This recording of the complete piano music of Arthur Foote (1853–1937), performed by Kirsten Johnson, is a major contribution in the study not only of the music of the composer, but also of the piano music of the time being performed in the salons of Boston and probably the rest of the United States. It is also of interest to scholars researching the music of the Second New England School, examining the development of piano music in America, or studying the exchange of musical influences between Europe and the United States. The recording also should inspire current pianists to perform this almost forgotten repertoire of important and beautiful music by an eminent American composer.
Boston in the late nineteenth century and early twentieth century was a major cultural and musical center. Besides its rich history in choral and organ music in churches and music instruction in its schools, Boston also had music study in colleges and conservatories. The establishment of a symphony orchestra and professional chamber ensembles, along with an increased interest in the piano, provided many opportunities for performances in concert halls and in more informal settings such as receptions and recitals. Foote was a member of a group of prominent composers—sometimes called the Second New England School, the Boston Group, or the Boston Academics—many of whom held academic positions at Boston's universities or conservatories.Footnote 1 Most of them had also studied in Germany and returned to the United States, where they wrote highly crafted, abstract music in classical styles as well as art songs, character pieces for piano, and other forms from the romantic tradition.
Foote, however, is reputed to be the first American composer to receive his entire musical education in the United States.Footnote 2 Unlike most of the Boston composers of his time, Foote did not study in Germany. Many of his teachers had done so, however, and they gave him a thorough European training. Born in 1853 in Salem, Massachusetts, he began piano lessons at age twelve with a local piano teacher, Fanny Paine, and two years later music theory studies with Albert Emery at the New England Conservatory. He studied composition with John Knowles Paine at Harvard, and after graduation in 1874 took keyboard lessons with Benjamin J. Lang, who encouraged him to embark upon a music career. In 1875 he earned a Master of Arts degree in music, also at Harvard, the first granted by an American university.
Unlike some of his Boston contemporaries, Foote held no long-term academic positions, although he did have private students at the New England Conservatory and spent a year as a visiting professor at the University of California at Berkeley. Thus his professional career without academic patronage contributes to a fuller view of contemporary musical life in Boston while also providing insight into his compositional output. In his twenties, Foote gained an excellent reputation as a concert pianist who gave recitals and played chamber music with such ensembles as the Kneisel Quartet. In 1875, he opened a piano studio, responding to the demand for good piano instructors from both amateurs and professionals. Foote served as organist in various Boston churches from 1876 to 1910, but regarded the organ as second to his work in composition and piano teaching. With this background in keyboard music, it is not surprising that a sizeable portion of his compositional output was for the piano, although he also wrote organ, chamber, orchestral, and vocal music, as well as pedagogical and theory books, all of which are better known today than his piano music. Foote further promoted music making in the United States as one of the founders of the American Guild of Organists and a participant in the Music Teachers National Association.
Most of Foote's eighty-eight piano works are short character pieces, often presented in cycles or suites of three or more miniatures. Other compositions are technical studies written for his students. All are melodic, fluent, and carefully crafted, often in ternary form, and designed for the salons of Boston at that time. They reflect the styles and warmth of the music of Felix Mendelssohn, Robert Schumann, Fryderyk Chopin, and Johannes Brahms. Although Foote is labeled conservative today, in the 1880s when he began composing piano music, these composers were not yet firmly established. Curiously, even though he was aware of the later innovations of Claude Debussy, Igor Stravinsky, Arnold Schoenberg, and others, Foote rarely employed the new harmonic idioms, even those of Richard Wagner, despite having visited Bayreuth on at least three of his eight European trips.Footnote 3
Foote was known in his day as the first native-born classical American composer to achieve international recognition, although there is little in his music that reflects his native land. Foote's inclusion in the inner circle of musicians in England and the Continent when abroad was in part a result of the wide distribution of his music by the Boston publisher Arthur P. Schmidt, who had agreements with his counterparts in England, Germany, and France. As a result, major international artists performed Foote's compositions in addition to his own concertizing in the United States and Europe.
This set of three discs is especially significant because there are practically no recordings of Foote's piano music, although there are some of his chamber and orchestral compositions. The pieces are presented mostly in chronological order, starting in 1880 and ending around 1922. Disc one begins with Trois Morceaux, op. 3 of 1880 (Impromptu, Gavotte, and Mazurka). The first and third show the influence of Chopin, whereas the second shows influence of Brahms. Cinq Pieces, op. 6 (1882) (Prelude, Nocturne, Sarabande, Petite Valse, and Polonaise) mixes forms of the Baroque dance suite with Romantic short pieces reflecting styles of Chopin and Schumann. Foote wrote no sonatas, but his two suites, No. 1 in D Minor, op. 15 and No. 2 in C Minor, op. 30, are similar to sonatas in style, moods, intensity, and form, and they appear to be the most substantial works of his early years.
Disc two opens with Nine Studies for the Piano, op. 27 (n.d.), possibly influenced by Chopin's Etudes in their attempt to make piano technique interesting and musical. Five Bagatelles, op. 34 (1893) are titled Pierrot; Pierette; Without Haste, Without Rest (Etude Mignonne); Idyl; and Valse peu dansante. Five Poems after Omar Khayyam, op. 41 (1898) is perhaps Foote's best-known piano composition, with several recordings and four of the five numbers having been orchestrated. This work is one of Foote's most programmatic and expressive, and it captures several moods of the The Rubáiyát of Omar Khayyám. Johnson gives a moving performance, ranging from the pensive in “Iram Is Indeed Gone” to the dramatic in “They Say the Lion and the Lizard.” Two Pieces for the Piano, op. 42 (n.d.) consists of a lively Scherzino and a beautiful Etude Arabesque, both of which require the technique of a virtuoso and are brilliantly played. The Little Etude in A Minor was published in 1901 with no opus number.
Disc three contains music from the twentieth century and begins with 20 Preludes for the Pianoforte in the Form of Short Technical Studies, op. 52 (1903). They are attractive pieces, much like the Nine Studies for the Piano, op. 27 (n.d.). Serenade, op. 45 (n.d.) consists of five pieces of varying moods, as does the Five Silhouettes, op. 73 (1913); a favorite is No. 3, the Valse Triste. The CD also includes “An Irish Folk Song” (1906), which is reminiscent of Foote's vocal music, Two Compositions for Piano, op. 60, Meditation, op. 61 (1907); Two Pieces, op. 62 (1907); Octave Study in G Minor, Allegro Moderato (1917); and Rondo in G Major (1921). It ends with a cycle entitled From Rest Harrow (A Little Suite for the Pianoforte) (1922) with five pieces reflecting the countryside. Rest Harrow was the name of Foote's country home in South Hampton and Kensington, New Hampshire.
Johnson has done a remarkable job locating all of Foote's piano music in various libraries throughout the United States, most of which has been out of print for decades. Her performance is brilliant, both in piano technique and expression. She has mastered the romantic style of the time and has communicated it to the listener. With her beautiful sound and exquisite phrasing, she has made Foote's piano music come alive. A self-proclaimed “piano explorer,” this internationally acclaimed concert artist has built her reputation on making world premiere recordings of forgotten music of the classical repertoire.Footnote 4 Her other recordings include piano music of Albania and the complete piano music of Heinrich Schulz-Beuthen (1838–1915), Hermann Goetz (1840–1876), and Amy Beach (1867–1944). Johnson recorded Foote's music in May and October 2012 on a Steinway “D” at Wyastone Leys in Monmouth, United Kingdom. Delos Productions, Inc. is noted for its technical excellence and leadership in audiophile quality recordings, and the sound on this CD furthers the company's fine reputation. The comprehensive twelve-page booklet accompanying the CD set presents information about each composition and background on the composer. Its author is Lindsay Koob, General Manager of Delos and a freelance classical musician and journalist. Johnson's recording of Foote's music has created international interest in this American composer, with well-deserved rave reviews on both sides of the Atlantic Ocean. This writer agrees and hopes the recording will help bring Foote's piano music the attention it deserves.
