Myles Lavan's wide-ranging and acute analysis of how the Roman élite conceived their relationship to subject peoples, from the mid-first century b.c.e. to the early third century c.e., puts Roman imperial ideology under the spotlight. Studies of the Roman Empire in recent decades, informed by post-colonial sensibilities and drawing on ever more sophisticated archaeological approaches, have focused primarily on the agency of provincial subjects and the development of hybrid provincial cultures. The perspective of the occupiers has not been altogether ignored; but the classic piece by Peter Brunt (in P. Garnsey and C. A. Whittaker (eds), Imperialism in the Ancient World (1978), 159–92) and even John Richardson's extended essay The Language of Empire (2008) focus on just a handful of passages relating primarily to the Republic. As L. demonstrates, these, and the many other texts he considers, need to be seen in a complex ideological context. How Roman claims about the nature of their empire are articulated has important implications, not least for our understanding of how empire worked.
Drawing inspiration from the approach of Edward Said's Culture and Imperialism (1993), L. tracks some of the key ways imperial identity and élite self-definition are mutually implicated in the Roman world. Focusing primarily on texts in Latin (though ch. 6, on letters sent by Roman emperors and officials to provincial communities, looks mainly at Greek material), L. explores the language of laws, of imperial decrees, of letters, and of speeches as well as that of history writing, with Cicero, Tacitus and Pliny as key witnesses.
A contrast between rulers and ruled operates in many of the texts examined by L. Yet it is often quite unclear, as he underlines, who is on which side. While distinctions are sometimes drawn between citizen and non-citizen, at other times the contrast is rather between Italians and provincials. The term nos ‘we’ is notably underdetermined. L.'s study deftly emphasizes the complex interplay of factors here, the slippage between geography, ethnicity and culture — not to mention juridical status — in these binary formulations. Particular scrutiny is given to the work done by the term socii, applied to Rome's provincial subjects well into the second century c.e. As L. underlines, Latin authors rarely use this word with legal precision. Where exactly could one locate the division between rulers and ruled in an empire where a man born in Spain or Africa might become emperor?
Latin texts present Romans as an imperial people through a notably consistent range of imagery over an extended period. Yet while the range is consistent, there are also revealing tensions between the different models deployed. While the language of favour, benefit and obligation is certainly recurrent, a far more significant model, on L.'s view, is that of masters and slaves. This model notably dominates in relation to situations of crisis or of transition; slavery is the obvious paradigm for communities whose obedience to Rome depends on the threat of force, a paradigm conspicuous in Roman historiography well into the third century c.e. But to characterize the relationship between Romans and subjects thus is not a criticism of Roman rule. The apparently unembarrassed use of the language of chattel slavery here might seem surprising; L. notes by contrast negative uses of master/slave imagery in critical accounts of relations between emperors and their senatorial subjects. Nevertheless, in relationships where there was no fiction of social equality, slavery could operate as a powerful model for legitimate authority, on the one hand, and self-effacement and devotion, on the other. Thus Cicero might cast Sicily as Rome's devoted wet-nurse, reminding us of the complex ways in which empire (like slavery) combined intimacy with violence.
Ch. 3, through a series of close readings, interrogates the deployment of this metaphor in relation to the agendas of three Tacitean accounts of provincial revolt, highlighting the interdependency of slavery as a model for relations between Rome and the provinces and for relations between emperor and senate. L. also offers some reflection on how these usages, particularly as they articulate or imply a psychology of the enslaved, might feed back into the ideology of slavery more generally, informing the ways Romans imagined the relationship of actual masters to their actual slaves.
Other significant models from the world of social relations are the focus of chs 4 and 5. The model of parent-child relations, despite the idiosyncratic vision articulated by Pliny (NH 3.39), is notably rare in characterizations of relations between nos and subject peoples (though Roman emperors often figure as fathers in relation to their subjects). The idea of the civilizing mission (a notion enmeshed in the legacy of later empires, and which some have detected in this Pliny passage) turns out to play a very limited rôle. Sharply critical of recent scholarship on patronage in Roman society, L., in exploring the deployment of patronage as a model for imperial rule, stresses that this strategy is largely confined to the writings of Cicero and Livy, who use it when they wish to highlight the empire's duty of care — to vilify those officials who have fallen short, or to offer a contrast between Roman rule and that of Hellenistic kings.
As L. underlines in this most important study, a deeper understanding of the language of empire is crucial. Different models entail vastly different conceptions of the means and ends of the exercise of rule. And discursive practices played a critical rôle in the way provincial governors and other representatives of Roman authority actualized Roman power in their engagement with Rome's subjects.
