Portland, Oregon, made the national news on May Day 2017. On that day, belligerent black bloc anarchists clashed with aggressive police officers during the annual celebration of an international working people's holiday—a holiday memorializing organized labor's 1886 fight for the eight-hour day that is officially recognized in most of the world's countries but not in the United States. Most protesters, including union and immigrant rights’ activists, were peaceful, but civic leaders fixated on a small number of rioters responsible for property destruction to some downtown businesses while saying little about police repression. In the words of Mayor Ted Wheeler, “Last night was another chapter in a story that has become all too familiar in Portland.”Footnote 1
Perhaps Wheeler was aware that working-class activism in this city, broadly defined, is more than a century old. As Adam J. Hodges documents in his well-researched and important history of Portland during the World War I era, clashes between labor and leftist activists on the one hand, and establishment figures on the other, are nothing new. These types of disputes were expressed dramatically during the First World War, when business leaders, local politicians, the federal government, and union activists sought to influence the region's political economy. Hodges outlines these various conflicts with great care, never losing sight of national developments while drawing our attention to the particularities of this West Coast city. His grasp of power relations in the region, ability to tie local controversies to national and international developments, and talent for describing Portland's colorful figures will undoubtedly impress students of business, urban life, labor, the left, and the politics of the First World War.
Hodges makes a convincing case for local history in general and Portland in particular, insisting that we must appreciate “regional exceptionalism in this period” (5). This region was home to an active, though often divided, labor movement in the Progressive period. The American Federation of Labor (AFL) and Industrial Workers of the World (IWW) made their marks on the city, and some labor activists in the years before the war's start championed syndicalism, the idea that workers, not employers, should “coordinate the government and economy” (29). Organized labor, representing different political orientations, repeatedly confronted hostile employers, many of whom were active in the “Citizens Alliance,” a euphemistically named employers’ association. Portland's laborers faced off against employers on numerous occasions, but seldom secured victories.
Ordinary Portlanders, employers, and the federal government faced new challenges and opportunities during the First World War. This major shipyard city was crucial to the federal government's production demands, and establishing labor peace remained a central priority. Hodges makes this point plainly: “there was no more pressing question in American cities than how to create industrial peace” (1). Government oversight took on numerous forms as it sought to secure labor peace and enforce moral order. He introduces us to some of the key players, including the local individuals behind the federal government's Council of National Defense (CND), which promoted industrial productivity and stability while challenging labor activism. Led locally by newspaperman Bruce Dennis, Oregon's CND promoted food conservation, policed sexuality, and fought IWW activists. Repression and surveillance was a central part of domestic life during the First World War.
Historians like Joseph McCartin have taught us that organized labor benefited from World War I's industrial relations system, expressed most clearly by the pro-labor decisions issued by the National War Labor Board.Footnote 2 And the AFL's Samuel Gompers pledged his support for the war, winning admiration from President Wilson. But Hodges shows that McCartin's findings, which illustrate that union activists were chiefly interested in achieving a patriotic “industrial democracy,” do not adequately describe conditions in Portland. Many of Portland's labor activists were inspired by the revolution in Russia, where, in the words of one union activist during a protest in 1917, workers secured “real harmony” (66). Portland's most committed labor activists were class conscious and militant, not patriotic flag-waivers.
Unsurprisingly, employers and their state allies fought against revolutionary-inspired movements as well as against organized labor's more modest goal: recognition. Most employers in Portland before, during, and after the war remained stubbornly unwilling to modify their managerial style by accepting genuine collective bargaining, which, as Howell Harris argued more than two decades ago, was the labor movement's central goal.Footnote 3 Hodges captures the employers’ interests perfectly in the face of both union and government pressure, noting that “employer intransigence even in the face of federal commands made clear that the open shop was of higher priority than even profit or patriotism” (82).
The region's employers got their way in other areas as well. They continued to employ sizable numbers of German-born employees in war-production establishments even after authorities passed a federal law meant to bar “enemy aliens” from working on, or even congregating near, these types of workplaces in June of 1917. Hodges tells us about a handful of cases involving controversies over the employment of skilled German and Austrian employees. Waterfront businesses complained to federal officials about what they considered onerous restrictions, which often resulted in no change to their businesses practices. After all, as Hodges puts it, “Both the yards and the government were interested primarily in maximizing productivity and the enemy alien program needed to be subordinated to that goal” (110).
Backed by arms of the state, employers continued to harass union members and leftists after the war. Portland was home to much labor activism, which coincided with a national “red scare.” Hodges does an outstanding job outlining the local political landscape, the enduring influence of the Russian Revolution, the left's internal battles, and the viciousness of state and local repression after the United States helped make “the world safe for democracy.” Especially original are his insights into the ways radical unionists sought to influence the political orientation of the AFL. We learn about the importance of the One Big Union (OBU), the name first used by Calgary, Canada, IWW members in early 1919, on Portland's shipyards. Following Seattle's general strike in February of that year, militant unionists sought to, as Hodges explains, “radicalize the rank and file on the shop floor” and transform the AFL “from the bottom” (130).
This relatively short, lively book should appeal to a good-sized readership. First, it will work well in advanced undergraduate and graduate classes. And general readers seeking information about our unaccountable surveillance state, police repression, and the excessive power of business will profit from learning about the deep roots of these problems and the ways ordinary people have fought back.
