These two new books on political participation and local politics in Mexico contrast the optimism of earlier scholarship on Mexico's democratization by addressing persistent weaknesses in Mexico's nascent democracy. Both books begin with evidence that the poor are much less likely to participate in politics than the rich, but then diverge to examine political participation from dramatically different perspectives. The books complement each other and speak to each other in interesting and important ways. Together, they shed light on participation and local governance in Mexico. Matthew Cleary's book points out that the introduction of competitive elections is not enough to ensure democratic accountability and argues that political participation is the key to democratic responsiveness. Claudio Holzner's book seeks to explain the gap in political participation between the rich and the poor and the decline in the political participation of the poor during Mexico's transition to democracy. He argues that neoliberal reforms and the uneven nature of the transition to democracy made political participation for the poor more costly and less fruitful.
Cleary is concerned with why governments respond to the political interests of their constituents. He suggests that there are two main factors that may drive democratic responsiveness: electoral competition and political participation. Cleary provides a very careful, lucid, and useful theoretical review of the potential causal mechanisms and obstacles for both electoral competition and political participation to enforce governmental accountability. He argues that electoral competition can theoretically create accountability through selection and sanctioning mechanisms, but suggests that the sanctioning method may not be very effective in Mexico because consecutive reelection is not permitted for any elected office in the country. Political participation can influence democratic accountability through social networks that enforce norms of public service and through the information that leaders gain about the preferences of their constituents. Cleary also advances a psychological explanation, arguing that politicians respond to citizen demands because of the “psychological discomfort” or “embarrassment” of not responding.
Using a massive dataset of over 2,400 municipalities in Mexico, Cleary tests the effectiveness of competitive elections versus participation on municipal governments' responsiveness. He measures government responsiveness with the provision of water and sewage systems and the ability to raise taxes locally. To measure political participation, he uses voter turnout, poverty, and illiteracy. He justifies the use of poverty and illiteracy as measures of political participation by providing survey data that wealthy and educated people are more likely to be politically active than poor, less educated people. The electoral competition variables are for the most part not significant. The strongest finding of the statistical analysis is that municipalities with high levels of illiteracy and poverty are less likely to have water and sewage coverage and less able to raise local revenue. Voter turnout is significantly related to government responsiveness in the full sample regressions, but is not significant in the noncompetitive municipalities for water coverage or locally raised revenue. This suggests that participation in elections yields more responsive government only if the elections are competitive. Cleary interprets the statistical evidence as clear support for the participation hypothesis over the electoral competition hypothesis. Undoubtedly, government is significantly less likely to be responsive in municipalities with high levels of poverty and illiteracy. That may be because poor people are less likely to participate in politics (as Cleary contends), or it may be because the rich are more likely to have economic and personal ties to the governing elite and have more resources to influence political outcomes.
The greatest strength of Cleary's book is to showcase an example of electoral competition failing to deliver the expected benefits of better governance. Given previous evidence of the positive consequences of electoral competition in Mexico, Cleary's findings force us to rethink when and why electoral competition matters. The excellent theoretical chapters clarify the possible causal mechanisms at work in democratic responsiveness. The use of municipal data provides a great example of how subnational comparisons can be much more useful for testing theoretical propositions than traditional cross-national comparisons. The main weakness of the book involves the difficulty in directly measuring political participation. Cleary could make a much more compelling argument with more direct measures of participation, but of course, such measures would be nearly impossible to obtain for the over 2,400 municipalities examined. Thus, as with all large-n studies, we must make the best of the data we do have. In this regard, Cleary makes an important contribution to the literature on participation, competition, and democratic accountability.
Cleary's conclusion leaves us with an important concern regarding the gap in participation between the rich and the poor. Since the wealthy are much more likely to participate than the poor, and participation is central to government responsiveness, we should expect that greater participation will lead to political outcomes that favor the rich over the poor and thus undermine the quality of democracy. Claudio Holzner's book provides important insights into the inequality of political voice in Mexico and helps answer some questions left open by Cleary's analysis.
Holzner analyzes why the poor participate in politics less than the rich, and why the participation gap between the rich and the poor expanded during the transition to democracy. He combines extensive field research in four municipalities in Oaxaca with a statistical analysis of national survey data. He masterfully weaves together rich and engaging case studies of local politics in Oaxaca and embeds these case studies within a broad understanding of Mexican politics. By comparing the participation of the poor in different types of communities (urban, rural, one party dominated, competitive) he takes seriously the diversity of the poor and helps us understand how people behave differently when faced with different political realities.
Holzner's case study of Nezacubi (pp. 20–22), an urban squatter community in the city of Oaxaca, sheds important light on the statistical findings of Cleary. The neighborhood unsuccessfully employed traditional corporatist strategies to get water service during the era of PRI domination. The municipal government did not have sufficient resources for major infrastructure projects, and the state water utility was unwilling to connect the community to the water system because the squatters did not have legal title to their land. In 1995, a majority of neighbors in Nezacubi abandoned the long-ruling PRI and supported the opposition PAN in the municipal elections. The new PAN municipal government installed the water and sewage pipes in Nezacubi, but could not connect the neighborhood to the water system without the support of the state-level water utility, which was still controlled by the PRI. The state connected all the surrounding neighborhoods but refused to connect Nezacubi, presumably as punishment for its support of the PAN. As a result, many of the residents became discouraged and stopped participating in politics. This case study helps us understand more fully Cleary's statistical findings. While Cleary argues that municipalities with more poor people have less access to sewage and water because the poor participate less, it could be that the poor are more likely to live in irregular squatter communities without legal title to the land and in areas more difficult to reach with urban infrastructure. The poor may also be more susceptible to punishment for defecting from clientelist relationships. Holzner's case study also highlights the importance of state-level politics. If the city of Oaxaca did not have the resources to fund basic infrastructure projects, then surely the very small, poor, rural municipalities that make up the vast majority of Mexican municipalities must be even more dependent on the state government for infrastructure projects.
To explain the participation of the poor, Holzner focuses on institutions rather than individual characteristics. He argues that institutions create unequal political opportunities and incentives that lead to differences in levels of political participation. While the poor usually participate less than the rich, in some contexts, the poor participate more. What determines when the poor will participate in politics? Holzner shows that participation rates of the poor dropped dramatically in Mexico during the 1990s: he argues that the transition from state-led development to neoliberal economic policies resulted in less political participation by the poor because austerity reduced the income of the poor, and because the state's withdrawal from the market and its increasing reliance on centralized technocratic decision making left little room for political negotiation. Even a small drop in income for the poor can affect political participation, making the price of a bus ticket to attend a protest out of reach. The shift to a market economy “increased the costs, decreased the benefits, and narrowed the opportunities the poor had for political action” (p. 83).
Democratization had mixed effects on the participation of the poor, creating new opportunities but also new constraints, because of the persistence of authoritarian enclaves. Where there was more competition, the poor were more apt to participate, but the poor were more likely to live in the places where elections were not free and fair. Where political competition was restricted to the centrist PRI and the right-wing PAN, the poor participated less, but where there was a viable leftist party to mobilize the poor, they participated more. Decentralization coupled with opposition victories had the potential to open the political opportunity structure and increase the participation of the poor, but Holzner argues that changes at the state level were more important because states controlled most of the resources. Thus people living in competitive municipalities within authoritarian state governments faced the strong possibility of punishment from state agencies.
While Cleary suggests that if the poor participated more in politics, the government would respond to their demands, Holzner, in contrast, suggests that the poor participate less in politics because they have been disappointed by previous attempts to influence the government. Turning Cleary's argument upside down, Holzner finds that political attitudes such as interest and efficacy are a result of the responsiveness of the state. If people have a negative experience with the state, they are likely to lose interest in politics and feel less efficacious, and thus participate less. Holzner's interview data do a fabulous job of bringing the voice of the poor into the analysis of political participation. The quantitative analysis supports the main findings of the case studies and gives us confidence that the qualitative findings extend beyond the municipalities studied. Holzner's combination of intensive field research with statistical analysis represents the best of social science methodology.
Both of these books shed important new light onto Mexican politics and political participation more broadly. The greatest asset of Cleary's book is its theoretical insight, while Holzner's most important contribution is his extensive field research and his subtle understanding of how politics works on the ground.
