In Middle East Drugs Bazaar, Philip Robins has produced a comprehensive account of the regional geopolitics of drugs in the Middle East and North Africa based on a compelling examination of the nexus of money, power, and influence. Working across a range of primary and secondary sources, Robins has constructed a series of ten case studies that shed valuable and comparative perspectives on “the narco-geography as viewed from the Middle East” (14). The result is a nuanced analysis of what Robins labels the production, consumption, and transit spaces that draws up political, economic, and social trends in an accessible and highly readable manner.
Middle East Drugs Bazaar is divided into ten case studies spread across three sections that deal variously with the social and public policy aspects and transnational dynamics of narcotics that integrates the role both of states and non-state actors in regional narcotics flows. Robins includes chapters on Israel, Iran, and Turkey in addition to seven Arab states that exhibit “a range of examples with markedly different levels of state capacity” (3). Source material is drawn from national and international government and non-governmental agencies, media reports and semi-structured interviews, and, importantly, the portrayal of drugs in regional culture and literature.
Robins has structured his book around three pillars of drug production, consumption, and transit. The opening section on production spaces contains case studies that focus on Morocco, Lebanon, and Yemen. In Morocco, the balance between soft and hard drugs shifted significantly in the 2000s “against the backdrop of Morocco's greater involvement in a wider cocaine connection” linking traffickers in Latin America and West Africa with consumers in Europe (37). Such linkages feature also in the study of Lebanon through the relationships that Hezbollah has established with groups in Mexico, Colombia, and Venezuela, which appear “oriented towards raising cash for the main organization in Lebanon” (55). In Yemen, Robins constructs a detailed portrait of “an embedded set of clustered vested interests” that have grown rich from the production and consumption of qat that constitute “a powerful qat lobby” bound together by tribal ties (76, 66).
The middle section on consumption spaces contains arguably the most interesting and innovative material in the book and includes cases from Egypt, Israel, Saudi Arabia, and Iran. Robins weaves anecdotes about drug-related incidents into otherwise-familiar analysis of political and economic issues and illustrates their sometimes-surprising centrality in major points of sociopolitical fracture. Thus, readers learn that the detention (and subsequent killing) of Khaled Said in Egypt in 2010 arose after Said “posted a clip allegedly showing corrupt policemen sharing confiscated drugs and their proceeds” (93). Moreover, Robins notes that the police sought to escape allegations of brutality by calling Said a drug addict and claiming he “had swallowed a bag full of hashish on being approached by the policeman, and consequently had died from an overdose” (94).
Case studies of addiction patterns in Israel, Saudi Arabia, and Iran allow Robins to draw a complex picture of the intersection of organized criminality with the divergence of youth-led trends from religiously-conservative social norms. On Israel, Robins notes wryly that “it is impressive that Israel has been able to develop such a widely successful economy with such intoxicants in its midst” (118). Robins adds that Lebanon has become “a hard drugs gateway for Israel” with packages of drugs lobbed across the border from north to south and packages of money being “lobbed back in exchange” (115). In Saudi Arabia, Robins estimates that approximately 300,000 Saudi nationals are drug-dependent, but official responses were, for a long time, hindered by the fact that “Saudi Arabia was arguably the last to recognize and accept that it had a serious and persistent drugs problem” (138). In Iran, the scale of the “rampant drug abuse” (140), which reached epidemic proportions for opiates and heroin, integrated Iran more closely into multilateral initiatives led by the United Nations and contrasted sharply with the synchronous confrontation between Iran and the international community over Teheran's disputed nuclear program.
Turkey, Dubai, and Iraq are the focus of analysis in the Robins’ final section on transit spaces that link the Middle East with wider conduits of drug trafficking. Robins makes the eye-catching claim that, between 1992 and 1998, the Turkish state “teetered on the edge of a Columbian-style descent into failure” as “ultra-nationalist gangs” morphed into “death squads” (166, 167). This necessitated a clean-up campaign in the 2000s that was only partially successful in addressing Turkey's role as a “pivotal transit space” for illicit hard drugs (179). Dubai, by contrast, has emerged as a regional hub for the trans-shipment of drugs from the Indian subcontinent and Central Asia, and also for the distribution of cocaine from Latin America. This notwithstanding, readers from the United Arab Emirates may raise an eyebrow at Robins’ description of the Ruler of Dubai as presiding over ‘the structural presence of criminality prospering within the system [which] is also likely to accrue to the man at the top (191). War and insurgency in Iraq facilitated another regional transit network that ran from Afghanistan and Iran through Iraqi Kurdistan and onward via a northern route to Turkey and Jordan and a southern route to Kuwait and Saudi Arabia.
Philip Robins has shone a spotlight onto the variegated set of issues that account for the nature and scale of drug-related issues and their national and multilateral policy responses. His book is likely to be valuable not only to specialist readers but also to scholars and practitioners who seek an original approach to the study of the contemporary Middle East. Above all, Middle East Drugs Bazaar adds important layers to the complex relationship of states and societies which already have been tested sorely by political upheaval and conflict since 2011.
