Cindy Sondik Aron's Ladies and Gentlemen of the Civil Service introduced historians to the modern federal employee.Footnote 1 The 1987 classic explained how women came to be prevalent in federal office buildings, how their presence there changed the nature of white-collar work in the public and private sectors, and how the turmoil of the nineteenth-century spoils system stabilized into the twentieth-century civil service. Prior to Aron's work, federal workers stood primarily as symbols: of nineteenth-century corruption, of New Deal state expansionism, of Great Society promise (and disappointment), of government inefficiency. Since 1987, historians have sought to deepen our understanding of both the lives of those ordinary workers who have served in the nation's administrations and the ways in which federal employment shaped and diverged from the labor of all working Americans.Footnote 2
Jessica Ziparo's This Grand Experiment: When Women Entered the Federal Workforce in Civil War-Era Washington, D.C. is a definitive, well-researched, and admirably empirical entry into our developing understanding of the meaning and importance of public employment in the United States. Keenly aware of Aron's foundational work in the field, Ziparo carefully carves out new territory by asking new questions: What difference did the crisis of the Civil War make in federal office work? How, precisely, did women first enter federal offices? And what were their work and home lives like when Washington and its federal offices were at their most chaotic, exciting, and dangerous? What makes Ziparo's answers to these questions so useful is her deep empiricism: Ziparo has combed the abstruse, withholding, and irregular records of the mid-nineteenth-century federal government for the presence of thousands of women and grounds each and every claim in the experiences and writings of firsthand accounts. Whereas Aron was laying new ground through necessarily broad characterizations about a period with decent documentation, Ziparo starts in a murkier era and shows us individuality and trailblazing. Figures like the well-connected Kate Cahill, the political Julia Wilbur, the shrewd Sarah Wainwright, and the theatrical Ella Jackson make vivid the challenges and opportunities of the sudden emergence of this world of “women's work” during the Civil War.
By seeking an origins story, Ziparo fights some unwinnable battles. As she explains, the short tenures of early women workers (often a year or less) make it difficult to draw out thorough biographies and track change over time. The irregular nature of nineteenth-century federal paperwork leaves gaping and frustrating holes in the historical record. And the constant suppression and subordination of working women undermine the effort to reveal a cast of characters as diverse as the actual American working class. For all of Ziparo's efforts to widen the lens, middle-class, white people are the stars here, as they were in Aron's book. Finally, Ziparo's effort to find “labor feminism” in the era's equal pay discussions is somewhat unsatisfying because those efforts were so obviously doomed and because Ziparo's figures were so contradictory. It's not easy to square “labor feminism” with the convincing case Ziparo makes that it was women's claims of neediness and dependence upon men that won them jobs and, ultimately, denied them equal pay. Patriarchy lurked in every federal office then, but Ziparo does succeed at having us marvel that an equal pay discussion occurred in such circumstances at all.
Despite these probably unavoidable limitations, some strong and important conclusions emerge clearly from Ziparo's hard-won research. For one, this study shows powerfully that as the United States developed its industrial and bureaucratic institutions, middle-class women could become just as subject to the whims of men's sexist, inconsistent, and arbitrary management as lower-class women had long been. As Ziparo shows, it was only by testifying to their profound powerlessness, generally because of missing or ill husbands but also simply as the “fairer sex,” that middle-class women could even find work in the first place. Of course, this does not mean such women workers lacked agency, savvy, or even fun. Ziparo also makes clear that women quickly learned to play the games of political patronage, “managing up,” and pacifying managers’ egos, and that they could very much enjoy their work and individual freedom while doing so. Indeed, Ziparo's strongest chapters are those that take place outside of the federal offices, where Civil War-era women were changed by and helped to change the character of the nation's capital.
A bit of repetitiveness, a somewhat narrow scope, and lightness in theoretical range are the only drags on this otherwise fine and well-wrought monograph. Ziparo's work does honor to the brave and fascinating women who entered the nation's service to find freedom, decent wages, and comradery in a workplace suffused with war, corruption, sexism, and also openness and opportunity. These women not only changed federal offices and Washington, DC, but as Ziparo shows, they “proved to government supervisors and to private industry that women were capable of performing clerical work, opening what would become a significant labor sector to women across the country” (8). If Cindy Aron made the introduction, Jessica Ziparo has given us a deeper connection.
