I believe that the high rank of this article both indicates its importance for a transnational generation of scholars of comparative politics and international relations and reflects the enormous influence of Karl Deutsch's other writings from that time.
Most of the themes of Deutsch's career can be found either here or in his other contemporary article in the Review (Deutsch 1960). The core of that career was his personal experience of destructive nationalism in Central Europe, from which he fled with his family to the United States in 1939. His theory of nationalism (Deutsch 1953) focused on the social mobilization of previously repressed ethnic and social groups and the need for their assimilation into the national culture. This in turn implied government capabilities, institutions able to respond to the demands of the newly mobilized. For Deutsch, a social democrat, big government could be oppressive, but competent and responsive government had the capacity to temper political conflict by satisfying people's needs broadly, across society. It was in maintaining a favorable ratio of capability to demand that peace and representative government might be maintained. This perspective carried over into his work in international relations, on the sources of peaceful amalgamation and integration among countries.1
Deutsch (1960) expresses his interest in the balance of domestic to international transactions, following Deutsch et al. 1957.
Deutsch grew up with the humanistic education of a European intellectual. He wedded it with a scientific capacity derived from his study of mathematics and optics, and then with his determination to measure as many social and political variables as possible. His 1960 article was largely a conceptual inventory and shopping list; this one from 1961 delivered real goods, and it is not surprising that it garnered nearly eight times as many citations. In it he proposed a string of indices of particular aspects of social mobilization, illustrated them with what at the time was a very impressive array of data, and posited an underlying conceptual dimension with which they would be closely correlated. He thrived on data to stimulate, probe, and test his theories. Data were meant “as aids to political judgment, not as substitutes for it” (Deutsch 1960, 40). These two articles gave him the leverage to acquire one of the very first National Science Foundation grants to an international relations scholar, establishing the Yale Political Data Program to gather, publish, and energetically analyze it. In doing so he provoked a generation of scholars to evaluate, use, and vastly supplement anything he alone could do.2
The quintessential Deutschian product was Russett, Deutsch, Lasswell, and Alker (1964), but the project allowed us all to go in very different directions in our work then and after. The Handbook went through two more editions and finally was replaced by Internet sources.
Unlike some of the top 20 articles from his era, the citation count for this article fell off sharply after about 15 years, and then after another five years to an average of only about five citations per year. Because it was fundamentally about a specific kind of data (usually aggregate) and their manipulation, it is not surprising that most people stopped citing it. New and better data became available and widely used. Subsequent statistical techniques developed much more systematic procedures for multivariate analysis and for identifying the kind of underlying dimensions he hoped to find. This article talked about “significant” and “critical” thresholds of development; subsequently the profession learned to think rigorously and routinely about nonlinear relationships. Much of the theory was stated loosely, but key elements of it have been formalized by others. Our contemporary studies of civil conflict measure greed and grievance, deprivation and state capacity, with no apparent need to cite Deutsch—but the concepts and some of the indicators nevertheless emerge from his work.
Just because Deutsch's work made such a deep early impact, its very success contributed to its later obsolescence. This now somewhat quaint article serves still as a prominent artifact of our intellectual history.
Karl Deutsch was Stanfield Professor of International Peace at Harvard University. He joined the Harvard faculty after stints at MIT and Yale. He served as President of the American Political Science Association, of the International Political Science Association, and of the Society for General Systems Research.

Comments
No Comments have been published for this article.