No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 10 June 2004
Downsizing in America is an illuminating and thought-provoking book on an extremely important topic. Since the bubble burst on the 1990s boom, unemployment has once again become a major policy concern. William Baumol, Alan Blinder, and Edward Wolff examine the related phenomenon of downsizing, a term widely used in the media to describe job cuts by firms, and which they define as declining numbers of workers employed per firm. Their goal, as the book's title suggests, is to examine the causes and consequences of downsizing, and to compare the reality with the perception in the mainstream press.
The authors approach their topic systematically, and clearly explain their logic along the way. They posit six hypotheses that might explain downsizing, ranging from the character and pace of technological change, to foreign competition and even the “breakdown of the social contract between labor and capital,” which they call a “soft” hypothesis and “almost sociological” (p. 24).
They discuss the possible explanations within economic theory for downsizing and their relationship to their six hypotheses. They maintain that declining demand for an industry's output might lead firms to cut labor in the short run, but that in the long run average firm size in an industry should be unaffected by the total demand for the industry's product. The primary culprit for long-run trends in average firm size is technology. They note that technological change can either increase or decrease optimal firm size. They offer the hypothesis that the growth of information technology might have caused upsizing in retailing but downsizing in manufacturing. Part of their analysis that is likely to raise many eyebrows is that they do not incorporate any role for imperfect competition in their analysis, adopting as their standard perfectly contestable markets. It would have been very interesting to read their assessment of the relevance of the work on technology and market structure, such as that by John Sutton, when discussing their theories of firm size. Nor do they discuss the potential importance for their question of the large literature on transaction costs and the firm.
Next, the authors present extensive empirical analysis of downsizing using Census of Manufacturing and Department of Commerce Enterprise Statistics for the period 1958–1997. They analyze the evolution of firm size in two-digit SIC code industries. Noting that the manufacturing sector as a whole employs a lower percentage of the workforce than before, they find that labor employed per firm (average firm size) also has been falling within most American manufacturing industries since 1967, and not surprisingly, that downsizing has been most prevalent during recessions. The pattern in retail and service industries, however, is one of upsizing.
Insofar as manufacturing industries, their measures of technological change and technology intensity are associated with smaller average firm size. They also examine investment in information technology, and they find that it does not affect average firm size but is a statistically significant variable explaining the reduced dispersion of firm size in industries. Overall industry employment is strongly positively associated with firm size, confirming the hypothesis that downsizing is at least in part cyclical. In some econometric specifications, unionization is associated with more downsizing, not less, which they interpret as evidence in favor of the hypothesis that there has been a breakdown in the social contract between capital and labor. They find that increased export intensity is also a large and statistically significant factor explaining downsizing, which they attribute to the need to cut costs in order to capture foreign markets. Interestingly, the intensity of competition from imports is often insignificant and has a much smaller coefficient. These provocative results bring a new twist to the debates on globalization.
The regression analysis of service and retail industries is less illuminating, primarily because of the paucity of data, particularly historical data, on those sectors. They are keenly aware of this shortcoming and are forthright and circumspect in their conclusions.
The authors present some of their most fascinating results in the chapter on the consequences of downsizing in manufacturing. Consistent with previous studies, they find that downsizing does not increase productivity. Yet they find it does increase profits, and reduce average employee compensation. That is, “downsizing firms typically increase their profitability by decreasing their unit labor costs” (p. 233).
In sum, the authors find that the primary causes of downsizing are demand fluctuations in the short run, and technological change in the long run. They advocate a “more determined and more effective” government safety net to assist those workers who suffer as a consequence (p. 267).
The book is a major accomplishment. The authors had to address a daunting array of data problems and a disparate, but vast literature. The findings are presented in numerous tables and figures, which are almost all instructive and provocative. The book is highly relevant for many economic and business historians, especially those with a focus on labor markets and business-labor relations.