Who was John Milton, the English polemicist and poet, and to what extent can we separate Milton, the revolutionary writer, from Milton, the living, breathing person? In Poet of Revolution: The Making of John Milton, Nicholas McDowell centers the personal in our understanding of Milton. Methodologically, this book is an “intellectual biography,” offering a rich and detailed account of Milton's “intellectual and political formation” (8). The first part of a two-part volume, Poet of Revolution, focuses on Milton's “early education through his university life to his emergence as a polemical prose writer” in the 1640s (14). The book brings Milton alive for readers, describing his material life: where he lived and traveled, what he read and puzzled over, and whom he engaged with at school and abroad in his travels. It embraces a deeply Miltonic intuition that is strangely easy to forget—that the books on our shelves are not inanimate objects but real, living extensions of their authors.
By focusing on Milton's early education at St. Paul's School and then on his university years, McDowell offers a meticulous account of his intellectual formation. He examines the “humanist ideal of universal learning,” including not only what we think of as the humanities, but also arithmetic, geometry, astronomy, geography, and natural history. By stressing his conventional humanistic education, McDowell demonstrates that Milton's seemingly revolutionary ideas “derive mostly from a quite orthodox regimen of reading in patristic, classical, and modern texts” (410). Yet it is not this account of Milton's broad humanistic education that is most striking in McDowell's account; it is, rather, the prevailing approach to intellectual pursuits in early modern England. Education was viewed as a “tireless, violent effort” in early modernity, accounting well for Milton's steadfastness (66). It is, of course, important to remember that Milton lived most of his life not as the author of Paradise Lost, but as an aspiring poet, both deeply ambitious and afraid of the burden of his intellectual gift. Would Milton be capable of writing his epic poem and matching the achievements of Virgil and Homer? Or would Milton's talent be “lodged with [him] useless”? McDowell captures the anxious, yearning poet who so deeply feels the burden of his talent and the weight of his intellectual ambition. Perhaps Milton's intensity was not reflective of his idiosyncratic ambition, but of the intensity of intellectual endeavors in early modern England.
McDowell also accounts for Milton's intellectual trajectory by analyzing what he read during these early years, as well as by examining his one surviving common-place book. McDowell notes that “Milton had long been reading about the deadening effects of religious tyranny, censorship, and persecution on the cultural health of a nation,” certainly accounting for Milton's critiques of book licensing in Areopagitica (416). McDowell uses Milton's common-place journal to illuminate his reading, offering us some insight into his notes and musings as he read and processed ideas. Common-place books were frequently used by intellectual elites as a kind of notebook to store ideas for “future composition,” organized into a “categorical structure” rather than as a haphazard collection of ideas (270). McDowell examines Milton's one surviving common-place book, stressing that his defense of regicide in the Tenure of Kings and Magistrates draws heavily on his notes from one of his 1637 common-place books (259). This common-place book, McDowell argues, reveals continuity between Milton's early musings and his radical argument for regicide in the Tenure. McDowell's analysis of the common-place book left me curious about what it would mean to reconstruct Milton's intellectual trajectory if more of his notebooks had survived. McDowell's attention to this singular common-place book reminds us of all that we have lost—of all that we cannot account for in Milton's intellectual trajectory. This is simply one of the realities of working on Milton, and it justifies the kind of reconstructive work that McDowell takes on in this book. But I would like to hear more from McDowell about his view of the challenges of working on a figure like Milton and how he takes himself to be navigating and overcoming these challenges in this project.
The meticulous detail in McDowell's account of Milton's intellectual formation allows him to stress the continuity in Milton's career. Commentators often puzzle over how a “conservative and conformist young man [would] become a leading defender of regicide, republicanism, and . . . religious toleration within little more than a decade,” but as McDowell demonstrates, Milton's radical ideas appear in his earlier writings (12). McDowell challenges accounts that insist on Milton's “intellectual transformation,” demonstrating that many of the arguments that Milton defends in his revolutionary pamphlets are in fact an “elaboration of arguments that [he] had already advanced” (389). Here, I wanted to hear more from McDowell about the significance of his competing account. What is at stake in seeing continuity where others see transformation? How does it shape (or reshape) our understanding of Milton? How does it deepen our understanding of his ideas? Oddly enough, it is McDowell's intellectual biography that convinced me that neither account of Milton—neither one of continuity nor one of transformation—would be able to give us the full picture. Milton is, after all, as McDowell reminds us, a person, suggestive of more all-too-human uncertainty and complication than these two accounts allow. McDowell's book urged me to consider how Milton the person might have both defied and sustained his intellectual influences in complicated ways. Milton lies somewhere in the middle of revolution and tradition. This seems to be where we all—as flawed and thinking people—live.
