Sixteen years have passed since the original publication of Hans-Thies Lehmann's Postdramatisches Theater, during which time the concept of the postdramatic has increasingly been discussed by Lehmann and by others as closely connected to theatre's political potential. In response, Postdramatic Theatre and the Political: International Perspectives on Contemporary Performance presses the following question directly: In what way, exactly, is postdramatic theatre political? Noting a renewed interest on the part of contemporary theatre practitioners in addressing political and social issues directly, the editors of this collection put forward for debate the problem or provocation posed by Lehmann's assertion that postdramatic strategies remain “‘more suited’” to the task than “‘traditional’” models of socially engaged drama (3). Few of the contributors contest this premise, taking it more or less as a given that we can only offer, as Lehmann puts it, “stuttering answers” to the problems of ongoing and intensifying economic and political disenfranchisement (Postdramatic Theatre [2006], 175). They focus instead upon rethinking the parameters of the postdramatic, with a particular emphasis on what form the involvement or participation of the spectator ought to take if we are to avoid what Jacques Rancière calls the “‘stultifying logic’” of the pedagogue (10). The resulting collection is at once a compelling renovation of the postdramatic as a critical framework for discussing contemporary performance and a striking reflection of the need for our field to challenge more vigorously our inherited conceptions of the political.
The editors' introduction pivots around Lehmann's contention, following Lukács, that form (as opposed to the thematization of concrete political concerns) is the proper site of theatre's social dimension and therefore the source of any political potential it might carry (3). Following this, the book's twelve chapters are organized not into discrete parts but according to a more fluid movement from postdramaticism's relationship to legacy and history, to subjectivity and productive ambiguity, to reality/documentary theatre, and finally to a focus on the postdramatic text as itself capable of generating or initiating rupture in performance. (Karen Jürs-Munby's chapter on the “parasitic” [211] texts of Elfriede Jelinek is particularly compelling on this last point.) The progression works well, even as individual chapters delve deeply into diverse areas of focus, using a wide range of methodologies. The “International” in the title refers exclusively to Eastern and Western Europe, Australia, and the United States. This is acknowledged by the editors in the introduction, and seems primarily to reflect a continuation of the geographical focus of Lehmann's original study.
The primary point of contention, illustrated by the consistency with which the majority of contributors refer to the work of Rancière, rests on differing investments in what theatre already does versus what theatre must be made to do. In his own contribution titled “A Future for Tragedy? Remarks on the Political and the Postdramatic,” Lehmann contends that Rancière, when he proposes in The Emancipated Spectator that the emancipation of the spectator is simply a matter of leaving her alone, fails to recognize the need for specific techniques and practices capable of interrupting an individualistic mode of spectatorship. For Lehmann, Rancière does not account for the threat the spectacle poses to the political potential of theatre. In contrast, Theron Schmidt persuasively argues that the spectacular quality of the theatre is precisely the site of its political potential. In a chapter that will be of special interest to those working in the area of disability studies, Schmidt proposes that instead of conceiving of the presence of actors with Downs Syndrome onstage in Back to Back Theatre's production of Food Court as a Lehmannian “‘irruption of the real’” (190), we instead should recognize the way in which the production makes use of theatre's traditional function as a place of appearance, a place in which representations are “made and re-made” (204). Similarly, Ulrike Garde and Meg Mumford, in their chapter concerned with “productive insecurity” (148) in documentary theatre, emphasize the new ways of relating that might be generated not by an encounter with the real (as opposed to representation), but rather through the destabilization of what one had previously experienced as real or authentic—for example, by being drawn into an encounter with an actual hotel housekeeper, only to be confronted with evidence that what you are accessing is, in fact, also a performance of the sort you expect from an actor.
While the book as a whole successfully contests and expand the parameters of the postdramatic, the concept of the political does not receive the same scrutiny. The contributors are entirely persuasive insofar as they deal in a critical way with the medium specificity of theatre, and insist upon this as a basis for contending with its political potential. The problem lies not in this contention, but in the underlying assumption that seems automatically to follow that this is the only available understanding of politics. The exception to this might be David Barnett's essay, subtitled “Why Post-Brechtian ≠ Postdramatic,” which ends with the assertion that whereas post-Brechtian theatre articulates a reality that allows for the possibility of social change, postdramatic theatre does not. Leaving aside whether or not one agrees with his analysis, Barnett's suggestion that we might be looking at different politics (not just different performance practices invested in the political) does not find an echo in subsequent chapters. Ultimately this obscures the critical question of why we tend to foreground this conception of politics and not any other. Why is a “stuttering answer” desirable, or why have we begun from a position of conceding (as happens in the introduction) that there are no solutions? These are all reasonable positions, but they are positions rather than givens, reflecting a contextually specific assessment of when, how, and why social and political change takes place.
This, however, may be a minor point, as it weighs upon a broader tendency in our field more so than it does upon this text in particular. Without question, Postdramatic Theatre and the Political offers a critical engagement with those contemporary performance practices attempting to grapple with the complexity of political commitment and involvement, and as such it is a significant and welcome contribution.
