Why is it now time to draw lessons from pension reform in the Americas? One reason is that in pension economics research, with its long-term cohort and life-cycle focus, data availability sets the agenda. In 2002, the University of Chile's Microdata Center started collecting a new longitudinal survey, the Social Protection Survey (SPS), to evaluate the effects of the 1981 privatization of the pension system. Before the SPS, little micro-level data were available on labor supply and savings accumulation under private-account, multi-pillar programs. In light of this new information, this volume assembles several case studies of pension reforms through the continent, together with discussions of the pension design questions of the future.
The book opens with an instructive chapter on the SPS findings. The fact that the household survey is linked to administrative data allows Arenas de Mesa and his co-authors to compare self-reported savings accumulations with the corresponding numbers on record. Results show that Chileans over-report their months of contribution by 15 to 30%, and only 40% of them know the value of their pension assets. The survey also reveals major gaps in coverage, especially for women, and scant knowledge of the systems' rules on the part of its affiliates.
The volume also provides a comprehensive account of the diversity of American experiences with pension reform, from Costa Rica to the United States. A fascinating picture emerges of the combination of ideological, political, and institutional mechanisms driving the reform process. Before micro-evidence was available, Chile's pension reform had been given credit for many of the country's achievements including fiscal solvency, high returns on pension assets, financial markets development, high growth, and more. In his chapter, Weyland argues that this prestige and a lack of pension reform expertise led policymakers throughout the continent to import the Chilean model, sometimes with too few adjustments. World Bank studies including the influential Averting the Old Age Crisis (1994) were also widely seen as endorsing Chile's example, a perception that James, one of the original authors, sets out to refute.
The remainder of the book offers an uneven set of studies on implications of pension design. Coverage-related questions are barely touched on: can we improve incentives for participation? If not, can we rescue uncovered populations through minimum pension schemes, and at what fiscal cost? Will safety nets crowd-out capitalization programs? By contrast, gender equity issues receive an in-depth treatment. For instance, James, Cox Edwards and Wong argue that privatizations worsened gender inequalities when considering only individual annuities, but that the effect of joint annuities, survivorship benefits and public safety nets reverses that result. In her chapter, Michelle Dion argues convincingly that many reforms reduced women's own pension claims and increased their dependency on their husbands' pension or on poverty programs.
In short, while the collection overlooks some important topics, it does offer necessary historical and conceptual elements to understand new directions in the pension reform debate in both North and Latin America.
