On the cover of the book, though not on the title-page itself, is found an additional description of the work. The author admits to have adopted what he calls a post-conservative evangelical approach to the subject. This is a newly minted phrase which refers to a certain style of conservative-evangelical theology which, while not anti-conservative, is critical of the status quo in some way or other and is issuing challenges to it. For example, an open theist or a religious inclusivist, if considered evangelical either by themselves or by others, could be thought of as being post-conservative.
Since post-conservative is an umbrella term for various approaches of this type and not just one, to what nuance of it is Franke committed? A clue emerges as soon as we notice that Franke had been working with Stanley J. Grenz, who until his tragic death himself was committed to doing theology within postmodern culture. Concerning Franke we may say that he finds himself situated in a cultural ethos characterised by a critique of the modern project and (in particular) of its quest for certain, objective and universal knowledge. At the same time, we are reassured that they do not wish to do away with rationality but only to question some of the assumptions that govern our understanding of reason nowadays. In his survey of the theological landscape in chapter 1, he most helpfully brings to our attention a parallel movement in contemporary theology which is called post-liberalism which also does theology in the postmodern situation. He sees a new alliance forming between post-conservatives and post-liberals which holds out great promise. George Lindbeck has even voiced the suggestion that perhaps the post-conservative evangelicals (like Franke) will carry the ball, belonging as they do to the expansive and vital coalition known as evangelicalism.
Chapter 2 presents the trinitarian subject matter of this theology. In a sense this is not really the place for this material, since it precedes the discussion of method instead of following it. One can see this in the book that Franke wrote together with Grenz, entitled Beyond Foundationalism, where the trinitarian subject matter is discussed after consideration of such matters as the sources of theology. An explanation for this might be that books of prolegomena are famously dull, a trait that might be avoided by offering a stirring preview of where he plans to take us theologically using this method. It is also food for the soul and a foretaste of what is to come, for which evangelical readers (and not only them) are hungering.
Chapters 3–5, on the nature, task and purpose of theology, form the substance of the book and a very fine treatment it is too. The nature of theology (he tells us) is contextual, second-order and ongoing. The truth being pressed is that all human thinking is embedded in social conditions and as a result theology is inescapably contextual. As the old saying goes, ‘no one comes from nowhere – everybody comes from somewhere’. Theology is second-order in the sense that it is human reflection and not exactly the divine word itself. It is human reflection on and interpretation of the primary first-order commitments of the Christian faith, and it is ongoing because we are continually being challenged to find better ways of communicating the biblical story in terms that make sense within the culture that we inhabit. In the next chapter, the task of theology is explained as the articulation of models, which are biblically sound, culturally relevant and historically informed. Three sources (we read) have to be taken into account in the work of theology: canonical scriptures, cultural contexts and church traditions. As for the purpose of theology, explained in chapter 5, it is missional. Theology needs to be faithful to its subject matter by engaging in the life and work of the churches and participating in its vocation. Good theology will be related to life and ethics. It should promote the love of God and nourish human living in the context of the community as well as in society at large.
It is clear from this book that theology, done in the context of postmodernity, has something to offer. It makes us face (for example) the conditional nature of all our knowledge, it brings to light the role that presuppositions play in our thinking, and it exposes different weaknesses of epistemological foundationalism. However, a word of caution is in order. Evangelical theology, done in the context of postmodernity, must not cut itself off from extra-linguistic reality or react too strongly against what reason offers, when modestly deployed and suitably chastened, because it plays an indispensable role in the work of presenting the Christian message as truth for everyone, however inadequately grasped.
