My appointment to the Colonial Office, as the very first Minister of State, was a far better reward for me than the honours that had been showered on the Viceroy and many others after Indian independence. I was thankful to Attlee, not only for giving me another post in his Government, though outside the Cabinet, but particularly because it gave me a chance of doing something constructive about my concern for the inhabitants of the many dependencies whose lands we had taken in ‘the scramble for Colonies’ – the words are those of Lord Derby,Footnote 485 Colonial Secretary in 1884.
I had spoken frequently for the Labour Opposition in the past in the House of Lords on the Colonies, and I never lacked an expert brief from the Fabian Colonial Bureau.Footnote 486 The Fabian Society had taken a special interest in the Colonies thanks to the knowledge and enthusiasm of two of its members, Rita Hinden and Marjorie Nicholson.Footnote 487 They not only provided expert advice to members of both Houses of Parliament, but befriended many young colonials, mainly students, while visiting London for the first time. Many of the young men and women they assisted, such as Tom MboyaFootnote 488 from Kenya, Lee Kuan YewFootnote 489 from Singapore and Kwame NkrumahFootnote 490 from Ghana, were to become leaders of the National movements in their own countries. The Fabian Colonial Bureau, which was founded in 1940, did a useful service in making these young people aware that they had many friends in this country who supported their demand for more rapid progress towards independence.
My parliamentary interest in the Colonies had already been noted by the Colonial Office, which asked me to serve in a personal capacity on an Advisory Committee on Social Welfare and Economic Development in the Colonies. I had also become a trustee of a hostel for African students living in London, members of the West African Student Union or WASU.
So I had a limited but useful background of experience, which at any rate demonstrated a keen and abiding interest in the Colonies and their inhabitants, at the time that I took up my new job at the Colonial Office in 1948.
We now had three Ministers at the Colonial Office, the Secretary of State, Mr Creech-Jones [sic],Footnote 491 the Minister of State, myself, and an Under-Secretary, Mr Rees-Williams,Footnote 492 who sat in the House of Commons. His career in that Chamber was cut short by a peerage, and he chose for the title a Welsh place name, that of ‘Ogmore’. This choice of name caused some merriment among our colleagues when, after an eloquent defence of corporal punishment in Hong Kong, a witty member of our own Party rose to suggest that ‘Flogmore’ would have been a more appropriate title for the new Peer.
We three Ministers made a broadly geographical division of our Ministerial responsibilities. The most important area from the standpoint of parliamentary and public interest was undoubtedly the African continent. This went to the Secretary of State, together with his overall supervisory function which meant inevitably that he had to remain in touch with the Cabinet in Whitehall and therefore was unable to travel. The detailed work on economic development and constitutional advance for the African territories went to the Under-Secretary as a member of the House of Commons, and I was put in charge of our lesser known possessions in South-East Asia and the West Indies.
Our then system of administration of the Colonies was to have one lot of officials, the professional members of the Colonial Service, working in the field, and quite another lot, the civil servants in the Colonial Office, issuing instructions to them as directed by the Secretary of State from their offices in Whitehall. This dichotomy was mitigated by the somewhat infrequent meetings in London between Ministers and senior civil servants at home and Colonial Governors and Chief Secretaries from the Colonies. In practice, it gave the Governor of each Colony a pretty free hand. The current system of a single Foreign Service under the Foreign Secretary, with diplomats brought home for a few years at the Office after each period of service in a foreign country, has always seemed to me a far better system.
I should like to start with a brief account of our Colonial Policy when we formed the new Government in 1945. Our policy of de-colonisation was important not only in its effect of radical constitutional change in the Colonies, but because it was continued by our successors, prolonging in this field the bi-partisan policies pursued by the Political Parties during the war. It was dictated by our belief in the inherent right of colonial peoples to independence. Our objective was explained by the Secretary of State in the first White Paper he published in 1945, defining our Colonial Policy as ‘Guidance of the Colonial Territories to self-government within the Commonwealth’. This was echoed twelve years later in a famous speech by Mr MacMillan [sic]Footnote 493 about the ‘winds of change’ which were blowing over the British Empire.Footnote 494
While we shared the broad aims of Colonial policy with the Conservative Party, we differed very sharply about the tempo and the manner in which these aims were to be realised. We hoped to quicken the tempo, and to bring about a genuine partnership between rulers and ruled as they worked together for a common goal. We were determined to stop the traditional subordination of labour to capital in the economic field, as well as to lay foundations of democratic self-government in the field of politics.
The former task often involved greater difficulties and more drastic changes than the latter. It meant that the land, the minerals, and other natural resources of a Colony should not be allowed to become the monopoly of any one company or group of people inside or outside the Colony. Natural resources should be developed for the benefit of the whole community, and wealth should not be taken abroad by absentees, or unfairly divided between the owners of capital and the men and women they employed to produce it. Our policy for controlled economic development – promoting the growth of indigenous agriculture and related industries required for a balanced economy – was in stark contrast to the economic imperialism – imposing one crop economies – of the 19th century. In those days, economic development went forward with little regard for the welfare of the local inhabitants.
The usual practice of 19th century British companies was to go concession hunting in promising areas, imposing often ridiculous bargains on ignorant native societies, in search of the cheap and profitable production of food stuffs, raw materials, and valuable minerals, wanted by the expanding industries of Europe and America. The ruthless individualism of capitalist enterprise had a shattering impact on tribal societies, and the introduction of firearms ensured that what could not be secured by agreement could always be taken by force. During this time wealth was drained from Colonial Territories, and most of the profits of trade and production were enjoyed by alien shareholders, middle-men, and managers of European companies.Footnote 495
In our view the only firm foundation for self-government was a healthy and well-educated people, enjoying a reasonable standard of life, and not prevented by ignorance and poverty from understanding and supporting the development of local and national political institutions. Having such a background, constitutional advance could steadily progress to extension of the suffrage, democratic representation on Legislatures and Legislative Councils, and sharing executive authority with the official members of Governors’ Executive Councils.
It was against this background of economic exploitation and political stagnation, only mitigated by a limited amount of western technology and investment, that our plan for the future of our Colonies had to be measured. We believed that the State should play an important part in assisting economic development in the Colonies. This was an entirely new conception of the function of the home Government. Colonial Governments had hitherto been mainly concerned with security: protection of its territory from without, and preserving law and order within: and raising sufficient revenues to obviate grants from the home Government. We now wanted Colonial Governments to regard social welfare and economic growth as among their direct and most important responsibilities. Education and health which in the 19th century were left mainly to missionaries and philanthropists, economic planning and control, which had been left hitherto to private business interests, should become essential instruments for Colonial Governments to improve the standard of living and general welfare of those for whom they were responsible.
The extent to which both our political and economic programmes for individual Colonies were carried out depended primarily on the Colonial Governors. My experience has been that they were almost always men of outstanding character and ability who had reached their position in the Colonial Service after many years in different parts of the globe, starting as District Officers and graduating by hard work and devotion to the people they served, often in dreadful climatic conditions. This country has been fortunate to find a body of public servants who chose to spend their lives so far from home, and exposed to the risks and hardships of an often unfriendly and dangerous environment.
We were assisted in our aim to prepare the Colonies for self-government, by the fact that the vast majority (96%) of those employed by Colonial Governments were of local origin. We now proposed to train locally born people to qualify for service in every grade of the technical and administrative services and not purely the lower grades. Commonwealth Development and Welfare grants were now being spent on scholarships required for the higher branches of the Colonial Service.
The expatriate element of 4% was recruited and trained in the United Kingdom, returning at regular intervals for refresher courses and to compare notes with colleagues from other parts of the globe. There was a very large increase of numbers in 1946, as recruitment had stopped during the war. Sir Ralph FurseFootnote 496 was our most valuable recruitment adviser as he had an unerring eye for the right man to serve in the Colonies. But we made it clear that, in spite of the prospect of working themselves out of a job on the transfer of power, the security of appointments in the Colonial Service was no less than that of candidates for the Home Civil Service. Our conscience about neglect of the Colonies had been deeply stirred by the report of the Royal Commission on the West Indies (the Moyne Commission) in 1939.Footnote 497 This evidence of neglect made it possible for us to ask the British taxpayer to contribute to Colonial Welfare at a moment when our own country was in grave peril, in the first year of the Second World War.
We decided, in order to secure a minimum standard of welfare in each territory, and to promote maximum development of local resources in land and minerals, together with the transport infrastructure on which this would depend, to seek from Colonial Governments the preparation of Ten Year Plans to cover the whole field in each particular territory. The success of these Plans would of course depend on the money that could be put into them, and local funds would obviously not suffice. It was an Act of Parliament, the Colonial Development and Welfare Act of 1945, which really started the ball rolling. Under this Act the assistance available from the United Kingdom funds was raised to a total of £120,000,000 over a period of ten years. This made it possible to plan long term schemes of public works, social services, and agricultural improvement, and to consider wider schemes for regional development of health and communication services. The impetus given to colonial development after the war can be judged by comparing this figure with the figure of £5,000,000 per annum allocated by the original Colonial Development and Welfare Act of 1940.
These Ten Year Plans were eventually prepared for most of the Colonies. They were drawn up in the territory and had generally been worked out by the local Government in consultation with representatives of the local population. A large proportion of the money that went into each Ten Year Programme was provided out of local revenues and loans. We tried to preserve an element of balance between local funds and external aid, so as to prevent even a suggestion of political pressure from the United Kingdom.
Another step forward was taken by the passage of the Overseas Resources Act in 1947. This Act set up two Development Corporations, a Colonial Development Corporation, to operate in the Colonies, and an Overseas Food Corporation, to function anywhere in the world. The objectives of the Corporations were to bring about a ‘speedier and more widespread development of our territories overseas for the benefit of the Colonial peoples, whose low standard of living can only be raised by greater use of their natural resources’, and also to benefit ‘the inhabitants of this country and other countries which are still suffering from the acute shortage of agricultural produce brought about by the ravages and devastation of the war.’
After the unfortunate appointment of Mr John StracheyFootnote 498 to operate the Overseas Food Corporation, resulting in the total failure and considerable wastage of public money on his scheme for growing groundnuts in East Africa, the Colonial Office wisely decided to put a man with business experience in charge of the Colonial Development Corporation which owed much of its success to the appointment of an astute businessman Mr Garro Jones,Footnote 499 later Lord Trefgarne, to head it, and make a sound choice of schemes with a good chance of ultimate commercial viability.
For the Corporation was obliged by Statute to ‘break even’ in the long run. The money allocated to the Corporation could be spent by Colonial Governments on essential infrastructure, on social services, or on public utilities, according to the requirements of any particular scheme. In carrying out its operations it could act either on its own or in association with a Colonial Government or in partnership with private enterprise. By the end of 1956 it was operating 66 projects, mainly for agriculture and forestry, but including mines and factories. It was intended to operate in an area of marginal profitability, situated between the highly profitable undertakings of private enterprise, and the unremunerative public works provided by Colonial Governments, but partly owing to some initial mistakes, it became later on mainly concerned with advancing loans to successful private companies and territorial Governments.
I will now pass on to particular Colonial Territories with which I had to deal as a Minister, sometimes from Whitehall, sometimes in Parliament, sometimes in a Colonial territory when I was inspecting my areas of responsibility.
Palestine
On April 7th, 1948, I moved the Second Reading of the Palestine Bill in the House of Lords. The object of the Bill was to enable us to terminate our administration of the Mandate on May 15th, and to withdraw all our troops by August 1st. We were asking the League of Nations for a special Session ‘to consider the question of a future Government of Palestine’. We were thus refusing to stay on to enforce the truce between the two communities although we knew that it was most unlikely that any other country would be willing to take over from us. Lord Salisbury, for the Conservative Opposition, concurred in our proposal. The political background of the Bill was our determination not to allow our own troops to continue to be involved in policing the stormy relations between Jews and Arabs. Ernest Bevin had no soft spot for the Arabs, and none for the Jews. I have already explained that Attlee had given him a free hand in foreign policy, and his main concern was to save British lives even if it meant leaving Palestine to its undeclared war. In my view, this hardly reflected the attitude of a Trustee, which had accepted this responsibility from the Trusteeship Council of the League of Nations. We could not even plead that circumstances had changed for the better since our acceptance. However, we were now able to redeem the pledge which we gave in the Balfour Declaration,Footnote 500 and to recognise the new State of Israel,Footnote 501 albeit surrounded by Arab countries.
The Malayan Federation
I was delighted to be advised by Sir Thomas Lloyd, the Permanent Under-Secretary at the Colonial Office,Footnote 502 that I would be more useful to the Colonies by visiting them than by speaking for them in the House of Lords. Accordingly, in the winter of 1948, I was pleased to be asked to visit the Malayan Federation.
My first stop on my journey was Malaya where I attended the opening meeting of the Federal Legislative Council in Kuala Lumpur. The Council represented all the main ethnic communities in the Federation: the Malays, the Chinese, and the Indians; and was appointed by the British High Commission for Malaya,Footnote 503 pending the return to normal conditions after the war which would permit an electoral roll and direct elections. The setting up of a Federal Legislature was the first step towards eventual self-government as agreed by the British with the Sultans of the Malay States.
I delivered a message of goodwill from the Secretary of State, and made the acquaintance of many interesting figures in all the communities. None more informative and personally charming than Dato Onn,Footnote 504 the Prime Minister of Johore, and Leader of the majority Party, United Malays National Organisation. Many years later I heard from someone who had been present on that occasion that I was still remembered in the Federation for my black top hat and tailcoat, an outfit I had borrowed from my youngest brother who had acquired it to attend the Eton and Harrow Cricket Match at Lords. It was the very first time that such an outfit had been seen in Malaya. It appeared that everything else I had said in my numerous speeches had by that time been forgotten.
I had been armed just before I left London by a long letter from Malcolm MacDonald,Footnote 505 who had been Commissioner-General in South East Asia with oversight of the whole British area, written from Ottawa, where he had just arrived as High Commissioner, introducing me to all the leading personalities I would be likely to meet. He had been extremely popular in South East Asia, having the rarest quality in British officials out there, namely ‘the common touch’. It was not forgotten that he had slept with the Dyaks and other tribes in their Long Houses (communal dormitories) in Borneo and Sarawak.Footnote 506
I made a most interesting tour of the Federation: watching the rubber tappers at work in the rubber plantations, calling formally on several of the Sultans in their Istanas, and visiting the old Settlements in Penang and Malacca. The East coast of Malaya, with its magnificent beaches, then unspoilt by hotels or other tourist attractions, was particularly inviting. Sir Edward Gent,Footnote 507 the High Commissioner to Malaya, and Sir Ralph Hone,Footnote 508 with his special knowledge of the whole of the British South East Asia, also explained the intricacies of the political situation.
The Communist rising started in June 1949, the month after my visit had ended. What really astonished and alarmed me was that none of the senior British officials whom I met had the faintest suspicion of any danger from the Communists. Their preparations for an armed rising must have been going on for months, but no inkling of it had reached the British authorities. Their intelligence service must have been totally ineffective to have picked up nothing from the many Malays and Chinese who knew exactly what was going on. Absence of contact between British Colonial Service officials and the local population was unfortunately not uncommon.
The first-hand experience I gathered from this visit was extremely useful when I found myself replying in November to a Motion of Lord MancroftFootnote 509 in the Lords, ‘calling attention to the situation in Malaya’. I explained that the violence in Malaya was a legacy of the war against Japan. The resistance movement against the Japanese was organised by the Malayan Communist Party, and this was led by Chinese Communists. In the interval between the withdrawal of the Japanese from Malaya and the establishment of the British military administration in August 1945, the Malayan Communist Party had assumed control of the country, and hoped to set up an independent Malayan Communist Republic. Terrorist violence did not begin until June 1948, when the Communist Party decided that the patient penetration of the trade unions and propaganda in the villages had failed completely to smooth the constitutional path to power. They had exchanged one foreign master for another, and neither could be removed except by force. The Communist doctrine was that all Bourgeois Governments be removed by force: this was despite the British promise (considered to be bourgeois propaganda) to withdraw in any event. It should also be remembered that when British rule was re-established in Malaya we discriminated seriously against the Chinese. Malays were the only Asians admitted to the senior ranks of the Civil Service. Malay schools were paid for from public funds, but the Chinese had to pay for the education of their own children. The best soil for rice crops was owned by Malays, and made inalienable. Our discrimination resulted from the fear of the Communist Party.
After a couple of nights at Government House in Singapore, well situated outside the city, where Gimson,Footnote 510 the ageing Governor, was about to retire, I flew on to Kuching, for a short visit to Sarawak and North Borneo. I had had some correspondence with Rajah Brooke,Footnote 511 who for many years had treated Sarawak as the family property, and had been bought out after the war by the British Government. He retreated to Singapore during the Japanese occupation of Sarawak, and conceded the territory to us in 1946. But he still considered that he should be consulted about his former domain. We now had a British Governor, Charles Arden-ClarkeFootnote 512 who was already trying to associate representatives of the ethnic communities with his administration. Trade and commerce were in the hands of the urban Chinese, who were the dominating element owing to their wealth, though of course few in number compared with the indigenous Dyaks; but the Governor held a fair balance between town and country.
I had also accepted an invitation from the Sultan of neighbouring Brunei, on the advice of the Colonial Office, as the oil fields of Brunei were the largest in the British Empire and could be damaged by political instability.
The Sultan of Brunei was one of the richest men in the world thanks to his royalties from the sale of oil, and there was obviously some risk from an absolute monarch reputed to have a somewhat unstable character. His instability I found to be due to addiction to alcohol, and though he was well disposed towards the British, and wanted to visit the United Kingdom, he did not appear to take his political responsibilities very seriously. So it was with considerable relief that I passed on to my next port of call. It started from Jesselton,Footnote 513 the capital of British North Borneo, which had been bought from the Chartered Company of British Borneo for £1,400,000 in 1946. There I was warmly greeted by the burly figure of the Governor, Peter Twining (later Lord Twining),Footnote 514 who took me under his wing during my visit. He was a man with an infectious humour and prodigious enthusiasm for the economic development of the area.
The West Indies
I had been instructed by Attlee to report to him personally, not to my Secretary of State, on my visit to South East Asia, and a report was duly drafted and delivered to the Prime Minister. He evidently thought that ministerial visits to the Colonies were a good thing, because in the autumn of 1949 he approved of a similar visit to the Caribbean, again suggested by the Colonial Office.
Attlee told me that he was particularly anxious that I should not miss the Leeward Islands, as he had appointed as Governor there, Oliver Baldwin,Footnote 515 son of the late Prime Minister. Oliver Baldwin had become an undistinguished Labour member of the House of Commons, but Attlee insisted that ‘something must be done for him’ as son of the late Prime Minister and now he wanted to know how he was getting on. I said of course that I would make a point of seeing him when I reached Antigua.
Curiously enough, I had known Oliver much longer than Attlee. As a young man I sometimes went to Hyde Park on Sundays to listen to the orators at Hyde Park Corner. One evening I saw Oliver, whom I had first met at Eton, addressing a small crowd from a soap box. My home in Bryanston Square was quite close, and when he finished I asked him back for dinner. We talked politics afterwards, but his brand of socialism was not mine, and we did not meet again until I stayed with him at Government House in Antigua. He was an excellent host, but when I went around the Island I found to my dismay that he was not on speaking terms with most of the planters despite having become in the meantime Earl Baldwin of Bewdley. I was not surprised, as he was not the sort of person to keep quiet about politics, even in a position of representing the Crown that demanded political neutrality. On my return I duly reported my experience to Attlee, and I think Oliver was recalled very soon afterwards.
I had a pretty extensive programme including visits to the small islands of the Windwards and Leewards, Barbados of course, and the larger islands of Trinidad and Jamaica. After covering the mainland territories of British Guyana and British Honduras, I was due to finish at the British Virgin Islands, hitherto unvisited by any British Minister.
The pattern of these visits was always the same. Usually there was a dinner party at Government House on the night of my arrival, to introduce me to the Chief Justices, the Prime Minister, and other notabilities in the Colony. Then, according to the length of the visit, I would make a complete tour of the Colony by car or plane, being met and shown around by members of the local authorities, and by farmers and businessmen responsible for local agriculture or industrial undertakings. There were frequent short speeches of welcome to which I replied. It was always a fascinating experience, superbly organised by the Governor, and I cannot imagine how anyone could get to know more about the life of a Colony in so short a time.
I can remember a few highlights of my tour of the West Indies.
Barbados
In Barbados, I presided at a meeting of all the Colonial Governors in the West Indies. This was useful, not so much as a formal gathering, but because it enabled Governors, who seldom met because their territories were separated by such enormous distances, to compare notes in a relaxed atmosphere. I believe this was the first meeting of its kind, and I do not know whether it has been repeated.
British Guyana [sic]
The colony I remember best is British Guyana, which seemed at that time to be a land of great promise, if only the Indian minority and the African majority were able to get on better together. Both had able leaders in Mr JaganFootnote 516 and Mr BurnhamFootnote 517 but there was a good deal of fear on both sides and this was not diminished by the rapidly growing Indian population. A good start was being made however by sending the children of both communities to the same schools. The Governor, Sir Charles Woolley,Footnote 518 accompanied me on a fascinating tour by air of the whole Colony.
We landed on airstrips in jungle clearings, and met a number of the indigenous Amerindians in their villages. In one village school I picked up an English textbook, and read the following sentence: ‘The Scottish nobleman strode out from his castle into the snow’. As the village children in the heart of British Guyana had never heard of Scots or noblemen, or set eyes on a castle, or, of course a fall of snow, I suggested that a textbook based on local life in the tropics might be rather more suitable. Few Amerindians had the opportunity of a higher education, but their capacity was shown by the co-pilot of our plane, who belonged to the Arawak tribe of Amerindians.
I was greatly impressed by the magnificent sight of the Kaieteur Falls, which is one of the grandest waterfalls in the world, in the same class as the Victoria Falls on the Zambesi. Perhaps by now it has been harnessed to provide hydro-electric power for the local industries, such as mining and forestry in the interior and sugar and rice along the fertile coastal belt.
At New Amsterdam, I saw a ship with a cargo of cattle which had just come down the trail from the Rupunini River. Having seen them a few days earlier in good shape on the savannahs of the interior, I was shocked by their emaciated condition. It was a relief to hear that the cattle owning companies were planning to send the meat by air to the coast. In the sugar plantations, some planters were starting to move the workers from their old barrack lines into modern housing. I hope that these barrack lines are now a memory of the past.
Jamaica
In Jamaica I was royally entertained at his house in Kingston by the Governor, Sir John HugginsFootnote 519 and his charming wife Molly. I was invited to a meeting of the House of Assembly, where I sat next to the Speaker and gave a short address. I had been greeted on the pier on my arrival by Sir Alexander Bustamente [sic],Footnote 520 the leader of the majority Labour Party. He was a colourful personality, a powerful orator, who was recorded as riding through a village on a Palm Sunday on a donkey, to show his attachment to the bible. His opposite number, Mr Manley,Footnote 521 was a brilliant and distinguished lawyer, who had also been Prime Minister of the country. During my three days at Government House I was taken for an extensive tour of the Island, including the still popular seaside resort at Montego Bay. It was interesting to find a Co-operative Land Settlement – a new type of land tenure – and young light industries, such as a textile factory, saving expensive imports. Jamaica suffered seriously from violent fluctuations in commodity prices, and I assured the sugar producers that we would do our best in the United Kingdom to secure long-term contracts and a reasonable price level for sugar.
British Honduras
My most vivid recollection of British Honduras is the quantity and ferocity of the insect population, and the delightful and entertaining personality of the Governor, Sir Ronald Garvey.Footnote 522 I spent a very pleasant week with him on roads often degenerating into rough tracks that linked the villages of the picturesque and mountainous countryside. Traces of the ancient Mayan civilisation, which of course had been destroyed by the Spaniards, remained sometimes in pretty good condition in ruined shrines and powerful sculpted stone figures, and many place names were reminders of the centuries of Spanish occupation.
It was the only West Indian Colony whose existence was challenged by a foreign neighbour. The presence of British troops was essential to prevent an invasion from Guatemala. The locals were not at all afraid. According to my host, a common saying in the villages was, ‘Let's swot those Gwats’. We offered to submit the legal claim of Guatemala to the International Court of Justice, but this offer was always refused. Apart from an abundance of citrus fruit, there was little scope for agriculture, and less for industry in this poor Colony.
I had a kind letter of regret from Ronald Garvey on my departure in 1950 from the Colonial Office which also showed his robust commonsense. Princess Alice, Countess of Athlone,Footnote 523 was visiting the new University of the West Indies in Jamaica, of which she was Chancellor, and it had been suggested by the Colonial Office that she might spend a few days in British Honduras. He said in his letter:
I have never been more reluctant to make a decision than when I decided that the Princess Alice visit should be cancelled. The trouble was that one ‘boo’ or one bottle thrown from a street corner would have set the world press agog – and that would have done more damage than the visit would have done good.
Starting on my homeward journey, I called at Trinidad, and was given a fleeting glimpse of the scenery and wildlife of the beautiful Island of Tobago. I stopped next at Grenada, provider of nutmeg for the Chicago meat industry, then at St. Lucia still unspoilt by tourism, St. Kitts and Nevis, and finally ended my Island tour at Antigua. There I found that my digestion had collapsed alter the long succession of large typically English dishes at endless Gubernatorial dinners. I therefore cruelly abandoned the British Virgins, who may still be languishing for a handsome young Minister from Whitehall, and, when I was well enough to travel, I set out for home.
I paid an all too brief return visit to the West Indies in 1989, when I was sent by the Lord Chancellor to represent the House of Lords at the celebration by Barbados of the 350th Anniversary of its House of Assembly. It had been an independent member of the Commonwealth since 1966, but remained perhaps the most British of the former British Colonies in that part of the world by its long-standing and much admired system of Parliamentary Government, and its passionate addiction to cricket.
While my memories of my tour of the West Indies were still fresh, I took advantage of the recent Report of the Standing Closer Association Committee on the Federation of the British Caribbean Territories, which had been chaired by my old friend Sir Hubert Rance, to initiate a debate in July 1950 in the House of Lords to ‘call attention to the recommendations in the Report on the future of the British West Indies’. As the idea of the Federation had been mooted as long ago as 1945 by Colonel Oliver Stanley,Footnote 524 when he was Colonial Secretary, it was entirely uncontroversial, and could now be discussed without any Party animus in the light both of this Report and of debates in the West Indian Legislatures.
The argument for a self-governing Federation was economic as well as political. At the moment we were in the anomalous position of having a British Cabinet Minister at one and the same time responsible for helping West Indian producers to get the best possible price for their primary products, namely sugar, and for securing the lowest possible price for the home consumer. The producers should obviously be allowed to negotiate the best price they could get in the world market, preferably through a regional marketing organisation. But this would not be practicable if the larger territories, Jamaica and Trinidad, continued to stand outside a Federation.
I pointed out that they were too poor to run their own show without the grants they were getting from the British Government: ‘None of the West Indian Colonies, save possibly Trinidad, could possibly afford to pay for an independent administration, the wide range of social services and the cost of administering the territory and defence’. Accordingly, they needed to pool their expenditure to survive after political independence. At this point I entered a caveat:
it would be dangerous to rush straight away into political union. The main reason is the unpreparedness of public opinion. In the long run the only solid foundation for a Federal structure would be a general desire among ordinary people in the British Caribbean to live together under the same Government. Few who know the region at all well would maintain that at the present time the general desire among ordinary people for political union is felt by more than a minute fraction of the population. I had the privilege last October to visit all the Islands and the two mainland Territories, and this gave me an opportunity of talking to members of all sections of the population. I confess I returned in grave doubt whether the word ‘Federation’ is in the mind, or even the vocabulary, of the ordinary estate worker, small farmer, or townsman.
I followed this caveat with another: ‘if the leading Territories achieve their own political maturity outside a Federal framework, it would be very difficult for all the Territories to come together’. It will be remembered now that the ill-fated and essentially artificial Federation, after misjudged encouragement from Whitehall, only lasted for four years from 1958. Deserted by Jamaica after a referendum, Trinidad soon followed, and both Colonies became independent members of the Commonwealth. The enormous distances that separated the units had prevented their inhabitants from acquiring the ties of common citizenship or even knowledge of each other. The superiority of Jamaica and Trinidad in wealth to any of their poorer neighbours was another obstacle. The concept of a West Indian Federation as a new Dominion of the Commonwealth, linked with Canada in the western hemisphere, was a concept emanating from Whitehall, but not taking into account local circumstances in the British Caribbean or the prevailing spirit of nationalism among the local inhabitants.
The appointment of Hugh [sic] Rance as Chairman of the Standing Closer Association Committee was followed by the Governorship of Trinidad, which was the last official post before his retirement. When he came home he took a little house near Farnham in Surrey, and settled down to write his memoirs. We met for lunch occasionally, when he came up to London with his charming and indefatigable wife, Noël. But his health had been undermined by life in the tropics. He had picked up amoebic dysentery in Burma, and when he came back he had recurrent heart attacks. He was also in serious financial difficulties because, although he had served under Mountbatten as a Major-General, and was subsequently a Colonial Governor, he found that his retirement pension was awarded to him in the substantive rank of Major in the Army. He also had no private means. As Attlee had assured him that he would not suffer financially if he continued after Burma in the public service, I decided to put his case to the Prime Minister.
I was greatly relieved to be told that Attlee had a fund, placed apparently at the disposal of every Prime Minister by the Treasury, to be used in the public interest entirely at his discretion. He immediately suggested that he would like to draw on this fund to supplement Rance's meagre pension. His health did not improve and I had a letter in February, 1974 saying that he had had another stroke in December, and that he was still seeing his devoted former Private Secretary, Phillip Nash. He was struck down by a final stroke on February 23rd of that year. There was a memorial service at St. James's, Piccadilly, packed by his old friends and colleagues. I had lost the best friend I had made in my travels as a Minister to many parts of the world, and the country had lost a great public servant. He had saved us from a civil war in Burma, and had always placed public service before self advancement. Perhaps the most surprising of the gifts of this professional soldier was a genius for friendship. Wherever he went, in Asia, Europe, or the West Indies, he left countless friends who had benefited from his good advice or simply enjoyed his cheerfulness and good humour. In his last letter he told me that he had spent more time talking than shopping in the local village high street!Footnote 525
My career as a Minister at the Colonial Office ended with the General Election. I was a little nervous, after the Conservative victory in 1950,Footnote 526 that the new Government would not appoint another Minister of State at the Colonial Office. In that case I would have been the first and last Minister of State at the Colonial Office to hold that appointment, and it might have been thought that this was an example of ‘jobs for the boys’, Attlee having had to find me another post after my retirement from the Burma Office, and there being no vacancy at that time in his administration. So I was considerably relieved when almost the last appointment by Mr MacMillan was that of Alan Lennox-BoydFootnote 527 to the Colonial Office in my former capacity. He was subsequently promoted and became one of the most outstanding and successful Secretaries of State in that Department. It was a loss to the nation when he was killed in a road accident.
