In this brief examination of debates and strategies surrounding attempts to ban child labor, Betsy Wood frames such efforts as an extension of sectional tensions. Early efforts attempted to bond the North and South together under the common goal of saving children and avoiding the supposed racial degeneracy of whites. The language used by reformers mimicked that of abolition, referring to “white child slavery” to describe the labor of children in mills and on farms.
The association of free labor and children is introduced through the lens of the child placement program made famous by the Children’s Aid Society (CAS) and Charles Loring Brace, who advocated for farm labor as a gateway to “socially mobile, independent male citizens” (9). This is an interesting way to introduce sectional differences as they related to children, because, ironically, the CAS later faced intense scrutiny for allowing children to work in slave-like conditions and for distributing children in a way that was said to resemble slave auctions. After the Civil War, dueling language about which parents were fit to own the labor of their children pitted reformers who worried about factory children against capitalists who blamed exploitative parents and white landowners clamoring for the indenture of Black children confiscated from their parents under the guise of reducing the need for relief funds.
Many groups were invested in the discussions of child labor: government, industry, and charity and reform experts. These groups brought their own conceptualizations of sectionalism to the discussions. Wood uses the work of Edgar Gardner Murphy to move the narrative forward into the Progressive Era. Murphy, watchful of southern fears about federal overreach, tried to urge state-level reforms in response to the dramatic increase in the number of children laboring in southern textile mills. Murphy tried to appeal to southern industrialists first, claiming that the debilitating and often stunting work children did was dangerous for the future of the region and its racial hierarchy. While the work of white southern children in mills raised the ire of reformers, less was initially made of immigrant children laboring in industry in the North. The emphasis placed on white unity, and the dangers to the white race posed by children doing industrial work, caught the attention of reformers outside the South, but such reformers wanted federal action, not the local and regional responses that Murphy believed were necessary for southern support. Indeed, the federal push for child labor laws by the National Child Labor Committee (NCLC) alienated needed southern allies, as Murphy feared.
What is clear from Wood’s work is that sectional differences about the economic role of government and children could not be overcome through calls for the national (white) good. Adopting the language of abolition to describe the child labor movement did little to encourage southerners to break away from their own economic interests. The political positioning of the Beveridge Bill over Murphy’s objections is an important component. Proponents of the bill, which would have blocked the transportation of products made using child labor, used the concept of the child-as-future-citizen to advance their cause. But this concept was unappealing to southerners both because it applied to nonwhite concepts of citizenship and because it involved federal oversight of trade. As Social Gospel reformers and the NCLC experienced almost continual defeats of their efforts to outlaw various types of child labor through the federal government, Wood demonstrates a connection between the language of sectional division and the child labor movement.
Where this link between child labor and sectionalism is made less clear is in the discussion about agricultural labor. Reformers tended to emerge from a middle class that conceived of children as sacred and their labor as irrelevant to the household economy. But well into the twentieth century, children’s labor had tangible value on farms. More than half of all child labor in the United States was farm-based. This was labor undertaken by children of all races in all regions. Any effort to legislate this work proved unpopular across the country. There is some necessary but missing historiography—especially work by Kathleen Mapes and Pamela Riney-Kehrberg—about agriculture, children, and rural life that may have clarified these issues. Public discourse about the well-being of rural children dates farther back than the NCLC efforts to intercede on their behalf, and the primacy of agrarian idealism and the powerful mythology of farm life as part of the democratic ethos played a major role in removing children’s farm labor of various types from legislation. Farmers discussed children working on farms and the constant stream of young people moving off farms, but they preferred to do so without the interference of urban, middle-class reformers. States found some success in moderating farm child labor through mandatory schooling laws; examining the way truancy was handled regionally would have perhaps contributed to the discussion about sectional differences. What is different between the regions is the off-farm work of southern sharecroppers, who sometimes divided family labor between the mills and the farm—a distinction that could have been made more explicit. Nevertheless, the attention Wood paid to the communication between southern reformers and their northern counterparts, the language they used to argue their positions, and the eventual breakdown of interregional cooperation is a useful addition to discussions of whiteness, Progressive Era reform, and federal intervention.
