This book examines the linkages between Black men and criminality in New York City between 1890 and 1930. It explores how criminality intersected with masculinity and the poverty and racial injustice that African Americans faced in the American North before, during, and after the Great Migration. Although he explores the stories of famous Black men such as Booker T. Washington and Jack Johnson, Douglas Flowe primarily relies on the historical experiences of largely unknown Black men—and some women—to construct a historical argument that he contends has contemporary relevance. Flowe argues that to understand the connection of crime, poverty, and police violence today, it is crucial to understand “the politics of black criminality, protest, and policing in these early years of the formation of black freedom” (25).
Flowe’s archival research into the records of correctional facilities and parole divisions reconstructs the historical experience of New York. The book’s first chapters examine housing, unemployment, and policing in a city with a rapidly growing African American population. Flowe investigates both integrated and racially exclusive black saloons, the male havens and sites of masculinity that were so fiercely targeted by progressive reformers, and offers a nuanced analysis of the interracial prostitution trade and subsequent anti-prostitution campaigns. In chapter four, Flowe explores the “politics of black intimacy” by examining how black men sought to assert their masculinity by carrying out both crimes of passion and property crime in order to attempt to create or solidify patriarchal households and relationships. Finally, Flowe looks at black criminals who were imprisoned and the bonds they maintained, or failed to maintain, with their families, as well as the difficulties they faced after leaving prison.
Missing from Flowe’s study is any serious analysis of the victims—white or Black—of crime. Flowe states early on that his goal is not to judge crimes; moreover, much of his narrative examines the imagined criminality of African American men. Nevertheless, at the end of his study, Flowe offers a romanticized view of criminality, writing that there is “hope in their defiance, a belief in their ability to wrestle power from the jaws of defeat, in an effort to remain free in the face of condemnation, self-governing, and uncontrollable” (195). While Flowe does reveal criminal motivations as complicated, an analysis of victims and the injustices that they, too, could experience at the hands of criminals would have offered an even more refined view of criminality.
Flowe makes the argument that “extra-legal activities became effective responses to a legal system that double-crossed” black men (193). While he shows that this was true in some cases, his book also reveals starkly negative consequences. For instance, in chapter 5, Flowe examines the major health issues that black men experienced due to the lack of proper health care and the overall poor conditions in prisons (164). He also discusses the problems associated with parole, writing, “In most cases, parole complicated the lives of former convicts and kept them precariously poised for recidivation. Even those who avoided the pitfalls of joblessness sometimes succumbed to the temptations associated with freedom and ended up back in prison” (176). The penalties paid by these men complicate Flowe’s more hopeful conclusions.
Other criticisms are more minor. Elsewhere, the term “New Negro” is typically capitalized. Here, without explanation, it is not. There may be an important historical or ideological reason for not capitalizing the phrase or capturing it in quotation marks, but without explanation, it may mislead naive readers—undergraduates particularly—into normalizing the term.
Such criticisms, however, should not take away from the book’s overall achievement. It is a well-researched study that breaks new ground in exploring Black criminality. Moreover, it contains interesting and engaging stories that further reinforce its larger argument about the intersection of crime, masculinity, and racial injustice in the late nineteenth- and early twentieth-century North. Flowe’s book would offer good reading for graduate courses and stands as a useful work of history for scholars of African American history and the Progressive Era.
