The literature on veiling has exploded in recent years, much of it rehearsing familiar arguments with little new contribution of perspective or analysis. So why am I encouraging anyone and everyone with an interest in the subject to read this book? The short answer is: it's brilliant. Stephanie Cronin's introduction is the best comprehensive discussion of the issues connected with the politicization of veiling—national, social, cultural, historical—that I have seen. The essays cover countries and whole regions—the Caucuses, the Balkans—whose histories in regard to this issue are almost never addressed; the essays on the more familiar national stories of Afghanistan, Iran, and Turkey provide striking revisions to conventional wisdom. The scholarship in the individual essays is impressively thorough. How did this volume come to pull together such original and unexpected material? The answer is explicit in the volume title. Instead of interrogating the issue of veiling, the volume presents an elegantly simple reversal: Anti-Veiling Campaigns in the Muslim World: Gender, Modernism, and the Politics of Dress.
By switching the inquiry to antiveiling campaigns in the Muslim world, the volume is able to exclude those national cases in which either formal European colonialism or the politics of minority rights have been most central. Instead, the authors concentrate on Muslim societies and states that turned against what had been locally accepted as their own sartorial and cultural practice. This is a different dynamic than the external imposition of foreign practices, and all the essays make clear that during the periods in question (mostly early 20th century, though some essays extend their range earlier and later) intellectual exchange and political arguments flowed as much if not more among regional Muslim communities as between the supposedly binary discourses of the “West” and the “East.” But in almost every case, the authors reveal how elite and/or radical women's projects of modern emancipation through unveiling ran into middle-class aspirations to attain the perceived status of veiled seclusion, poor women's inability to replace their habitual clothing with new wardrobes, and male strategies to utilize antiveiling campaigns as part of the consolidation of weak central state authority.
Early and mid-20th-century antiveiling campaigns were diverse efforts specific to local conditions and political pressures. Cronin does a masterful job of tying together the underlying trends shared among them while noting their dissimilarities. She wisely sidesteps the endless arguments over whether women's veiling involves agency or subjugation (a fool's choice when the question is extracted from any specific context). Instead, Cronin focuses on the power dynamics and tensions inherent to state-sponsored campaigns that legitimized themselves in terms of national modernization and claimed to be emancipatory, even as they depended upon authoritarian means and sought to entrench new lines of hierarchy. In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, unveiling initiatives were often indigenous efforts by women, and modernism was a contested alternative and a mostly elite project. But after World War I, new governing regimes sought to deemphasize social cleavages and shape unified national identities out of heterogeneous populations. Modernity became a shared national goal, and modernization became the hegemonic justification for repressing some modes of experience in favor of others. Cronin points out that everyone claimed to be acting in the interests of the modern nation (or soviet), even as competing visions of a proper modernity, and of the proper relation of modernity to tradition, came into conflict. There was plenty on which to disagree: the role of religion and religious authorities in public and private life; issues of class and regional identity; and women's national and familial roles. These competing visions politicized veiling as a newly contentious symbol of rival claims to power, even though negative popular and religious reactions to unveiling at the time were usually muted.
The collected essays present a fascinating overview of “modernization” as a defensive posture, and a selective endorsement and delegitimization of traditions. Early 20th-century states and elites in Turkey, Iran, and Afghanistan were concerned by the loss of regional autonomy (and territories) and their vulnerability to the expansionist military and economic tendencies of European imperial powers (including Russia). The response tended to be local initiatives to reform state and society, including a refashioning of dress and behavior that targeted men even more directly than women. Contemporary conventional narratives have tended to elide the emphasis on men's clothing and give the impression that veiling was legally banned by powerful central states. Instead, the collected scholars make clear (Kathryn Libal, Sevgi Adak, and Murat Metinsoy on Turkey; Jasamin Rostam-Kolayi, Afshin Matin-Asgari, and Firoozeh Kashani-Sabet on Iran; Thomas Wide on Afghanistan) that while men's dress reforms were often officially imposed, women's dress reforms were dealt with through support rather than regulation. But relations between central and regional officials were often strained, and local administrative officers could be heavy handed in their enforcement (rather than encouragement) of unveiling, although central authorities usually regarded this as dangerously provocative. In the Balkans and the Caucasus, the cases were somewhat different. Nathalie Clayer explains that in Albania, the combination of weak state sovereignty and the realities of being a Muslim-majority but multiconfessional nation within Europe pushed both state and society to identify secular modernization as the best hope for strengthened autonomy. For Bulgaria, Mary Neuburger explores the extent to which the local Slavic-speaking Muslim minority was both targeted and celebrated as the essentially authentic national fragment whose dress was to be reclaimed as the epitome of national folkloric costume as long as it was properly cleansed of external “Turkish” (linguistic or religious) contaminants. But in a surprising chapter on the Soviet exceptions, Marianne Kamp makes clear that although local discourses on modernization in Azerbaijan and Uzbekistan had been indigenous and more connected with international Muslim (Turkic) publications than a “colonial” Russian or Soviet state, the antiveiling campaigns in the Caucasus were earlier and more radical than elsewhere. They were also subject to a much more severe backlash, with unveiled Uzbek women in particular facing a uniquely high rate of mortal violence from within their own communities.
Modernization through dress reform also provided more subtle costs and opportunities, tending to expand consumer culture as well as local production by some tailors and manufacturers in a period when most women were still expected to home-produce family clothing. With neither the economic capacity nor the sewing expertise to produce new sets of these more closely tailored items, women were encouraged to locate themselves in a newly gendered class of consumers rather than producers; sponsored domestic sewing classes in Iran and elsewhere seem to have offered assurance that the unveiled “new women” would not challenge the limits of the modernity in which she was being urged to participate.
State-sponsored antiveiling campaigns were not the dictatorial imposition of external practices on cowed populations that much local contemporary historiography makes them out to be. Neither were they the emancipatory attacks on patriarchy that some have claimed. Rather, dress reform for both men and women was part of a modernization project that initially seemed to offer the promise of greater sovereignty for both states and individuals. That it is conventionally recollected as almost exclusively a gendered imposition by authoritarian regimes or valiant vanguards (depending on the perspective of the narrator) says more about contemporary politics than about the realities of local experience and policy. This excellent volume goes a long way in demystifying those entrenched narratives, providing an unusually comparative overview of (anti)veiling policies and politics in Muslim societies and states.
