In Past Performance: American Theatre and the Historical Imagination, Roger Bechtel's commitment appears to be twofold: to update readers in theatre and performance studies to the theories dealing with our waning sense of history; and to look at how theatre, in this post-Brechtian age, has the potential to reignite our impoverished historical imagination. Drawing in part from Walter Benjamin's “Theses on the Philosophy of History,” Bechtel argues that it is the theatrical image's ephemerality that allows it to seize the past in a flashing counterpoint to the present. The plays chosen by Bechtel as case studies add depth and texture to his concern. The notion of a collective national trauma (Wendy MacLeod's The House of Yes and Oliver Stone's film JFK), the relevance of utopian narratives (Tony Kushner's Angels of America), representations of race and racism (Eugene O'Neill's-The Wooster Group's Emperor Jones), the political role of the intellectual/artist (Heiner Müller/Robert Wilson's Hamletmachine), and the erotics of the racial imaginary (Suzan-Lori Parks's Venus) are contextualized in relation to what Bechtel sees as the main goal of these plays and his own critical interpretation: to intervene against American forgetting and its ensuing historical malaise.
Bechtel remarks that the various critiques of the “postmodern condition” (via Baudrillard and Jameson, predominantly, and generously elaborated in the first chapter) have pointed out the privileging of spatial over the temporal dimensions, but also the centrality of historical imagination and its crisis. Nevertheless, the “spatial turn” in theatre and performance studies criticism has accepted this paradigmatic change uncritically, which has led to the assumption (erroneous, says Bechtel) that “today's audience has the given ‘sense of history’ that would allow it to engage politically with the performance” (52). On the other hand, Bechtel downplays the potential of spatial criticism in the form of a Jamesonian cognitive mapping, for example. Postcolonial, border, and hemispheric studies theories, among others, are therefore bypassed as ways of examining the intersection between theatricality and the production of history effects. Bechtel, though, finds fruitful and provocative lenses in phenomenological and case-specific approaches to Benjaminian and Lacanian theories. While his resistance to seeking a unifying theory could be perceived as a mark of tentativeness on his part, he compensates for this with meticulous articulations of the theories applied in each case.
In Chapter 2, The House of Yes and JFK are analyzed as symptoms of a collective and traumatic engagement with Kennedy. The use of Lacan's Real mixed with trauma theory effectively directs the reader toward the experiential nature of the works' history effect, consisting here in the traumatic repetition of an American loss of a liberal humanist identity. Bechtel convincingly argues that The House of Yes, by focusing more directly on our Kennedy obsession, points to the necessity of working through historical trauma. In Chapter 3, Bechtel takes issue with Savran and others' criticism of Angels in America's politics on the grounds of the play's liberal pluralist agenda, discernible in its dramaturgy. Bechtel's polemic raises the political stakes in criticism, inviting scholars to be more self-conscious about our political or even utopian impulses. Benjamin's model for producing momentary and redemptive fissures in the perceived monolith of history is compared to Kushner's staging of a plurality of identities in conflict but also, at moments, mixed by necessity and commonality. Bechtel is careful not to confound Benjamin's messianic materialism with Kushner's democratizing goals; yet his comparison appears dependent on the assumption that the constellation of American identity politics is the only available site of praxis and progress.
The Wooster Group's production of The Emperor Jones, as shown in Chapter 4, is a feat of self-conscious contextualization in relation to other productions by the Group as well as to the Provincetown Players' 1923 premiere of the same play. Bechtel argues that this production created in the spectator a “retrospective horizon” whose historical force coalesced in the moment of performance. The notion of an experiential thinking about the history of racial representation is exemplified most particularly by the multimedia blackface performed by Kate Valk, because of the “ever-shifting performative realization” (151) of the synchronic presentations. Bechtel seems inspired to contrast the cultural and economic milieus of the Provincetown Players and the Wooster Group, adding to the sense of historicity in our appraisal of these avant-garde troupes.
Chapter 5 contextualizes the allegorical construction of the text of Hamletmachine in relation to Müller's own anxious encounter with an “end of history” in East Germany. Veering away from Artaudian readings of the play, the textual analysis extrapolates on the baroque materiality of the figure of Hamlet as a corpse of history and on its relation to Müller's own crisis as an intellectual of the Left. Bechtel's contextual reading allows him to introduce American treatments of Müller's allegory. He argues that Wilson's production safeguards the power of the play (in a way that Fred Newman's mimetic 1996 production does not) by disassociating his own choreography from the text. He concludes that both productions, though, betray an enduring American anti-intellectualism that threatens our historical imagination.
The figure of chiasmus, “broadly conceived as any rhetorical repetition and reversal” (214), is revealed in the last chapter as a useful tool for understanding Parks's oeuvre. In Venus, a play that recounts the story of an African woman displayed in early nineteenth-century London for her protruding buttocks, a variety of visual chiasmus bring in the spectator as another producer of discourse. The metatheatrical enactment of a comedy, whose normative resolution contrasts with the subversive quality of the erotic union of Venus and the Baron Docteur, for instance, invites other imaginative reversals by the spectators. Bechtel's positing, via Kristeva, of self-conscious (and therefore theatrical and self-critical) love as an antidote to the “the scopic regime [racial or otherwise] of history” (35) is provocative and appealing in its coupling of theory and practice. Here Bechtel also insinuates a spatial perspective that pays attention to distancing and approach to the Other.
Bechtel's theoretical digressions are sometimes distracting, and they seem more to focus on opening the reader's own theoretical availability than to guide him or her through an argument. This impulse is understandable in view of the ambitious project of matching the postmodern challenge to historical temporality with strategic and forceful theoretical perspectives. Much more appreciated are his contextual readings of texts and performances, where theory itself comes alive and throws new light on the plays' performativity. More important, the book successfully presents the challenges and possibilities that both practitioners and scholars face in their will to recuperate an experiential history as well as political self-consciousness.
