It is well known to even the casual observer of contemporary Chinese politics that Beijing has long placed a premium on protecting the national unity and territorial integrity of the People's Republic of China (PRC). It is also common knowledge that accomplishing both tasks has often proved to be quite daunting, especially along China's territorial periphery. However, the dynamics encompassed within these dual missions are still at best poorly understood. Why have some conflicts within China's frontiers proven quite intractable, while others have been mitigated? How assertive has the PRC been in dealing with such spaces, those who reside there, and the states that border them? Is China becoming more or less aggressive in this regard? Yufan Hao and Bill K. P. Chou's China's Policies on Its Borderlands and Their International Implications is intended to provide new answers to such crucial queries.
The book's primary strength lies in its survey of the vast territories that are identified in its introductory chapter as “borderlands.” There are few, if any, current publications that cover so much of this land and water. More specifically, the book contains substantive chapters dealing with Tibet and Xinjiang, the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO), the entire stretch of the PRC's northern border (continental and maritime), Taiwan, Hong Kong, and Macao.
The best contribution to the volume may very well be Colin Mackerras's discussion in chapter 2 of recent protests in both Tibet and Xinjiang, as it takes on content that is both very current and controversial. In addition, Gudrun Wacker's review in chapter 4 of China's relationship with Central Asia illuminates all of the main facets of this dynamic, as does Quansheng Zhao's chapter 7 on the PRC's main northern maritime disputes. On the other hand, in chapter 8 You Ji's survey of Beijing's Taiwan policy is sweeping, but too wide in its scope. Weiqing Song's chapter on the SCO is thin. Moreover, T. J. Cheng's chapter 5, which concentrates primarily on a single city, Hulunbeier, is a bit narrowly construed. Finally, Hong Zhao's chapter 11 on Sino-Myanmar relations is relatively insubstantial and also incongruous with the rest of the volume as it has little to do with frontier-related concerns.
In short, the chapters are not uniformly outstanding, but all are informative, engaging, and thought provoking. Moreover, in composite they provide a very thorough overview of almost all of the main issues at hand. This is no small accomplishment. However, the volume is not an unmitigated success. First, it lacks a clear framework, as it does relatively little with the “borderland” concept in regard to the extant literature on this score (both inside and outside the PRC). Second, the structure of the volume is rather uninspiring. The book could have been oriented around policy arenas relating to minority nationalities, regional autonomy, and territorial issues within bilateral relations. Instead, its main organizing principle appears to be a simple geographic rotation through peripheral spaces. As a result, the book at times has more of the feel of a travel guide than a rigorous study. Finally, the absence of chapters devoted to the Sino-Indian border and the South China Sea is surprising, and unfortunate, as it leaves aside two of China's more prominent borderland concerns.
Such points are raised not to suggest the book is especially weak, but rather to observe that it also does not reach its full potential. Nonetheless, it would be remiss not to add that the exact same difficulties have hampered most previous studies that have taken on similar terrain. Moreover, despite such flaws, the book still pushes the discussion of these contested regions forward, while at the same time revealing just how much more there is to be written about them.
In sum, Hao and Chou's volume is quite strong, and should find a broad readership. Those looking for a balanced, thorough survey of the PRC's territorial periphery are especially likely to find the volume to be of interest. Specialists, on the other hand, may discover that there is not a great deal of new ground broken in its pages.
