Powerfully demonstrating the direct relevance of human rights for the historic tremors of the Arab Spring, this intelligent and well-informed study makes for stimulating reading. It promises to be particularly illuminating for those who have not so far appreciated the degree to which human rights have shaped the political consciousness of people in contemporary Arab societies, as well as in Iran. Of course, the forces engaged in fighting ingrained despotisms have also mobilized around the cause of Islamism, and Chase recognizes the need to compare and differentiate the oppositional Islamist and human rights movements.
Relying on many years of studying human rights activism in the Arab world, Chase deploys his expertise to challenge the stubborn tendency on the part of many scholars to classify human rights as alien, Western creations. His analysis should prove an antidote to persistent stereotypes and clichés of the Arab world as “a region of monolithic identities at odds with notions of human rights and other, pluralistic, democratic ideas” (p. 188). In an account that stresses the importance of grassroots mobilization for human rights, Chase criticizes the common assumption that Arab academics, nongovernmental organization, and local movements and networks demanding human rights should be regarded as belonging to an inauthentic transnational class that is manipulated by the West, decrying this caricature for dismissing the agency of non-Western peoples (p. 100). For example, Chase offers a tough critique of Joseph Massad's insistence (Desiring Arabs [Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2007]) that the struggle for human rights for sexual minorities in the Arab World be viewed as a product of gay missionaries from “a monolithic ‘West’ writ large” (pp. 156–61). Chase's critique should prompt questions about the pattern of attributing the emergence of gay identities and related human rights claims to the imposition of an alien culture.
Focusing on the shifting meanings that human rights take on over time and in various contexts, Chase proposes what he calls an “antifoundational” perspective on human rights, rejecting the view that human rights are a fixed set of rules for authorities to apply from the top down. He proposes that human rights evolve in response to a variety of factors as they play roles in “transnational conversations,” and depend on “dynamic interaction between the global and the local and on political and normative movements that are shifting and pluralistic” (p. 11). Cited in support of this are recent shifts in understandings of human rights at both the national and international levels that are moving in the direction of accommodating protections for people's rights regardless of their sexual orientations (pp. 73–74).
Viewing the current upheavals in the Arab world, Chase offers sobering assessments of where things may be headed. Far from assuming that the popular embrace of human rights and pressures for reform will necessarily dislodge the forces of entrenched despotisms, he points out that contemporary revolutionary movements suffer from a lack of leadership that “complicates attempts to transition their anarchic energy into a consolidated role in their governments” (p. 186). The prospect looms of a backlash and of crackdowns by ruling elites that feel compelled to resort to brutal repression when they realize that they cannot manage the challenge of human rights. Chase warns that the outcome could be fleeting revolutions that will result in “a contained reform,” leaving the structures of the deep state in place (p. 188). Meanwhile, despotisms struggling to survive find it expedient to masquerade as champions of human rights. Chase dissects how Iran's clerical rulers respond to the collapse in legitimacy that their appalling human rights violations have caused. In this predicament, they have resorted to awkward attempts to associate their Islamic theocracy with democracy and freedom—this after crushing the prodemocracy protests that erupted in the wake of the rigged 2009 elections (p. 131). Thus, the same regime that mercilessly repressed the Green Movement feels it necessary to appropriate that movement's prodemocracy language, providing a dramatic illustration of how central human rights discourse has become.
Going beyond the confines of the Middle East, Chase addresses human rights issues that have wider implications. In this relatively short work Chase includes discussions of general topics such as the history of human rights and the problems of enforcing international human rights law. He also offers critical appraisals of U.S. human rights policy. Moreover, he briefly outlines two ideas that one hopes will receive further elaboration in subsequent writing. First, he regards human rights as being divorced from ideology, indeed as “the opposite of an ideology” (p. 189). Second, he considers the “respect, protect, fulfill” categories, which have conventionally been used to assess compliance with economic and social rights, as being equally apposite for assessing civil and political rights (pp. 80–81). One awaits more detailed explications of both positions.
Chase is far from being the only scholar to assert that human rights are severable from any particular ideology, but many would argue that attitudes toward rights are closely tied to ideological stances, citing, for example, how differently countries with contrasting political systems and ideological orientations regard the first and second generations of human rights, the civil and political rights that constrain the state and the economic and social rights that impose affirmative obligations on the state. One would ideally wish for Chase to offer more specific explanations of how these rights can be severed from political ideologies—for example, showing why we should discount examples like the hostility of the arch-capitalist United States to economic and social rights—supposedly embodying socialistic ideas at odds with freedom—as contrasted with the prioritizing of these same rights by many countries with strong socialist heritages.
When Chase wants to carry over the “respect, protect, fulfill” classifications to assessing performance in the area of civil and political rights, like prohibitions of discrimination or torture (p. 80), one craves a more explicit exposition of why he concludes that the analysis will be enhanced by applying these classifications. Chase does show that rigidly distinguishing civil and political rights from economic and social rights can be artificial—offering, for example, a provocative discussion of how the two seem blurred in the case of Kurdish rights and concluding that “the political, economic, and social are conceptually indistinguishable” (p. 81). Nonetheless, one might still maintain that, when deciding if a state is complying with a negative right such as the prohibition of torture, one does not have to enter into the calibrations that are involved in measuring the steps that a state is taking to comply with positive rights. It is more complicated to ascertain when a state is meeting obligations to provide adequate food, clothing, and housing or the highest attainable standard of physical and mental health. With regard to such categories, local variables such as individual states’ resources and the problems that they face in carrying out their obligations become relevant considerations. Thus, one can hardly ignore the fact that Egypt, Kuwait, and Yemen face dissimilar burdens in fulfilling their obligations in these categories, meaning that reference to the “respect, protect, fulfill” standards can facilitate the analysis. In contrast, these standards would be less obviously helpful when confronting the question as to whether these same states are complying with their unqualified obligation to end torture.
All in all, Chase has produced a thought-provoking and eminently readable account that illuminates a crucial current development: the salient role that human rights ideas have assumed in the politics of the Middle East and in the transitions that the region is undergoing.
