A coalition of Indian groups from eastern North Carolina struck against the colonial settlements south and west of Albemarle early one September morning in 1711, killing some 130 people and kidnapping perhaps twenty-five more. For two years following, Tuscarora and allied warriors kept the settlers on edge with further raids. The fledgling planter elite of North Carolina appealed to their peers in Virginia and South Carolina for military aid, for the Quaker-dominated Assembly would muster neither men nor supplies. South Carolina settlers, delighted at a slave-raiding opportunity, sent Indian armies in 1712 and again in 1713. Meanwhile, Virginia governor Alexander Spotswood negotiated with King Tom Blount to keep northern groups of Tuscarora neutral. John Barnwell, commander of the initial South Carolina campaign, blamed the lack of support from North Carolina for his failure to score a complete victory. A tentative peace treaty was under negotiation, until colonial treachery trapped more Tuscarora into slavery. Anyway, land-hungry planters bent on extending their empire did not want peace. They had instructed Barnwell to “extirpate them according to the laudable custom of South Carolina” (21). So a second, bigger army led by Goose Creek progeny James Moore Jr. came north in early 1713. After some ferocious fighting, Yamasee warriors finally destroyed Fort Neoheroka, burning hundreds alive and enslaving hundreds more. With single-minded focus, planters such as Thomas Pollock seized the neighboring Indian lands, while Moore amassed plenty of North Carolina territory for the Family. King Blount became a figurehead leader of the Carolina Tuscarora, but most survivors gradually made their way north to join their Iroquois brethren, and the smaller groups, such as the Machapunga, Core and Bear River Indians, kept as low a profile as they could.
The significance of The Tuscarora War lies in filling a large gap in the literature of the colonial South and of North Carolina in particular. We have had no full-length narrative for the war, despite how very important a turning point in the region's history it represented, especially when it is seen as being of a piece with the Yamasee War. The story in outline is well known to historians of the colonial South, but La Vere zooms in on the years from 1711 to 1713, detailing the actions and explaining the motivations of each of the players, Indian and settler. La Vere provides a rich and full description of Tuscarora economy, culture, and politics, and even the architecture of Tuscarora forts, presenting the material in a readable style for nonspecialists. He carefully lays out the movements back and forth of Barnwell's forces across the inlets of North Carolina, keeping his reader engrossed as he traces the shifts of momentum between the colonial planters and the Indians. His delineation of Indian history after the fall of Neoheroka is especially welcome.
The new interpretive contribution he makes is found primarily in his argument of the role of the Seneca in the outbreak of hostilities. La Vere argues that Core Tom, a Seneca agent, bullied and cajoled the more reluctant Tuscarora into launching the first attack. Asking us to consider a context of Indian relationships and diplomacy beyond the regional challenges all readers, widening the perspective not merely of this war, but of early southern history generally. Although scant sources render conclusive causality impossible, La Vere's scouring of the archives lends some credence to his assertion of decisive Seneca involvement. Other new contributions include the role as a player of William Brice, a character who corresponds to the mythologized rugged frontiersman of American lore. Brice's slave-trading does nuance the “bootstraps” concept, of course, since some of his prosperity was predicated upon his part in the coerced labor of others.
A natural storyteller, La Vere aims for both an academic and a popular audience. The maps help the reader stay with the movement of forces along the creeks and inlets of North Carolina's coastal region, but La Vere's lively prose is the most important element. Framing his narrative through the biographies of male protagonists, the individuals personalize the era as he explains the origins of the conflict, the strategies of the belligerents, and the outcomes for all the parties. We sense the fragility of the early settlements and gain a better feel for the worldview of the many Native American groups in the area. Although the reader might benefit from a fuller description of how the postbellum order ushered the brutal South Carolina slave society northward, La Vere's work includes more than enough fresh insight to be highly recommended.
