At a recent meeting of the Association for the Study of African American Life and History (ASALH), a host of plenaries and concurrent sessions theorized the politics of Emancipation as nonevent and the practice of historiography in the wake of the fiftieth anniversary of the March on Washington. Held in October 2013 in Jacksonville, Florida, the 98th Annual Meeting of ASALH attracted a record number of attendees, despite obstacles associated with the shutdown of the federal government, closures at a local airport, and increased mobilization in opposition to the state's controversial “Stand Your Ground” statutes.Footnote 1 Indeed, rushing into one conference room a few minutes late, having just presented earlier that day myself, I was struck by the sheer number of scholars in the room, the palpable enthusiasm to get things under way. Then again, perhaps I shouldn't have been too surprised. Taking as its subject Shonda Rhimes's hit television show Scandal – the Season 3 premiere of which had aired only the night before – the panel stoked a range of interests: race and popular culture, matters of sexuality and desire, even the impeccable style of protagonist and professional “fixer” Olivia Pope (played by actress Kerry Washington). Titled “Crashing the Ol’ Boys Club: Interrogating Power and Representation in ABC's Scandal,” the discussion sutured fans and critics alike into a collective accounting for the effects of a nation's apparent seduction by the labyrinthine exploits of Pope, head of the foremost crisis-management firm in Washington, DC, and her paramour, white, married, Republican US President Fitzgerald Thomas Grant III (played by Tony Goldwyn).
The extended, at times heated, exchange in response to panelists’ interpretations of the show, however, exceeded the bounds of Rhimes's latest network sensation, pinpointing a key debate within the context of African American studies more broadly. Several audience members contested the construal of Pope (based, in part, on Judy Smith, special assistant and deputy press secretary in the George H. W. Bush administration and co-executive producer of the show) as a modern-day Mammy, Sapphire, or Jezebel, likewise problematizing perceived misappropriations of Patricia Hill Collins's foundational work on stereotyping, and attendant elisions of historical specificity analogizing a contemporary fictional character to Saartjie Baartman and/or Sally Hemings. Analyses of the professional and intimate lives of Pope as inextricable from a history-laden context of interracial violence and coercion, those likening the illicit rendezvous between Olivia and “Fitz” to “consensual rape” clashed with impassioned endorsements of Rhimes's public display of black female eroticism, embodiment, and pleasure on the small screen. “Why can't she just be brilliant, just be good at her job? Why does she have to open her legs?” opined one participant. “Can black women ever have an unapologetic sexual self in public without being called Jezebel?” intervened Brittney Cooper. “How is it that a black woman who owns and runs the company is called a mammy because of her nurturing moments?”Footnote 2 I, too, struggled to position myself in the conversation, to eschew black respectability discourses which always already fix black sensuality as threatening without disavowing the aggression and dehumanization to which black women historically have been subject. Finally, we dispersed, lacking any satisfactory answers.
A critical dialogue about the relationship between African American studies as an interdisciplinary, intellectual project and legacies of bondage and exploitation is by no means new. Nevertheless, in the last ten years, there has been a concerted, if heterogeneous, scholarly effort – in part in reaction to a proliferation of cultural touchstones (i.e. the elections of Barack Obama, the anniversaries of Martin Luther King Jr.'s “Letter from a Birmingham Jail” and of the Emancipation Proclamation) and of portrayals of blackness in the media (i.e. Scandal, Django Unchained) – to define even more concretely the nuances of the point of contact between slavery, resistance, and the present. Kenneth W. Warren, for instance, in So Black and Blue: Ralph Ellison and the Occasion of Criticism, approaches this problematic via a critique of what he terms “a bourgeois hegemonic project centered in an African American politics of culture.” For Warren, the cultural turn projects an affinity between elite and working-class subjectivities without any tangible shift in conditions of labor or access for the latter, at the same time that it defers state accountability for black marginalization within formal, institutional politics. Citing the work of scholars such as Henry Louis Gates Jr., Hortense Spillers, and Paul Gilroy as representative of a troubling intellectual shift toward what James C. Scott refers to as the “infrapolitical,” Warren contends that scholars
have been inclined to treat any recurrence as evidence that the truth about black political hopes and desires lies hidden within apparently nonpolitical activities. These studies, though historical in intent, tend to freeze and generalize specific moments in the historical experiences of black people, and then to read the whole of that history through the lens of this crystallization. Slavery – whether through its economics, its conditions of literacy, or its strategies of gendering black populations – provides the template for discussing black cultural production … something like “the memory of slavery …” becomes a permanent fixture in the psyches of black people.Footnote 3
Overall, Warren takes issue with the deployment of slavery as a trope, as a malleable index of covert subversion and reservoir of essentialized blackness. Theorizing the vernacular as an aesthetic and probing the vestiges of the black Atlantic, in fact, signal little more than uncritical complicity between African American (literary) studies and racialized, canonical sociology. Privileging the slave past as paradigmatic, in Warren's view, holds dire consequences, positioning the field as stagnant, reactionary, and reductive.
Saidiya Hartman's 2007 historical memoir Lose Your Mother denotes another crucial contribution to this renewed critical discourse. In a marked stylistic departure from her by-now classic Scenes of Subjection: Terror, Slavery, and Self-Making in Nineteenth-Century America, Hartman narrates her passage along former slave routes in Ghana “as both a professor conducting research on slavery and a descendant of the enslaved.” Indeed, an acute tension between the two roles saturates the text. On one level, like Warren, like many of us present at ASALH, Hartman decries linear, causal links to black captivity. “The hope is that return could resolve the old dilemmas, make a victory out of defeat, and engender a new order,” she writes. “And the disappointment is that there is no going back to a former condition. Loss remakes you. Return is as much about the world to which you no longer belong as it is about the one in which you have yet to make a home.”Footnote 4 Hartman foregrounds her own alienation from a history striking in its opacity, ever conscious of the impossibility of the very act of communion she seeks. The pall of death suffusing much of the work precludes any tidy, commonsense engagement with experiences of subjugation.
Even still, Hartman articulates an “intimacy” with the unknowable. Accordingly, she argues,
If slavery persists as an issue in the political life of black America, it is not because of an antiquarian obsession with bygone days or the burden of a too-long memory, but because black lives are still imperiled and devalued by a racial calculus and a political arithmetic that were entrenched centuries ago. This is the afterlife of slavery – skewed life chances, limited access to health and education, premature death, incarceration, and impoverishment. I, too, am the afterlife of slavery.Footnote 5
Without covering over her own privilege, Hartman undermines static temporal renderings which cannot account for the endurance of the epistemologies and ideological frameworks subtending enslavement as an institution. The contemporaneity of past and present subjection, Hartman maintains, lies precisely in the persistence of unfreedom as a habit of being. The killing of Trayvon Martin, and the subsequent acquittal of George Zimmerman in July 2013, only crystallize, for many, the contiguity which Hartman describes. As the reconstitution of repressive systems of valuation and capital accumulation perpetuates the precariousness of black life, historicizing the naturalization of domination in these ways amounts to an act of memorialization and a means of attaining emancipation in even more capacious terms.
Significantly, Stephen Best cites the felt, often melancholic, register informing Hartman's project in his 2012 Modern Language Quarterly essay, “On Failing to Make the Past Present.” “Hartman,” he avers,
compellingly substitutes the affect of her own encounters with traces of the slave past for the dispassionate analysis that prevails in most histories of slavery. Her embrace of slavery's dispossession as the generative condition of African Americans … corrects for a vindicationist strain in several generations of work in social history that has tended to find only resistance to slavery's oppression worthy of historical recovery.
Pinpointing 1988 as the inaugural year in which slavery becomes “the constituent object and metaphor in African American studies,” he adds,
The rise of Beloved moved the entire field of literary studies to a central place in African American studies … With Morrisonian poetics as a guide, the black Atlantic provided a way of making history for those who had lost it and as such secured the recent rehabilitation of melancholy in cultural criticism.Footnote 6
The draw of the historical moment of slavery, for Best, has everything to do with the seismic disciplinary shift ushered in by Morrison's Pulitzer Prize-winning novel (and thus implicitly with questions of marketability); its utility in interrogating intergenerational, racialized trauma, including processes of melancholia; and its capacity to problematize dominant narratives of selfhood, progress, and reason undergirding Enlightenment and modernity. Concomitant preoccupation with notions of ethics, authenticity, redemption, and black collectivity cohere around histories of enslavement, permitting a sanitized, self-interested view of realities we may well never know.
Hence, Best inquires,
Why must we predicate having an ethical relation to the past on an assumed continuity between that past and our present and on the implicit consequence that to study that past is somehow to intervene in it? Through what process has it become possible to claim the lives and efforts of history's defeated as ours either to redeem or to redress?
In contrast to Hartman's vision of contemporaneity, he asks, “if we take slavery's dispossessions to live on into the twenty-first century, divesting history of movement and change, then what form can effective political agency take?” Via a close reading of Morrison's later fiction, particularly the novel A Mercy, Best ultimately concludes that studies of African American literature and political culture must suspend a politics of reclamation in favor of a dynamic of estrangement. “To be historical in our work, we might thus have to resist the impulse to redeem the past and instead rest content with the fact that our orientation toward it remains forever perverse, queer, askew,” Best suggests, importing insights from Leo Bersani and Daniel Tiffany in the context of sexuality studies to posit the racial past and present as a nexus of dislocation.Footnote 7
Sharon Patricia Holland is, in many respects, invested in theorizing precisely this juncture in The Erotic Life of Racism. “We are not yet done with slavery because we have yet to thoroughly investigate its psychic life,” she declares early in the text. “This is not to pit the past against the present in a dysfunctional causal relationship … No one has asked for a return; rather, we have asked for a more thoroughgoing and therefore intellectually challenging way of seeing ourselves – past, present, and future.”Footnote 8 In tune, as is Hartman, with the intransigence of slavery's protocols of ownership and expendability, Holland shares with Best a desire to bridge the divide between African American studies and queer theory. “Can work on ‘desire’ be antiracist work? Can antiracist work think ‘desire’? What would happen if we opened up the erotic to a scene of racist hailing?” she muses.Footnote 9 Calling for a return (unlike Warren) to Hortense Spillers's “Mama's Baby, Papa's Baby: An American Grammar Book,” in particular, she posits renewed interrogation of intersections between sensual and racist expression as a necessary next step for the ongoing viability of both fields of inquiry. In fact,
The place of slavery in queer studies has yet to be reckoned with, and this is perhaps because the boundary-breaking futurity in which queer studies finds its subject would balk if such a subject were held to a transhistorical vision of time – that expands Foucault's conceptualization of a queer calendar to other historical events in its vicinity: a queer begetting of magnificent proportions.Footnote 10
Mining – rather than minimizing – the effects of bondage on such practices as motherhood, pleasure, desire, and reproduction, Holland continues, addresses a formidable lacuna in present-day African Americanist research.
In her analysis of Scandal, Treva Lindsey probes yet another space of possibility as it pertains to the relationship between slavery and African American studies. Specifically, Lindsey troubles a privileging of representational politics. That is, she questions emphases on iconographies of suffering within black cultural studies, especially at the expense of sustained engagement with the prospect of interiority. To charges of the flat, hackneyed nature of Rhimes's African American characters, including Senator Edison Davis and Harrison Wright, but also Olivia Pope, she suggests, “You miss hearing the lower frequencies of black women's experiences when you encase them in historical tropes without exploring the specific contours of the world they inhabit.”Footnote 11 Lindsey's approach, a refusal to jettison the subtlety and reserve of black experience in favor of the dictates of oppositional struggle, corresponds with another trajectory in the field more broadly, perhaps best signaled by Kevin Quashie's recent book project, The Sovereignty of Quiet: Beyond Resistance in Black Culture. By examining the ways in which, in his words, “constructions of blackness-as-resistance … serve the needs and fantasies of the dominant culture,” Quashie speaks to an enduring incumbency of theorizing race differently. Troubling conditions under which “[r]esistance is, in fact, the dominant expectation we have of black culture,”Footnote 12 he cites the agency embedded in awareness, quiet, and surrender. Deploying an archive from Du Bois to Zora Neale Hurston, Marita Bonner to Gwendolyn Brooks, James Baldwin to Elizabeth Alexander, he renarrates broader cultural tropes of signifying, dissemblance, double consciousness, and masking. He resituates politicized action in the terrain of imagination, waiting, and prayer. In recuperating spaces of inner pleasure, desire, and vulnerability, Quashie complicates easy equations of blackness with public expressiveness, calling attention to modes of black articulacy previously overlooked.
Indeed, The Sovereignty of Quiet reflects sensitivity to the challenges with which we grappled at ASALH, the difficulty of thinking blackness apart from narratives of interracial strife and violence: “This shift can feel like a kind of heresy,” he notes.Footnote 13 And yet, by relinquishing understandings of blackness tethered to the terms of a hierarchical social order, one may gain access to a richer sense of black subjectivity, of humanity. For Quashie, loosening the ties by which race is bound to resistance means that the former is no longer predicated upon a transcendence of alterity; instead, it enables indulgence in processes of black being and becoming. By not unduly foregrounding historic conditions of subjection as absolute, he offers, one might likewise more readily advance a culture of intersectional theorization, of ways of knowing that can more effectively contend with contradictions within blackness. “Intersectionality has made it possible, at least metaphorically, for blackness to stand for something more than or different from its name,” Quashie – via a reading of the Combahee River Collective's “A Black Feminist Statement” – reminds us.Footnote 14
In the interest of transparency around my own critical investments, I have (as an African Americanist scholar of nineteenth-century literature, rhetoric, and cultural production) devoted much of my work to the theorization of political, social, and economic practices of resistance, however subtle or ephemeral, performed by marginalized communities in America. Yet, without fixing literature as the proper object, or academic institutions as the only viable sites, for that matter, of inquiry in African American studies, I find that it may well be to the literary genre of “neo-slave narrative” that we might turn for some of the most complex and compelling engagements with the axes of history, race, and power outlined above. A conceptual framework elaborated by the likes of Ashraf Rushdy, Bernard Bell, and Arlene Keizer to encompass texts as varied as Margaret Walker's Jubilee (1966), Ishmael Reed's Flight to Canada (1976), and Edward P. Jones's The Known World (2003), neo-slave narrative references the imaginative renderings of slave culture and antebellum racial politics evident in modern-day fictional pursuits. While Best relegates neo-slave narrative to little more than a footnote in “On Failing to Make the Past Present,” the grounding of the crux of his argument within a close reading of Morrison's novel A Mercy indeed establishes literature as a significant mode of knowledge production.
Notably, creative writers and artists working in this field today openly wrestle with many of the very same questions at play in the aforementioned work of Warren, Hartman, and Quashie. Poet–scholar Evie Shockley speaks of the utility of contemporary narratives of slavery in her essay “Colorblind(ed): Visuality, Discursivity, and Slavery in Rita Dove's and George Elliott Clarke's Verse Plays.”Footnote 15 However, when asked about the current popularity of the genre, Shockley critiques inattentiveness to poetry in the context of neo-slave narrative as a whole. In fact, the choreography of a poem on the page, she suggests, insists upon the viability of racial constructs in the same way that slavery does not allow for a disavowal of race. Neo-slavery poetics, then, offer a striking contestation of the “post-racial,” ever necessary in the wake of the retraction of welfare; an altered, post-9/11, racial landscape; and the presidencies of Barack Obama. Likewise, as author Attica Locke explained at a public reading of her historically rooted, yet contemporary, murder mystery novel The Cutting Season at Los Angeles Central Library on 9 October 2012, her interest lies precisely wherein the “past and present hit each other.” On the other hand, Locke expresses ambivalence about holding on to cultural benchmarks and other familiar historical moments: “Perhaps the best way to honor our history is to not need it so strongly,” she offers. Avoiding traditional conventions of neo-slave narrative such as ghosting or flashbacks, Locke's fiction manifests a need for history that is present, but which simultaneously runs awry, or which, in many ways, does not feel the way we think it should. The Cutting Season gives voice to intra-racial conflict, to the heterogeneity of post-Katrina Louisiana, and to the often starkly gendered conditions and violence attending migrant labor in the present. Its relation to legacies of enslavement is evident but, as Best suggests, is “forever perverse, queer, askew.”
Distinctively, neo-slave narrative exposes the dialogical relation of past and present – a dynamic at times intimate, at times alienating – and challenges us to cultivate agile reading and interpretive frameworks accountable to how fraught resistance always has been and will ever be. Rather than positioning novels such as Octavia Butler's Kindred (1979) and Sherley Anne Williams's Dessa Rose (1986) as means of redressing that which antebellum slave narrative (and even postbellum black poetry, fiction, and prose) strategically omits, my current research theorizes Harriet Wilson's Our Nig (1859), Elizabeth Keckly's Behind the Scenes (1868), and Anna Julia Cooper's A Voice from the South (1892), for example, as key intertexts. Apprehending contemporary narratives of slavery as irreducible to mere catalogues of the immense struggles faced by the enslaved allows us to focus instead on older and new texts alike as storehouses of intricate epistemologies regarding sovereignty, privilege, and consent of increasing relevance in our neoliberal age.
Ultimately, I don't know if a room full of critics and fans of the series Scandal will ever come to a consensus as to the show's sociopolitical implications and effects – another parallel to African American studies, which has never presumed unity as a beginning or an end. Surely, the reinvigoration of debate across disciplinary borders signals vitality, not defeat. In the meantime, I think I'll keep watching.
