a low frequency and only at its far wake. The honeycomb nature of mode Y is a result of its relatively higher forcing frequency causing multiple vortex sheddings over a rather compact space. Higher cylinder oscillation amplitude increases the overall drag, with the two-dimensional flow regimes generally yielding lower drag and lift. The results here suggest mode Y to be a unique three-dimensional mode of azimuthally oscillating cylinders and mode D/Z to be merely an intermediate state with the cylinder wake transitioning from the classical three-dimensional mode B to a two-dimensional state.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2026. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematic of the computational domain used in this study showing the location of the oscillating cylinder and the numerical boundary conditions (as labelled) are shown in $(a)$, while in $(b)$ a slice of the domain around the cylinder in the $x{-}y$ plane shows the uniform mesh used here.

Figure 1

Figure 2.A mode map of oscillating cylinder wake summarising the cases investigated in Bhattacharyya et al. (2022) (hollow symbols) and the cases numerically simulated in this study (filled symbols). Specific cases shown, including their spanwise vortical structures ($Q$-criterion, with $Q=0.1$) are , mode B; , mode C; , mode D/Z; , two-dimensional flow and , mode Y. The dashed lines correspond to the lock-on regions of Bhattacharyya et al. (2022) while the shaded region shows the modal boundary for mode Y computed in this study.

Figure 2

Table 1.Different mesh resolutions showing some important numerical and flow parameters. Here, $\Delta x/D$ is the streamwise spatial resolution, $N_g$ is the mesh size, $\Delta t U_{\infty }/D$ is the time resolution and $f_r|_{\textit {max}}$ is the frequency ratio at which the maximum energy is observed in the SPOD spectrum (see figure 6$a$). Among flow parameters, $C_l|_{\mathrm{RMS}}$ is the r.m.s. value of lift coefficient and $\lambda _z/D$ is the spanwise wavelength of the vortical structures, which is visualised in the last column via a $Q$-criterion of $Q=0.1$ in the wake. $\lambda _z/D$ reported here are averaged values calculated over the domain $x/D\in [0.5,3]$ and $y/D\in [0.5,1.5]$.

Figure 3

Table 2.Summary of cases simulated in this study, their flow parameters and the observed modal structure (see also figure 2). Case II did not yield the ‘mode Z’ of the experiments while case S indicates the stationary cylinder case, used here as a reference. The spanwise wavelengths $\lambda _z/D$ of the present results are matched with the experiments of Bhattacharyya et al. (2022) whenever possible, while the lift and drag coefficients are recorded for some. Case IV results for $\lambda _z/D$ are not reported for its poor spanwise coherence. $f_r|_{\textit {max}}$ records the dominant frequency from SPOD results for selected cases.

Figure 4

Figure 3.Visualisations of mode Y corresponding to case I ($\theta _0 = 3\pi /4$ and $F_r =2.75$, see table 2), showing $(a)$ vorticity contours ($|\omega _z|$) at $z/D=3$ and $(c)$ spanwise vortices visualised via the $Q$-criterion ($Q=0.1$) based on present simulations, compared with $(b)$ top and $(d)$ side views of the corresponding experimental images, respectively (Bhattacharyya et al.2022). Additionally, $(e)$ shows $w/U_{\infty }$ variation at $(x,y)$ = $(1.6D,0.5D)$ (marked as a vertical dashed line in $c$) and $(f)$ shows the PSD of the same, where the dominant wavelength is highlighted via a vertical dashed line.

Figure 5

Figure 4.Visualisations of case II of table 2 ($\theta _0 = \pi /2$ and $F_r = 1$), showing $(a)$ contours of $|\omega _z|$ at $z/D=0$ and $(b)$ spanwise vortices visualised via the $Q$-criterion ($Q=0.1$) based on the present simulations, the latter compared with $(c)$ spanwise view of corresponding experimental images (Bhattacharyya et al.2022).

Figure 6

Figure 5.Visualisations of mode corresponding to case III ($\theta _0 = 3\pi /2$ and $F_r = 1$, see table 2), showing $(a)$ contours of $|\omega _z|$ at $z/D=0$ and $(c)$ spanwise vortices visualised via the $Q$-criterion ($Q=0.1$) based on the present simulations, compared with $(b)$ top and $(d)$ side views of corresponding experimental images for case II ($\theta _0 = \pi /2$ and $F_r = 1$), respectively (Bhattacharyya et al.2022). Additionally, $(e)$ shows $w/U_{\infty }$ variation at $(x,y)$ = $(2D,-0.7D)$ (marked as vertical dashed line in $c$) and $(f)$ shows the PSD of the same, with the dominant wavelength highlighted via a vertical dashed line.

Figure 7

Figure 6.Coherent spatio-temporal features for case I of table 2 (mode Y), showing $(a)$ the first SPOD eigenvalue ($|\lambda ^{(1)}(f_r)|$) (black curve) and power spectrum of fluctuating spanwise velocity from a probe at $(x,y,z) = (D,0.5D,0)$ (grey curve) as a function of $f_r$, while the contours of $w/U_\infty$ are shown for $(b,h)$ DNS results and the corresponding five leading SPOD eigenmodes at $(c,i)$$f_r = 0.62$; $(d,j)$$f_r = 1.37$; $(e,k)$$f_r = 2.75$; $(f,l)$$f_r = 4.12$; and $(g,m)$$f_r = 5.37$, all shown as projections on the $z$ (left) and $y$-planes (right), respectively. The horizontal line in any view traces the location of the viewing plane for the other view.

Figure 8

Figure 7.Contours of streamwise vorticity $\omega _x$ for the dominant SPOD mode, occurring at $f_r=2.75$ for case I, shown on (a) $y{-}z$ plane at $x/D=2$ and (b) $x{-}z$ plane at $y/D=0.5$.

Figure 9

Figure 8.Coherent spatio-temporal features for case III of table 2 (mode D/Z) showing $(a)$ the first SPOD eigenvalue ($|\lambda ^{(1)}(f_r)|$) (black curve) and power spectrum of fluctuating spanwise velocity from a probe at $(x,y,z) = (D,0.5D,0)$ (grey lines) as a function of $f_r$, while the contours of $w/U_\infty$ are shown for $(b,h)$ DNS results and the corresponding five leading SPOD eigenmodes at $(c,i)$$f_r = 0.5$; $(d,j)$$f_r = 1.0$; $(e,k)$$f_r = 1.5$; $(f,l)$$f_r = 2.0$; and $(g,m)$$f_r = 3.0$, all shown as projections on the $z$ (left) and $y$-planes (right), respectively. The horizontal line in any view traces the location of the viewing plane for the other view.

Figure 10

Figure 9.Contours of streamwise vorticity $\omega _x$ for the dominant SPOD mode, occurring at $f_r=1.0$ for case III, shown on (a) $y{-}z$ plane at $x/D=2$ and (b) $x{-}z$ plane at $y/D=0.5$.

Figure 11

Figure 10.Cross-correlation between cases I (mode Y) and III (mode D/Z) with case VI (forced two-dimensional flow) of table 2 are shown in $(a)$ as a split graph for the respective correlation contours. The red star in $(a)$ indicates $f_r = 0.5$ for which isosurfaces of Q at $5 \times 10^{-5}$ are shown for $(b)$ case III (mode D/Z); $(c)$ case VI (forced two-dimensional flow) and $(d)$ case I (mode Y) to demonstrate any visual similarity between them, if at all. The blue dashed lines in $(a)$ show the dominant frequencies of the SPOD spectra for these modes (see figures 6, 8 and 15), respectively.

Figure 12

Figure 11.Variation of $(a)$ lift coefficient $C_l$ and $(b)$ drag coefficient $C_d$ over two oscillation cycles shown for (black), case I (mode Y); (magenta), case II; (blue), case III (mode D/Z); (red), case VI (forced 2-D flow) and (grey), case S (stationary cylinder) of table 2. The $\omega _z$ contours are shown for $(c)$ case III (mode D/Z); $(d)$ case II; $(e)$ case VI (forced 2-D flow); $(f)$ case I (mode Y) and $(g)$ case S (stationary cylinder). In $(c-g)$ solid and dashed arrows locate primary and secondary vortices, respectively.

Figure 13

Figure 12.Visualisations of case IV of table 2 for mode B showing $(a)$ computed vorticity contours ($|\omega _z|$) at $z/D=0$; $(b)$ computed spanwise structures in $x{-}z$ plane visualised via isosurfaces of $Q$ ($Q=0.1$) compared with $(c)$ spanwise view of corresponding experimental images from Bhattacharyya et al. (2022).

Figure 14

Figure 13.Visualisations of case V of table 2 for mode C showing $(a)$ computed vorticity contours ($|\omega _z|$) at $z/D=0$; $(c)$ computed spanwise structures in $x{-}z$ plane visualised via isosurfaces of $Q$ ($Q=0.1$) compared with $(b)$ top view and $(d)$ spanwise view, respectively, of corresponding experimental images from Bhattacharyya et al. (2022).

Figure 15

Figure 14.Visualisations of case VI of table 2 for forced 2-D flow showing $(a)$ computed vorticity contours ($|\omega _z|$) at $z/D=0$; $(c)$ computed spanwise structures in $x{-}z$ plane visualised via isosurfaces of $Q$ ($Q=0.1$) compared with $(b)$ top view and $(d)$ spanwise view, respectively, of corresponding experimental images from Bhattacharyya et al. (2022).

Figure 16

Figure 15.Coherent spatio-temporal features for case VI of table 2 (2-D flow) showing $(a)$ the first SPOD eigenvalue ($|\lambda ^{(1)}(f_r)|$) and power spectrum of fluctuating cross-stream velocity from a probe at $(x,y,z) = (D,0.5D,0)$ (grey lines) as a function of $f_r$, while the contours of $w/U_{\infty }$ are show for $(b,f)$ DNS results and the corresponding three leading SPOD eigenmodes at $(c,g)$$f_r = 0.62$; $(d,h)$$f_r = 1.25$; $(e,i)$$f_r = 2.0$, all shown as projections on the $z$ (left) and $y$-planes (right), respectively. The horizontal line in any view traces the location of the viewing plane for the other view.

Figure 17

Figure 16.Convergence of the SPOD modes quantified via relative error $\epsilon$ as a function of the number of ensembles $N_b$ for $(a)$ case I (mode Y) and $(b)$ case III (mode D/Z) showing the , first; , second and , third most energetic modes. The horizontal grey line indicates $\epsilon = 5\,\%$.

Supplementary material: File

Boral et al. supplementary movie 1

mode Y visualization
Download Boral et al. supplementary movie 1(File)
File 9.2 MB
Supplementary material: File

Boral et al. supplementary movie 2

mode Z visualization
Download Boral et al. supplementary movie 2(File)
File 4.6 MB