Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T20:45:04.760Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Transient growth and nonlinear breakdown of wavelet-based resolvent modes in turbulent channel flow

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  30 July 2025

Eric Ballouz*
Affiliation:
Mechanical and Civil Engineering, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91125, USA
Scott T.M. Dawson
Affiliation:
Mechanical, Materials and Aerospace Engineering, Illinois Institute of Technology, Chicago, IL 60616, USA
Hyunji Jane Bae
Affiliation:
Graduate Aerospace Laboratories, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91125, USA
*
Corresponding author: Eric Ballouz, eballouz@stanford.edu

Abstract

In this work, we study the effectiveness of the time-localised principal resolvent forcing mode at actuating the near wall cycle of turbulence. This mode is restricted to a wavelet pulse and computed from a singular value decomposition of the windowed wavelet-based resolvent operator (Ballouz et al. 2024b, J. Fluid Mech. vol. 999, A53) such that it produces the largest amplification via the linearised Navier–Stokes equations. We then inject this time-localised mode into the turbulent minimal flow unit at different intensities, and measure the deviation of the system’s response from the optimal resolvent response mode. Using the most energetic spatial wavenumbers for the minimal flow unit – i.e. constant in the streamwise direction and once-periodic in the spanwise direction – the forcing mode takes the shape of streamwise rolls and produces a response mode in the form of streamwise streaks that transiently grow and decay. Though other works such as Bae et al. (2021 J. Fluid Mech. vol. 914, A3) demonstrate the importance of principal resolvent forcing modes to buffer layer turbulence, none instantaneously track their time-dependent interaction with the turbulence, which is made possible by their formulation in a wavelet basis. For initial times and close to the wall, the turbulent minimal flow unit matches the principal response mode well, but due to nonlinear effects, the response across all forcing intensities decays prematurely with a higher forcing intensity leading to faster energy decay. Nevertheless, the principal resolvent forcing mode does lead to significant energy amplification and is more effective than a randomly generated forcing structure and the second suboptimal resolvent forcing mode at amplifying the near-wall streaks. We compute the nonlinear energy transfer to secondary modes and observe that the breakdown of the actuated mode proceeds similarly across all forcing intensities: in the near-wall region, the induced streak forks into a structure twice-periodic in the spanwise direction; in the outer region, the streak breaks up into a structure that is once-periodic in the streamwise direction. In both regions, spanwise oscillations account for the dominant share of nonlinear energy transfer.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2025. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Daubechies-8 scaling function $\zeta$ in time (a) and frequency (b) domain.

Figure 1

Figure 2.(a) Magnitudes of the (i) wall-normal component of the principal forcing mode and the (ii) streamwise component of the principal response mode. (b) Integrated energy of the principal forcing (red) and response (black) modes. (c) Principal forcing mode shown at peak amplitude ($t u_\tau /\delta \approx 0.40)$. (d) Principal response modes at peak amplitude ($t u_\tau /\delta \approx 2.41)$. In (c) and (d), the contours represent the streamwise magnitude; the arrows, which show the direction of the cross-flow components, are coloured according to their magnitudes $\sqrt {| \phi _{1,2}|^2 + | \phi _{1,3}|^2}$ in (c), or $\sqrt {| \psi _{1,2}|^2 + |\psi _{1,3}|^2}$ in (d).

Figure 2

Figure 3.(a) Average streak energy as a function of time; the cases plotted are $\gamma = 1\, \%$ (black $\circ$), $\gamma = 2\, \%$ (cyan $\bullet$), $\gamma = 5\, \%$ (purple $\times$) and $\gamma = 10\, \%$ (red $*$). (b) Streak energy peaks, (c) peak times and (d) decay times as a function of $\gamma$. The dashed line represents the trends (b) $80.48 |\gamma |^{1.44}$, and (d) $|\gamma |^{-0.65}$.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Effective amplification $\sigma _{\textit{eff}}$ (solid) and $\sigma _1$ (dashed).

Figure 4

Figure 5.Average deviation in the streamwise velocity of the $(0,1)$-Fourier mode, $|\overline {\Delta \hat {u}^{(0,1)}/\kappa }|/u_\tau$, for the (a) $\gamma = 1\, \%$ and (b) $\gamma = 10\, \%$ cases. The contours correspond to $7\, \%$, $15\, \%$, $25\, \%$, $75\, \%$ and $90\, \%$ of the maximum value of $\sigma _1 \boldsymbol{\psi _1}$. The lines represent the forced DNS case (blue), and the resolvent response (red).

Figure 5

Figure 6.Average deviation in the streamwise velocity of the $(0,1)$-Fourier mode at $x_2^+ \approx 16$ (a) and $x_2^+ \approx 39$ (b). The cases plotted are $\gamma = 1\, \%$ (black $\circ$), $\gamma = 2\, \%$ (cyan $\bullet$), $\gamma = 5\, \%$ (purple $\times$), $\gamma = 10\, \%$ (red $*$), and the linear response mode $\sigma _1 \boldsymbol{\psi _1}$ (black, dashed).

Figure 6

Figure 7.Average streak energy for cases forced by $\boldsymbol{\phi _1}$ (red $*$), $\boldsymbol{\phi _3}$ (cyan $\bullet$) and $\boldsymbol{\phi }_{\boldsymbol{rand}}$ (dashed black). The unforced case is shown in black.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Integrated streamwise spectral energy content $\overline {[|\hat {u_1}^{(k_{1},k_{3})}|^2]}/(2 u_\tau ^2)$ for $\gamma = 2\, \%$ (a–c) and $\gamma = 10\, \%$ (d–f). The spectra shown are at times $t = 0$ (a,d), $t = 0.6 \delta /u_\tau$ (b,e) and $t = 1.2 \delta /u_\tau$ (c,f). The energy contained in the $(0,0)$, $(0,1)$ and $(0,-1)$-modes (black) are excluded for clarity.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Streamwise spectral energy content at (a) $x_2^+ \approx 16$ and (b) $x_2^+ \approx 39$ for the $(0,\pm 2)$–Fourier mode (dotted lines) and the $(\pm 1,\pm 1)$–Fourier mode (dashed lines). (c) Energy peak times for the $(0, \pm 1)$-mode (solid) and the smaller scales (dashed) cases. (d) Time scale for the cross-scale energy transport. Colours indicate $\gamma = 2\, \%$ (blue), $\gamma \approx 5\, \%$ (purple) and $\gamma = 10\, \%$ (red). The vertical lines in (a) and (b) represent the local peaks of $|\hat u_1^{(0,1)}|$. The horizontal black lines in (c) and (d) represent $x_2^+ = 15$ and $x_2^+ = 40$, which delineate the buffer layer.

Figure 9

Figure 10.(a) Integrated nonlinear energy transfer from the $(0,1)$-mode to the non-forced modes; (b) integrated nonlinear energy transport from the $(0,1)$-mode normalised by the forcing magnitude $|\kappa |^2$. The cases plotted are $\gamma = 1\, \%$ (black $\circ$), $2\, \%$ (cyan $\bullet$), $5 \, \%$ (purple $\times$) and $10 \, \%$ (red $*$).

Figure 10

Figure 11.Nonlinear energy transfer $\Delta \hat M^{(0, 1)} (s_1, s_3)$ for $\gamma = 2\, \%$ (a–c) and $\gamma = 10\, \%$ (d–f), at $tu_\tau / \delta = 0.35$ (a,d), $0.74$ (b,e), $2$ (c,f).

Figure 11

Figure 12.(a) Integrated nonlinear energy transfer from the $(0,1)$-mode to the $(0, 2)$-mode (${\cdots}$) and the $(1,1)$-mode ($-\,-$); (b) integrated nonlinear energy transfer from the $(0,1)$-mode normalised by the forcing magnitude $|\kappa |^2$. The cases plotted are $2\, \%$ (cyan) and $10 \, \%$ (red).

Figure 12

Figure 13.(a) Total nonlinear energy transfer from the $(0,1)$-mode, i.e. $ \sum _{s_1} \sum _{s_3} \overline {\Delta \hat M^{(0, 1)}(s_1, s_3)} \delta / u_\tau ^3$. The cases plotted are for (a) $\gamma = 2\, \%$ and (b) $\gamma = 10 \, \%$. The black lines are contours of $\overline {|\hat u_1^{(0, 1)}|^2/2}$ and represent $10\, \%, \; 25 \, \%, 50\, \%, 75\, \%$ and $90\, \%$ of the maximum value across $x_2$ and $t$.

Figure 13

Figure 14.(a,b) $\overline {\Delta \hat M^{(0,1)}(0, 2)} \delta / u_\tau ^3$ and (c,d) $\overline {\Delta \hat M^{(0,1)}(1, 1)} \delta / u_\tau ^3$ in the $t-x_2$ plane. The cases plotted are for (a,c) $\gamma = 2\, \%$ and (b,d) $\gamma = 10 \, \%$. The black lines are contours of $\overline {|\hat u_1^{(0, 1)}|^2/2}$ and represent $10\, \%, \; 25 \, \%, 50\, \%, 75\, \%$ and $90\, \%$ of the maximum value across $x_2$ and $t$.

Figure 14

Figure 15.Ensemble-averaged streamwise velocity deviation $\overline {\Delta u_1}$ for (a,c) $\gamma = 2\, \%$ and (b,d) $\gamma = 10 \, \%$. The results are for $x_1 = 0$ and two wall-normal heights: (a,b) $x_2^+ = 16$ and (c,d) $x_2^+ = 75$. Before ensemble averaging, the $(0, 1)$-mode for each ensemble member is multiplied by $\textrm{e}^{-i\angle \kappa }$ to ensure their phase alignment.

Figure 15

Figure 16.Nonlinear energy transfer from the $(0,1)$-mode to unforced modes, broken down by streamwise (blue $-\bullet$), wall-normal (green $-\blacktriangle$) and spanwise (red $-\blacksquare$) contributions. The cases plotted are (a,c) $\gamma = 2\, \%$ and (b,d) $\gamma = 10\, \%$. Panels (a) and (b) represent the contributions to the total nonlinear energy transport from the $(0,1)$-mode, with the black line representing the sum of the contributions; panels (c) and (d) represent the transfer to the $(0, 2)$- and $(1, 1)$-modes, denoted by $(\cdots )$ and ($-\,-$), respectively.

Figure 16

Figure 17.Nonlinear energy transfer from the $(0,1)$-mode split by NLT$_2$ and NLT$_3$ contributions: (a,b) $\overline {\Delta \hat M^{(0,1)}_2} \delta / u_\tau ^3$ and (c,d) $\overline {\Delta \hat M^{(0,1)}_3} \delta / u_\tau ^3$. The cases shown are for (a,c) $\gamma = 2\, \%$ and (b,d) $\gamma = 10 \, \%$. The black lines are contours of $\overline {|\hat u_1^{(0, 1)}|^2/2}$ and represent $10\, \%, \; 25 \, \%, 50\, \%, 75\, \%$ and $90\, \%$ of the maximum value across $x_2$ and $t$.

Figure 17

Figure 18.Quasilinear approximation $\widetilde {M}^{(0,1)}$ for the nonlinear energy transfer from the $(0,1)$-mode, normalised by the forcing magnitude $|\kappa |^2$. Panels (a) and (b) correspond to the transfer to the $(0,2)$-mode, and panels (c) and (d) correspond to the transfer to the $(1,1)$-mode. The cases plotted are for (a,c) $\gamma = 2\, \%$ and (b,d) $\gamma = 10\, \%$. The black lines represent contours of $\hat { M}^{(0,1)}$ and correspond to $10\, \%$, $25\, \%$, $50\, \%$, $75\, \%$ and $90\, \%$ of the minimum (most negative) value (–), or $10\, \%$, $25\, \%$, $50\, \%$, $75\, \%$ and $90\, \%$ of the maximum (most positive) value ($-\,-$).

Figure 18

Figure 19.Nonlinear energy transport from the $(0,1)$-mode to the (a,b) $(0,2)$-mode and the (c,d) $(1,1)$-mode, broken down by streamwise (blue $-\bullet$), wall-normal (green $-\blacktriangle$) and spanwise (red $-\blacksquare$) contributions, and normalised by forcing magnitude. The solid lines correspond to the nonlinear energy transfer in the quasilinear model $[\overline {\widetilde { M}^{(0,1)} / |\kappa |^2}]$, while the dashed or dotted lines correspond to $[\overline {\hat { M}^{(0,1)} / |\kappa |^2}]$, the results from DNS (also shown in figure 16). The cases plotted are (a,c) $\gamma = 2\, \%$ and (b,d) $\gamma = 10\, \%$.

Figure 19

Figure 20.Magnitude of the streamwise component of the principal resolvent response modes for (a) $(k_{1}, k_{3}) = (0, 2)$ and (b) $(k_{1}, k_{3}) = (1, 1)$. The modes are normalised so that their action pseudonorm is unity. The horizontal lines represent the peak location of (a) $\hat M^{(0, 1)}(0, 2)$ and (b) $\hat M^{(0, 1)}(1, 1)$ for $\gamma = 2\, \%$ (blue) and $\gamma = 10\, \%$ (red).