Paul Rotha was a Marxist filmmaker at the very heart of the British establishment from the 1930s to the 1950s, almost throughout the period of Stalin's regime. Readers of Gary Werskey's The Visible College (New York, 1978) will recall that Marxism was not uncommon among academic scientists in Britain during this period; it may nevertheless come as a surprise to discover that someone so closely associated with the Ministry of Information and the BBC could be so characterized.
Timothy Boon's analysis of Rotha's oeuvre forms the core of Films of Fact. Boon helps make sense of this apparent conundrum. Rotha's Marxism was of a somewhat untutored and unexamined kind, rather like, say, the Anglicanism of John Lubbock and many of his Victorian peers. Rotha had some idea of dialectic as a cinematographic technique, although, as Boon shows, this was not employed with much rigour. What Rotha did have was a passion for social planning and the role of science in the reconstruction of post-war society, in particular its contributions through nutrition and housing. Rotha's working definition of science was often not the activity that goes on in laboratories but a more pragmatic one, enshrining an optimistic vision not so much of the scientific method as of the scientific mission. His left-leaning sympathies also meant that enhancing the role of scientists in film was a useful way of boosting the Association of Scientific Workers.
Rotha's career faltered around 1947, due in part to financial problems and a reputation as a difficult person to work with. But a second generation went on with scientific filmmaking, and Rotha himself managed briefly to step back into a leading role in the new medium of television during the 1950s. Things were not the same, however. The BBC was at that time engaged in renegotiating both the presentation of science and even the nature of science itself. Rotha's visionary take on science was replaced with a more didactic one, uncomfortably balanced with the producer's concern for the medium: an ‘enrichment of the audience's experience’ (p. 232) that, without too much anachronism, could be translated as ‘entertainment’.
Throughout his history, Boon is sensitive to historiographic issues that have been widely discussed among historians of science, such as the distinction between amateur and professional science. In his first chapter, for instance, he places the earliest, spectacle-orientated natural-historical films in the tradition of lay science explored by Anne Secord. Many of Boon's historiographical reflections echo those familiar from writing on the history of the book: the distinction between the dissemination and construction of knowledge, and also between content and production as frameworks to understand the true meaning of a primary source. Readers familiar with such themes may find themselves a little impatient with these methodological excursions, but they are undoubtedly useful for students.
Films of Fact will prove instructive for twentieth-century historians of all kinds (social, media, scientific) and also for science communication specialists. Its detailed account of the making and content of specific films illuminates many aspects of the context of the day, and even, as Boon briefly explores in his conclusion, poses questions about the nature and role of scientific communication in the present day. The one big disappointment of the book lies beyond the author's control, and that is that one cannot see the films discussed. (There are some remedial possibilities at www.screenonline.org.uk/film/id/1334043/ and www.filmandsound.ac.uk/. Both sites must be accessed via an institutional subscriber.) Boon does his best to make up for this deficit with detailed accounts of scenes and excerpts from scripts, but what I wanted was a DVD that came with the book. Readers in the London area may have caught Boon's exhibition at the Science Museum, which ran until February 2009. But everyone else will have to hope that this thorough and loving book creates a demand for this hitherto overlooked aspect of Britain's scientific and filmic heritage.
