The Narrator, the Expositor, and the Prompter in European Medieval Theatre, edited by Philip Butterworth, brings wide-ranging reflections on its title subjects together within a cohesive theoretical frame that foregrounds the performative and communicative function of medieval drama. Identifying narrators, expositors, and prompters as operating “simultaneously both ‘inside’ and ‘outside’ of the action of the play” (1), Butterworth challenges the contributors of the collection to consider the potential of these uniquely metatheatrical roles to affect the nature and reception of performance. The fourteen scholars who respond to Butterworth's charge are among the most established and accomplished voices in the field, including Peter Happé, Peter Meredith, and David Mills, among others. Equally admirable for the depth of its scholarship as well as the boldness of its unexpected examples, the collection explores diverse topics, from English morality plays to Spanish puppet theatre, and considers evidence ranging from historic texts to modern stagings. On the whole, the essays are also commendable for balancing introductory information necessary for nonspecialists with richly detailed new perspectives that will excite those already familiar with this material.
Although many of the essays focus on dramatic texts, most engage with Butterworth's theoretical frame, and almost all move beyond literary analysis. The most interesting essays of the collection are those that interrogate the performative and communicative function of the interlocutory roles by examining textual references alongside extratheatrical evidence. Elsa Strietman's work on rhetorician drama of the Low Countries, which incorporates analysis of visual material and financial records, is a particularly keen example of how scholarship on medieval ephemeral traditions requires an interdisciplinary approach. Similarly, Nerida Newbigin's assessment of the Italian sacre rappresentazione tradition uses her deep knowledge of the culture that produced these dramatic texts in order to correct often repeated assumptions about the plays. Though many of the chapters delve into cultural history, the performative function of the narrator, expositor, and prompter remains a central theme of the book. The essays by John McKinnell and Christine Dymkowski, in fact, are of particular interest in their attention to the needs and potential impact of modern productions.
In addition to the variety of evidence considered, the volume is refreshing in its inclusion of multiple perspectives on similar topics. For example, Milla Cozart Riggio and Alan Hindly both examine moralities. However, whereas Riggio's consideration of English examples explores the layers of reality that expositors and narrators might provide within the play, Hindley asserts, in his discussion of French moralités, that expository characters served to subordinate the theatrical illusion. Another strength of the collection is that it encompasses references to well-known traditions and examples as well as to new trends in medieval theatre scholarship. Thus, Jolanta Rzegocka's examination of popular theatre in Poland stands alongside discussions of English cycle plays.
One criticism of the volume is that, like many previous studies of medieval European theatre, much of the text is focused on English subjects: a full one-third of the essays consider English examples, and two chapters discuss Shakespeare. Such a focus suggests that there is not enough material on other regions or earlier eras to warrant inclusion; that is not the case. On the contrary, perhaps what is missing from medieval theatre scholarship is more research on underrepresented genres and geographic areas. One need look no further than Max Harris's chapter on Spanish theatre of the twelfth through seventeenth centuries to see that exciting work continues to be done on lesser-known topics. Ultimately, editors should be conscious of the need to provide a balanced image of the diversity of theatrical practices throughout the many regions of medieval Europe.
The great strength of the collection, however, is Butterworth's organization and his introductory remarks, which highlight the connections among these diverse studies. For example, McKinnell's discussion of issues facing a modern production of a fourteenth-century Latin tragedy may seem, at first, to be wholly disconnected from Rzegocka's analysis of the narrator in seventeenth-century Polish popular theatre. Yet, as Butterworth points out, both focus on the need for performance “to tell the story,” and therefore both analyze specific means through which narrators may help audiences to understand and appreciate the drama. Another aspect that adds to the cohesive feel of the collection is that, despite the diversity of topics, the writers often engage one another's work directly. In part this interaction may be due to the relationships among the contributors; most are active and long-standing members of the Société Internationale pour l'Étude du Théâtre Médiéval (SITM) and, as Butterworth notes, his interest in creating the book came after an experience at a SITM colloquium. Nonetheless, the credit for sharing this scholarly conversation goes to Butterworth.
In bringing together some of the leading voices in medieval scholarship and allowing them to apply their extensive knowledge to an underappreciated subject, Butterworth encourages readers to see narrators, expositors, and prompters as much more than dramatic devices. The essays in this volume reveal the diversity and importance of these roles in an era when performance practices throughout Europe were dynamic cultural expressions. To the specialist, the essays in this volume are particularly useful for their inclusion of unpublished materials; to theatre generalists, this book is worthwhile for its varied reflections on the theatrical possibilities of the narrator, the expositor, and the prompter. Moreover, the collection demonstrates both the variety of performance practices in medieval Europe and the vitality of contemporary medieval theatre scholarship.
