M. W. Daly has written a comprehensive historical account of the crisis in Darfur that offers a welcome, in-depth analysis of the factors that have resulted in the tragic conflict there. The overarching thesis of Darfur's Sorrow is that the crisis in Darfur is rooted in a long history of both divisive political interventions and marked socioeconomic neglect institutionalized by a chaotic period of Ottoman-Egyptian rule and the codification of “native administration” by the British beginning in 1916, when Darfur was incorporated as part of modern Sudan.
The first part of the book presents a detailed overview of the politics and economy of Darfur under precolonial and colonial rule. In contrast to much writing on the subject, Daly carefully details the political and economic consequences underpinning British rule in Darfur and Sudan more generally. Notably, he explains how British rule not only institutionalized a policy of divide and rule but also “underdeveloped” Darfur with fateful consequences. Underdevelopment was spearheaded by economic policies that undermined the production and export of Darfur's products and was marked by a concerted absence of infrastructural investment in the region. A distinguished scholar of colonial Sudan, Daly is at his best when detailing the legacy of British rule. Colonial authorities, he argues, “institutionalized neglect” in Darfur by focusing exclusively on the twin objectives of pacification and the establishment of a limited and inexpensive administration made possible via the patronage of a small number of “native authorities.” However, as Daly notes so poignantly, the most tragic legacy of this period was the “failure to provide for the future” (p. 133). On the eve of independence in 1956, the chief legacies of colonialism to Darfur were minimal educational opportunities, a stark absence of investment in infrastructure, and an uneven pattern of development between Darfur and other northern regions.
The latter chapters of the book tackle the roots and nature of the recent crisis. Daly locates the roots of the conflict in a combination of political and climatic factors with blame placed squarely at the hands of the “Arabized” elite in Khartoum, who have utilized their privileged access to education, commerce, and political power to sponsor proxy militias against the people of Darfur. Much of the narrative here is well known. Daly's contribution is his focus on the problematic interplay of climatic disaster and local livelihoods, which is often neglected in more popular accounts of the conflict. Of great significance is the way Daly discusses the mass migrations that occurred as a result of the 1980s famine. It is at this historical juncture that we see the first signs of enmities between nomadic and semisedentary tribes in Darfur that, in combination with the influx of arms from Chad and Libya, set the stage for the violent conflict. Rather than focusing exclusively on the recent emergence of the Janjawid, Daly correctly traces the rise of armed militias to this earlier period wherein self-identified, Arab tribesmen armed themselves against the Fur and other semisedentary communities in a struggle over scarce resources. Daly makes a crucially important contribution here by pointing out the microfoundational antecedents of the conflict, arguing that the crisis was ultimately made possible because mechanisms of settling tribal disputes were in disrepair. Daly correctly observes that the role of blood payment (diya) and other traditional conflict-resolution mechanisms broke down under the burden of external interventions, mass migrations, and livelihoods under stress, resulting in both the timing and severity of the war.
The last two chapters present a succinct review of the Islamist-backed regime's policies in the 1990s that ultimately led to the Darfur crisis in 2003. Of great interest here is Daly's discussion of the regime's internal divisions, which saw Omar al-Beshir oust Hassan al-Turabi from power in a move that ultimately helped to usher in the North–South peace process but left the people of Darfur vulnerable to Khartoum's brutal reprisals. Daly argues that the age-old struggle for land and other scarce resources in Darfur was increasingly endowed with “a new ethnic and even racial element” (p. 244). This common theme of an unproblematized Arab supremacist ideology underpinning the conflict is less persuasive than Daly's discussion of the key political factors responsible for the grievances behind the Darfur rebellion and Khartoum's response. Of great import here was the Islamist regime's policy of altering borders to make the Fur the minority in each state, its doling out posts to their loyalists in Darfur, and its invocation of land-registration laws that did away with hereditary rights to land. Moreover, by the 1990s, new changes occurred having more to do with political than with ideological objectives. These included an influx of inexpensive modern weaponry and the arming of a small number of pastoralist groups in the region. Daly claims that the rebellion in Darfur was about the “overthrow of Arab supremacist ideology” (p. 308). However, he provides scant evidence of this as a primary causal factor and, given the extent of the divisions among Darfur's rebel factions, it is unlikely that this was ever a unifying cause among the region's rebel leaders. Indeed, Daly does a masterful job of detailing the political policies initiated by a weak central state whose elites are clearly more driven by power considerations than religious or racial zeal.
In the concluding chapter, Daly discusses the array of political factions in Darfur and the obstacles to the implementation of the 2006 Darfur Peace Agreement. These include the lack of political experience among rebel leaders, divisions among the Darfurian factions, and the silence on the part of the wider Muslim and Arab world, which according to Daly served to embolden the Khartoum regime. Daly offers an insightful analysis of the Darfur Peace Agreement in the context of security arrangements, rehabilitation, and political developments; he rightly contends that it was the factionalism among the Darfur rebels, as well as the Khartoum regime's refusal to disarm the Janjawid and their paramilitary militias, that led to the breakdown of the peace talks.
Darfur's Sorrow is deeply engaging, well researched, and highly poignant. Daly mostly utilizes colonial archives and English-language resources, which provide a rich historical account of Darfur but little that allows for an agency-driven analysis of the crisis. There is not much in the way of interviews of Darfurians or of the key political actors involved in the conflict. The book's major themes of economic and political neglect, climatic change, and regional interventions offer an important explanation of the roots of the conflict. What is missing is a closer examination of the disparate grievances and objectives of the various rebel factions, the competing motivations among the elites in Khartoum regarding Darfur policy, and the external obstacles behind successful humanitarian intervention and implementation of the peace agreement. There is little question, however, that students and scholars alike will find Daly's account of Darfur extremely insightful, especially in light of recent literature on the region that has obscured the social and political complexity of its history.
