Caesar and Hirtius's Commentaries on the Gallic War lit a torch that burned brightly, illuminating with their first-hand testimony the peoples, politics, and potential of temperate Europe, however selective and partisan and in parts creative they may have been with the truth. This is when northern Gauls, Germans, and Britons came alive in the literary record for the first time. Like any illumination it has drawn toward the flame emperors in search of their heroes, archaeologists in search of an explanation for their site, and hoards in search of a historical context. This collection of papers, stemming from a conference in Oxford in 2017, is not only therefore the story of archaeology's contribution to our understanding of the Gallic War, but also a story of the relationship between archaeology and history.
The papers can be divided into three broad themes: those providing background to the events in Gaul (historical and archaeological), those relating to discoveries linked to Caesar's campaigns, and finally those reflecting on the past, present, and future implications of how we have constructed our chronological frameworks for the period, a practice fundamental to the interpretative narratives that we subsequently weave.
Papers by C. B. Krebs (Chapter 1) and G. Woolf (Chapter 2) provide some historical context, without delving into the detail of the campaigns. K. reflects on how we have come to see the battle almost entirely through Caesar's eyes: while Napoleon III may have been a great admirer of Vercingetorix, his knowledge of him was almost entirely a literary creation of Caesar. W. focuses on the asymmetry in power between the Romans and northern Europeans, in terms of economic might, and the military's capability and professionalization. While the consequences of the war were fundamental to the future of Gaul (liberty, equality, fraternity, or death), W. considers that the success of the campaign was relatively immaterial to the future of Rome. It was but a stepping-stone on Caesar's path to pre-eminence in Rome. In that context W. points out some of the characteristic populist elements of Caesar's commentaries – denigrating aristocratic commanders by highlighting the heroism of normal soldiers, stereotyping foreigners, and other rhetorical devices. If only other narratives had survived, we might be better able to recognize the fake news within the accounts. But W. also reflects upon the way we see the period today. No longer do we read the conquest through the mentality of 19th-c. colonialism, as a fractious Gaul being conquered by a mighty nation-state, but more as one unstable set of dominions being invaded by another equally fractious and chaotic state.
I. Ralston (Chapter 3) takes on the challenge of summarizing the archaeological background of non-Mediterranean Gaul, drawing together the most notable changes in perspective that have taken place over the last few decades in the wake of major research projects and the growth of archaeological work ahead of development. One of the biggest changes has been the increased recognition of a series of semi-urban sites which complement and often predate the development of Late Iron Age oppida. Like the oppida themselves, they are a diverse collection; many are lowland undefended sites and fairly dispersed. They are generally ascribed labels such as “industrial villages” or “agglomerations” (e.g., Acy-Romance, Ardennes). Their importance lies in their messy disorganized layouts, which are helping to reframe the discussion of the origins of urbanism in Gaul, with lesser reference to Roman orthogonal influences, and more emphasis on endogenous processes. In parallel to this, R. discusses the increasing evidence for the rise of hierarchy. One way this is manifest is in the differential distribution of joints of meat across the site of Acy-Romance. Another way is the elaboration of selected farmsteads to become “aristocratic” enclosures (e.g., Batilly-en-Gâtinais, Loiret) some even themselves defended with a murus gallicus, a status symbol normally reserved only for oppida (Luant, Indre). R. also highlights recent work on sanctuary sites, citing the curated headless remains of a defeated army at Ribemont-sur-Ancre (Somme), a practice echoed in the decapitated amphorae from the sanctuary at Corent (Puy-de-Dôme). With the huge amount of information coming out, any brief survey is going to be difficult; but R. divides things up succinctly to give a strong flavor of where the study of Late La Tène Gaul is heading.
Providing a background to military matters, Á. Morillo and F. Sala-Sellés examine how the Republican army was developing its craft in Spain; L. Pernet considers the role of Gallic auxiliaries in the Roman army; and S. Krausz discusses the extent to which Gallic knowledge of Greco-Roman military technology impacted on the development of defensive strategies in Gaul.
Morillo and Sala-Sellés (Chapter 4) start by providing an overview of Republican warfare in Iberia. Since the creation of the Roman provinces, after the Second Punic War, the peninsula had suffered ongoing warfare as Lusitanians and Celtiberians fought and rebelled, culminating in the siege of Numantia. This was followed rapidly by the civil strife of the Marian-Sullan conflict, which spilled over into Spain in the form of the Sertorian revolt (82–72 BCE), ultimately crushed by Pompey. Archaeologically, the fortresses revealed by Schulten's work in and around Numantia have dominated our vision of the Republican military, their irregular shapes forming a prelude to the trapezoidal Augustan forts in Germany and the regimented playing-card-shaped fortresses of the Empire. Yet recent work has significantly expanded the number of Sertorian sites know to us. To the site of Cáceres el Viejo, we can now add the Numantian sites of Renieblas IV and V, and, perhaps more importantly, several ephemeral timber and earthen fort enclosures which are now starting to be recognized (e.g., Vila Joiosa, Alicante). These have enlarged the corpus of rectangular Republican enclosures, providing confirmation of Polybius's description of how tent encampments were laid out (Polyb. 6.28.10; 6.42.6). Alongside the classic focus on the larger forts, there has also been a refreshing attention to the much smaller castella or fortlets, some only 1 ha in size. Many contain early 1st-c. BCE metalwork, and can be found along the Alicante and Valencian coast in positions observing bays where boats could be beached. The authors consider they could have been the bases of Sertorian allies; but they are honest with the limits of data and conclude that some could also relate to Caesar's later confrontation with Pompey in 49–45 BCE, evidence for which is still virtually unknown.
Turning to the Gallic forces, Pernet (Chapter 10) considers the role of Gallic auxiliaries in the Roman army in the 1st c. and 2nd c. BCE, drawing in a large part upon his earlier analysis of a large corpus of graves from across the Gallic world. From these he typologically related the military metalwork to what he considered to be Germanic, Gallic, and Roman traditions. In this chapter, he particularly focuses on the change that can be seen around the conquest period. For example, in the area of the Treveri at Hoppstädten (Birkenfeld) and Wederath (Bernkastel-Wittlich), the presence of chariot fittings in La Tène D2a begin to disappear in D2b, which he associates with the later generation losing ”both symbolically and materially the political and military prerogatives of their ancestors” (188) in the new post-conquest reality. Yet he then goes on to discuss Gallic auxiliaries fighting alongside Caesar (and his foes) in the civil war; and usefully points out cases where non-local Gallic coins have been discovered elsewhere in Gaul, suggesting auxiliary contingents posted away from home in another's territory (such as La Chaussée-Tirancourt near Amiens; Sermuz near Yverdon-les-Bains in Switzerland). In my eyes, all this suggests that the reduction of martial material in graves cannot quite so easily be accounted for as the loss of politico-military prerogatives, as elements of the native martial elite clearly continued to be in charge.
Krausz (Chapter 9) drills into the nature of Roman siege warfare and the Gallic response to it. After starting off with a discussion of the defenses of the Bituriges, and the siege of Bourges-Avaricium in 52 BCE, she then rapidly broadens out into a wider consideration of Gallic strategic knowledge and engineering capability. Caesar famously described murus gallicus structures as timber-frames, pegged with massive iron nails and filled with rubble (BG 7.23); but K.'s interest is on the conversion of some of these impressive defenses into massive dump ramparts in the mid-1st c., a phenomenon common in Belgic and Central Gaul. The slope of the later dump ramparts undermined the ability of the Romans to roll their siege towers up to the walls. They also proved to be relatively impervious to the tactics of sapping and setting them on fire. K. interprets this adaptation as a Gallic response to having developed an understanding of Roman siege tactics, knowledge perhaps derived earlier from spending time in the Roman army. She even wonders whether the Gauls had a specific engineering corps within their armies which could be called upon, though that would suggest a remarkable degree of professionalization by this stage.
A series of papers goes on to deal with the identification and archaeology of specific sites and battles. The late G. Kaenel (Chapter 5) covers Caesar's casus belli: the unsuccessful migration of the Helvetii westward. His chapter lays plain the difficulties of finding correlates between the historical testimony and the archaeology. Signs of the burning of the Helvetian homesteads as the migration began are wanting; the long wall Caesar had built along Lake Geneva and the bridge he destroyed in 58 BCE are elusive; and the only potential site for the battle near Bibracte where Caesar finally confronted the Helvetii is a large earthwork near Montmort which has only produced two rusty nails. To try to find some more positive evidence, K. turns to the settlement evidence back in the Helvetian heartlands, looking for signs of continuity and discontinuity, and here recent work has paid dividends. The oppidum of Yverdon-les-Bains, on the coast of Lake Neuchâtel, tells a story of discontinuity where the defenses were destroyed in 60/50 BCE followed by a hiatus for perhaps 10–20 years. Ultimately, K. demonstrates how much our archaeological knowledge has advanced, but also shows how the historical evidence for Caesar is still profoundly mercurial in its archaeological manifestations.
M. Reddé (Chapter 6) is on firmer ground, revisiting the descriptions in BG of various battlefield and siege sites, and Stoffel's exploration of them for Napoleon III. He focuses on four in turn, starting with the Battle of the Axona (57 BCE), where Caesar fought to lift the siege of the oppidum of Bibrax by the Belgae. Stoffel identified a Roman camp at Mauchamps, and the fortuitous discovery of a Balearic island coin from the nearby oppidum of Vieux-Laon seems to offer confirmation, correlating with Caesar's mention of Balearic island slingers accompanying him. By way of contrast, the evidence for the identification of Gergovie (52 BCE) is a plague of riches, with three major sites potentially laying claim to be the capital of the Arverni: the hilltop on the Merdogne plateau has traditionally been accorded the name, but unfortunately was not actually settled at the time; and there are also the neighboring oppida of Corent and Gondole. Recent work by Deberge et al. has done much to confirm and elaborate upon Stoffel's geography of the battle;Footnote 1 but the identification of the precise location of “Gergovie” is ultimately a semantic problem. Like R. and Poux, I am inclined to think that the name was accorded in some way to all three in this densely packed landscape, with the empty upland defenses being a site of refuge during the war. The siege of Uxellodunum (50 BCE) is R.'s third site, where again Stoffel's suppositions have been confirmed with an extensive array of Roman arrowheads and catapult bolts, as well as evidence of a complex of saps used to undermine defenses, as mentioned in Hirtius's narrative. The lion's share of the chapter, however, is taken up by R.'s final example, his iconic work with von Schnurbein around Alesia, teasing out the archaeological evidence of the circumvallation and contravallation of the siege ending the Gallic revolt (52 BCE).
Rather than focusing on forts or locating battlefield sites, N. Roymans (Chapter 7) turns attention to the issue of mass violence, reflecting a growing interest in conflict archaeology.Footnote 2 This he differentiates from military history in that it broadens out the focus from military installations to include the consideration of enslavement, genocide, and scorched earth policies. He then goes on to describe cases of each. For an example of enslavement, he identifies the oppidum of Thuin (Hainaut) as the capital of the Aduatuci, who were defeated in 57 BCE, sold off, and promptly disappeared from history. One thing that I find surprising is that this is the only real reference in the entire volume (other than a passing mention) to slavery. Taking captives and selling them off was one of the fundamental forms of booty shared among the troops and a way that generals made money. Tens of thousands of enslaved captives would have been marched across Gaul to the markets of the Mediterranean (Plutarch put it at over a million; Vit. Caes. 15); but direct archaeological evidence of this is still lacking. As an example of a massacre, R. reconsiders finds from the confluence of the Meuse and the Waal which he once interpreted as a cult deposit. Based on a combination of geographical, literary and archaeological evidence, including remains of more than 70 men, women, and children with perimortem injuries, he argues that the material derives from a battle clearance, most probably the massacre of the Tencteri and Usipetes (55 BCE). Finally, for evidence of scorched earth policies he turns to landscape archaeology, which shows significant signs of demographic regression in the Rhine delta. He observes that in much of Gaul this is argued to be due to rural populations moving into oppida, but, since such sites are absent here, other processes must be at play, such as disease, ecological crisis, or migration. Overall, the chapter draws on a remarkably wide range of data to show how much broader conflict archaeology can be than site-based work.
A. P. Fitzpatrick (Chapter 8) brings Caesar to the shore of the English Channel and the sites involved in his expeditions to Britain in 55 and 54 BCE. F. reviews the historiography of the campaigns (though this time not including Napoleon III's military surveyors), but then goes on to consider the logistics of transporting forces in relation to what we know of the maritime archaeology of the Late Iron Age. (What kind of harbors should we be looking for? How long a coastline do you need to beach 800 vessels?) Nearly all the potential sites in the discussion have been subjected to significant geomorphological change which has challenged archaeological research, but the article highlights various successes, not least the identification of the probable beachhead at Ebbsfleet in Kent for the landing of 54 BCE. What the chapter does not include is anything about the additional work that F. and Haselgrove have gone on to do since, which has included targeted excavations at Ebbsfleet, and the identification of other sites in Caesar's campaigns inland. Their work has finally and convincingly pinned down direct evidence for Caesar in Britain, but for the publication of this we will have to wait.Footnote 3
As Caesar crossed the Rubicon, the civil war erupted. The final case study takes us back to Spain, where À. Pujol et al. (Chapter 12) discovered violent destruction deposits at the site of Puig Ciutat (Barcelona Province). The assemblage was varied, incorporating weapons, hobnails, and Arretine and amphora fragments, all of which seem to fit a mid-1st-c. date. The authors argue that it is probably to be associated with the action in the run-up to the Battle of Ilerda, where Caesar was victorious over the Spanish army of Pompey the Great in 49 BCE.
The establishment of chronologies is the final main theme that comes out of the collection. L. Olivier (Chapter 15) provides an excellent historiography of the development of our Iron Age chronological framework. He recounts how the military finds from Napoleon III's enterprise at Alesia were fundamental to the recognition that the metalwork from Lake Neuchâtel was in fact pre-Roman and Celtic. He goes on to outline how our chronological framework for what we now know as the La Tène period evolved through the work of Tischer and Déchelette, drawing on the evidence from Alesia, the Marne, the Marzabotto cemeteries, and elsewhere.
S. Hornung (Chapter 11), focusing on the territory of the Treveri, shows how far these chronologies have subsequently been refined. In recounting the discovery of a fortress and an associated cemetery at Hermeskeil (Trier-Saarburg), not far from the “Hunnenring” oppidum, she describes the finds and measurements of the humble hobnails which have helped confirm an early Caesarean date for the site. Her synthesis goes on to locate the site within the historical context of the conquest, with the Treveri divided into pro- and anti-Roman factions, the consequences of which appear to be that some oppida continued and thrived, like the Titelberg, while the “Hunnenring” and others were largely abandoned around the D2a/D2b transition.
If the preceding chapters show the triumph of discovery and chronological refinement, the last two highlight the challenges yet to be fully resolved. Both relate to Gallic coinage, discussing the problems of dating issues by reference to historical events, and laying bare major fault lines in the dating of coin series between Britain and the Continent.
C. Haselgrove (Chapter 13) dives deeply into the historiography of the dating of Iron Age coinage. It is a detailed but necessary paper. With much coinage uninscribed, historical assumptions (and absolute convictions) have framed a lot of our chronological frameworks, and the fragility of these is little understood. This is neatly narrated, starting with the dating of potin coinage, which was considered to be early by Déchelette and Blanchet at the start of the 20th c., then to be late by Colbert de Beaulieu, and is now thought to be earlier again. The story is not easy to summarize neatly but, suffice it to say, views on the dating of British potin on the other side of the Channel were not always in step, though they have now largely come into alignment.
If that story has had a happy resolution, then the dating of Gallo-Belgic gold remains contested and badly needs resolution. Despite brilliant work on the die linkage within this series and on its metallurgy, there remain historical assumptions which have skewed how these coin series have all been dated – most notably by viewing Gallo-Belgic E (Scheers 24) as the emergency Gallic War coinage of the Belgae. This series can be viewed in two ways. If viewed as an emergency coinage over the seven years of the Gallic War, its production was immense, and its declining gold content can be read as testimony to the crisis: it creates a neat self-reinforcing narrative (though oddly enough there is no concomitant peak of hoards of this date, which much other warfare seems to generate). However, if the series is envisaged as an issue produced over a longer time period, starting earlier in the 1st c. BCE (as some stratified finds are beginning to suggest), then both the scale of production and the decline in gold content become less remarkable. H. has done much to promote the idea of the longer chronology over the last couple of decades. This would be entirely in keeping with a general shift earlier that the whole chronological framework of La Tène has been undergoing on the Continent.Footnote 4 Meanwhile in Britain, the most recent “standard catalog” of Iron Age coins continues to ascribe Gallo-Belgic E to the confines of the historical peg of the Gallic War.Footnote 5 Britain, yet again, is out of step.
To the west of Gallia Belgica, P. de Jersey (Chapter 14) discusses the coinage in Brittany and the Channel Islands, particularly in the context of the extraordinary Le Câtillon hoards, the second of which had almost 70,000 coins in it, alongside a relatively smaller number of torcs and other objects. De J. outlines the history of the finds on Jersey and contextualizes them well with a discussion of Coriosolite coinage. However, while French numismatists have always had a strong temptation to ascribe these extraordinary deposits to the Gallic War (a historical assumption), the presence of a few British coins in both has caused problems, as the currently late British dating would make them all decidedly post-Caesarean (though their dating is also based on different historical assumptions about the dating of Gallo-Belgic coinage). As Fitzpatrick and Haselgrove remark in the introduction (Chapter 1), both chronologies might be wrong, but both cannot be right. The dating of much of British Late Iron Age material is in need of a radical overhaul.
Collectively this is an extremely useful volume, neatly bringing together a wide range of archaeological work, filling what had become a glaring gap in the English literature. Much still remains elusive – sites of battles, chronological certainty – but this pales compared to the new discoveries and also the value shown in revisiting earlier finds.
