Students and scholars of Bangladesh have been waiting a long time for this book, and the wait has been worth it. The last comprehensive introductory texts on Bangladesh were produced in the 1970s and 1980s,Footnote 1 and none of them can compare with the accessible quality of van Schendel's work. The main body of the text—22 chapters in 269 pages—covers all of Bangladeshi history, from the Mughal period until 2007, and it is explained with rich and interesting detail that has been culled from the author's own in-country experiences, complemented by current scholarship. In addition, there are many aids to help the reader: a timeline, 12 maps, 2 figures, 104 plates, a list of 21 key political figures, a glossary, and 31 human-interest “boxes” interspersed in the text, featuring people, wildlife, art, the Bengali script, bridges, and even sweets.
The book is structured around three types of historical process: 1) The first four chapters cover the forces of nature that have constructed Bangladesh as an active delta, a moving frontier, or an open crossroads –with the resultant flexible urbanization and an inherently unstable and yet creative mix of cultural, political, religious, and linguistic identities. 2) The second eleven chapters survey Bangladesh's colonial encounters, with the Mughals until 1757, the British until 1947, and the West Pakistanis until 1971. Map 10.2 on page 99 shows graphically what an odd division occurred at Partition in 1947, with East Pakistan receiving 64% of the territory and 65% of the population of British Bengal. In addition, 197 enclaves resulted from Radcliffe's line—parts of India nestled in East Pakistan and parts of East Pakistan nestled in India; people living in these enclaves are stateless and unrecognized by either nation, as the box, “Lives in Limbo” poignantly narrates (pp. 97–98). Van Schendel is careful to point out that 1947 is not the seminal year of celebration for Bangladeshis, as it ushered in 24 years of the failed “Pakistan experiment,” but 1971, the year of independence. He gives an excellent overview of the imbalances between the west and east wings of Pakistan between 1947 and 1971; for instance, until 1955 there was not even a direct flight between Islamabad or Karachi and Dhaka [p. 3]) The last seven chapters describe post-independence Bangladesh, from 1971 to the present, and focus on its evolving political system, its transnational linkages, its population and environmental challenges, and the debates in Bangladesh as to what constitutes a true national culture.
Apart from its readable, attractive presentation and wide coverage, there are other commendable features to this book. Van Schendel's idea of introducing a nation like Bangladesh goes beyond a mere recounting of political history. He also attends to economics (livelihoods in different eras of history, aid dependence, the importance of remittances from Bangladeshis working outside the country, and the growth of non-governmental organizations); foreign relations, especially with China, India, Russia, and the United States; the oscillation of military with democratically elected rule; and environmental degradation.
Perhaps van Schendel's greatest interpretive interest in Bangladesh is the question of Bangladeshi identity. What has it been, and what is it becoming? In what he calls the “Bangladesh culture wars,” he juxtaposes the “vernacular cultural model,” in which a mixed Bengali identity, suffused with humanist aspirations and a pride in folk traditions, rural themes, and the poetry of Rabindranath Tagore and Kazi Nazrul Islam, is challenged by a Bangladeshi Muslim identity which aspires to a “creeping Islamization” (p. 207). While van Schendel himself clearly leans toward the flexible resilience of the vernacular model, his portrayals of both are even-handed and fair, and one comes away from A History of Bangladesh with a sense for the great varieties in language use, dress, gender relations, festivals, music, education, and media that are available today in this vibrant, multilayered culture.
The success of this book is proof of what can happen when a scholar who has published multiple monographs on a country—van Schendel has written on Bangladeshi peasantry and labor; trade and espionage under the British; border issues with Burma and India, including the enclaves and the Chittagong Hill Tracts; and the implications of globalization – turns his hand to writing an introductory text. It is a real gift to the field.
