Examining tensions animating theatre under National Socialism, Gerwin Strobl's The Swastika and the Stage: German Theatre and Society, 1933–1945 emphasizes the “underlying continuities” of German theatre from the Wilhelminian to the postwar period, accentuating the role of the middle-class cultural elite, the Bildungsbürger, and the conservative pressure it exercised toward the stage (194–5). Strobl refuses to characterize National Socialist theatre as “second-rate,” given that its architects—among them Reichsdramaturg Rainer Schlösser, Intendant (theatre director) and Nazi ideologue Hans Severus Ziegler, playwright and president of Propaganda Ministry's Reich Chamber of Literature Hanns Johst—were hardly “semi-literate” or “philistine” (9), but rather came from the Kultur-worshipping elite prior to the Weimar Republic. With the rise of the politically charged aesthetics of Weimar-era modernism, influential Bildungsbürger were traumatically driven from the theatre, either from artistic positions (future Hitler Youth leader Baldur von Schirach's father was dismissed by the Social Democrat minister of culture from his Intendant post at Weimar's Hoftheater, for instance) or from the audience. Exhausted by worldwide and national crises, the Bildungsbürger had their remaining refuge, the classics, seized by stage experiments that attacked the cultural values enshrined in their self-confirming education. The modernism of Jeßner, Piscator, and others worked to break down their “mental landscape” (21). Having “long adhered to a strict separation between the political and artistic realms” (15), the Bildungsbürger abandoned the progressive stage; as Strobl concludes, “The left-wing avant-garde had helped to open the door to the far right” (34).
Pointedly, the onstage device of theatrical alienation was mirrored offstage, as the social and cultural alienation of the conservative Bildungsbürger spectators became the material of right-wing Bildungsbürger politics. The “deposed professionals” and distressed audiences of the Weimar Republic “were determined to wrest ‘their’ theatre from [the] hostile hands” of the experimental avant-garde (23–4), seizing their opportunity with the Third Reich. The Nazi theatre was to have been urgently weltanschaulich, oriented toward a specific worldview; but as Strobl argues, its principal genres—Thingspiel (a mass spectacle seeking to fuse nationalism and Christianity), its aggressively anti-Christian relative De Stedinge, and various tendentious dramas of historical and contemporary nationalism—nearly led to its collapse after a single season. As Strobl sees it, the regime's sense of theatre as propaganda found no footing with the middle-class audience's archetypal conception of the pure pleasure of Kultur. Intendanten and stage directors Gustaf Gründgens, Heinz Hilpert, Heinrich George, Jürgen Fehling, and others were then able to “recapture” the Reich's principal playhouses for the “Bildungsbürger and their favoured eternal verities” (194). In Strobl's account, “Intendanten hoped that the barbarians would eventually be tamed by culture” and “the leading Nazis thought that the thespians would eventually embrace National Socialism” (195).
Yet despite this sense of struggle surrounding the stage, for Strobl, theatrical performance takes place in and creates an ideological vacuum: the Bildungsbürger sense of a Kultur apart from politics preserved “liberal playhouses” (203) removed from ideological tendentiousness and drew a wider audience, setting the stage for an “überzeitlich” (transcending time) art after the war (194). Strobl asserts that the role of the Reich's prominent Intendanten continued after 1945 “not simply due to the failure of denazification,” but more critically due to the “belief to which many Bildungsbürger clung: namely, that the innermost walls of their ‘final redoubt’”—their stage—“had held, that the keep had never fallen, and that the leading Intendanten had been fighting all along under the rightful colours of old” (196). The link to this notion also lies in the experiences of the “playgoers” themselves, who bonded in a “mythical union” with the performers during “the inferno of the Allied bombs” (219). Rather than the co-opted cocreators and consumers of totalitarian culture traumatized in the unfolding post-Holocaust era, the Bildungsbürger here are seen to enforce the transmission of an apolitical pre–Weimar Republic German Kultur through the Third Reich period to postwar Germany, sustaining an alternative national mythology.
The Swastika and the Stage includes illuminating chapters on the Weimar Republic theatre, völkisch theatre reform, Thingspiel, theatre and ethnic struggle, censorship and the propaganda apparatus, on theatre entwined in foreign policy and in “total war,” drawing in detail from the documentary records of institutional archives. Nonetheless, Strobl's detailed study also invites further reflection in the field of theatre and performance studies. Conceptualizing the Bildungsbürger as the homogenous preservers of German Kultur leads him to undervalue differences within this group; indeed, to problematize Jewish assimilation to the Bildungsbürgertum would complicate Strobl's argument. At times, he presents the Third Reich nearly as an abstraction, cleansed from human agency: “the German public began to perceive the theatre again as an institution distinct from the Third Reich” (229). As this separation perhaps suggests, Strobl also relies on an untheorized paradigm of theatre, both as an object of inquiry and as a social institution. “Theatre” is presented mainly as a vehicle for the transmission of the dramatic text: how a given performance, even a conservative one, might have spoken through a given play lies beyond the bounds of this study; theatre reviews are barely analyzed. As a result, there is little discussion of performance here, either the discursive interplay between stage productions and concurrent artistic and social performative events, or the interplay between different elements of a single performance. While Strobl accounts for the application of racial laws and policies to the theatre, stage practices are distinguished from the surrounding racialized events and practices of daily life, as though the evident cleansing of the casts, the repertoire, and the audiences would have had little effect on the signifying force of individual performances. Private sources—letters to playwrights, actresses, and actors, for example—witness spectators drawing parallels between events onstage and those in their personal and social lives: much as performance is not restricted to the theatre, so too the fictions onstage were not kept separate from social reality. A dialogue with the secondary literature in theatre/performance studies might have been useful throughout the monograph; the treatment of Thingspiel, for instance, overlooks the opportunity to engage with Erika Fischer-Lichte's theoreticization of the genre in Theatre, Sacrifice, Ritual: Exploring Forms of Political Theatre (2005).
Even though Strobl's argument depends on an uncritical acceptance of the unified Bildungsbürger elevation of pure art and Kultur, The Swastika and the Stage brings suggestive archival material to an English-speaking readership, training attention on the contending attitudes about Kultur arising within the regulatory structures of the Nazi regime and in the wider public. It is a valuable volume precisely because Strobl's meticulous detail and the general contour of his argument unsettle the boundaries separating the disciplines of history, sociology, and theatre/performance studies.
