The growth of research in the field of science and literature has been tremendous in the last two decades. What was once a niche field has become an area well populated by researchers, teachers and students. While the growth of critical texts on the field – both historical and theoretical – has been significant, an appropriate text for undergraduate students has been a largely overlooked component of this canon. Charlotte Sleigh's Literature and Science is an excellent introductory text that is appropriate for undergraduate students who are approaching the field of science and literature for the first time. This is not to deny the sophistication of her argument and analysis, which are both exemplary, but rather to identify how her work bridges the gap between academic research and accessible textbook, making it appealing for both scholars and students.
Sleigh frames her argument about the natural relationship between science and literature by debunking several myths about their differences, namely science as objective and literature as subjective. She easily and persuasively points out that the relationship between the two disciplines lies in the use of language. ‘Science cannot be conducted without language’, writes Sleigh, ‘and language is not a neutral tool. It actively shapes knowledge just as much as does the decision to dissect this animal, use that microscope, perform this test, and so on’ (p. 6). This intersection of language – along with the shared ‘big’ questions of the disciplines (such as ‘Why am I here?’) – are the focus of her historical and literary analysis, which spans the Restoration to the present day. The scope of her project is impressive, given the length of the text, yet Sleigh manages to succinctly and effectively discuss this period of over 350 years without giving the impression of having unfairly or incompletely analysed her chosen texts and their historical and scientific contexts. My only criticism of this timespan is that the nineteenth century receives more attention than any other period, which is often the case with this type of text, and reflects the greater attention given to the nineteenth century by scholars. That said, Sleigh covers a diverse range of topics, as identified in her chapter titles: ‘Epistolarity and the democratic ideal’, ‘Scientists, moral realism and the new world order’, and ‘Says who? Science and public understanding’. This last chapter is a real strength of her work, as she moves from the laboratory to the public sphere to address the more recent consumption of science. The arc from the simultaneous emergence of the modern novel and modern science to the science wars, and the attempt to strengthen a divide between the disciplines, creates a rich picture of the continually shifting view of science and literature, disciplines that are seen as complementary by some and combative by others.
Not only does Sleigh provide a clear overview and in-depth insight into the intersection of science and literature, she also frames her book in the spirit of further investigation, offering suggestions for areas that need additional consideration and research, as well as including an annotated ‘further reading’ section that complements each of her chapters. This approach is extremely useful for the undergraduate student's reading list; it also encourages scholars to broaden or reconsider their existing arguments in light of the issues she raises. She concludes with a point that I have pondered myself, and begs for further research: ‘it has become commonplace to rehabilitate “trash” literature from the nineteenth century and subject it to serious literary scrutiny. No one has yet asked what it might mean to do this for the scientific airport thrillers of the late twentieth and early twenty-first centuries’ (p. 202). Sleigh's desire to see further research of all literary works in relation to science – classics, non-fiction scientific books, and even airport thrillers – is representative of her encompassing approach and her ability to break down existing barriers, both between and within the two fields.
I can only end by echoing the sentiments already expressed by fellow reviewers Carol Colatrella and Vike Plock: I am excited to include this text in my undergraduate classes. Its quality and accessibility assure Science and Literature a firm place in the canon and in the classroom.
