Published originally in French in 2008, the 2011 translation of Film and Attraction: From Kinematography to Cinema, by the noted University of Montreal scholar André Gaudreault, is an important addition to the ongoing debates in film history over the origins of modern cinema. Gaudreault, who, along with scholar Tom Gunning, coined the famous term “Cinema of Attractions” in 1986, wants not only to stir the pot in the argument over origins and influences but to upend the stove as well.
When published in 2008, this book attracted considerable attention, setting off arguments among film scholars. This translation neatly addresses those debates by including, as an appendix, special issues of the film journal 189 from 2009 and 2010 that focused on the book. What's all the fuss about? Gaudreault believes that film historians have too cavalierly incorporated early film as part of the pre-history of cinema. He argues for not simply a revised periodization of cinema history, but a reclassification of how to think about the whole thing. He sees early film as not part of cinema at all—which he characterizes as a cultural category beginning in the early years of the twentieth century—but instead an element of late nineteenth-century popular culture that also included photography, animated lectures, and fairy plays. For example, in discussing Méliès, often thought of as a founding father of cinema and certainly an icon to such filmmakers as Martin Scorcese (Hugo, Scorcese's Academy Award winning 3D epic from 2011 is fundamentally about Méliès), Gaudreault writes:
The arrival of Cinématographe in Méliès's professional life, was, for him, a moment of transition. In my view, however, it was not a real moment of rupture. Méliès's magic “views” were an extension of his stage performances. … This is why, in the end, a film such as Le Royaume de fées (Fairyland, or The Kingdom of the Fairies, 1903) is as much a part of the history of the fairy play as it is the history of cinema (65).
Using the language of those engaged in such creations, Gaudreault refers to this early work as kinematography (hence the title of the book) and urges film historians to begin to take this work seriously on its own terms and not simply as some stuff that preceded and led up to the real show—modern cinema. To that end, this book is both a challenge to current film historiography and a call to further research into the late nineteenth-century “cultural series” that created the conditions and context for kinematography. These cultural series are, for Gaudreault, the heart of a new interpretive paradigm.
In many respects, this is a kind of inside-baseball book for film scholars and not necessarily of essential interest to those studying the period more broadly. As one of the latter types, it struck me that Gaudreault was also having some kind of coded conversation with his film studies companions about the implications of history itself. Or perhaps simply how history has been written within film studies. He muses often on the relationship of past and present in the historian's work and the role of the historian's voice. For example, he asserts, “It is not the past as past that comes to the surface in the historian's work, but rather the present of this past—the present of the historian's discourse on the past” (26). Or, “the historicity of the historian's approach is the primary determinant of writing history” (37). Well, yes. Some version of that was what I was taught in my basic graduate school historiography course at U.C. Berkeley in 1984. I'm pretty sure the word “historicity” wasn't in vogue yet, but I got the point. So, while I don't particularly disagree, I found myself somewhat confused by Gaudreault's proclamatory tone on the topic. Still, those introducing the book and blurbing it seem to feel that books on film historiography as insightful as this one are rare. So perhaps these concepts are news in some quarters.
For those of us more generally interested in film and history, particularly in this era, the call to further research into the vast landscape of visual culture that was available to consumers of late nineteenth-century popular forms is very welcome. How film scholars decide to periodize and classify their findings, I leave to them and look forward to reading the synthesis when they work it out. If this book provides a new impetus to research as well as a spur to disciplinary debate inside film studies, well done. If it offers the possibility of enhanced engagement with other disciplines and fields of study, even better. Although film studies has somewhat stabilized over the past generation in many academic venues, like all humanities disciplines, it too has come under increasing attack for its emphasis on critical theory. All of us who understand that certain other voices of the present are bearing down intently on our capacities to write about the past in our own voice need to press forward in the search for new interpretations. If for no other reason, at this moment in history, the act of demanding a new interpretation instead of settling for received wisdom is itself rapidly becoming an endangered practice.
