Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T05:43:32.677Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Dual-stage radial–tangential vortex tilting reverses radial vorticity and contributes to leading-edge vortex stability on revolving wings

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  19 May 2023

Long Chen
Affiliation:
School of Aeronautic Science and Engineering, Beihang University, Beijing 100191, PR China
Chao Zhou
Affiliation:
School of Transportation Science and Engineering, Beihang University, Beijing 100191, PR China
Nathaniel H. Werner
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Liberty University, Lynchburg, VA 24515, USA
Bo Cheng
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA 16802, USA
Jianghao Wu*
Affiliation:
School of Transportation Science and Engineering, Beihang University, Beijing 100191, PR China
*
†Email address for correspondence: buaawjh@buaa.edu.cn

Abstract

The physics of leading-edge vortex (LEV) stability on flapping wings and autorotating seeds is still underexplored due to its complex dependency on Reynolds number ($\textit {Re}$), aspect ratio (AR) and Rossby number (Ro). Our previous study observed an interesting dual-stage vortex tilting between radial and tangential components in a stable LEV. Here, the establishment of this novel mechanism, i.e. dual-stage radial–tangential vortex tilting (DS-VT$_{r-t}$), is investigated and explained in detail using numerical methods. The contributions of other tangential vorticity transport terms are also considered. It is shown that the stable LEV region coincides mostly with a constant ratio of tangential and radial vorticity components. The DS-VT$_{r-t}$ mechanism functions as a negative feedback loop for radial vorticity, thereby contributing to the LEV stability at $\textit {Re} > 500$. Specifically, this mechanism involves a dual-stage vortex tilting starting from negative radial component to positive tangential component, and then back to positive radial component, thereby leading to a $180^{\circ }$ reversal of radial vorticity. The radial Coriolis acceleration can also assist the DS-VT$_{r-t}$ by enhancing the tangential vorticity component and the reduction of radial vorticity inside the LEV via the second stage of DS-VT$_{r-t}$. The effects of $\textit {Re}$, AR and Ro on the constant radial–tangential vorticity ratio and DS-VT$_{r-t}$ are then analysed. The coupled effects of AR and Ro are separated into rotational effects and those of tip and root vortices. Our results establish an evident relationship among the LEV stability, the constant radial–tangential vorticity ratio, and the DS-VT$_{r-t}$, thereby deepening the understanding in the vorticity transport of LEV formation and stability.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematics of wing geometry and kinematics: (a) the rectangular wing model and revolving motion, and (b) two procedures in the research of AR and Ro. The global and rotating Cartesian coordinate frames at a selected point A $({x}, {y}, {z})$ are shown by base axes $(\boldsymbol {e}_x,\boldsymbol {e}_y,\boldsymbol {e}_z)$ and $(\boldsymbol {e}_t,\boldsymbol {e}_y,\boldsymbol {e}_r)$, respectively. The tangential ($\boldsymbol {e}_t$) and radial ($\boldsymbol {e}_r$) axes vary with the azimuth angle ($\theta$) of point A.

Figure 1

Table 1.Parameter space of AR, $r_{0}$, Ro and $\textit {Re}$ in the current research.

Figure 2

Figure 2.The computational mesh and the validation of mesh density. Here, $C_{L}$ denotes the lift coefficient.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Schematics of cylindrical slices, the LEV region, and quantity integrations. Three cylindrical slices at radii $r_1$, $r_2$ and $r_3$ are shown here as representatives.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Evolution of 3-D vortical structures (outlined by ${Q}=1$) of the benchmark case (defined in table 1). RGB values of the isosurface colour correspond to the magnitudes of vorticity components: $\omega _t^*$ in red, $\omega _y^*$ in green, and $-\omega _r^*$ in blue.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Mixing of radial and tangential vorticity components of the benchmark case: (a) local LEV circulation (radial vorticity intensity), (b) local tangential vorticity intensity and (c) intensity ratio.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Three-dimensional structures of critical vorticity transport terms in the tangential direction: (a) vortex tilting of radial vorticity component ($T_{r\rightarrow t}$); (b) vortex tilting of vertical vorticity component ($T_{y\rightarrow t}$); (c) PVT$_t$; and (d) vortex stretching/compression ($S_t$).

Figure 7

Figure 7.Spanwise distribution and cylindrical slice of critical vorticity transport terms in the tangential direction: (a) $T_{r\rightarrow t}$, (b) PVT$_t$, (c) $S_t$ and (d) $u_{t}^*$ and its radial gradient. All cylindrical slices are located at 25 $\%$ span, and the positive sub-terms of vorticity transport are integrated within the LEV region as $\hat {T}_{r\rightarrow t}^+$, $\widehat {\mathrm {PVT}}_{t}^+$ and $\hat {S}_{t}^+$.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Vortex tilting of the tangential vorticity component ($T_{t\rightarrow r}$) attenuates the radial vorticity component in the LEV: (a) spanwise distribution of $\hat {T}_{t\rightarrow r}^+$; (b) cylindrical slices of $T_{t\rightarrow r}$ at 25 % span; and (c) comparison of spanwise flow and its tangential gradient at 25 % span.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Schematics of DS-VT$_{r-t}$: (a) sketch of the local LEV structure; and (b) $180^{\circ }$ reversal of the local radial vorticity component via DS-VT$_{r-t}$. The white box represents a specific grid point, and blue and red lines indicate negative radial and positive tangential directions, respectively.

Figure 10

Figure 10.Effects of $\textit {Re}$ on the LEV structure and its vorticity components: (a) 3-D vortical structures at $\textit {Re}=100$, (b) LEV circulation, (c) 3-D vortical structures at $\textit {Re}=500$, (d) local tangential vorticity intensity, (e) 3-D vortical structures at $\textit {Re}=5000$ and (f) intensity ratio. The 3-D vortical structures are outlined by ${Q}=1$. The curves in (b,d,f) are at $\lambda =4$.

Figure 11

Figure 11.Comparison of critical vorticity transport terms related to DS-VT$_{r-t}$ at the steady states ($\lambda =4$) of different $\textit {Re}$ values.

Figure 12

Figure 12.Effects of Ro on the 3-D vortical structures of revolving wings: (a) $\textit {Ro}=1.73$ and $r_0=0$, (b) $\textit {Ro}=4$ and $r_0=2.41$ and (c) $\textit {Ro}=6$ and $r_0=4.44$. The 3-D vortical structures are outlined by ${Q}=1$.

Figure 13

Figure 13.Effects of Ro on the vorticity component distribution within the LEV: (a,b) LEV circulation at $\lambda =2$ and 4; (c,d) intensity of tangential vorticity component at $\lambda =2$ and 4; (e–h) intensity ratio at $\textit {Ro}=1.73$, 2.56, 4 and 6, respectively. The LEV circulation and local intensity of the tangential vorticity component at $\lambda =6$ are also plotted, by dashed lines, in (b,d).

Figure 14

Table 2.Spanwise limits ($r_{{lim}}$) of the constant $\hat {\omega }_t^*/{\varGamma }$ at various Ro values.

Figure 15

Figure 14.Effects of Ro on the critical vortex tilting and stretching terms in the tangential and radial directions: (a,b) $\hat {T}_{r\rightarrow t}^+$ at $\textit {Ro}=1.73$ and 6; (c,d) $\widehat {\mathrm {PVT}}_t^+$ at $\textit {Ro}=1.73$ and 6; (e,f) $\hat {S}_t^+$ at $\textit {Ro}=1.73$ and 6; (g,h) $\hat {T}_{t\rightarrow r}^+$ at $\textit {Ro}=1.73$ and 6. The transient cylindrical slices at 30 % span are given in (f,h).

Figure 16

Figure 15.Effects of AR on the LEV structure and its vorticity components at $\textit {Ro}=2.56$: (a,b) 3-D vortical structures at $\textit {AR}=1$ ($r_0=2.05$) and $\textit {AR}=4.44$ ($r_0=0$); and (c,d) the intensity ratios at $\textit {AR}=1$ ($r_0=2.05$) and $\textit {AR}=4.44$ ($r_0=0$). The 3-D vortical structures are outlined by ${Q}=1$.

Figure 17

Figure 16.Effects of AR on the critical vortex tilting and stretching terms at $\textit {Ro}=2.56$: (a,b) $\hat {T}_{r\rightarrow t}^+$ at $\textit {AR}=3$ and 4.44; (c,d) $\widehat {\mathrm {PVT}}_t^+$ at $\textit {AR}=3$ and 4.44; (e,f) $\hat {S}_t^+$ at $\textit {AR}=3$ and 4.44; (g,h) $\hat {T}_{t\rightarrow r}^+$ at $\textit {AR}=3$ and 4.44.