The four great written accomplishments of the American Founding are the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, the Federalist, and Franklin's Autobiography. Dustin Gish and Daniel Klinghard aim to persuade modern readers to place Notes on the State of Virginia on that list by explaining in painstaking detail its structure and content, as well as its connection to the Constitution and the Federalist.
Gish and Klinghard pursue their aim by discussing the history of and major influences on the composition of Jefferson's only book, by interpreting its contents, and by presenting the complicated history of the book's publication and reception. These three sections of their book constitute a “political biography” of Notes because taken together they display the political purpose that guided its composition and publication during the years 1780–87, “to teach Americans how to think constitutionally” (21), especially as a convention met to reform the Articles of Confederation in the summer of 1787 (242, 261).
With regard to the structure of Notes, Gish and Klinghard argue, as others have, that it is more than the mere collection of notes and digressions that it appears to be. They join those who see that the book of twenty-three queries or chapters is divided into two equal sets of queries joined by the central query, query 12. The first set of queries focuses on both physical and human nature, the second on law. The middle query offers a brief reflection on the relationship between nature and convention. Gish and Klinghard agree also with those who argue that it was Jefferson's intent to make convention conform to nature as much as possible, without letting physical nature (rivers, mountains, vast distances) dictate limits to the republican empire rising on the eastern seaboard (69).
In discussing Jefferson's account of nature, Gish and Klinghard argue that Jefferson used the first books of the Bible as a rhetorical guide and that his other major influence was Francis Bacon. Bacon's approach to learning about nature—cautious and experimental—became Jefferson's approach to politics. This meant that thinking constitutionally for Jefferson meant thinking experimentally, learning by trial and error, revising as one goes (21, 317). Discussing the influence of Bacon on Jefferson's constitutionalism prepares the way for their claim that “the source of the authority of constitutions as a fundamental law was a problem at the core of the American Enlightenment.” According to Gish and Klinghard, an emphasis on revision makes constitutional foundations appear capricious (196).
The account of Jefferson as a political Baconian prepares the way in turn for the pivotal contrast with James Madison in the third section of the book. (This section also contains a comparison of Notes and John Adams's A Defense of the Constitutions of Government of the United States [1787].) Using Jefferson's letters and the chronology of political events in the United States (Jefferson was at this point ambassador to France), especially Madison's work on the Federalist papers, Gish and Klinghard argue for a fundamental difference of opinion between Jefferson and Madison. Madison, they argue, wrote Federalist Nos. 47–49 to refute the constitutional thinking of Notes. Madison based constitutional authority in a founding moment separate from the people that the people must learn to venerate. Jefferson based constitutional authority in the people who were to revise their constitution, according to republican principles, as experience and circumstances suggested (322).
Gish and Klinghard make their case thoroughly, drawing on in-depth knowledge of the scholarship on Notes, Enlightenment science and scientific polemics, and the political history of the United States in the years they say constitute the book's political biography. The benefit of their serious, thoughtful, imaginative scholarship becomes evident in the culminating section on Jefferson and Madison, perhaps the most thought provoking and thus rewarding section of the book.
Still, doubts about their claims and arguments remain. Readers will need to decide for themselves whether the evidence Gish and Klinghard present for the biblical rhetorical model in Notes is persuasive (the claim of a Jeffersonian Decalogue seems a stretch, for example), and the authors never explain why Jefferson would have chosen as a subtle implicit model for Notes a book that Notes explicitly criticizes. Why use as a model a book of revelation, which for that reason was an authority not available to all men as men and thus an authority incompatible with the Declaration's claim of equality, and ultimately with the sovereignty of the people? This question arises again in the final section of their book when they present Madison, and not Jefferson, as if he, Moses-like, were carrying the Constitution down from the mountaintop.
Precisely because it was a corollary of a politics based on human equality, Jefferson wanted politics to be as reason based as it could be. Gish and Klinghard interpret this aspect of Jefferson's thinking by insisting, as most scholars do, on the influence of Bacon on Jefferson. On this basis, they present Jefferson's appeal to reason as an effort to rationalize politics. But Jefferson's rationalizing was a mathematizing of reality, which was not present in Bacon. While it is the case that Jefferson had a tendency to overprecision in some of his political reasoning, a tendency that Madison often sought to restrain, Gish and Klinghard do not discuss instances in which Jefferson himself recognized the irrational aspects of experience. This recognition is evident in Notes itself, in Jefferson's use of the phrase “accidental circumstances” in the central query, as well as in other passages.
We should also note that in the illuminating contrast Gish and Klinghard set up between Jefferson and Madison, it was not Madison but Jefferson whose constitutional thinking was consistent with the principle of human equality, and thus popular sovereignty, since he insisted on revision rather than veneration as a constitutional principle. This was not a foolish consistency in Jefferson's mind. As the ultimate guardians of the republic, the people were to be educated (Gish and Klinghard are good on this point), but above all constrained and morally formed by the farming life Jefferson sought to make available to them. Gish and Klinghard have little to say about farming and its importance for Jefferson, even though Notes contains some of the most famous words ever written about this way of life.
This brings us to a final question. Are the 1780s an adequate context for understanding Notes? Gish and Klinghard are clear that such a context is not definitive. Indeed, much that is in Jefferson's book is not relevant to or only to the 1780s and the debate over the Constitution. Their political biography, we might say, covers only the adolescence of Notes. Even so, it establishes the case that Jefferson's book belongs on the short list of the most important writings of the American Founding.
