Almir, Ibrić. Das Bilderverbot im Islam. Eine Einführung [The Prohibition of Images in Islam An Introduction]. Marburg: Tectum 2004, 113 pp. ISBN 3-8288-8766-X. €27.00. The author, born 1974 in Bosnia, studied art history and philosophy in Vienna and now works on a doctorate thesis about the Islamic prohibition of images. The present volume is a short introduction to the same problem. He points out that there is no clear and precise prohibition of images in the Koran. Yet, it is accepted throughout the Islamic world that there should not be images of god or persons. As a monotheistic religion, Islam wants to prevent polytheistic trends and idolatry. The prohibition is not the expression against art and art professions. Islamic art is highly respected with its abstract designs, beautiful calligraphy, and magnificent architecture. The book deals with all aspects of the prohibition of images in Islamic religious and philosophical literature.
American Association of Museums (ed.). Vitalizing Memory. International Perspectives on Provenance Research. Washington: American Association of Museums 2005, 185 pp. Many black and white illustrations. ISBN 1-933253-02-9. $25.00. This volume publishes the essays originally presented at the International Provenance Research Colloquium held on November 15 to 16, 2004, in Washington, DC. The inspiration behind the colloquium was the German Arbeitskreis Provenienzforschung, which began with a handful of provenance researchers meeting in Hamburg 2000 and has continued, without institutional funding, to grow and meet at irregular intervals since then. Originally envisaged as a meeting between Germans and Americans, the colloquium was expanded to include colleagues from Austria, Belgium, Canada, Czech Republic, Poland, Switzerland, and the United Kingdom. The colloquium was conducted in sessions reflected in the organization of the published papers. The first session made it clear that provenance research is recognized at a national level as vital to art historical scholarship as well as a fulfillment of principles adopted in response to ownership issues that have arisen in recent years. Subsequent sessions moved the focus from the macrocosm of guidelines to the microcosm of current research. Topics included the exegesis of collections of the Nazi elite (Hitler, Göring, Ribbentrop), the recreation of historic family collections (e.g., Rothschild, Steiner), case studies of specific object provenance (e.g., Portrait of Jean d'Albon, Ruben's Allegory of Eternity), the presentation of lesser-known archival resources, and observations concerning the art trade in the twentieth century. Despite all progress made, the conference also illuminated the amount of work yet to be done in the arena of provenance research.
Arnold, Ken. Cabinets for the Curious. Looking Back at Early English Museums. Aldershot: Ashgate 2006. XII, 297, pp. ISBN 0-7546-0506-X. £47.50. Ken Arnold of the Wellcome Trust (the world's largest private biomedical charity established by the American-British pharmaceutical entrepreneur Sir Henry Solomon Wellcome, 1853–1936) argues that we can do much to reassess the rationale that inspires contemporary collections through the study of seventeenth-century museums. England's first museums were quite literally wonderful: founded on the disciplined application of the faculty of wonder. The type of wonder employed was not that post-Romantic idea of disbelief, but rather an active form of curiosity developed during the Renaissance, particularly by the individuals who set about gathering objects and founding museums to further their enquiries. The argument put forward in this book is that this museological practice of using objects actually to create as well as disseminate knowledge makes just as much sense today as it did in the seventeenth century and, further, that the best way to reinvigorating contemporary museums is to return to that form of wonder.
Bayer, Waltraud. Gerettete Kultur. Private Kunstsammler in der Sowjetunion 1917–1991 [Rescued Culture. Private Art Collectors in the Soviet Union 1917–1991]. Wien: Turia + Kant 2006, 415 pp. Approximately 70 black and white illustrations. ISBN 3-85132-463-3. €32.00. This is the doctoral thesis of the historian Waltraud Bayer (already known for her studies on Russian patrons and the Russian sale of works of art after the revolution to buy tractors) submitted to and accepted by the University of Graz, Austria. In this study she is interested in Russian private art collectors who, in Soviet times of a controlled and officially guided cultural life, were interested in unofficial and hidden art movements of modern and experimental style and collected that despised and prohibited degenerate art. The book describes the beginning of these private art collections and their growth in times of art confiscations after the revolution and during the years of a revival of art trade in Russia. She also tells us about the growing influence of private collectors in the 1950s and 1960s. She finishes her research with a rehabilitation of Russian modern art after the Perestroika and the affect of private collectors on contemporary Russian cultural policy with emphasis on Russian art and artists and the flourishing art trade of today with original and fake Russian art objects.
Bazyler, Michael, and Roger P. Alford (eds.). Holocaust Restitution. Perspectives on the Litigation and Its Legacy. New York: New York University Press 2006, XVIII, 374 pp. ISBN-13. 978-0-8147-9943-7. $42.14. The editors, an international law litigator (Bazyler) and a former legal advisor for the Swiss Claims Resolution Tribunal in Zürich (Alford), put together 31 essays on all aspects of Holocaust litigation, including claims involving bank accounts, slave labor, insurance, and looted art. Seven essays deal with general problems of Holocaust litigation, such as with international law aspects in general (by Thomas Burgenthal), human rights, and procedural issues. Three essays are completely devoted to the looted art litigation, especially to the Holocaust Claims Processing Office in New York state (Monica S. Dugot), to the proceedings concerning Schiele's painting Portrait of Wally seized in New York in January 1998 (Howard N. Spiegler) and the affair Altmann v. Republic of Austria concerning paintings of Klimt (one of them, Portrait of Adele Bloch-Bauer I, was acquired in 2006 by Ronald Lauder and is exhibited in the Neue Galerie in New York) which has finally been decided by an arbitration tribunal in Vienna on January 15, 2006, (E. Randol Schoenberg). Five essays conclude the volume with general litigation problems in recovery proceedings.
Bevan, Robert. The Destruction of Memory. Architecture at War. London: Reaktion Books 2006, 240 pp. Many black and white illustrations. ISBN 1-86189-205-5. $29.95. The author, a specialist on architecture and design, examines the effects of conflict on architecture over the last century. His global survey includes World War II area bombing, the razing of Warsaw in 1944 and 1945, the Holocaust, the Chinese destruction of Tibetan Lhasa, Israel and Palestine, the Soviet assault on religious architecture, the smashing of Greek graveyards in Cyprus, and the Coalition's invasion of Iraq. He also discusses the architectural destruction that accompanied ethnic cleansing and genocide in the former Yugoslavia, including the bombing of Dubrovnik, the razing of the bridge at Mostar, and the shelling of the National Library of Sarajevo. These incidents are cultural cleansing, examples of genocide by other means, and as such are human rights issues. The United Nations (UN) Genocide Convention applies and the crimes should be punished by the International Criminal Court.
Bewahrt-Wiederhergestellt-Erneuert. Restaurierungsführer durch die preussischen Schlösser [Protected-Restored-Renovated. Restoration Guide to the Prussian Castels]. Berlin: Koehler & Amelang 2006, 128 pp. ISBN-10: 3-7338-0348-5. €8.90. There are many castles and residences in former Prussia close to Berlin. For a long time they have been inhabited, and many of them were changed and renovated. The Restoration Guide with many colored and black and white illustrations of the war destructions and the present restorations gives a fascinating impression of the efforts to restore and protect cultural heritage in Northern Germany.
Biedermann, Heike, Ulrich Bischoff, and Mathias Wagner (eds.). Von Monet bis Mondrian. Meisterwerke der Moderne aus Dresdner Privatsammlungen der ersten Hälfte des 20 Jahrhunderts [From Monet to Mondrian. Master Works of Modern Art from Private Collections of Dresden of the First Half of the 20th Century). Berlin: Deutscher Kunstverlag 2006. 308 pp. Lavishly illustrated. ISBN 3-422-06631-4. €29.90. Dresden, until 1918 the capital of the former Kingdom of Saxony and since then the capital of the German Free State of Saxony (Freistaat Sachsen) has been one of Europe's cultural centers of music, literature, and art science for centuries. Many private art collectors of Dresden continued collecting when the princes of Saxony had left the country or could not any more afford such a passion. For the celebration of 800 years of the city of Dresden in 2006, the State Gallery New Masters in Dresden exhibited paintings from some of the major collections of, for example, Oscar Schmitz, Adolf Rothermund, Ida Bienert, and Fritz Glaser. This book is the catalog of this exhibition. It also tells the story of collection of Jewish citizens, the expropriation of the collectors, and the restitution of art objects now on loan from the owners.
Bogdanos, Matthew, and William Patrick. Die Diebe von Bagdad. Raub und Rettung der ältesten Kulturschätze der Welt [The Thieves of Baghdad. Theft and Rescue of the Oldest Cultural Treasures of the World]. München: Deutsche Verlags-Anstalt 2006, 411 pp., 5 maps, 38 colored illustrations. ISBN 10: 3-421-04204-2. €19.90. (German translation of: Thieves of Baghdad, New York 2005.) The author studied law and archaeology and later went on to a military academy. After having worked in New York City as a state attorney, he joined the U.S. forces after September 11, 2001, and served as a U.S. Marine in Afghanistan and Iraq. Back in New York he now fights illegal trade in antiquities and recently wrote this book about theft and rescue of cultural treasure of Iraq after in invasion of March 2003. The author gives a vivid picture of the chaos in Baghdad after the invasion and the taking of the National Museum. Not yet covered are the later destruction of archaeological sites, the tomb robbers of these sites, and the illegal trade in looted antiquities.
Bon Valsassina, Caterina. Restauro made in Italy [Restauration made in Italy]. Milano: Electa 2006, 275 pp. ISBN 88-370-4851-3. €19.00. The Italian Istituto Centrale per il Restauro (Piazza San Francesco di Paola 9, 00184 Roma), the Italian Central Institute for Restoration in Rome, is famous. It was promoted and finally founded by the art critic and politician Giulio Carlo Argan (1909–1992); the jurist, art historian and restorer Cesare Brandi (1906–1988); and the politician Giuseppe Bottai (1895–1959) in 1938 as the Istituto Centrale del Restauro. For the centenary of Brandi's birth in 2006, the author tells in four chapters the history of the creation of the institute under the direction of Cesare Brandi (1938–1961), the institute under the direction of Pasquale Rotondi (1961–1973), the transformation of the institute under Giovanni Urbani (1973–1983), and the new developments in the eighties and nineties of the last century. The appendix of 100 pages is devoted to interesting documents on the creation of the Institute and on later developments.
Boos, Sabine. Kulturgut als Gegenstand des grenzüberschreitenden Leihverkehrs [Cultural Property as Objects of Transnational Loans]. Berlin: Duncker & Humblot 2006, 328 pp. ISBN 3-428-12034-5. €88.00. This book is a thesis submitted to and accepted by the University of Düsseldorf Faculty of Law. After having inspected the relevant national, international, and supranational sources and nonbinding codes of ethics on loan problems, the author deals with loans from foreign countries without any binding return guarantee and immunity from seizure or similar assurances of safe return. In the last chapter she discusses the various kinds of immunity provisions attributing to loans from foreign countries the assurance of safe return. The interesting book was reviewed Kurt Siehr in International Journal of Cultural Property 13 (2006): 253–257.
Borghi, Alvaro. Le blocage et la restitution internationale de biens illicitement acquis [Blocking and international restitution of Illegally Acquired Goods]. Basel: Helbing & Lichtenhahn 2006, L, 253 pp. ISBN 3-7190-2599-3. SFr. 60.00. This publication is a doctorate thesis submitted to and accepted by the University of Fribourg, Switzerland. The thesis deals with all kinds of goods illegally acquired but also with cultural property covered by the UNESCO Convention of 1970. Also the remedies under international assistance in criminal matters are discussed. The main emphasis of research is, however, on money illegally acquired by money laundering or by appropriation of national funds by autocratic heads of state.
Bourdieu, Pierre, and Alain Darbel. Die Liebe zur Kunst. Europäische Kunstmuseen und ihre Besucher [The Love of Art. European Art Museums and Their Public]. Konstanz: UVK Verlagsgesellschaft 2006, 239 pp. ISBN 13: 978-3-89669-667-6. €24.50 (German translation of the 2nd edition of the French original L'amour de l'art. Les musées d'art européens et leur public of 1969). In 1969 Pierre Bourdieu (1930–2002), the famous French sociologist and teacher at the Collège de France, and Alain Darbel (1932–1975), a pioneer of quantitative education research, published an interesting classic of cultural sociology on the attitude of the public visiting museums. In three chapters of learned reflections the authors deal with the social conditions of cultural practice, cultural objects and civilized taste, and the laws governing the spreading of cultural goods. The English translation of this book is available under the title The Love of Art. European Art Museums and their Public (1997).
Bourdieu, Pierre, Luc Boltanski, Robert Castel, Jean-Claude Chamboredon, Gérard Lagneau, and Domimique Schnapper. Eine illegitime Kunst. Die sozialen Gebrauchsweisen der Photographie [An Illegitimate Art. The Social Usages of Photography]. Hamburg: Europäische Verlagsanstalt 2006, 324 pp. ISBN 10: 3-434-46162-0. €14.90. (German translation of the French original L'art moyen. Essai sur les usages de la photographie published in 1965.) Forty years ago the book qualified photography as a kind of cross between documentation of daily life and the claim to constitute art. Today we are used to photos of famous photographers being sold for millions (e.g., Edward Steichen's rare platinum print The Pond-Moonlight of 1904 sold for $2.9 million with Sotheby's in New York on February 14–15, 2006) and that today there is no dispute that photos may qualify as art. The authors of this book as sociologists and philosophers explore photography from its use in daily life and discuss its importance for documentation of life, events, and experiences. Once photography has become a common habit, it started to raise the claim of creating works of art. The authors were right and their predictions soon became true. The book is available in English under the title Photography. A Middle-brow Art (1990).
Brodie, Neil, Morag M. Kersel, Christina Luke, and Kathryn Walker Tubb (eds.). Archaeology, Cultural Heritage, and the Antiquities Trade. Gainsville: University of Florida Press 2006, XI, 349 pp. Some black and white illustrations. ISBN 0-8130-2972-4 (hardback). $65.00. The book publishes a collection of essays, some of them presented to the Fifth World Archaeological Congress in Washington, DC, in June 2003. World-recognized experts, such as Neil Brodie (McDonald Institute, Cambridge, U.K.), Patty Gerstenblith (De Paul University, Chicago), Lyndel V. Prott (former director with UNESCO), Colin Renfrew (University of Cambridge, U.K.), Kathrin Walker Tubb (University College, London), and Peter Watson (McDonald Institute, Cambridge, U.K.), investigate the ways that commodifying artifacts fuels the destruction of archaeological heritage and consider what can be done to protect it. Despite growing national and international legislation to protect cultural heritage, increasing numbers of archaeological sites—among them, war-torn Afghanistan and Iraq—are subject to pillage as the monetary value of artifacts rises. Offering comprehensive examinations of archaeological site looting, the antiquities trade, the ruin of cultural heritage resources, and the international efforts to combat their destruction, the authors argue that the antiquities market affects cultural heritage around the world and is burgeoning global crisis.
Cannadine, David. Mellon. An American Life. New York: Knopf 2006, XVI, 779 pp. Many black and white and 20 colored illustrations. ISBN 0-679-45032-7. $35.00. This is a comprehensive biography of Andrew William Mellon (1855–1937). Mellon, the successful financier and banker, was not only treasury secretary under presidents Handing, Coolidge, and Hoover (1921–1932) and American ambassador to the court of St. James (1932–1933), but also one of America's outstanding benefactors. He financed the National Gallery in Washington (opened in 1941) and he and his son Paul Mellon (1907–1999) donated to the nation their art collection (cp. the colored illustrations), acquired from Lord Duveen, from the Hermitage of Leningrad via Knoedler & Company or directly from this art dealer, to the nation. These aspects of his life are dealt with extensively on pp. 395 et seq. and on pp. 546 et seq.
Carrier, David. Museum Skepticism. A History of the Display of Art in Public Galleries. Durham/London: Duke University Press 2006. XIII, 313 pp. 22 black and white illustrations. ISBN 0-8223-3694-4. $22.95. The author, professor of art history at Case Western Reserve University and at the Cleveland Institute of Art, contributes an excellent work to the historical studies of public museums and to the discussion of the future role of these institutions. Times of unlimited collecting are gone and museums are more concerned about their importance for mass culture and education. Not only the display of art works has changed, but also the museums themselves with their advisors and architects. These changes are exemplified with respect to the Louvre with Vivant Denon as Director, the Isabella Stewart Gardner's Museum in Boston with Bernard Berenson as a supreme connoisseur, the Barnes Collection in Philadelphia with Albert Barnes' very personal directions for hanging and explaining, and the Paul Getty Foundation in Malibu with Richard Meier's architecture. Some scepticism remains; museums must serve very different purposes. It has to serve the public as well as those interested in history and historical evolution. Not all people share the view that understanding of history is futile because it can only be understood by contemporary observers with their subjective views and prejudices. Museums may help to understand our history better.
Casalta, Nabais, José Tavares da Silva, and Suzana Tavares da Silva (eds.). Direito do património cultural. Legislação [Law of Cultural Heritage. Legislation]. 2nd ed., Coimbra: Almedina 2006, 507 pp. ISBN 9-724-02836-4. €26.10. This is a collection of Portuguese, international, and European sources of cultural property. Most of them are reproduced in Portuguese.
Cools, Hans, Marika Keblusek, and Badeloch Noldus (eds.). Your Humble Servant. Agents in Early Modern Europe. Hilversum: Verloren 2006, 167 pp. ISBN 90-6550-908-9. $49.85. In early modern Europe, agents were everywhere. They engaged in the transmission of political news; were employed on diplomatic missions; and negotiated economic, cultural, and intellectual dealings between patrons and clients. The agents' extensive networks, established to succeed professionally on one level, often provided them with an ideal resource for the execution of additional offices. This book presents the papers delivered at the seminar “Agency in Early Modern Europe,” held at the Royal Netherlands Institute at Rome in February 2004. The essays deal with agents from different professional groups—artists, soldiers, clergymen, diplomats, merchants and bankers—and explore the differences and similarities in their contracts, activities and backgrounds. Inter alia the agents for Lord Arundel, the Colonna family, Axel Oxenstierna, and Giovanni di Medici are presented.
Cowen, Tyler. Good & Plenty. The Creative Success of American Art Funding. Princeton and Oxford: Princeton University Press 2006, 196 pp. ISBN-13: 978-0-691-12042-3. $27.95. Few would deny that America produces and consumes art of a quality and quantity incomparable to that of any country. But is this despite or because of America's meager direct funding of the arts relative to European countries? Overturning the conventional wisdom of this question, Tyler Cowen, Holbert C. Harris chair of economics at George Mason University at Fairfax, Virginia, argues that American art thrives through an ingenious combination of small direct subsidies and immense indirect subsidies such as copyright law and tax policies that encourage nonprofits and charitable giving. This decentralized and even somewhat accidental—but decidedly not laissez-faire—system results in art works that are arguably more creative, diverse, abundant, and politically unencumbered than that of Europe.
Crenshaw, Paul. Rembrandt's Bankruptcy. The Artist, His Patrons, and the Art Market in Sevententh-Century Netherlands. New York: Cambridge University Press 2006, XIV, 221 pp. 39 black and white illustrations. ISBN-10: 0-521-85825-9. $80.00. The author, professor of art history and archaeology at Washington University in St. Louis, Missouri, examines scholarly the causes, circumstances, and effects of the 1656 bankruptcy by Rembrandt van Rijn (1606–1669). Following a highly successful early career, Rembrandt's idiosyncratic art and lifestyle came to dominate his reputation. His evasion of responsibility to his creditors was so socially disreputable that laws in Amsterdam were quickly altered. The poor management of his finances magnified other difficulties that he had with family, paramours, friends, neighbors, and patrons. Collectively, Rembrandt's economic and social exigencies affected his living and working environment, his public station and his art. This study examines all these aspects of Rembrandt's bankruptcy, including his marketing practices, the appreciation of his work, and his relations with patrons, in addition to the details of the bankruptcy itself. Several patterns of short-sighted decision making emerge as Rembrandt conducted his affairs within a constantly changing framework of relationships, a shifting set of obligations, and evolving artistic pursuits.
Dei ed eroi della Grecia nell'Italia antica. Recuperi archeologici della Guardia di Finanza [Gods and Heros of Greece in Italy of Ancient Times. Archaeological Recoveries of the Customs Authorities]. Treviso: Sedi Museali 2005, 117 pp. No ISBN. $47.50. This is a catalog of an exhibition in Treviso (Veneto, Italy) held from April to September 2005 and exhibiting archaeological objects recovered by the Italian Customs Police (Guardia di Finanza) during recent years. At the same time the book is an excellent account of the success of Italian police to protect Italian cultural objects. Similar exhibition have already been organized in the past and shown in Rome (Castel Sant'Angelo) and other places to sensitize the public for the Italian cultural heritage and its protection.
Dohna, Yvonne zu. Canova und die Tradition. Kunstpolitik am päpstlichen Hof [Canova and the Tradition. Cultural Policy at the Papal Court]. Frankfurt am Main: Lang 2006. 399 pp. 87 black and white illustrations. ISBN 3-631-55116-9. €59.85. The author submitted her doctorate thesis to the School of Design (Hochschule für Gestaltung) in Karlsruhe, Germany. She is now teaching art history at the Richmond University in Rome. Her thesis is devoted to the Italian artist Antonio Canova (1757–1822) and his political and cultural activities in Rome and Paris in Napoleonic and post-Napoleonic times. According to the Peace Treaty of Tolentino of February 19, 1797, the Holy See had to transfer to France mayor objects of the art collection of the Vatican. This is one of the turning points of modern history of cultural heritage protection. Not only the French archaeologist and philosopher Antoine Chrysostome Quatremère de Quincy (1755–1849) condemned art looting and forced art displacement, but also the Holy See reacted and passed the Editto Pacca of October 1, 1802, the first modern legislative act protecting national treasures and the model of many similar acts of later times. On October 10, 1802, Canova was appointed Ispettore Generale delle Belle Arti (Inspector General of Fine Arts) and Director of the Vatican Museums; and it was he who, in 1815, was commissioned by Pope Pius VII (1800–1823) to recover the abducted art objects from Paris to Rome where they arrived on January 4, 1816. Canova engaged in rearranging the Vatican art treasure, opened the collection to the public and supported the construction of the Braccio Nuovo, connecting the Museo Chiaramonti with the Stradone dei Giardini and inaugurated it on February 14, 1822. All this is well described, explained and documented by the author. She also adds an extensive chapter on the frescos decorating the Museo Chiaramonti visualizing episodes of the time of Pope Pius VII (Luigi Conte Chiaramonti) including the return of Roman art objects from Paris to Rome.
Dresdner Geschichtsverein (ed.). Rückkehr der Kunst. Dresden 1956/1958 [Return of Art. Dresden 1956/1958]. Dresden: Dresdner Hefte 2006, 100 pp. Many black and white illustrations. ISBN 3-910055-83-4. €4.00 (vol. 87 of the quarterly Dresdner Hefte, issue no. 3 of 2006). The Historical Society of Dresden edits Dresdner Hefte over some decades, each devoted to interesting subject matters of the history of Dresden. One of the latest issues deals with the return of art objects taken by the Russian Army to Russia in 1945 and returned in 1956 to 1958 to Dresden. Fifty years later the Historical Society asked several scholars to contribute to a collection of essays commemorating this event. Art historians, museum people, and other scholars tell the story of one of the examples which could qualify as a return under the First Protocol of the 1954 Hague Convention had this instrument already entered into force in 1956 and 1958.
Dromgoole, Sarah (ed.). The Protection of the Underwater Cultural Heritage. National Perspectives in Light of the UNESCO Convention 2001 (Publication of Ocean Development, vol. 55). Leiden/Boston: Martinus Nijhoff 2006. 2nd ed. XXXVIII, 420 pp. ISBN 10: 90-04-15273-3. €141.00. The UNESCO Convention of November 2, 2001, on the Protection of the Underwater Cultural Heritage (cp. International Journal of Cultural Property 2002, no. 1, p. 107) has been ratified, as of December 2007, by 14 States and has not yet entered into force. Sarah Dromgoole, reading law at the University of Leicester and being one of the few specialists of underwater cultural heritage, asked 16 colleagues of 16 different countries to report on national legislation, practice, and case law of their countries with respect to underwater cultural heritage. The book has reports on the following countries: Australia (Bill Jeffery), China including Taiwan (Kuen-chen Fu), Finland (Maija Matikka), France (Gwénaëlle Le Gurun), Greece (Anastasia Strati), Ireland (Nessa O'Connor), Federal States of Micronesia (Bill Jeffery), the Netherlands (Thijs J. Maarleveld), New Zealand (Piers Davies, Paul Myburgh), Norway (Frode Kvalø, Lyder Marstrander), Poland (Wojciech Kowalski), South Africa (Craig Forrest), Spain (Mariano J. Aznar Gómez), Sweden (Thomas Adlercreutz), United Kingdom (Sarah Dromgoole), United States of America (Ole Varmer). There is a foreword by James A. R. Nafziger of Willamette University College of Law and Rapporteur of the International Law Association project, which finally became the basis of the UNESCO Convention, an extensive introduction by Sarah Dromgoole, and the text of the UNESCO Convention in the annex. This book has been reviewed by Joel B. Gilman in International Journal of Cultural Property 14 (2007): 121–125.
Edsel, Robert M. Rescuing da Vinci. Hitler and the Nazis Stole Europe's Great Art. America and Her Allies Recovered It. Dallas: Laurel 2006, XVIII, 303 pp. Many illustrations. ISBN 0-977-43349-4. $34.65. Hitler, Göring, Rosenberg, and other Nazis looted Europe and Russia during World War II. Hitler wanted to build the world's greatest collection—the Führer Museum—in his hometown Linz, Austria. Museum officials in Europe took extraordinary measures to protect art from Hitler and the ensuing war. When U.S. forces landed in Europe, they assembled a special force of American and British museum directors, curators, and historians, known as the Monuments, Fine Arts, and Archives section. These Monuments Men attempted to minimize damage to European monuments and architecture, then track down stolen works of art. Their effort would become one of the greatest treasure hunts in history. In the end, Allied Forces located more than 1000 repositories, in mines and castles, many of which contained art, sculptures, furniture, and other treasures stolen by the Nazis. But many pieces are still missing. Efforts to locate and return missing art continue to this day. This book tells the story of the Nazi theft and Allied rescue of Europe's art in brief text and hundreds of rarely published photographs from the period.
Enderlein, Angelika. Der Berliner Kunsthandel in der Weimarer Republik und im NS-Staat. Zum Schicksal der Sammlung Graetz [The Art Trade in Berlin during the Weimar Republic and the Nazi-State. The Destiny of the Collection Graetz]. Berlin: Akademie Verlag 2006, X, 327 pp. 16 black and white illustrations and 10 charts. ISBN-13: 978-3-05-004255-8. €49.80. This is another German doctorate thesis, this one submitted to and in 2005 accepted by the Faculty of Philosophy III (Art History) of Humboldt University Berlin. After a short introduction the author extensively describes art trade in Berlin after World War I. She also deals with public and private collections the usual customers of art galleries and auction houses. But her main interest is the creation and dispersion of the art collection of Robert Graetz (1878–1945), the Jewish industrialist (manufacturer of coats for women) of Berlin. Graetz collected contemporary art and his collection comprised approximately 200 pieces when he had to sell them after 1933 and when the rest was confiscated before he was deported to a concentration camp. After World War II his heirs tried to locate the art objects of Robert Graetz diligently reconstructed and cataloged by Enderlein on pages 245 to 266. The heirs are still trying to get back some of Robert Graetz's paintings relying on the Washington Principles of 1998 and the German Guidelines for Dealing with Cases of Holocaust Art (Declaration of 1999).
Faber, Ronald, and Franz-Stefan Meissel. Nationalsozialistisches Steuerrecht und Restitution [National Socialist Tax Law and Restitution].Wien: Manz 2006, XII, 104 pp. ISBN-10: 3-214-00148-5. €24.00. The book is based on a memorandum prepared for the Jewish Community of Vienna for restitution proceedings under the Austrian Statute on the Restitution Fund (Entschädigungsfondsgesetz of 2001). The authors show that the Nazis applied tax law discriminatorily to Jewish citizen to get hold of their assets. The reasons of arbitration award of January 15, 2006, in the case of Maria Altmann against the Republic of Austria show how Ferdinand Bloch-Bauer was illegally treated by the Austrian tax authorities. The present book also contributes to the broader and extensive research of the Austrian Historical Commission (Historikerkommission) established to make public the events in Austria during Nazi times. This is emphasized by Professor Clemens Jabloner, the President of the Austrian Administrative Court and the chairman of the Historikerkommission, in his foreword.
Fagan, Brian. The Rape of the Nile. Tomb Robbers, Tourists, and Archaeologists in Egypt. 3rd ed. Boulder, Colorado: Westview 2004, XV, 303 pp. Approximately 30 black and white illustrations. ISBN 0-8133-4061-6. $16.95. Fagan, one of the leading archaeological writers and emeritus professor of anthropology at the University of California, Santa Barbara, presents a revised edition of his classical account of the cavalcade of archaeologists, thieves, and sightseers who have flocked to the Nile Valley since ancient times. This edition updates the saga with new accounts of stunning recent discoveries including the Royal Tombs of Tams, the Valley of Golden Mummies at Bahariya, the Tomb of the Sons of Ramses, and the sunken city of Alexandria. Fagan concludes with a clear-eyed assessment of the affect of modern mass tourism on archaeological sites and artifacts.
Fanelli Franco. Luciano Pistoi. Il mercante d'arte è il consigliere del principe[Luciano Pistoi. The Art Dealer is the Prince's Counsel]. Torino: Allemandi 2005. 47 pp. Some black and white illustrations. ISBN 88-422-1351-9. €9.00. Luciano Pistoi (1927–1995) was an important Italian art dealer promoting Arte povera and especially artists as Lucio Fontana, Alberto Burri, Piero Manzoni, Cy Twombly, Jackson Pollock, Mario Merz, and others. He was also known for the art exhibition in Castello di Volpaia in Tuscany. The present volume reproduces a conversation of Franco Fanelli with Luciano Pistoi in 1994 and partially published in 1995 in the Giornale dell'Arte.
Feilchenfeldt, Rahel E., and Thomas Raff (eds.). Ein Fest der Künste. Paul Cassirer. Der Kunsthändler als Verleger [A Festival of Arts. Paul Cassirer. The Art Dealer as Publisher]. Munich: Beck 2006. 423 pp. 156 colored and black and white illustrations. ISBN-13: 978-3-406-54086-8. €29.90. Paul Cassirer (1871–1926) was a successful art dealer in Berlin and at the same time a publisher of illustrated books (Pan-Press). He was a vigorous supporter and champion of French and German impressionism. The book, also a catalog of an exhibition in the Max-Liebermann-Haus in Berlin, shows the beginning of modernism in art and literature at the beginning of the twentieth century and the part Paul Cassirer played in this respect.
Feilchenfeldt, Walter. By Appointment Only: Cézanne, Van Gogh and Some Secrets of Art Dealing. Essays and Lectures. New York: Thames & Hudson 2006. 322 pp. Many illustrations. ISBN. 0500976562. $60.00. (Schriften zu Kunst und Kunsthandel Cézanne und Van Gogh published in 2005.) Walter Feilchenfeldt (born 1939), son of Walter Feilchenfeldt, Senior, and Marianne Feilchenfeldt, is an art dealer in Zürich and the successor of his father who continued the art gallery of Paul Cassirer (1871–1926) in Berlin, transferred it 1933 to the Netherlands and in 1939 to Zürich where it still exists under the name Feilchenfeldt. The book is a collection of essays and lectures first published in periodicals, catalogs, or other books. Especially interesting are those essays dealing with art trade and the vast experience of the author as an art dealer.
Fuhrmeister, Christian, Stephan Klingen, Iris Lauterbach, and Ralf Peters (eds.). Führerauftrag Monumentalmalerei. Eine Fotokampagne1943–1945 [Führer-Mandate Monumental Paintings. A Photo Campaign 1943–1945]. Köln, Weimar, Wien: Böhlau 2006, XIII, 285 pp. Many colored and black and white illustrations. ISBN 978-3-412-02406-2. €24.95. In the years 1943–1945 Adolf Hitler ordered the German Ministry of Public Education and Public Relations (Reichsministerium für Volksaufklärung und Propaganda) to photograph historically and artistically important paintings and decorations of buildings endangered by war and air raids. This was done. Approximately 40,000 color slides of art objects of about 480 buildings in Austria, Czechoslovakia, Germany, Italy, Poland, and Russia were taken and preserved in various depots in Germany. In October 2005 a conference on this photo campaign took place in Munich with the Zentralinstitut für Kunstgeschichte. The present volume publishes the papers given at this conference and unites authors of diverse specialization (art history, preservation of monuments and historic buildings, history of photography, image and media technology, photogrammetry) and evaluates the current state of research. The evolutionary history and the complex administrative history of the Führerauftrag are comprehensively dealt with, based on previously unknown archive material. Investigations relative to the history of photography examine the development of color photography within the context of documentation and propaganda. The possibilities for current utilization of the digital images in restoration and preservation of monuments and historic buildings are controversially discussed; thus, opinions are given regarding current reconstruction debates, for example regarding the rebuilding of Dresden's Frauenkirche completed in 2005. An appendix of documents as well as lists of photographers involved and buildings photographed complement the textual contributions.
Gabus, Pierre, and Marc-André Renold. Commentaire LTBC. Loi fédérale sur le transfert international des biens culturels (LTBC) [Commentary CPTA. Federal Act on the International Transfer of Cultural Property]. Zürich: Schulthess 2006, XXVI, 374 pp. ISBN 3-7255-5215-0. SFr. 148.00. On June 1, 2005, entered into force the Swiss Federal Act on the International Transfer of Cultural Objects, implementing the 1970 UNESCO Convention on the Means of Prohibiting and Preventing the Illicit Import, Export and Transfer of Ownership of Cultural Property. This important statute is commented article by article by two specialists. Pierre Gabus is attorney-at-law in Geneva and director of the Art-Law Center together with his colleague Marc-André Renold who is also professor of art law at the Geneva University Faculty of Law.
Gillman, Derek. The Idea of Cultural Heritage. Leicester: Institute of Art and Law 2006. VIII, 135 pp. 18 black and white illustrations. ISBN 1-903987-19-9. £21.00. Gillman, since October 2006 executive director and president of the Barnes Foundation and former president of the Pennsylvania academy of fine arts, publishes his ideas on three basic questions dealing with “Claims about Heritage,” “Heritage and Narrative” and “Regulation and Rights.” In the first part of his books he takes the Bamiyan Buddhas (destroyed by the Taliban in 2001), Pablo Picasso's painting Guernica (since 1981 in the Prado of Madrid), the Parthenon/Elgin Marbles (since 1816 exhibited in the British Museum) and Gilbert Stuart's portrait of George Washington (the Lansdowne Portrait, formerly owned by Lord Primrose of Scotland and now in Washington's National Portrait Gallery) as examples of potential national treasures and confronts such treasures with the policy arguments as “internationalism or nationalism” (Merryman), “cosmopolitanism and particularism” Hegel, Herder) and “primitivism and world culture” (Quatremère de Quincy, Gombrich). In two chapters of the other part the author discusses various means of protection of cultural property against destruction and export. Although pleading for a quite liberal cultural policy he can imagine that certain cultural objects of national importance are correctly protected against illegal export. This “other way of thinking” may become a “minimal, but peaceful, modus vivendi.”
Goddio, Franck, and Manfred Clauss (eds.). Egypt's Sunken Treasures. Munich: Prestel 2006, 464 pp. ISBN 3-7913-6078-7. €29.00. In the shallow waters off the coast of Egypt, the French underwater archaeologist Franck Goddio discovered and excavated parts of three ancient cities: Alexandria, Herakleion, Egypt's gateway to the Mediterranean, and the old port of Canopus. These cities sank into the sea probably before 1300 c.e. and have been excavated since the middle 1990s. Modern technology has made it possible to recover relics, including statuary, jewelry, pediments, stone tablets and fragments of buildings, all lost for nearly thousand years. The lavishly illustrated book served as a catalog of the exhibition of many of the recovered items in the Martin-Gropius-Bau Berlin from May to September 2006.
Hoffman, Barbara T. (ed.). Art and Cultural Heritage. Law, Policy, and Practice. New York: Cambridge University Press 2006, XXXVIII, 562 pp. ISBN-10. 0-521-85764-3. $120.00. Barbara Hoffman, the well-known New York arts lawyer and former chair of art law committees of the American and the International Bar Association, presents a book with 65 articles with comprehensive in-depth analysis of national and international laws respecting cultural heritage. The articles deal with ethics, philosophy, politics, and working principles about how cultural heritage law, policy, and practice should be sculpted from the past as the present becomes the future. Art and cultural heritage are two pillars on which a society builds its identity, its values, its sense of community, and its individuals. The authors explore these demanding concerns, untangle basic values, and look critically at the conflicts and contradictions in existing art and cultural heritage law and policy in their diverse sectors. The rich and provocative contributions collectively provide a reasoned discussion of the issues from a multiplicity of views to permit the reader to understand the theoretical and philosophical underpinnings of the cultural heritage debate.
Houpt, Simon. Museum of the Missing. A History of Art Theft. New York: Sterling 2006. 192 pp. Many, mostly colored illustrations. ISBN 13-978-1-4027-2829-7. $16.47. The author, New York-based arts and culture columnist for The Globe and Mail, Canada's national newspaper, recounts in five chapters (Art as Commodity; Theft in a Time of War; The Uncommon Criminal; The Lost Art Detective Agency; The Space on the Wall) the story of the valuable holdings of a “museum of missing art objects” and investigates some of the men and women involved in the thefts committed in places like Amsterdam (1993: Museum Van Loon; 2002: Van Gogh Museum); Baghdad (2003: National Museum of Iraq); Berlin (1988: Neue Nationalgalerie); Boston (1990: Isabella Stewart Gardener Museum); Dumfries, Scotland (2003: Drumlanrig Castle); Ghent (1934: Cathedral of St. Bayo); Haarlem, Netherlands (2002: Frans Hals Museum); Hoorn (2005: Westfries Museum); London (2004: Victoria & Albert Museum); Oslo (2004: Munch Museum); Paris (1998: Louvre); Palermo (1969: Church of San Lorenzo); and St. Petersburg (2001: Hermitage). Hopefully, most of these objects will “deaccession” to the former owners. Some of them already did, such as the Munch paintings stolen from the Munch museum in Oslo.
Hubel, Achim. Denkmalpflege. Geschichte-Themen-Aufgaben. Eine Einführung [Preservation of Historical Monuments. History-Topics-Tasks. An Introduction]. Stuttgart: Reclam 2006, 360 pp. With several black and white illustrations. ISBN-10: 3-15-018358-8. €9.00. This pocketbook is written by German specialists for the preservation of historical monuments. The chapters deal with the history of preservation of monuments since ancient time, the science of monuments (Denkmalkunde) and the present problems and necessities of protection of monuments.
Hubert, Jean (ed.). Il Paradiso di Tintoretto. Un concorso per Palazzo Ducale [The Paradise of Tintoretto. A Competition for the Doge Palace]. Milano, Paris: 5 Continents Editions/Louvre 2006, 183 pp. Many illustrations. ISBN 88-7439-286-9. $67.50. On December 20, 1577, under the Doge Sebastiano Vernier (1577–1578) a fire destroyed big parts of the Doge Palace of Venice and the hall of Maggior Consiglio (Supreme Council) entirely. It lasted until April 1582 that it was decided to renew the hall of Maggior Consiglio and artists were invited to take part in the competition for a huge fresco decorating the end wall of the huge hall. Many famous artists took part in the competition: Francesco Bassano (1549–1592), Palma il Giovane (1544–1628), Jacopo Tintoretto (1518–1594), Paolo Veronese (1528–1588) and Federico Zuccari (1540/41–1609). When Veronese passed away in 1588 Jacopo Tintoretto won the competition and executed the fresco “Paradiso” from 1588 to 1592. The present book is the catalog of an exhibition shown 2006 in Paris (Louvre), Madrid (Museo Thyssen-Bornemisza) and Venice (Palazzo Ducale) exhibiting the projects and materials which finally led to the redecoration of the hall of Maggior Consiglio admired up to now by hundreds of thousand visitors of the Doge Palace every year.
Hutt, Sherry (ed.). Yearbook of Cultural Property 2006. Walnut Creek, California: Left Coast Press 2006. 215 pp. ISBN 1-59874-072-5. $63.00. This is the inaugural edition of the Yearbook sponsored by the American Lawyers' Committee for Cultural Heritage Preservation, presided by Patty Gerstenblith of DePaul University College of Law. The Yearbook seeks to inform cultural property practitioners of the previous year's developments in cultural property law with respect to legislation, regulation, casework, publication, education, and policy. It covers a broad spectrum: federal land management, state and local matters, tribal management and matters affecting tribes, management of marine environment, museum matters and concerns, the art market, the international arena, and enforcement. In addition to the Practice Area sections, the Yearbook includes a law school update, which deals with cultural property law in American law schools, a review of books, articles, and resources dealing with scholarship and web sites of interest to the field, and articles and items on noteworthy events. This is a very useful publication.
Karner, Ernst. Gutgläubiger Erwerb. Zum Spannungsfeld von Bestandsschutz und Verkehrsinteressen [Bons fide Purchase. On the Tension between the Preservation of Ownership and the Interests of Business]. Wien, New York: Springer 2006, XX, 475 pp. ISBN-10: 3-211-24487-5. €98.00. This is a doctoral thesis submitted to and accepted by the University of Vienna Faculty of Law in 2004. Based on a broad comparative survey and a detailed research in Austrian, German, and Swiss law the author discusses all problems related to good faith purchase in potentially all imaginable circumstances. Without superfluous statistics about the importance of bona fide purchase the author starts straightforward with the problems which existed since Roman times. There is a tension between the interests of the owner and the interests of business represented by good faith purchasers. In modern times, however, the interests of business should not be exaggerated because there is no need for good faith purchase of commodities. Good faith purchase is mainly reduced to art objects and motorcars and some other valuable objects of high quality. Without formulating proposals for a statutory regime of bona fide purchase (what should not be done without regulating at the same time the law of prescription, laches and limitation of actions) the author diligently stresses the importance of creating the appearance of good title with bailees and the attribution of the owner to the situation which led to the good faith purchase. He admits that there may be special circumstances in which a good faith purchase may be justified much more than in normal commerce. He mentions public auctions and the sale by specialized merchants. A high standard of care is required for any qualification of “good faith.” In general, the author does not want to expand good faith purchase beyond the traditional limits of European civil codes.
Kemle, Nicolai B. Kunstmessen: Zulassungsbeschränkungen und Kartellrecht [Art Fairs: Limitations for Admission and Antitrust Law] (Schriften zum Kulturgüterschutz/Cultural Property Studies). Berlin: De Gruyter 2006, XX, 424 pp. ISBN-13: 978-3-89949-338-2 (hardback). €98.00. This is a doctorate thesis submitted to and accepted by the University of Heidelberg Faculty of Law in 2005. We all know about the art fairs in Basel, Miami (Art Basel), Cologne (Art Cologne), London (Frieze Art Fair), Maastricht, The European Fine Art Fair (TEFAF) Madrid, Arte Contemporáneo (ARCO), and other places. Everybody wants to visit them as potential customer or as an art addict, but what about the art galleries and their interest to exhibit their art objects for sale? Do they have a right to be admitted to the art fair or can their application be declined without any reason or because of lack of space? German courts applied article 20 (2) of the German Antitrust Act (prohibition of discrimination) and, in principle, recognized a right to be admitted. The author discusses this issue and the European perspective under European antitrust law. He agrees that any discrimination should be avoided and, because of limited space, some neutral devices (restricted subject matter of the fair, priority, casting lots) should be applied to reduce the art galleries taking part in the spatially limited art fairs. This seems to be the first detailed penetrating study of a very important problem.
King. Dorothy. The Elgin Marbles. London: Hutchinson 2006, XII, 340 pp. Many colored and black and white illustrations. ISBN 0-09-180013-7. £18.99. The author tells the history of the acropolis of Athens, the Parthenon, and its Marbles from ancient times until today. Special interest is given to Lord Elgin and the detachment of the Marbles, their shipment to England in 1804 and their sale to the British Museum in 1816. She finally concludes that the Marbles should not e given back to Greece, the Greek do not deserve it. They are, in her opinion, best preserved in the United Kingdom.
Krieken-Pieters, Juliette van (ed.). Art and Archaeology of Afghanistan. Its Fall and Survival. A Multi-Disciplinary Approach (Handbook of Oriental Studies, Handbuch der Orientalistik, Section eight: Central Asia, vol. 14). Leiden, Boston: Brill 2006, XXI, 412 pp. With more than 64 black and white and colored illustrations. ISBN-10: 90-04-15182-6. €89.00. Not only people suffer in times of war. Also cultural objects are in danger and need to be protected, hidden, and returned at the end of armed conflict. This volume is edited by Van Krieken-Pieters, lecturer at Webster University (campuses in the Netherlands, United States, and Thailand) and the first secretary of the Society for the Preservation of Afghanistan's Cultural Heritage. The first 11 chapters deal with Afghanistan's cultural heritage protection in general and with respect to specific objects. The last seven chapters are devoted to legal problems, especially to the perspective of international management (Lyndel V. Prott), the dilemmas with respect to the Afghan case (Juliette van Krieken-Pieters), the Buddhist Manuscripts of Gandhara in the Schøyen Collection in Norway (Atle Omland), the case of the Buddhas of Bamiyan (Francesco Francioni and Federico Lenzerini), the looting of cultural heritage in general (Jos van Beurden), safe havens for endangered cultural objects (Kurt Siehr), and threats to cultural heritage in armed conflict (Fabio Maniscalco).The Afghan Law May 20, 2004, on the preservation of historical and cultural heritage is reproduced in English translation in Annex II.
Kubersky-Piredda, Susanne. Kunstwerke—Kunstwerte. Die Florentiner Maler der Renaissance und der Kunstmarkt ihrer Zeit [Art Objects—Art Value. The Florentine Painters of the Renaissance and the Art Trade of Their Time], Norderstedt: Books on Demand 2005, 577 pp. 37. Black and white illustrations and many charts. ISBN 3-8334-3404-X. €69.00. This is an extraordinary study based on a doctorate thesis on art history written in the German Institute of Art History in Florence and submitted to and accepted by the University of Cologne, Faculty of Philosophy. The author is interested in the economic condition of Florentine artists in the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries. Having examined several accounting books of artists and the prices of about 1500 art objects, she comes to the following conclusions:
Most artists remained craftsmen and did rise, as some of them (e.g., Michelangelo, Titian, Leonardo, Raphael), to respected, well-paid, rich masters. The simple painter was still a member of handicraft guilds and earned enough money to survive on a rather modest level.
Prices for panels and artistic movables remained quite stable during the centuries. Only the price of works of famous artists rose considerably, and this was not because of valuable paint and decorations but because of the artistic quality.
Most of the art works were commissioned and their price was often fixed by a final expert opinion (lodo) after they were finished. Payment was also made in kind and by transfer of real estate.
There were not yet specialized art dealers. Art works produced for the open market were traded by merchants trading also with other commodities.
During the late fifteenth and the sixteenth century, artists became a well respected member of the artes liberales after having fought for their unique profession in the Paragone-contest stressing the artistic value of their creations. More than 200 pages of the book are devoted to charts full of numbers and references to the results of the penetrating research on renaissance art in Florence.
Kuhrau, Sven. Der Kunstsammler im Kaiserreich. Kunst und Repräsentation in der Berliner Privatsammlerkultur [The Art Collectors in Imperial Germany. Art and Representation in the Berlin Culture of Private Collectors]. Kiel: Ludwig 2005, 319 pp. 87 Black and white illustrations. ISBN 3-937719-20-2. €34.90. This doctorate thesis was submitted to and accepted by the Free University of Berlin, Faculty of History and Cultural Sciences. It describes the developments of private art collections in Berlin of Imperial Germany and after World War I. Supported by many photos of various private collections and their presentation in the palaces of the collectors the author reveals how the collectors and the collections gradually shifted from ancient art to international contemporary art. Special emphasize is laid on the evaluation of private collections by the public in the daily press, art journals, and literature. Most of the collections described have been dissolved or destroyed.
Kunth, Felicitas. Die Rothschild'schen Gemäldesammlungen in Wien [The Rothschild Picture Galleries in Vienna]. Wien: Böhlau 2006, 328 pp. Several black and white and colored illustrations. ISBN 3-205-77306-3. €39.00. The Austrian branch of the Rothschild family was founded in 1820 and headed by Salomon (1774–1855), his son Anselm Mayer (1803–1874), his grandson Albert (1844–1911) und finally by his great grandson Louis (1882–1955). The Austrian Rothschilds collected art objects, especially paintings and enjoyed them in their palaces in Vienna and other places. The art collection was seized by the Nazis on March 14, 1938, and arrangements were made as to where the treasures should be exhibited and integrated either in already existing museum or in Hitler's museum planned to be built in Linz. After the World War II not all art objects were returned to the Rothschild family. Austria applied the national Statute of 1918/1921 on the Prohibition of Export of Art Object of National Importance also to art objects to be restituted and demanded that certain important objects should be given to Austrian museums in exchange for the permission to export the rest of the collection. This unfair policy was corrected in 1998 when the Federal Statute of 4 December 1998 on the Return of Art Objects from Austrian Federal museums and Collections was passed and 250 art objects were returned to the Rothschild family. On July 8, 1999, 224 objects of the former Rothschild collection were sold at auction with Christie's of London for £57.7 million. The author, as young German art historian, devoted her doctorate thesis—submitted to and accepted by the University of Vienna—to the history of the Rothschild art collection and to the reconstruction of its inventory.
Kunst im Konflikt. Kriegsfolgen und Kooperationsfelder in Europa [Art in Conflict. Results of War and Fields of Cooperation in Europe]. Osteuropa January/February 2006, pp. 5-496. ISSN 0030-6428. €28.00. The German monthly journal Osteuropa published 37 essays on four different subject matters: (1) the destruction, looting and booty of cultural property in World War II; (2) single cases such as the collections of Victor von Klemperer, collectors of Breslau, and the Koenigs family; (3) reports about cultural property issues in Austria, Czech Republic, Finland, Germany, Poland, Russia, Switzerland, and Ukraine; and (4) legal problems (restitution in Germany), institutions (Dutch Restitution Committee, French Musées nationaux recuperation, UNESCO, Koordinierungsstelle Magdeburg, Germany), and people. The book is a treasure of valuable and interesting information.
Kurtz, Michael J. America and the Return of Nazi Contraband. The Recovery of Europe's Cultural Treasures. New York: Cambridge University Press 2006, XI, 278 pp. 15 black and white illustrations. ISBN 10: 0-521-84982-9. $70.00. The author, at present serving as the assistant archivist for Records Services in Washington, DC, is well known because in 1985 he published the book Nazi Contraband: American Policy on the Return of European Cultural Treasures, 1945–1955. In the present publication he tells the story of how the American military government in Germany, spearheaded by a few dozen dedicated monuments, fine arts, and archives officers and enlisted men, coped with restoring Europe's cultural heritage. Caught up in often bitter diplomatic wrangling during and after the war, the American restitution effort struggled to uncover what the Nazis had hidden and to equitably return all that was found. Based on his previous studies the author presents new insights into how the American government and Jewish organizations managed the painful difficult problem of heirless Jewish cultural property during the Cold War and at present.
Lütgenau, Stefan August, Alexander Schröck, and Sonja Niederacher. Zwischen Staat und Wirtschaft. Das Dorotheum im Nationalsozialismus [Between State and Commerce. The Dorotheum in National Socialism]. Wien, München: Oldenbourg 2006, XIV, 495. ISBN 3-486-57954-1. €39.80. The Dorotheum was founded in 1707 as a publicly run pawnshop. In 2001 it was privatized and sold to persons running the Dorotheum, since then as a private auction house. Of the purchase price, $32 million was paid to the General Compensation Fund for Victims of National Socialism (Allgemeiner Entschädigungsfonds für Opfer des Nationalsozialismus). The Historical Commission of the Republic of Austria (Historikerkommission der Republik Österreich), established in 1998 with the mandate to investigate and report on the whole complex of expropriations in Austria during the Nazi era and on restitution and/or compensation after 1945 by the Republic of Austria, asked for a detailed study of the history of the Dorotheum during the Nazi era and during the first postwar years. This volume is the report of this research project. This report does not trace the history of Jewish art collections or single art objects. This has already been done by Sophie Lillie in her great study Was einmal war, published in 2003. The present book deals with the legal status of the Dorotheum, with the personnel policy during the Nazi period (with dismissal of Jews), organizations commissioning the Dorotheum to auction expropriated art objects, activity of the Dorotheum to acquire art objects offered or looted in occupied territories, head of the art history department Hans Herbst, and restitution policy of Austria after 1945. This is a well documented account of one of the important auction houses engaged in trade of looted and expropriated art during the Nazi period in Central Europe.
Mackenzie, Simon R. M. Going, Going, Gone: Regulating the Market in Illicit Antiquities. Leicester: Institute of Art and Law 2005, VIII, 290 pp. ISBN 1-903987-07-5 (softback). £20.00. The author, a professor of criminology at Keele University (Staffordshire, U.K.), examines the problem of the illicit traffic in looted antiquities. His final conclusions are summarized on page 252:
Remove the economic incentive to collect antiquities by ensuring that dealers and collectors in illicit goods are not financially rewarded for their acquisitions.
Address the political issues that allow system actors to discount their behavior with strategies that amount to blaming the victim, such as references to source countries being hoarders, unable to take care of their heritage.
Promote the value of scientific knowledge to dealers and collectors and the potential worth of dealing and collecting in the scientific community, by way of immanent preservation, encouragement of public esteem for antiquities and the knowledge they have given to archaeology, and financial sponsorship of exploration and excavation.
Establish a workable legal structure within which the legitimate market can flourish but the illegitimate market cannot.
A detailed review of the book by Craig Forrest can be found in International Journal of Cultural Property 13 (2006): 371–375.
Magnusson, Magnus. Fakers, Forgers & Phoneys. Famous Scams and Scamps. Edinburgh and London: Mainstream 2006, 414 pp. ISBN 1-84596-190-0. £17.99. The journalist and scholar Magnus Magnusson, living in Scotland, is interested in fakers, forgers and phoneys in art (e.g., Tom Keating, Han van Meegeren); archaeology (e.g., the Piltdown Man of 1908, the Vinland Map published in 1965); secret lives of impostors and hoaxers (e.g., the Tichborne claimant of the late nineteenth century); and literature (e.g., Thomas Chatterton and James Macpherson). Sixteen stories on such events are vividly told and evaluated.
Mangelsdorf, Frank (ed.). Der gläserne Schatz. Die Bilderbibel der St. Marienkirche in Frankfurt (Oder) [The Glass Treasure. The Picture Bible of St. Mary Church in Frankfurt (Oder)]. Berlin: Das Neue Berlin 2005, 188 pp. Many black and white and colored illustrations. ISBN 3-360-01265-8. €19.90. Medieval St. Mary of Frankfurt (Oder) in Germany was famous for its stained glass windows telling the biblical story in 117 panes. During World War II these windows were deposited and after the war taken by the Russian army to Russia. In 2002 Russia returned the windows to Germany and to the city of Frankfurt (Oder). Six panes were missing. After the windows have been restored in St. Petersburg and in Frankfurt, they have been replaced into St. Mary. The present volume tells this story in detail and reproduces all the windows in different sizes and with informative explanations.
Marquis, Alice Goldfarb. Art Czar. The Rise and Fall of Clement Greenberg. Aldershot/Hampshire 2006, XIII, 322 pp. 16 black and white illustrations. ISBN 0-85331-940-5. £25.00. Clement Greenberg (1909–1994) dominated the American art scene and is still considered one of the most influential American art critics of the twentieth century. He almost single-handedly established Jackson Pollock (1912–1956) and the Abstract Expressionists at the center of art in the West, and set the tone for art criticism for half a century to come. The author, an award-winning journalist, historian and visiting scholar at the University of California at San Diego, has used unpublished material for her biography; and she also recreates the heady art scene in America from the 1940s through the 1980s, detailing how a generation of art critics, with Greenberg at the helm, used personal conviction and innate notions of taste to define the course of modern art.
Mayer-Metzner, Helmut. Rechtsfragen rund ums Museum [Legal Problems of Museums]. Bayreuth: Bezirk Oberfranken 2006, 48 pp. ISBN 3-3-9804971-8-6. €3.00 The author, government official in Bavaria, deals with interesting legal problems of museums. These problems are ranging from art loans and sale of art objects to problems of copyright and acquisitions for the museum collection.
McShane, Thomas, and Dary Matera. Stolen Masterpiece Tracker. The Dangerous Life of the FBI's # 1 Art Sleuth. Fort Lee, New Jersey: Barricade 2006, XVII, 284 pp. 26 black and white illustrations. ISBN 10-1-56980-314-5. $18.21. Legendary Federal Bureau of Investigation undercover agent Thomas McShane (lives, after retirement, on Long Island, New York)—one of the world's foremost authorities on the billion-dollar art theft business—teams with the best-selling author Dary Matera (now living in Arizona) to provide a thrilling ride through the secretive, cloak-and-dagger underworld of stolen art and artifacts. For 25 years, Special Agent McShane masked his colorful alter egos in detailed disguises to chase down $300 million worth of stolen paintings and other valuable artworks including the Tintoretto painting stolen in Dresden and surfacing in New York in 1979 (cp. United States of America v. One Tintoretto Painting, 691 F.2d 603 [2d Cir. 1982]) and the theft committed 1990 at the Boston Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum.
Merryman, John Henry (ed.). Imperialism, Art and Restitution. New York: Cambridge University Press 2006, X, 267 pp. Few black and white illustrations. ISBN 0-521-85929-8. $45.00. The book is about the repatriation, or not, of great works of art and antiquity taken during the Age of Imperialism and held today by European and American museums. The Elgin or Parthenon Marbles are the most significant example, but there are thousands of others. The nations of origin want these cultural treasures returned, whereas museums unsurprisingly prefer to keep them (James Cuno, Talat Halman, Willard L. Boyd). In this volume prominent museum and government officials and leading scholars consider the ultimate disposition of the Elgin, Parthenon Marbles in the British Museum (Willian St. Clair, John Henry Merryman); the bust of Nefertiti in the Ägyptisches Museum in Berlin (Kurt G. Siehr, Stephen K. Urice); and American Indian artifacts and human remains in American museums (Michael F. Brown, Margaret M. Bruchac, David Hurst Thomas).
Moustaira, Elina N.

[Relation of Art and Law]. Athems: Sakkoulas 2006, 93 pp. ISBN960-15-1679-4. €9.00. The author, professor of private international law and comparative law at the University of Athens, Greece, and also specialist in art law, presents a booklet on some philosophical, hermeneutical, and aesthetic relations between art (including music) and law.
Odendahl, Kerstin (ed.). Kulturgüterrecht [Law on Cultural Property]. Baden-Baden: Nomos 2006, XXV, 944 pp. ISBN 3-8329-1723-3. €49.00. This is a collection of legal sources of cultural property law in Germany. It reproduces in German international conventions, instruments of the European Union, federal and state statutes, and certain guidelines and agreements.
O'Keefe, Roger. The Protection of Cultural Property in Armed Conflict. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 2006, XIX, 404 pp. ISBN-13. 978-0-521-86797-9. $100.00.This is a doctorate thesis submitted in 1999 at the University of Cambridge and updated as of February 1, 2006. The author is now university lecturer at the University of Cambridge, deputy director of the Lauterpacht Centre for International Law, and teaching international law and international criminal law. The thesis starts with a review of the history of the problem of cultural property in times of armed conflict from the Renaissance period to the Hague Rules 1899 to 1907 and from 1914 to 1954. He then analyzes carefully the 1954 Hague Convention of May 14, 1954, for the Protection of Cultural Property in the Event of Armed Conflict and the 1954 and 1999 Protocols. Interesting is that the author in his analysis discusses many cases of destruction and dispersion of cultural objects in recent times. For example, he correctly points out that the destruction of the Buddhas of Bamiyan in 2001 by the Taliban was no act of an occupying power and not related to an armed conflict and would not have been governed by the convention had Afghanistan been a party to it. The author also deals with the UNESCO's role in efforts to save cultural property, especially monuments in time of armed conflict and with the recent experiences in the Iraq and former Yugoslavia. After having explained the Second Hague Protocol of 1999 at great length, the author finally turns to other relevant bodies of law consisting of treaties (e.g., World Heritage Convention of 1972), customary international law (e.g., prohibition on plunder), and the UNESCO Declaration of 2003 concerning the International Destruction of Cultural Heritage.
Olsburgh, Carolyn. Authenticity in the Art Market. A Comparative Study of Swiss, French and English Contract Law. Leicester: Institute of ART and Law 2005, XIII, 100 pp. ISBN 1-903987-17-2 (softback). £18.00. Work is a revised version of a thesis submitted as part of the degree of master of Laws at the University of Cambridge. Authenticity of works of art is becoming ever more important in practice: Increased interest in art, in particular as an investment, results in soaring prices; and the collector's desire to own a genuine work is paramount. However, the courts in England, France, and Switzerland studied here take different paths to resolve disputes as to authenticity between buyers and sellers. If the buyer's belief that the work is authentic is legitimate, Switzerland and France would tend to favor the buyer and England the seller (in the absence of fraud). It is suggested works of art should be treated differently from other commodities, special information duties should eliminate the disparity between levels of knowledge and it should be made clear when a guarantee of authenticity exists and allocate the risk of forgery. A remedy should be given to the disappointed buyer, the contract be set aside, and damages awarded in cases of fraud. Limitation periods (a short one starting to run from the date of discovery of doubts) and a longer absolute limitation period should take account of the special situations of art trade.
Pallanti, Giuseppe. Mona Lisa Revealed. The True Identity of Leonardo's Model. Milano: Skira 2006, 119 pp. 8 illustrations. ISBN 88-7624-659-2. $17.95. For centuries, as the Florentine art historian Giorgio Vasari (1511–1574) claimed in his “Vite,” the Mona Lisa was considered the portrait of Lisa Gherardini, since 1495 the wife of Francesco del Giocondo (1465–1538). The accounts and documents referred to in the present book by the author (a Florentine scholar) clarify the question, as a result of which it is difficult not to side with Vasari's supporters that the lady was actually Mona Lisa Gherardini, The book is in two parts. The first tells the political and cultural history of Florence, the second is a small fresco of life in the city, in which the lives of Lisa Gherardini and Francesco del Giocondo cross with those of other famous Florentines.
Pascoe, Judith. The Hummingbird Cabinet. A Rare and Curious History of Romantic Collections. Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press 2006, XIII, 223 pp. ISBN 978-0-8014-4362-6. $35.00. The author, associate professor of English at the University of Iowa, describes the activity, during the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, of collecting birds, books, Napoleonic relics, botanical specimens, Egyptiana, and fossils. The author maintains that romanticism as a literary movement played a crucial supporting role in varied attempts by collectors of this era to fashion identities for themselves through collecting. She links the collecting craze during the period with the subsequent fetishization of romantic poets and their possessions, revealing the extent to which an ongoing fascination with material objects—with Keats' hair and Shelley's guitar, for example—helped to produce an enduring image of these poets as spiritual emissaries of a less materialistic age. Pascoe makes the case that the romantic period stands out as a distinct moment in collecting history, a transition between the flourishing of the Renaissance wonder cabinet and the rise of the Victorian museum.
Pawlowsky, Verena, and Harald Wendelin (eds.). Enteignete Kunst. Raub und Rückgabe. Österreich von 1938 bis heute [Confiscated Art. Looting and Return, Austria from 1938 until Today]. Wien: Mandelbaum 2006, 282 pp. ISBN 3-85476-185-6. $17.80. In 1938 Hitler joined Austria to Germany; and the Nazis expropriated Jewish citizens of Austria, expelled them, and sent many of them to death camps. After World War II Austria felt to have been the first victim of Hitler and reluctantly started to return confiscated property, especially cultural property. Some objects, although protected under the Austrian prohibition to export cultural treasures, could be exported if other objects were dedicated by the former owners to the Republic of Austria. In 1998 the Austrian parliament passed the Kunstrückgabegesetz (statute on the return of cultural property), which changed this former policy and obliged all state museums to engage in provenance research and to return confiscated art objects to their former owners or their heirs. Fifteen essays collected in the book edited by two historians deal with several aspects of the Austrian postwar history of restitution. Objects of visual art are discussed as well as music and rights of composers and publishers, books, and their transfer to state libraries. The history of specific art objects are traced such as of the Klimt painting Amalie Zuckerkandl formerly owned by the family Bloch-Bauer, of the Munch painting Sommernacht am Strand owned by Alma Mahler-Werfel (restituted November 2006), and of a Thora cover of a Jewish Viennese family. This book is another valuable addition to publications describing the late Austrian efforts to come to terms with Austria's sad part of modern history.
Prisching, Margareth. Gutgläubiger Erwerb an beweglichen Sachen im Rechtsvergleich. Ein Beitrag zur Diskussion um ein europäisches Zivilgesetzbuch [Bona fide Purchase of Movables. A Contribution to the Discussion of a European Civil Code]. Graz: Leykam 2006, 381 pp. ISBN 3-7011-0064-0. €34.90. This is a doctorate thesis submitted to and accepted by the University of Graz (Austria) Faculty of Law. The author was an assistant to the research project “Transfer of Movables” of the “Study Group on a European Civil Code.” She based her studies on European legal systems with special emphasize on Austrian, Dutch, and German law. She proposes to provide a certain kind of bona fide purchase in a forthcoming European Civil Code especially for entrusted and lost movables. With respect to stolen or looted objects and to objects taken under force and duress, she excludes any bona fide purchase altogether and does not distinguish whether these objects have been sold at auction or in the open market or not. Also, bona fides in the authority to sell is protected, however, in all cases she denies any bona fides if the purchaser acted negligently at the time of purchase. Therefore, even minor negligence excludes bona fides. On the whole she strengthens the position of the original owner and reduces bona fide purchase considerably.
Prott, Lyndel V. (ed). Finishing the Interrupted Voyage: Papers of the UNESCO Asia-Pacific Workshop on the 2001 Convention on the Protection of the Underwater Cultural Heritage. Leicester: Institute of Art and Law 2006, XXVI, 168 pp. 9 colored illustrations. ISBN 1-903987-11-3 (paperback). £18.00. The UNESCO Convention of November 2, 2001, on the Protection of the Underwater Cultural Heritage is about to enter into force. As of July 31, 2007, 15 states have ratified the convention and five additional ratifications are needed for the entry into force of the convention. From November 18 to 20, 2003, 82 experts in maritime archaeology, underwater exploration, and the relevant national and international legislation met in Hong Kong, special administrative region Macau, to exchange views on the 2001 UNESCO Convention.
Rabinow, Rebecca A. Cézanne to Picasso. Ambroise Vollard, Patron of the Avant-Garde. New York, New Haven, and London: Metropolitan Museum of Art/Yale University Press 2006, XIV, 450 pp. 299 and 202 illustrations. ISBN 0-300-11779-5. €64.00. Ambroise Vollard (1866–1939) was the most influential art dealer in Paris at the turn of the twentieth century. His activities as promoter of artists, author, and publisher of many of the landmark prints and illustrated books of his epoch earn him a singular place in the history of art. Vollard's groundbreaking 1895 exhibition of the works of Paul Cézanne (1839–1906) established the artist's reputation and proclaimed the 29-year-old Vollard a major new presence in the Paris art world. Throughout the remainder of the decade Vollard organized significant displays of the Nabis (e.g., Denis, Bonnard, Vuillard, Maillol) and of the works of Paul Gauguin (1848–1903), and Vincent van Gogh (1853–1890). He gave Pablo Picasso (1881–1973) his first Paris exhibition in 1901 and Henri Matisse (1869–1954) his first solo exhibition in 1904, and he commissioned André Derain (1880–1954) to paint his colorful London series of Thames River pictures (1906–1907). At the time of his death in 1939, Vollard was still busy selling art and producing editions of sculpture, prints, and illustrated books. The present volume is the catalog of the exhibition launched by the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York and devoted to Ambroise Vollard, his sales and books with many loans and much information drawn from the voluminous archives of Vollard's papers that were acquired by the Direction des Musées de France and the Musée d'Orsay in 1989.
Raulff, Ulrich (ed.). Vom Künstlerstaat. Ästhetische und politische Utopien [On the State of Artists. Aesthetic and Political Utopias]. München, Wien: Hanser 2006, 187 pp. ISBN-10: 3-446-20723-6. €16.90. This book contains eight essays on certain artists and groups of artists (e.g., pre-Raphaelites) who advocated for state policies and state organization based on aesthetic and artistic ideas. Most of them, fortunately, failed because they would have led politics as well as artistic life into a dictatorship of a self-proclaimed elite of artists and politicians.
Renold, Marc-André, Pierre Gabus, and Jacques de Werra (eds.). Criminalité, blanchiment et nouvelles réglementations en matière de transfert de biens culturels [Criminality, Laundering and New Regulations on the Transfer of Cultural Objects]. Zürich: Schulthess 2006, 197 pp. ISBN 3-7255-5150-2. SFr. 42.00. This volume publishes the eight papers read at the conference of October 8, 2004, in Geneva, organized be the Art-Law Centre of this city. Two papers deal with the new Swiss Statute of 2003 on International Transfer of Cultural Property and the Swiss Regulation of 2005 both implementing the 1970 UNESCO Convention and reproduced in the Annex in their French version. Three papers discuss problems of criminal law, the problem of money laundering, and the international legal assistance in criminal matters. The last two papers deal with the criminal law problems in France and in the United Kingdom.
Reulecke, Anne-Kathrin (ed.). Fälschungen. Zu Autorschaft und Beweis in Wissenschaft und Künsten [Fakes. On Authors and Evidence in Science and Arts]. Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp 2006, 425 pp. Approximately 50 black and white illustrations. ISBN3-518-29381-8. €15.00. Nineteen essays deal with different aspects of fakes in science and humanities. The authors, mostly members of German universities or Max-Planck-Institutes, trace the origin of forgery; discuss the incentives of producing fakes; and present the effects of fake documents, of plagiarism, and fake art objects.
Reuther, Silke. Die Kunstammlung Philipp F. Reemtsma. Herkunft und Geschichte [The Art Collection Philipp F. Reemtsma. Origin and History]. Berlin: Mann 2006, 168 pp. Many color and black and white illustrations. ISBN 3-7861-2534-1. €39.00. Philipp Fürchtegott Reemtsma (1893–1959) was a owner of a big cigarette manufacturing company in Hamburg, Germany. He was also an art collector. After World War II he restituted those objects of his collection which had been looted abroad. In 2002, under the influence of the Washington Principles of 1998, the son of Philipp Reemtsma, Professor Jan Philipp Reemtsma (professor of German literature at the University of Hamburg and director of the Hamburg Institute of Social Research) asked Silke Reuther for provenance research with respect those objects of the Reemtsma Collection which had been acquired during the Nazi period. This book is the documentation of this research. Very few art objects have been found which were acquired under dubious circumstances. The book also reproduces all objects of the collection with information about their provenance and their actual location.
Rosenberg, Pierre. De Raphaël à la Révolution. Les relations artistiques entre la France et l'Italie [From Raphael to the Revolution. The Artistic Relations between France and Italy]. Milano: Skira 2005, 307 pp. 46 color and 136 black and white illustrations. ISBN 88-7624-006-3. €30.00. Pierre Rosenberg (born 1936) was the President-Director of the Musée du Louvre from 1994 to 2001. As a specialist of French and Italian art of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, he organized and co-organized many art exhibitions devoted to Italian art in France. The volume reproduces 26 essays on Italian and French art written for exhibitions in mostly French museums. Most essays are dealing with art history and cultural history of France and Italy. The Napoleonic policy to take Italian art treasures to Paris is only mentioned en passant in the last essay the relations between Tuscany and France during the French revolution (p. 271). Also interesting is the essay on a “fraudulent exportation of Nicolas Poussin's ‘Sacrements’ in the eighteenth century” (pp. 259–263). The paintings were bought by Sir Robert Walpole (1676–1745) but prohibited to be exported by Pope Benedict XIV. They were later copied and substituted against the originals. The originals were finally exported as copies and brought to England in 1786. They are now on the National Gallery of Scotland in Edinburgh. Sir Joshua Reynolds (1723–1792) who had taken part in smuggling the Poussins said in 1786: “The Poussins are a real national object. Rome is now much poorer, as England is richer than it was, by this acquisition.”
Rovira Llorens, Salvador (ed.). La Dama de Elche [The Lady of Elche]. Madrid: Ministerio de Cultura 2006, 109 pp. Many illustrations. $21.50. On August 4, 1897, a bust was excavated in near the Spanish city of Elche, a few miles South-West of Alicante. The bust, later called La Dama de Elche, became one of the national treasures of Spain illustrating bank notes and decorating palaces and rooms. The bust was sold in 1897 to French buyers who exhibited it in the Louvre. In 1941 the Lady of Elche was returned to Spain, exhibited in the Prado, and in 1971 transferred to Madrid's Museo Arqueológico Nacional. The bust is believed to be produced in the fourth century b.c., but some scholars and others date it to the Hellenistic or Roman periods. Some people even qualify it as a fake. The present booklet is a catalog of the Museo Arqueológico Nacional with essays an the history of the discovery, the history of the bust's movement between France and Spain and on the archaeological importance of the Lady of Elche.
Savoy, Bénédicte (ed.). Tempel der Kunst. Die Geburt des öffentlichen Museums in Deutschland 1701–1815 [Temple of Art. The Birth of the Public Museum in Germany 1701–1815]. Mainz: von Zabern 2006, 567 pp. 284 black and white illustrations. ISBN-10: 3-8053-3637-3. €59.90. Thirteen authors present, in a common scheme, the history of 13 museums or collections of princes in Germany and Austria. These are the museums and collections in Braunschweig (including Salzdahlum), Dresden, Düsseldorf, Göttingen, Kassel, Mainz, Mannheim, Munich, Potsdam, and Vienna. Whether all thee collections really qualify as public museums is questionable. Important, however, is the information about the early history of princely collection before the big national or regional museums were founded later.
Schack, Haimo, and Karsten Schmidt (eds.). Rechtsfragen der internationalen Museumspraxis [Legal Problems of International Pratice of Museums]. Köln 2006, VIII, 157 pp. ISBN-13: 978-3-452-26466-4. €48.00. This volume reproduces the 10 papers presented at the Art Law Symposium held in October 2005 at the Hamburg Bucerius Law School. These papers deal with contracts of donations to a museum (Peter Raue), acquisition and sale of art objects by museums (Haimo Schack), transport and insurance of exhibition object (Robert Kirchmaier), intellectual property and museums (Wojciech Kowalski), legal effect of codes of ethics on art and antiquities (Norman Palmer), European promotion policy for museums (Isabel Kühl), international protection of cultural property, preservation and restitution (Mark M. Boguslawskij), federal promotion of art and art museums (Max-Emanuel Geis), state guarantees in Europe and the United States (Andrea F. G. Raschèr), and the affect of the 1970 UNESCO Convention on museums in Germany and Switzerland (Marc Weber). The discussions of these subject matters are summarized in separate reports.
Schultz, Bernd (ed.). James Simon. Philanthrop und Kunstmäzen. Philanthropist and Patron of the Arts [German and English bilingual edition]. München: Prestel 2006, 160 pp. Many colored and black and white illustrations. ISBN 3-7913-3759-9/978-3-7913-3759-3. €49.95. James Simon (1851–1932) was a Jewish successful businessman in Berlin. He was engaged in cotton trade and textile business and at the same time was interested and specialized in art, especially in medieval and renaissance art as well as in archaeology from the Near East and Egypt. He donated his collection of renaissance paintings (1904) and medieval statues (1918) to the Berlin museums. In 1898 he founded the Deutsche Orient-Gesellschaft (German Oriental Society) and since 1911 sponsored the German excavations in Egypt. The German share in the partition of excavated objects (also the head of Nefertiti) belonged to James Simon and also this he donated to the Pergamon and Altes Museum in Berlin. The present volume is dedicated to the memory of James Simon as the most important patron of the Berlin museums. Apart from biographical studies, 10 museums of Berlin deal with their relation to James Simon as interested citizen and generous patron.
Seipel, Wilfried (ed.). Europa ohne grenzen. Beispiele zur entstehung der künstlerischen vielfalt europas. [Europe Without Borders. A sampler of the evolution of artistic diversity in Europe]. Wien: Kunsthistorisches Museum 2006, 136 pp. no ISBN. €20.00. This is a catalog of an exhibition in the Kunsthistorische Museum of Vienna in Spring 2006. The exhibition of 46 art objects of the big museum in Vienna wanted to show that in former times many artists and many collectors acted internationally having their customers and their painters and artisans abroad in other parts of Europe. Insofar already in former times there was a Europe without borders and collections and collecting policies not restricted to local artists and local productions. Artists travelled from one court to another and collectors ordered art objects in Venice, Brussels or other places in Europe.
Settis, Salvatore. Battaglia senza eroi. I beni culturali tra istituzioni e profitto [The Battle without Heros. Cultural Property Between Institutions and Profit]. Milano: Electa 2005, 410 pp. ISBN 88-370-3794-5. €18.00. Settis, director of the Scuola Normale Superiore in Pisa and professor of art history and classical archaeology at the same institution, presents a critical study on the modern Italian (but not only Italian) trend to privatize culture and cultural institutions and to change them into commercial enterprises. Based on intimate experience in the United States (especially with the Getty Foundation) and in Europe, the author points out that American museum and cultural institution are mostly privately run but not as an enterprise. The museums are charitable institutions financed by donations and trust funds with the museums as beneficiaries. Are still tax exempt charitable institutions that expressly decline to run for profit. As so often occurs in Europe where governments pretend to introduce American models, such copies look like a caricature. Where are the private funds, where are the donations of millions of euros, where are the contributions of trustees subsidizing and promoting cultural institutions? They do not exist. Instead of providing sufficient funds for cultural institutions and encouraging donators by liberal tax exemptions, the European institutions are left with insufficient means and are told that they should make money with assets which cannot be disposed of and which need expensive care. We still have to learn a lot. Salvatore Settis may help to do it.
Siegfried, Felix Heinz. Internationaler Kulturgüterschutz in der Schweiz. Das Bundesgesetz über den internationalen Kulturgütertransfer (Kulturgütertransfergesetz, KGTG) [International Protection of Cultural Property, The Federal Act on the International Transfer of Cultural Property (Cultural Property Transfer Act, CPTA)] (Schriftenreihe zum Urheber-und Kunstrecht vol. 4). Frankfurt am Main: Lang 2006, XXIX, 306 pp. ISBN 3-631-55494-X. €56.50. On June 1, 2005, the Swiss Federal Act of June 20, 2003, on the International Transfer of Cultural Property and the Regulation of April 13, 2005, on the International Transfer of Cultural Property entered into force. These pieces of Swiss federal legislation implement the 1970 UNESCO Convention ratified by Switzerland. Siegfried in his doctorate thesis, submitted to and accepted by the University of Zürich Faculty of Law, analyzes the Act of 2003 and the Regulation of 2005 and compares the Swiss situation with the European regime under the national statutes of European Union Member States implementing the 1993 Directive 93/7/EEC on the return of cultural object illegally removed from the territory of a Member State and with the future regime under the 1995 Unidroit Convention on Stolen or Illegally Exported Cultural Objects. All these national and international instruments are reproduced in German in the Annex.
Skripsky, Martin. Die Online-Kunstauktion [The Online Art Auction] (Studien zum Kunstrecht, vol. 18). Zürich: Schulthess 2006, XLIX, 353 pp. ISBN 3-7255-5114-6. SFr. 54.00. This doctorate thesis submitted to and accepted by the University of Zürich Faculty of Law the author deals with online art auctions and the legal aspects of this kind of art trade. After having explained the details of online auction and the participants of it, the author traced the public law implications of online art trade and turns to the more complex problems of private law. Here he discusses the mechanics of contracting via Internet. Also, some special questions of consumer contracts are raised because under Swiss law many contracts of sale of art objects may qualify as consumer contracts and therefore are subject to specific rules protecting the consumer. An analysis of matters of private international (jurisdiction and the law governing) form the last chapters of the thesis the first German written book on the subject matter of online art auctions. There is an English and a German summary at the end of the important volume.
Solé, Robert. Bonaparte à la conquête de l'Egypte [Bonaparte and the Conquest of Egypt]. Paris: Seuil 2006, 366 pp. 16 colored and 19 black and white illustrations. ISBN 2-02-066453-4. €42.80. In 1798, 210 years ago, the French and the British army landed in Egypt and fought for supremacy in that remote region. The author, born in Egypt and by profession journalist of Le Monde and writer of several novels, is not only interested in the military events of the conquest of Egypt. He also describes the scientific staff of the French expedition corps and the scientific interest of Napoleon and that staff to discover again Egyptian culture and history. He also cites the remarkable proclamation of June 22, 1798 (4 messidor an VI) printed on board of Napoleon's ship L'Orient and addressed on June 28, 1798, to his soldiers before disembarking in Alexandria (p. 40 et seq.). Part of it reads: “Le pillage n'enrichit qu'un petit nombre d'hommes; il nous déshonore; il détruit nos ressources, il nous rend ennemis les peuples qu'il est de notre intérêt d'avoir pour amis.” (Looting enriches only a small number of people; it destroys our resources, it is degrading us; it makes the population our enemies whereas it is in our interest to have them as friends.) Napoleon must have learned his lesson in Italy and other countries where looting artworks and taking booty raised considerable public concern.
Spitzer, Gerd (ed). Ferdinand von Rayski in der Dresdner Galerie [Ferdinand von Rayski in the Dresden Gallery]. Dresden: Sandstein 2006, 120 pp. 57 black and white and colored illustrations. ISBN 978-3-937602-86-8. €15.00. Ferdinand von Rayski (1806–1890) was one of the German painters of realism and preimpressionism. He mainly worked in Saxony and was asked for his good portraits. The Dresden Art Gallery New Masters had quite a collection of works of Rayski. Many of them got lost in the destruction of Dresden on February 13 to 14, 1945. During the time of socialism in East Germany private collections were nationalized and 17 works of Rayski were added to the seriously reduced collection of Rayskis in the Dresden Gallery. After the unification of Germany the formerly nationalized art objects were returned to the former owners and until now only 4 of the 17 paintings are exhibited on loan in the Dresden Gallery. Habet suum fatum museum! (Also the museum has its fate!) The present booklet served as a catalog of an exhibition of Rayski's paintings available in Saxony and other collections.
Stehrer, Sabine. Der Goldzug [The Gold Train]. Wien: Czernin 2006, 87 pp. ISBN 3-7076-0064-5. €18.60. In 1944 a train full of gold, diamonds, furs, wedding rings looted by the Nazis in Hungary pulled out of Budapest station and moved North. It arrived in Austria and there it was plundered apparently also by the troops of the Allies. Ronald Zweig in his book “The Gold Train” (cp. International Journal of Cultural Property 12 (2005): 537) describes the events in detail. The present book briefly tells this sad story to inform the public of this almost forgotten tragedy. In April 2006 an American court ruled on the Hungarian Gold Train Case Settlement of September 30, 2005, and the United States denied any wrongdoing but issued a statement acknowledging that the property was “either abandoned, retained, or damaged beyond repair” and agreed to pay $25.5 million into the Settlement Fund.
Strobl, Andreas. Curt Glaser. Kunsthistoriker—Kunstkritiker—Sammler. Eien deutsch-jüdische Biographie [Curt Glaser. Art Historian—Art Critic—Collector. A German-Jewish Biography]. Köln, Weimar, Wien: Böhlau 2006, 441 pp. 15 black and white illustrations. ISBN 3-412-26305-2. €49.90. Curt Glaser (1879–1943), born in Leipzig and passed away in Lake Placid, studied art history in Berlin, Freiburg, and Munich, became an art critic and in 1924 the director of the Berlin Kunstbibliothek (Art Library). He was also an art collector and became a friend of many contemporary artist. This is the first biography of a formerly well-known art critic and art historian in Berlin of the pre-Nazi period. Recently, the Hannover Landesmuseum restituted the painting Römische Campagna of Lovis Corinth (1858–1925) to the heirs of Curt Glaser.
Szilágyi, András (ed). Die Esterházy-Schatzkammer. Kunstwerke aus fünf Jahrhunderten. [The Esterházy-Treasure Cabinet. Art Objects of five Centuries]. Budapest: Kunstgewerbemuseum 2006–2007, 219 pp. Approximately 200 black and white and colored illustrations. ISBN 963-7098-99-2. €30.00. The family Esterházy was one of the most important and influential noble families of Hungary. Apart from its political activity, the family held one of the valuable art collections in the country and supported artists, such as the composer Joseph Haydn (1732–1809). The Esterházy art collection was partially sold in London in 1867 and partially destroyed in Budapest in 1945. Many of the restored pieces of the vast collection were exhibited in the Budapest Museum of Applied Arts. This is the catalog of this exhibition with detailed and scientifically documented essays on the history of the Esterházy family and their collection.
Tamiozzo, Raffaele. Il Codice dei Beni Culturali e del Paesaggio. Decreto legislativo 22 gennaio 2004, n. 42 [The Code of Cultural Objects and the Environment. Lefgislative Decree no. 41 of 22 January 2004]. Milano: Giuffrè 2005, XX, 792 pp. ISBN 88-14-11464-1. €53.00. In 2004 the Italian parliament passed the legislative decree on the new comprehensive Code of Cultural Objects and the Environment covering all aspects of cultural property law including the implementation of European law and the reference to the 1995 UNIDROIT Convention and the 2001 UNESCO Convention on the Protection of the Underwater Cultural Heritage both ratified by Italy. The present volume is an Article by Article commentary of the new Italian Cultural Property Code.
Tijhuis, Antonius Johannes Gerhardus. Transnational Crime and the Interface Between Legal and Illegal Actors. The Case of the Illicit Art and Antiquities Trade. Nijmegen: Wolf 2006, V, 234 pp. ISBN 10: 90-5850-195-7 (softback). €28.30. This is a doctorate thesis (proefschrift) submitted to and accepted by the University of Leiden Faculty of Law (Institute of Crime and Law Enforcement). It is mainly interested in criminological and sociological relations between illegal and legal actors in the field of criminal law in general and especially in art trade. But certain conclusions may be drawn from the research done by the author: Special legislation should be passed to act effectively against the traffic in stolen and smuggled art and antiquities. International instruments dealing with these problems should be ratified and implemented. Statutes of limitations and rules on bona fide purchase should be revised and redrafted to protect owners of art objects. Special law enforcement agencies should be created to improve the law enforcement of national statutes. Stolen art should be registered to prevent the sale of illegally obtained objects, and finally the public awareness should be stimulated that it is illegal to excavate clandestinely antiquities and sell them in the grey or black art market.
Tokeley, Jonathan. Rescuing the Past. The Cultural Heritage Crusade. Charlottesville, Va.: imprint-academic 2006, XII, 374 pp. Many black and white illustrations, ISBN 1-84540-019-4. $49.90. Jonathan Tokeley-Parry was convicted in 1997 of smuggling antiquities and using false documents, sentenced to 6 years in prison (of which he served 3) and supplied Frederick Schultz, the New York art dealer who was convicted to jail because of violation the National Stolen Property Act (United States v. Schultz, 333 F3d 393, 2d Cir. 2003), with smuggled Egyptian antiquities. In his book Tokeley now launches a crusade against the “cultural heritage crusade” and hopes to stir a serious discussion.
Trotta, Gaetano (ed). Codice dei beni culturali e del paesaggio [Code of Cultural Objects and the Environment]. In: Le nuove leggi civili commentate 2005, n. 5/6 and 2006 no. 1. Padova: Cedam 2005–2006, XXX pp. ISSN 0391-3740. €40.00. The Italian journal Le nuove leggi civili commentate (The new civil law statutes commentated) published an article-by-article commentary to the new Italian statutory decree number 42 of January 22, 2004, on code for the protection of cultural property.
Universitätsbibliothek Leipzig (ed.). Codex Sinaiticus. Geschichte und Erschliessung der “Sinai-Bibel” [Codex Sinaiticus. History and Reconstruction of the “Sinai-Bible”]. Leipzig 2006, 48 pp. Several illustrations. ISBN 3-934178-72-3. €7.85. On March 9, 2005, a cooperation treaty was signed in London by representatives of the British Museum, the Cloister St. Catherine of Mount Sinai; the Russian National Library in St. Petersburg; and the University Library of Leipzig, Germany. In a joint effort the University Library of Leipzig agreed to reconstruct all parts of the Codex Sinaiticus (347 pages are in London, 43 pages in Leipzig, 5 pages in St. Petersburg and about 330 pages are missing) and to make the Codex (written in the fourth century a.d.) accessible in facsimile and in an online version. On occasion of this joint effort financed by the German Research Community (Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft), the University Library of Leipzig edited this brochure with a short account of the history and the significance of the Codex Sinaiticus, taken to Europe by Konstantin von Tischendorf (1815–1874), given to the Russian Tsar in 1869 and sold to the British Museum in 1933 for £100,000.
Utimut—Return. The Return of more than 35,000 Cultural Objects to Greenland. Copenhagen: National Museum of Denmark 2004, 48 pp. Many illustrations. ISBN 87-893-8481-4. In 1953 Greenland became an autonomous part of Denmark. since 1979 it has had a separate parliament for matters of local affairs and sends two citizens as members of the Danish parliament in Copenhagen. Since 1814 and before these modern developments, Denmark governed Greenland as a kind of colony. Many objects of Greenland culture were taken to Denmark and exhibited or stored in Danish museums. Since 1979 more than 35,000 cultural objects have been returned to Greenland. The booklet informs about this important fact and tells about the help of UNESCO in realizing this unique transfer of cultural property from a former colonial state to the formerly colonized part of its territory. No NAGPRA (Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act) was necessary to achieve this result in Denmark.
Vecchione, Gennaro, and Massimo Rossi. La tutela del patrimonio archeologico nazionale [The Protection of the National Archaeological Heritage]. Roma: Gangemi 2006, 254 pp. With many illustrations. ISBN88-492-0954-1. €24.00. Gennario Vecchione was a Commander of the Italian Nucleo Speciale Servizi Extratributari della Guardia di Finanza (Special Unit for Non-Financial Services of the Customs Authority) and Massimo Rossi is a Commander of the Italian Gruppo Tutela Patrimonio Archeologico (Group for the Protection of the Archaeological Heritage). They analyze the Codice Urbani (Statutory Decree of January 22, 2004) with respect to archaeological objects and provide useful information to those who have to protect these treasures of the Italian extraordinary museo a cielo aperto (museum of open sky).
Vergine. Lea. Quando i rifiuti diventano arte. TRASH rubbish mongo [When Trash Becomes Art. TRASH, rubbish, mongo]. Milan: Skira 2006, 179 pp. 297 black and white illustrations. ISBN 88-7624-727-0. €15.00. This booklet illustrates those art objects which can hardly be distinguished from trash. The first part reproduces in color or in black and white more than 100 art objects of modern artists with quotation of the artists on their attitude towards modern art and their own work. The second part is historically arranged and show in almost 170 illustrations the developments of trash art.
Vrdoljak, Ana Filipa. International Law, Museums and the Return of Cultural Objects. Cambridge, New York, Melbourne: Cambridge University Press 2006, XXXIX, 342 pp. Several black and white illustrations. ISBN-13 978-0-521-84142-9 (hardback.). £55.00. The author is Marie Curie Fellow at the Law Department of the European University Institute in Florence and senior lecturer at the Faculty of Law of the University of Western Australia in Crawley, Perth. In her book she explores the removal and the return of cultural objects from occupied communities during the last 2 centuries and analyzes the concurrent evolution of international cultural heritage law. The book focuses on the significant influence exerted by British, United States, and Australian governments and museums on international law and museum policy in response to restitution claims. It shows that these claims, far from heralding the long-feared dissolution of museums and their collections, provide museums with a vital, new role in the process of self-determination of Cultural identity.
Walton, Kenneth. Fake, Forgery, Lies & eBAY. London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson 2006. 298 pp. ISBN-10: 0-297-85188-8. £9.99. Walton (born 1967) was a lawyer until he became an art trader on eBay in December 1998. Over time his online sales tactics grew increasingly fraudulent, culminating in the $135,858 sale of a forged painting of Richard Diebenkorn (1922–1993) in May 2000. The story of this infamous auction, first broken by an investigative report published in the New York Times, ultimately resulted in his prosecution by the federal government for placing shill bids. He pleaded guilty and was sentenced to 9 months of probation and forced to pay $75,000 in restitution to victims. In his book Walton takes readers from the innocent beginnings of his online art trading hobby to the felony conviction that would rock the eBay universe where thousands of gullible, optimistic bidders went online in droves, ready to spend millions of dollars cash on unseen paintings they hoped might be by well-known artists. Walton shows how easily big bucks could be swindled from naïve bidders, the wealthy Dutch software tycoon who bought hundreds of thousands of dollars' worth of unvetted art on eBay.
Watson, Peter, and Cecilia Todeschini. The Medici Conspiracy. The Illicit Journey of Looted Antiquities, from Italy's Tomb Raiders to the World's Greatest Museums. New York: Public Affairs 2006, XX, 379 pp. with 25 illustrations. ISBN-10: 1-58648-402-8. $26.95. This book deals with one of the most fascinating affairs concerning the return of illegally exported cultural treasures. Apparently, many American museums and art collections acquired from dubious art dealers, especially from Robert E. Hecht, Jr. (born 1919), and Giacomo Medici (born 1935), antiquities looted in Italy and Greece. Hecht sold the Crater of Euphronios to the Metropolitan Museum in New York for approximately $1 million in 1972, and many antiquities also were bought by other museums and by the J. Paul Getty Foundation. In 2005 Marion True, the former curator of the Antiquities Department of the Getty, was indicted in Rome for having acquired for the Getty several antiquities looted in Italy, especially in Morgantina, Sicily. On February 21, 2006, the Metropolitan Museum returned to Italy several antiquities, among them the Crater of Euphronios, now being “on loan by the Republic of Italy” in the New York museum. Also in 2007, the Getty returned 40 antiquities. Italy threatened to stop all cultural cooperation with museums that do not return illegally exported antiquities to Italy. All this is told in detail and with historical competence by the scholar Peter Watson and the journalist Cecilia Todeschini.
Watson, Peter, and Cecilia Todeschini. Die Medici-Verschwörung. [German translation of The Medici Conspiracy by the same authors, supra] Berlin: Parthas 2006, 300 pp. ISBN 978-3-86601-905-8. €34.00.
Wolff-Thomsen, Ulrike. Die Wachsbüste einer Flora in der Berliner Skulpturensammlung und das System Wilhelm Bode. Leonardo da Vinci oder Richard Cockle Lucas? [The Wax Bust of a Flora in the Berlin Collection of Sculptures and the System of Wilhelm Bode. Leonardo da Vinci or Richard Cockle Lucas?]. Kiel: Ludwig 2006, 279 pp. 82 black and white illustrations. ISBN -10: 3-937719-42-3. €38.90. In July 1909 Wilhelm von Bode (1845–1929), the Director General of the Berlin Museums, purchased from the London art dealer Murray Marks (ca. 1840–1918) the wax bust of Flora, allegedly a work of Leonardo da Vinci (1452–1519) for £8000. Very soon the authenticity of the bust was questioned and a European debate about it filled the pages of the general press and of professional journals. Today it is accepted that the bust is likely the work of an English sculptor and is as such exhibited in the recently opened Bode Museum in Berlin. The book scholarly describes in detail the acquisition of the bust and the fight between Wilhelm von Bode and his opponents charging him with having purchased of a fake for much money.
Wolff-Thomsen, Ulrike. Willy Gretor (1868–1923). Seine Rolle im internationalen Kunstbetrieb und Kunsthandel um 1900 [Willy Gretor (1868–1923). His Position in the International Art Circles and Art Trade Around 1900]. Kiel: Ludwig 2006, 392 pp. 57 black and white illustrations. ISBN 3-937719-33-4. €34.90. Willy Gretor, born as Wilhelm Petersen in Denmark, was an art dealer in Paris and acted as an important agent for the Berlin museums before World War I. This book is a doctoral thesis submitted to and accepted by the University of Kiel, faculty of art history and tells the story of Willy Gretor with an annex of letters written by contemporaries to Willy Gretor.
Woollett, Anne T., and Ariane van Suchtelen, Rubens & Brueghel. A Working Friendship. Zwolle: Waanders 2006, XIV, 274 pp. With many illustrations. ISBN 90-400-8288-X. $65.00. This is a catalog of an exhibition on Los Angeles (The J. Paul Getty Museum) and The Hague (Mauritshuis) devoted to the friendship between Jan Brueghel the Elder (1568–1625) and Peter Paul Rubens (1577–1640) and their frequent collaboration during more than 25 years (ca.1598–1625). A prolific landscape and still-life painter, Brueghel was renowned for his remarkably meticulous and jewel-like works which won him the sobriquet the Velvet Brueghel. Rubens was an ambitious painter of large-scale altarpieces and historic paintings, who was notably successful at capturing emotions and corporeal energy. The uniting of their distinctive styles of brushwork and individual visual modes produced beautiful and richly allusive compositions that are as highly sought after today as they were by the artists' contemporaries.
Wynne, Frank. I was Vermeer. The Legend of the Forger Who Swindled the Nazis. London: Bloomsbury 2006, 277 pp. 25 colored illustrations. ISBN 0-7475-6680-1. £14.99. A journalist tells the story of Han van Meegeren (1889–1947), the Dutch artist who produced many paintings in the style of Jan Vermeer (1632–1675) and sold them as originals of the Dutch master. He also painted Christ with the Woman Taken in Adultery, which was sold for what would now be $14 million to Hermann Göring, the German Nazi. He also fooled the Dutch art historian Abraham Bredius who authenticated van Meegeren's Supper at Emmaus as a masterwork of Vermeer and who caused the Boymans-van Beuningen Museum in Rotterdam to buy the painting what would now be $14 million. Van Meegeren was finally tried in a Dutch court after World War II and passed away a few weeks after he had been sentenced. All this is vividly told based on historical facts.
Ziegler, Susanne. Russische Kapitalverkehrs- und Kulturgüterschutzbestimmungen im deutschen Internationalen Privatrecht [Russian Provisions on Capital Mobility and on Protection of Cultural Property in German Private International Law]. Baden-Baden: Nomos 2006. 340 pp. ISBN 3-8329-2319-5. €64.00. Under European private international law mandatory rules of a foreign country with which the situation has a close connection may be given effect if they are internationally mandatory and their application is reasonable: article 7 (1) of the Rome Convention and article 8 (3) of the forthcoming Rome I Regulation. For capital mobility article VIII section 2 (b) sentence 1 of the Convention on the International Monetary Fund provides for the application of foreign currency exchange control regulations. With respect to cultural property no similar provisions apply in Germany. There is only the general public policy clause for German internationally mandatory rules and, since 2007 and 2008, provisions implementing the 1970 UNESCO Convention. The author in her thesis submitted to and accepted by the University of Konstanz Faculty of Law convincingly argues that Russian provisions on import and export of cultural objects (as well as those of other foreign countries) should be enforced in Germany as rules of public policy of a foreign state protecting national and common interests in the retention of national cultural treasure by their state of origin.
