This is in fact two books, both of them quite good. The first book is that which Ted Anderson has intended to write. It is a wonderfully detailed, anecdotal biography following the life of David Lack from earliest childhood, through education and war service, and finally to an honoured place in British ornithology. Lack, in his rise as a pioneering field ornithologist, had a significant impact on the direction of evolutionary ecology and evolutionary biological science. In this intentional book Anderson has captured a fading and unrepeatable human moment in the voices and reminiscences of people who knew and worked personally with Lack, who died in 1973 from lymphoma. Anderson's access to, and collected memories from, those who knew and worked with Lack constitutes a precious opportunity to personalize an account of the man. Had Anderson done nothing else but collect the oral history and memories he has here, he would have made a fine contribution.
But certainly Anderson has done more than that. He chose for his subtitle ‘Father of Evolutionary Ecology’. This is a big claim which Anderson defends on a number of points: endorsements from prominent colleagues and an appreciation of Lack's fine work itself. The first of these is the authority of no less a figure than Ernst Mayr, who cited Lack's work as foundational to the modern species concept and therefore to the viability of the mid-century Darwinian synthesis. Mayr, of course, played a long-standing role as a titan of evolutionary biological science and the philosophy and history of science. He also had the great good fortune to live much longer (and therefore to write much longer) than many of his interlocutors and opponents. The sheer longevity of Mayr's voice and authority did much to amplify his already monumental contributions and his Crafoord Prize.
Mayr was famously anti-reductionist in his development of evolutionary theory, specifically in his criticisms of statistical genetic models. He was unafraid to sling arrows at the likes of J.B.S. Haldane, Carl Woese and later such popular figures as Richard Dawkins. And his dislike of theories overemphasizing (as he saw it) single specific genes in evolution is key to understanding his cultivation of an anti-reductionist following. Enter David Lack.
Lack was trained and even self-trained as a field ornithologist. He disliked the older dissection-and-classification model of nineteenth-century British ornithology still influential in the early twentieth. Instead he followed the path of Julian Huxley, who had done pioneering field observation work, particularly during a stint at the then Rice Institute in Houston, Texas. This ultimately led to his own influential work stemming from his 1938–1939 field trip to the Galapagos Islands. There he investigated speciation among finches. His earliest publication from that research rejected Darwin's idea that variations among the species had adaptive significance. However, during his military service in the Second World War he had time to develop and revisit his conclusions.
Under the influence of Gause's work on competitive exclusion, Lack reversed his own ideas on species variations. By the 1947 publication of Darwin's Finches Lack was ready to embrace Mayr's argument, fully articulated in 1942, that reproductive isolation was the best definition of species. Lack refined that argument by adding that sustained reproductive isolation must be accompanied by persistent ecological isolation as defined in terms of range, habitat and food niche. Anderson delivers this story clearly and in a manner that will bring in non-academic readers and students as well as experts.
The second book is that which Anderson has not written but which he has clearly shown should be. Over the course of twentieth-century debates in evolutionary theory, there was more than a hint that the divisions on the species question bore philosophical influences as well as those of more purely scientific interpretation. This is a huge topic to introduce in a book review, but Anderson has done us a favour by presenting an unfinished case study in David Lack. Lack not only sided with Mayr in emphasizing the holistic genome-in-organism as the vehicle for evolutionary adaptation; he went further by showing signs of a potential vitalism. In fact, in mid-life Lack embraced a vibrant Anglican Christian faith, which he practised in a traditional manner. The conversion came after completing the research that led to Darwin's Finches, and was sufficiently vigorous that he felt compelled to speak and write publicly on the matter of science and faith in collision. His turn to religion and religious ideas mirrored experiences of people like W.H. Thorpe, Alister Hardy, E.S. Russell and C.H. Waddington. This recurring fascination with the juxtaposition of theology and science in the era of the neo-Darwinian synthesis remains an underexplored area specifically of British science history. Anderson's book is a beacon in this respect.
Overall, this book is readable and will be consistently interesting as history of science, as history of British academic culture and, to a lesser extent, as philosophy of science. Anderson has made a very helpful contribution and has opened a further research agenda for those willing to follow the lead.
