In the past two decades, English-language scholarship has challenged the gendered dimension of the Buddhist tradition. Spearheaded by Rita M. Gross (Buddhism after Patriarchy: a Feminist History, Analysis, and Reconstruction of Buddhism [Albany: State University of New York Press, 1993]), Karma Lekshe Tsomo (Buddhist Women Across Cultures: Realizations [Albany: State University of New York Press, 1999]), and Bernard Faure (The Power of Denial: Buddhism, Purity, and Gender [Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press 2003]), to name a few, the new scholarship exposes the ways in which androcentric and often misogynistic Buddhist history has left half the story untold—namely, the story of Buddhist women. Several dozen monographs and edited volumes now examine the lives and practices of female Buddhists in the East and the West and analyze implications of these recovered stories for understanding Buddhism as a whole. However, aside from two books, by Martine Bachelor (Women in Korean Zen: Lives and Practices [Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press, 2006]) and Daehaeng Sunim (No River to Cross: Trusting the Enlightenment That's Always Right Here [Boston: Wisdom Publications, 2007]), a comprehensive scholarly analysis of Korea's female Buddhists had not been undertaken. Thus, Korean Buddhist Nuns and Laywomen, the first English-language effort to reconstruct a picture of “the life and history of Korean Buddhist nuns and laywomen, from the fourth to the twentieth century” (p. 8), is a welcome and long overdue volume.
As the editor Eun-su Cho points out, contemporary Korean Buddhist nuns comprise half the monastics in the largest Korean Buddhist order, the Chogyejong. Moreover, in comparison with nuns in other Asian countries, Korean nuns enjoy a high level of autonomy, as well as significant visibility in Korean Buddhism and culture. Equally important is the role that laywomen have played in protecting and buttressing the sangha, both at its zenith and nadir, throughout Korean Buddhist history. Therefore, a clear and thorough understanding of Korean Buddhist women is essential to the larger project of revising the place of women in the entirety of the Buddhist tradition.
The book's eight chapters shed light on the tenacious religiosity of female practitioners, against great odds, and on their central yet unrecognized position in Korean Buddhism. With the exceptions of chapters 4 and 6, the book is based on papers from an international conference on East Asian nuns held in Korea in 2004 (p. xi). Cho begins the book by presenting the broad issues in gender and religion in East Asia. She then lays out three obstacles to finding a coherent picture of the life and history of Korean nuns and laywomen: the lack of records on and writings by these women, the nuns' skewed self-presentation, and the difficulty in applying Western theories of gender and feminism to nuns in Korea. In chapter 2, Cho offers an overview of prominent nuns and laywomen from the inception of Korean Buddhism up to the present. She further discusses how nuns in early eras who lived abroad shaped the Buddhisms of Japan and China. Cho also explains why contemporary female monasticism has flourished despite several centuries of persecution during the Chosŏn period and four decades of colonial rule. While the nuns' collective cohesiveness and diversity of Buddhist practices and ideals were essential to their success, Cho primarily credits their reemergence to changes in Korean society, economy, and women's status (pp. 36–38).
In chapter 3, Young Mi Kim examines the tradition of women's spiritual practice by looking at how the male Koryŏ master Chin'gak Hyesim (1178–1234) taught hwadu to his nuns. Kim argues that these meditating nuns were very confident that they could reach enlightenment as women, though many Buddhist scriptures traditionally argue otherwise. Chapter 4 concerns the period of Mongolian rule over Koryŏ during which a large number of Koryŏ women were relocated to China as a form of tribute to the Yuan dynasty. Tonino Puggioni describes how these women, together with the last Yuan empress Lady Yi, not only supported China's Koryŏ temples and expatriate communities but also promoted Buddhism in China. In the following chapter, Heung-sik Heo compares the lives of two nuns, Chinhye in the Koryŏ dynasty and, five hundred years later, Chŏngyu in the Chosŏn dynasty. Each became monastics late in life, continued her relationship with family after becoming tonsured, and engaged in domestic (or economic) matters. While acknowledging that each remained to a large extent bound to the social, political, and male-centered realities of her time, Heo contends that they were conferred the title “master” (p. 91) based on their exceptional devotional and stereological accomplishments.
The seeming contradiction between the social confines of being a nun and the ways in which monasticism offers a degree of freedom is taken up in the following two chapters. In chapter 6, John Jorgensen leans toward the oppression mode of interpretation by analyzing the dire situation of nuns in the neo-Confucian Chosŏn dynasty. He characterizes Chosŏn nuns as “triply marginalized and effectively silenced” due to Buddhism's low status in the neo-Confucian hegemony, the misogynistic attitude among the Confucian and Buddhist hierarchy, and the nuns' consequent lack of education (p. 139). Ji-Young Jung, however, draws from the liberation mode and asserts in chapter 7 that Buddhist monasteries provided “an alternative cultural space” where aristocratic women, upon becoming nuns, could bypass the suffocating neo-Confucian social norms (p. 147). Nevertheless, Jung makes an observation that supports Jorgensen's point: while joining the sangha became a protest against Confucian society, these nuns had to make themselves “invisible” in order to avoid persecution (p. 158). In the final chapter, Pori Park explores the rise of nuns' status in the postcolonial period. She attributes the flourishing of several nunneries to the nuns' active involvement in the Purification Movement in the 1950s and their neutrality during the damaging power struggles among monks in the following decades.
The essays in this volume are well-researched, substantiated by ample primary-source materials, and examined with rich insights and nuances. Thus, the volume fulfills the editor's expectation of serving “as a major step forward,” as well as a springboard for further research (p. 8). One important subject for future scholarship is gathering extensive empirical data on contemporary Korean nuns and combining this with an anthropological examination of their conspicuous shift in status in recent decades. It would be useful to know, for instance, how contemporary Korean nuns perceive their own status in relation to the monks, laywomen, and female leaders of other Asian Buddhism and religions, in addition to detailing their views on controversial vinaya and doctrinal issues. The seven factors Cho enumerates in chapter 2 will serve as a useful interpretative tool in such an undertaking. Along these lines, another subject for further exploration is the subjectivity of laywomen in the context of Korean Buddhist institutions. Even though the word “laywomen” is in the book's title, all but chapter 4 focus on nuns, which is understandable given that this book resulted from a conference on nuns. The dearth of primary materials on laywomen, as Cho notes, is largely the problem. Yet, this unavailability of sources, compounded with a lack of scholarly attention, is a stark reminder of how little we know about laywomen's religiosity despite the fact that they constitute the majority of members at temples and are deeply devoted to the sangha.
In sum, Korean Buddhist Nuns and Laywomen is a must-read for students and scholars interested in gender issues in religious studies in general, and in the issues of nuns and laywomen in Buddhism in particular.
