Understanding the complexity of interethnic relations in the southern Philippines has long been hampered by competing narratives of indigenous ethnolinguistic groups' resistance to Spanish colonization. Perhaps the most powerful narrative is the one that cloaks the ethno-history of the thirteen indigenous Muslim peoples behind a trope of continual fierce opposition to conquest—a storyline often offered in contrast to a narrative of northern Filipinos' perceived capitulation to Spanish rule. Hidden between these narratives is another perception of the upland, mostly non-Muslim indigenous peoples of Mindanao as having been untouched by colonization owing to their location in remote upland homelands. Oona Paredes, in this groundbreaking book, completely dismantles this latter interpretation of indigenous history by skillfully weaving anthropological insights into the fragmented documentary evidence from northern Mindanao in the 1600s to the 1800s. She illuminates how centuries of close contact with Spanish missionaries occurred in ways that still enabled many of the Lumad (an ethnic category that encompasses eighteen indigenous ethnolinguistic groups) in this region to maintain a cultural distinctiveness that persists today.
Paredes presents a number of fascinating historical vignettes of the Lumad colonial experience. Methodologically, the book is based on an original review of primary sources in Spain, rather than secondary or translated versions. Arguing that the story of the Lumad cannot be presented through the usual lens of Hispanization and oppression of Filipino groups by a superior power, she shows that on the outer margins of the archipelago—far from the intensely concentrated Spanish influence—a handful of vulnerable Recoleto missionaries (Order of Augustinian Recollects) surrounded by thousands of indigenous peoples developed close relationships that profoundly influenced and transformed each other, as well as the entire colonial project. Ultimately, it led the Lumad to distance themselves from their former tributary alliances with the Maguindanao sultanate and to assume a protective relationship with the Spanish priests. The Recoletos themselves came to experience feelings of commonality with their Lumad converts—a trust that was shattered at times through episodes of treachery and cultural misunderstanding that Paredes fully explores and interprets. The Caraga revolt of 1631 was the bloodiest anti-Spanish uprising by Christianized Lumad, for example, and yet relationships with Spanish priests were reestablished relatively quickly.
Theoretically, this book relies on a comparative history of the role of Spanish missions and missionary impacts in the Americas, as well as Southeast Asian scholarship that emphasizes the tendency for peoples in the region to be attracted to various new influences that periodically have arrived with visiting Indian, Chinese, Arabic, and European explorers, traders, soldiers, and religious missionaries. The regularized contact between Spanish missionaries and the Lumad initiated a number of important changes in their social and political organization, including the familiar practice of consolidating small kin-based settlements into larger villages, constructing military fortifications of European design for protection from raids, and European-style training of Lumad militias. Perhaps one of the most significant ways that Spanish missionaries influenced the region was not just through Christian conversion and the establishment of new ways by which Lumad groups could relate to each other, but by persuading them to deescalate revenge raiding. In this manner, the Lumad became “legible” and viewed positively by the missionaries, especially compared to the way Spanish archival documents depict the Moro peoples.
A common characteristic of Southeast Asian peoples has been the way they have often been fascinated with ideas coming from outside cultures and enthusiastic about integrating them into their own traditions—a process known as “localization.” “Foreignness” has simply not been perceived as a threat to their own cultural authenticity, nor to their political autonomy. Rather than capitulate to Spanish power, the Lumad actively incorporated exotic items (such as the golden cane) and political terminology into their own royal regalia and ways of talking about leadership and status. Paredes argues that this is a vivid illustration of how the Lumad engaged in “a conscious attempt to ‘harmonize’ a foreign tradition with local politics” (p. 56).
This book ultimately restores the Lumad historical experience of Spanish colonization to its rightful place alongside the many different experiences of other Philippine groups. It also raises the larger question as to what actually constituted Spanish colonial authority in Mindanao. Paredes's own reading of the archive and ethno-history clearly suggests that in this region, a lens of mutual, if shifting local alliances rather than outright subjugation offers a more nuanced understanding of the colonial encounter. This monograph is extremely well-written and thought-provoking, and would work in advanced undergraduate and well as graduate classes in history, anthropology, and Philippine studies.
