Few people agree about the 1960s. But, then few people agree about any decade. To take just one example, Sharon Monteith (acknowledging, quite rightly, that the 1960s and 1950s overlap) quotes Robert Lowell's famous comment about “the tranquillized Fifties.” She might just as well have quoted Lowell's poetic contemporary, Frank O'Hara, who had a very different take on things. O'Hara once complained that Lowell's “confessional manner” let him “get away with things that are just plain bad” – “but you're supposed to be interested,” he added, “because he's so upset.”Footnote 1 Lowell was certainly upset by what he perceived as the blandness and conformity of the 1950s, a decade in which, as he put it,
O'Hara, however, took a contrary view. At the epicentre of what he saw as new, exciting and often collaborative movements in painting, poetry and other arts like film and music, O'Hara identified the 1950s with the birth of the cool. “Poetry was declining,” O'Hara wrote in one of his poem–painting collaborations with the painter Larry Rivers, “Painting advancing/we were complaining/it was ‘50.’ ”
Monteith doesn't quote O'Hara. And, if this remarkable book has one regrettable omission, it is that it doesn't find room for such surely seminal, countercultural poetic groups of the period as the New York poets (a group of which O'Hara was the honorary, unofficial founder) or the Black Mountain poets (a group that includes Charles Olson, Robert Creeley, Ed Dorn, Robert Duncan and Gary Snyder). What she does find plenty of room for, however, is a fierce interrogation of the whole business of periodization and, in particular, the habit of dividing social and cultural history into segments of ten years. And what she also finds room for is the pursuit of a persuasive and occasionally brilliant case for seeing what we know as the 1960s – a period, as she shows, with loose, permeable and fluctuating borders – as at once seminal, conflicted and multifaceted. We, and especially those of us of a certain age, may believe we know the 1960s – either as a period when it was bliss to be alive or a low, dishonest decade, or perhaps both – but Monteith shows us that we don't, really; she sheds a fresh, bright and original light on what might seem an overly familiar subject.
Monteith does this by offering a variety of lenses through which to perceive the period. There are separate chapters on music and performance, film and television, fiction and poetry, art and photography and (a stroke of inspiration, this) the cultural implications of new social movements and creative dissent. Within each of these chapters, and without attempting to monumentalize or erect a canon, she investigates significant and symptomatic works, and she does so by attending closely both to textual specifics and to the degree to which each work is caught up in a kind of dialogue or debate, implicated in the social ferment and culture wars of the time. The usual suspects are rounded up, ranging from John and Robert Kennedy to Martin Luther King and Malcolm X; Norman Mailer, Gore Vidal and Andy Warhol; Motown and Bob Dylan; Easy Rider, Bonnie and Clyde and In the Heat of the Night. But Monteith manages to say something new and revelatory about nearly all of them: pointing out, for instance, the symbiotic relationship between the movies she analyses and the emergence of a culture of commodification, fashion and celebrity. And she incorporates into her analyses a series of groundbreaking accounts of, for instance, photographers as the “cultural shock troops” of their time (138), the gradual erosion of the barriers between politics and mass culture, and the emergence of new forms of celebrity and authority from chat-show hosts to newsreaders (the CBS newsreader Walter Cronkite, she reminds us, was for a while the most trusted person in America).
This is also a book that negotiates a difficult argumentative terrain by operating above and below the national grid. The notion of the 1960s is interrogated and problematized; so, too, is the idea of a specifically “American” – which is to say, national – culture. Monteith reminds us of the global issues at stake here: Haight-Ashbury and the first Moon landing as international media sites; Kennedy and King as protagonists on a world political stage; movies like Easy Rider and Bonnie and Clyde as sources of fashion, cultural signposts and guides to lifestyles anywhere there happened to be a movie theatre. More interestingly, and persuasively, she makes a case for the regions – the West and, even more, the South – as pivotal. She shows how supposedly local events swiftly assumed national significance, the Civil Rights demonstrations in the South being a particularly powerful but by no means unique instance. “The South,” Monteith argues, “was the primary testing ground for sixties ideology” (2), with radicals, liberals, conservatives and reactionaries initiating conflicts there that were symptomatic of fissures at the heart of American culture, wounds in the national body politic that have still not been healed. Looking to the South and the West in particular, in the making of the 1960s, Monteith offers a crucial corrective to those readings of the period that depend on a kind of mid-Atlantic/East Coast consensus. This is a revolutionary book, in its own way, in keeping with the turbulent, troubled spirit of the period it dissects. It is bound to become the standard reading of a key moment in the national narrative of the United States – a narrative that, as Monteith shows, is made up equally of history and myth.
